Re:Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for offic...
by citizen_friend on Monday July 01, 2024 @03:16PM
(#40849437)
I don’t think others in this thread hold this same understanding. In fact there were threads calling that ridiculous when the issue was brought up.
Anyway I think this is a logical conclusion of that principle. If past actions retroactively became politically unpopular it would be unproductive to litigate action (see bush or Clinton).
Re:Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for offic...
by vlovich123 on Monday July 01, 2024 @04:07PM
(#40850066)
US v Nixon very clearly put limits of what the president could do in office. Under this ruling, Nixon could have kept the tapes of him ordering the Watergate break in a secret and would have remained in office.
> While the Court acknowledged that the principle of executive privilege did exist, the Court would also directly reject President Nixon's claim to an "absolute, unqualified Presidential privilege of immunity from judicial process under all circumstances."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Nixon
This ruling directly contradicts and overturns US v Nixon which is a blaring signal considering just how criminally we now know Nixon, his administration, and his reelection committee was behaving.
What’s specifically new here is the claim by SCOTUS that the President also has post-presidency immunity. It used to be you could use it as a defense whereby you provide evidence that you weren’t acting corruptly within your official acts. Now it’s a blanket immunity - a trial can’t even be brought and your motivations are largely irrelevant and immune from examination.