News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by jameshart on Friday June 28, 2024 @05:11PM (#40825351)
Combined with yesterday’s ruling on administrative courts, this amounts to a massive increase in the role of the federal judiciary in the execution of government action.

By 2040 the normal procedure every April will be, rather than filing a tax return, filing a suit in federal court disputing the right of the IRS to determine whether your income is actually ‘income’. Eighty federalist society AI lawbots will automatically file amicus briefs in support of your case. The court clerkputer will autoschedule oral arguments at the first available date, around 2175.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Friday June 28, 2024 @05:45PM (#40825605)
> Combined with yesterday’s ruling on administrative courts, this amounts to a massive increase in the role of the federal judiciary in the execution of government action.

Sounds great. How we got to the point where executive-branch agencies were making rules with the force of law, binding upon the public with no judicial oversight, is a mystery to me, but it's good to see that the courts are taking their responsibilities seriously again, and restoring some measure of checks and balances.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by anigbrowl on Friday June 28, 2024 @07:27PM (#40826431)
a mystery to me

It's ably explained in Roberts' opinion. In short, Congress often left the fine details to the agencies, not least because the laws were often drafted within those same agencies. Chevron was based on the idea that if statutory text is ambiguous the people in charge of implementing said statute were best positioned to figure out what it meant, in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act (which sets out rules for for how agencies make rules, eg requiring consultations, publications of proposed rules, public comment periods thereon etc.).

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by rhaksw on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:04PM (#40827354)
> Chevron was based on the idea that if statutory text is ambiguous the people in charge of implementing said statute were best positioned to figure out what it meant

Wouldn't it be odd if the police also acted as the judge in your criminal trial? That's the point here, to separate lawmaking and interpretive power from the enforcers. Consolidation of power is dangerous because it doesn't work.

> in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act

This ruling made clear that the Chevron doctrine was not in line with the APA,

"Courts must exercise their independent judgment in deciding whether an agency has acted within its statutory authority, as the APA requires."

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/22-451_7m58.pdf

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by anigbrowl on Saturday June 29, 2024 @12:14AM (#40827842)
I think it's more analogous to the overlap between police and prosecutors. Those who are the object of regulatory enforcement can and do bring their objections to courts. Another difference is that agency rulemaking is not made in a vacuum; there's a pretty elaborate rulemaking process which includes (iirc) notices of proposed rulemaking, mandatory public comment periods spanning months, pre-publication of draft rules to allow the possibility of litigation and so on.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by rhaksw on Saturday June 29, 2024 @12:24AM (#40827868)
> I think it's more analogous to the overlap between police and prosecutors.

Those both fall under the executive branch. Plus, Chevron deference was about the court's actions, not prosecutors'.

> Another difference is that agency rulemaking is not made in a vacuum; there's a pretty elaborate rulemaking process which includes (iirc) notices of proposed rulemaking, mandatory public comment periods spanning months, pre-publication of draft rules to allow the possibility of litigation and so on.

That gives the illusion of a democratic process, but in reality, agency rulemakers are not accountable to the people, whereas Congress is. Keep in mind that the fisheries regulation in question on this case was passed during the Trump administration– so it's not like electing a conservative to head the executive put a stop to excess regulation, which is generally a position that conservatives advocate.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by anigbrowl on Saturday June 29, 2024 @01:57PM (#40832353)
Those both fall under the executive branch.

They do, but courts judge your case.

That gives the illusion of a democratic process, but in reality, agency rulemakers are not accountable to the people

I didn't claim it it to be a democratic process, I said it was not an arbitrary or isolated one. The democratic element is in the selection of an executive every 4 years. the rulemaking procedures under the Administrative Procedures Act won't be formally changed by this, but I suspect it'll be lengthenedand more heavily litigated, resulting in less regulatory clarity and slower enforcement.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by rhaksw on Saturday June 29, 2024 @02:16PM (#40832464)
> The democratic element is in the selection of an executive every 4 years.

That did nothing to help the fishery in this case. The burdens placed upon them came from a lower level bureaucrat, a decision that likely never crossed Trump's desk. That's just one regulation among thousands per year for which there is no accountability.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:18PM (#40832784)
> Chevron was based on the idea that if statutory text is ambiguous the people in charge of implementing said statute were best positioned to figure out what it meant

Yes, that's an accurate assessment of what Chevron doctrine entails. And again, it is a mystery to me how anyone could ever have thought that this was a good idea, or was in any way consistent with the constitutional separation of powers.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by ytpete on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:30PM (#40826005)
There's been plenty of judicial oversight – courts could always overturn any regulations or actions by an agency that the court decided were not based on a "reasonable" interpretation of the law passed by Congress.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by imchillyb on Friday June 28, 2024 @07:13PM (#40826344)
> ...that the court decided...

You've just touched upon why this hasn't worked in the past. With Chevron the interpretation was left up to the agency, and courts never got to decide anything.

Without Chevron, the courts will now be able to do exactly what you're suggesting.

You're _actually_ in favor of disabling Chevron, which the SC just did.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:22PM (#40832809)
Well, no, they couldn't, that's the whole point of this. Under Chevron doctrine, the courts were deferring to the agency's own interpretation of the law they were testing that agency's actions against, and not applying their own "reasonable" interpretation of the law at all. Reversing Chevron restores the court's responsibility to engage in that interpretation on their own part.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by freejazz on Friday June 28, 2024 @07:33PM (#40826483)
> binding upon the public with no judicial oversight

What on earth are you talking about?

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by rhaksw on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:31PM (#40827463)
He's probably referring to Administrative Law Justices (ALJs), who are part of the executive, not the judiciary.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by freejazz on Saturday June 29, 2024 @02:14PM (#40832454)
But they do have judicial oversight. It's a really bizarre response in the context of this thread.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:29PM (#40832852)
They do now. Before Chevron was reversed, the stuff that appeared to be judicial oversight was being done by the agencies themselves, not by the judiciary.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by freejazz on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:36PM (#40832887)
That's not true at all.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:44PM (#40832923)
That is literally what Chevron doctrine is.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by freejazz on Monday July 01, 2024 @02:55PM (#40849131)
In part, yes. But it's certainly not the whole of the issue and you are purposefully misrepresenting the nature of litigation here.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @03:28PM (#40832843)
I'm not sure what was ambiguous about my initial phrasing, but to elaborate for the sake of clarity, I'm talking about the reversal of Chevron doctrine (i.e. the topic of this thread) -- under this doctrine, the federal courts had delegated interpretation of the statutes under which administrative agencies operate to those agencies themselves.

This created a state of affairs in which agencies were indeed making rules that were binding upon the public, and doing so without the courts exercising oversight on their own part to determine whether those rules were consistent with the prevailing statute law.

Now that Chevron doctrine has been reversed, when agencies engage in novel rulemaking that expands the scope of their authority, it will be up to the courts, not the agency itself, to decide whether that expansion of authority is consistent with current prevailing law.

Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by quickthrowman on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:05PM (#40825779)
It’s not a mystery, Congress delegated their authority to the executive branch willingly.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by Gormo on Sunday June 30, 2024 @06:12PM (#40840811)
That's not what's at issue here, even remotely. Whatever Congress did willingly was enacted in statute law. The entire question here is who is responsible for interpreting that statue law. This entire debate is downstream of legislation.
Re:Supreme Court overrules Chevron deference [pdf] by sanktanglia on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:05PM (#40825772)
at least well be able to legally bribe our way to the front of the line as long as we dont admit its a bribe