for posterity, this is "the blueprint for a [sic] American dictatorship" to which you refer:
exceedingly doubtful.
I hope you read Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s very important dissent while you're at it.
Some people actually have a clue what's going on. It takes work, you can't just lazily consume nonsense from journalists.
If you read the complete ruling, the justices work to clarify how "official" and "unofficial" acts apply to the case at hand. For example, many of the conversations had with Pence and the AG are considered off limits for prosecution as they are "official." Other charges, however, can stick if the lower court decides:
> Trump can point to no plausible source of authority enabling the President to not only organize alternate slates of electors but also cause those electors—unapproved by any state official—to transmit votes to the President of the Senate for counting at the certification proceeding, thus interfering with the votes of States’ properly appointed electors
The damning part starts on page 27 of the ruling[0].
[0]: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-939_e2pg.pdf
The actual ruling: https://prod-i.a.dj.com/public/resources/documents/SCOTUSTRU...
We are in an age where the media cannot be trusted. Gotta read the source documents.
The guy who did it’s probably about to be President again and just got a lot more legal cover.
Folks need to read up on how democracies fail. Shit’s getting real iffy here.
> democracies fail
Is this the democracy where we need to stop voters from voting or give them incomplete information to avoid making bad choices?
Very narrowly, and not but for the uncharacteristic acts of a small number of others like Mike Pence. It could have gone very differently very easily.
Only because his coup failed. That's a very important fact.
I remember events differently.
As far as "coup" - I'd say summoning thousands of folks to the Capitol, then not calling for dispersal once they have physically breached the perimeter of the building where the Congress and Vice President are assembled to certify the election results (where he lost), plus (arguably, more importantly) engaging in a campaign to establish networks of alternative electors in key swing states that do not match the popular votes in those states, then I'd say "coup" (granted, with a "attempted" modifier would be more accurate) would be a reasonable word to use for the events that transpired.
What is your view of the events that transpired?
Trump would argue he didn't lose the election, and would still be in power if he had his way. I think we should be making it harder, not easier, for the democratic process to be subverted.
All the "will you peacefully cede power" talk before the election sounded like alarmist clickbait, but he was weirdly resistive to admitting he lost, and there are a lot of batshit crazy people who seem to follow whatever he says (see also, Jan 6).
That is an understatement. His entire platform is that he won every state including Minnesota and New York. This is a personal revenge campaign made up around a lie.
Whatever else he did was fairly normal bad-president stuff. Like, pretty bad, but not the end of the Republic or anything. The attempts to overturn the election, and the utter failure of the state to swiftly punish same, are some real “this may not be the end, but you can see it from here” stuff.
Democratic states tend to vote in the person who ends them. It’s clear now that that’s a thing we’re very much at risk of doing. I don’t even necessarily mean a second Trump term, just anyone who follows his blueprint. The voters evidently don’t see that as disqualifying, and the system’s displayed an inability to respond to such attempts.
The sharks may or may not be circling yet, but there’s blood in the water.
as to what I actually feel, I am stating that the parent comment (as sibling comments have pointed out as well) seems completely oblivious to Jan 6 and the subsequent criminal events/statements since then.
Hope that helps your reading/rage issue, have a good day.
Highlights: - The DoJ reports directly to the President - No term limits for FBI head - Arrest and prosecute DAs he doesn't agree with - Use the military to enforce domestic laws on citizens
So I would take this one seriously.
i sincerely doubt that.
True for Biden, Obama, trump, etc.
What’s specifically new here is the claim by SCOTUS that the President also has post-presidency immunity. It used to be you could use it as a defense whereby you provide evidence that you weren’t acting corruptly within your official acts. Now it’s a blanket immunity - a trial can’t even be brought and your motivations are largely irrelevant and immune from examination.
Anyway I think this is a logical conclusion of that principle. If past actions retroactively became politically unpopular it would be unproductive to litigate action (see bush or Clinton).
> While the Court acknowledged that the principle of executive privilege did exist, the Court would also directly reject President Nixon's claim to an "absolute, unqualified Presidential privilege of immunity from judicial process under all circumstances."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Nixon
This ruling directly contradicts and overturns US v Nixon which is a blaring signal considering just how criminally we now know Nixon, his administration, and his reelection committee was behaving.
Has that been an issue so far?
If and when Trump gets elected how long do you think it will take the Supreme Court to differentiate between an 'official' act and a 'non-official' act when Trump acts illegally in 2025?
Throw in the recent ruling increasing the difficulty of proving bribery and things are looking grim ( IMHO ).
The problem isn't that Roe was overturned - it's that our legislative system is so dysfunctional that law is being settled in the other branches of government.
Comrade, in the United States, we have 9 supreme court justices.