News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by Analemma_ on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:13PM (#40780176)
I'm getting more and more convinced that tech people are living in a dangerous bubble re: the generative AI boom. I've been talking to people outside this bubble, and the unanimous response to all the "exciting" AI developments of the last ~3 years has been that their experience of generative AI has been purely negative with no upsides whatsoever. All they see is the content slop, the shitty search results, degraded experiences in e.g. customer service, and so on.

And it's starting to alarm me that nobody in tech appears to care about this and is just going "damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead". That kind of arrogant dismissal of popular mood and forcing unwanted change on people is how resentment and revolution happen.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by minimaxir on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:22PM (#40780261)
Unfortunately, the anti-AI discourse is a vocal minority in the grand scheme of things. As long as engagement metrics are up and the marginal benefits outweigh the marginal costs, the AI slop will continue.

Boomers using Meta AI to create nonsensical images on Facebook and WhatsApp aren't complaining about it on social media.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by ks2048 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:54PM (#40780637)
I'm not sure its Boomers who create these images. It's Boomers who reply "Amen" to a pictures of six-fingered Jesus wrapped in an American flag. (Actually I'm not quite sure - maybe it's just mostly bots replying to other bots...?)
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by Maken on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @11:22AM (#40789801)
It's all bots. Humans are hidden in the margins of modern internet.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:12PM (#40780857)
Boomers aren't making them. They are the captive audience in Facebook groups. I predict that around October, the content on those pages will switch to political stuff (at least for American audiences).
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by AlexandrB on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:22PM (#40780264)
There's already plenty of resentment aimed at "big tech". Gen AI will probably accelerate it.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by o11c on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:07PM (#40782667)
I choose to interpret "Gen AI" along the lines of "Gen X", "Millennial", and "Gen Z".
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by surfingdino on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:00PM (#40780704)
Gen AI is the worst thing that happened to AI research. It is a bullshit generation machine that feeds resentment towards all technologies that make up the broad field of AI.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by wkat4242 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:03PM (#40792957)
The same thing with meta verse. That hype is the worst thing that happened to VR. Now everyone treats it like a good for nothing flop. While it is good for some things. Just not for everything those retarded investors wanted it to be.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by probably_wrong on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:26PM (#40780310)
Here's my two hot takes on that topic.

First, you are on HN, a website full of entrepreneurs betting their savings on AI companies. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it" [1]. Remember that the CEO of OpenAI used to be the president of HN.

Second, remember NFTs? Bitcoin? Perhaps even MongoDB [2]? Tech lives and dies on hype and AI is the newest one. This too shall pass.

[1] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/11/30/salary/

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2F-DItXtZs

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by luzojeda on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:01PM (#40782622)
Did NFTs and Bitcoin indirectly cause a bullish rally such as the one we are seeing on Nvidia? Genuine question here. Because that's what scares me the most, what will happen with Nvidia.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rsynnott on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:14PM (#40782727)
I’d argue IBM to some extent; around 2016 the markets did get somewhat excited about its blockchain efforts (all but forgotten today). Nothing on the scale of the current thing, mind you.

> Because that's what scares me the most, what will happen with Nvidia.

What’s your concern? Ultimately if the bubble bursts, its stock price will fall, presumably. But, well, stock prices fall, life goes on.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:16PM (#40780906)
Bitcoin and crypto come with a get-rich-quick stench that turns off most people. AI hype is much more dangerous because it mixes real use cases, to push enthusiastic viewpoints for LLM slop.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by wkat4242 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:57PM (#40780673)
The President of YC's board, allegedly. Which he never was because that position didn't actually exist until after he left. There's been numerous articles about that recently.

Not to undermine your point, the techbroism is strong here but facts are facts

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by mr_toad on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:56AM (#40785700)
> First, you are on HN, a website full of entrepreneurs

I’m pretty sure the majority of people commenting here aren’t entrepreneurs.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by npoc on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:23AM (#40807195)
Isn't bitcoin at all-time highs? In what way has it died?
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by ToucanLoucan on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:35PM (#40780431)
> I'm getting more and more convinced that tech people are living in a dangerous bubble

You don't need the rest of this sentence. They are. Almost everyone I talk to in the Valley of Silicon speaks of broad trends in... I mean, anything really, in how people use technology, in what people need cars for, in what people eat, in what goods typically cost, genuinely any topic of sufficient breadth that escapes the technology itself, as though they have not been on planet earth since roughly 2009. It is astonishing how well insulated from common concerns tech workers are, which is probably how we got shit like Juicero, an incredibly overbuilt, over-spec, ludicrously designed wifi-connected machine to squeeze a fucking bag. And it explains a bunch of their other incredibly stupid ideas, like e-scooters.

This is why, I am sorry, but I simply do not put a lot of stock (literally, and metaphorically) into the opinions of SV's elites. That's like, a bubble in a damn bubble. That's a bubbled subset of people who haven't had a normal experience of being human for who knows how long, inside a bubble of people who largely do not share the same reality as me.

Bringing it back to what I was replying to: you are absolutely right about the common folk's experience with AI. It's an annoying thing being shoved into tons of products they use, that seemingly no one asked for, that doesn't work. And it's a massive, 400 foot tall neon sign, telling them that big tech doesn't give a fuck about them, what they want, or anything else besides sign up for the subscription dumbass.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by holtkam2 on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:32PM (#40783765)
Couldn’t one make the argument that EVERYONE is in a bubble of sorts?

I (one of the SV tech workers you mention) was recently in rural Georgia for a cousin’s wedding, where I was shocked to learn that many people in the area considered the previous presidential election to have been stolen. I wanted to scream “you need to get out of your bubble!”

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by myaccountonhn on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @07:25AM (#40787104)
You can, the issue is more that SV has way too little understanding of the world for the influence it has.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @10:12AM (#40788901)
And I would argue, more importantly, it has way too little understanding for the influence it wants to have. SV companies want to disrupt every industry, irrespective of if the inefficiencies present are down to organizational inertia on the part of the market holders, or whether those inefficiencies are down to a myriad of other reasons we might want to do any given thing a little slower and more carefully than we otherwise might. Like, for example, background checks for taxi drivers before we give them the job of transporting strangers, alone, with zero oversight. That's not to say the taxi industry prior to Uber was saintly, far fucking from it. But it had a baseline of safety that went along with the corrupt incentive structures present in many places, that Uber completely failed to replicate and we had to re-learn the lessons we had already learned, which has cost a non-zero amount of lives.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by NathanKP on Friday June 28, 2024 @04:10PM (#40824730)
I'm mostly with you but "other incredibly stupid ideas, like e-scooters" just sounds like a personal vendetta to me. I don't see anything SV specific about e-scooters, not is it a dangerous bubble or stupid to use compact electric powered modes of transport in a dense area.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by password54321 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:39PM (#40780472)
Perplexity is one of the only tools that I think takes great advantage of LLMs strengths (pattern matching, interpolation) while also making up for its weaknesses (hallucinations, lack of ability for novel contribution/thought) by using it for summarisation with search.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by wkat4242 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:58PM (#40780683)
It's not even that special imo. Openwebui does the same locally when you enable search engine integration. It's not really rocket science
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by BeFlatXIII on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:49PM (#40780575)
> And it's starting to alarm me that nobody in tech appears to care about this and is just going "damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead". That kind of arrogant dismissal of popular mood and forcing unwanted change on people is how resentment and revolution happen.

Tell that to the schoolchildren who excitedly use AI to do all the busywork for them.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by Yodel0914 on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:09PM (#40782682)
Except that schools are making kids do more and more on paper, in class, in order to combat AI usage.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:30PM (#40793875)
There was a discussion on /r/professors about this exact issue. The big downside they identified with blue exam books is that 90 minutes or 2 hours or whatever with no spell checker is insufficient time for most students to have developed appropriately deep insights for college-level work.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by AlexandrB on Monday June 24, 2024 @06:01PM (#40781405)
Isn't this going to be crippling once they're in a situation where the actually need some of the skills they skipped learning?
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by lmm on Monday June 24, 2024 @07:14PM (#40782163)
It might, in a world where school busywork had anything to do with learning useful skills.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by wkat4242 on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:03PM (#40780746)
I think AI has a place in this world. As does virtual reality, the previous hype. The problem with these hypes is, the overstressed business types that think it is the key to the future for everything. Almost nothing is the next internet. And in a year or so when they don't see their 2000% payoff, they will consider it a flop, which will also harm the genuine efforts that were made and usecases where the tech does add value. It's the overexpectations that hurt it.

The problem starts happening when you shoehorn it into a bunch of shit for the sake of it, where it adds no value and often even degrades it. Like what everyone is now doing with AI. Especially Microsoft.

It's great for some stuff, like making summaries. It's not GenAI and if we try to use it as such (as Nadella is doing) the bubble will burst sooner rather than later and that's bad for the tech community as a whole. I find the journey super interesting however from a personal tech interest point of view and I love playing with it locally. But I'm not blind to its glaring limitations and I don't care whether it makes money or not, I'm just into it for the tech. It's the money boys that keep blowing good stuff up.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:08PM (#40780808)
VR doesn't have anywhere near the same level of fossil fuel emissions as AI though.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by AlexandrB on Monday June 24, 2024 @06:04PM (#40781446)
Crypto certainly does.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2024 @07:48PM (#40782498)
Every company and their mothers aren't piling into it hoping to strike gold though.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rsynnott on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:09PM (#40782681)
They kind of were at one point. It’s sort of been memory-holed now, but some years back, everyone was trying to hawk a private blockchain, or their own cryptocurrency, or whatever. Even very big companies.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rustcleaner on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:45PM (#40782972)
Crypto mining is where solar system companies will go as states start letting grid operators only net meter instead of paying you for power your system puts in.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by wkat4242 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @06:59AM (#40786885)
I don't think so. Crypto hardware depreciates too quickly to leave it idle half the day
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by lanstin on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:11PM (#40783606)
It's almost like capital has become so big that the investment money sloshing around looking for high returns at the expense of anything else, does not care if excessive capital ruins the early dot.com companies, real estate, crypto, generative AI or anything else.

We need an investor class that just wants to get their 50 pounds a year to maintain the country estate, not one that wants to vacuum up 80% of the economy in short term speculative bubbles.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by hattmall on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @01:25AM (#40784792)
It's ultimately a lack of "class". The scenario you're describing requires that the wealthy maintain a set of social virtues that are more important than money. One of those virtues must then be that greed is seen as very low class. It's the stereotypical depiction of new vs old money. It does exist in the US, but it's mainly in certain industries and the uber wealthy are generally shunned / excluded because to be focused on the pursuit of money is taboo. It's literally the primary differentiator, "I'm so rich we don't care about money." Even though they are nowhere near as rich as billionaires. To be seen as concerned about making money shows a lack of class and even if you have billions of dollars from a social standpoint your no different than any random poor person working paycheck to paycheck.

So that investment class certainly is out there, but it's not really in places like California, New York, Florida etc. Those areas and the industries spawned in them are dominated by the profit obsessed social pariahs.

Of course money and investments are a major aspect but it's never about how much money you can make, all the pursuits are profitable, but it's about how much importance and control they will generate.

Most Tech, Crypto, AI, anything like that, if it gets shut down tomorrow, the impacts are minimal and easily mitigated. People involved lose money, but everyone else carries on, possibly somewhat inconvenienced. If a regional cold storage facility, railroad, pipeline, quarry, or container yard decides to shut down you have real impacts that start to get serious quickly.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rchaud on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:06PM (#40780770)
The AI power brokers are all getting rich by hyping up the tech to the high heavens, while pooh-pooing AI ethics and safety concerns. Governments are following in lock step so as not to appear "anti-innovation".

I don't see revolution on the cards. Maybe a giant market correction once the hype wears off and pension funds figure out that throwing more H100 GPUs into the mix isn't going to make AGI happen any faster, and that there there's no real road to profitability for startups making shitty genAI chatbots, images and music.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by medhir on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:07PM (#40780792)
Think it’s worth calling out that many people in tech have significant reservations about the reckless push of generative AI into just about every product — the issue is the executive class that insists on chasing hype and potential short-term stock growth over everything else.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by joe_the_user on Monday June 24, 2024 @06:58PM (#40782026)
I actually know two ordinary people who pay to use ChatGPT. One uses it to write sex education policy statement and the other uses it for D&D narrative descriptions.

But I understand lots of people are very annoyed by it and with things like this, reasonably so. The problem that revolution only comes from desperation, not annoyance. If health care, rents, the experience of flying and traffic, global warming and so-forth hasn't produced a revolution, generative AI won't.

And this situation is pretty much what has brought-about the present "death by a thousand paper-cuts" world.

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by rsynnott on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:10PM (#40782690)
_Sex education policy statements_? I mean, how many can one possibly need to write? What does the LLM bring to it?
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by lmm on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:35PM (#40783782)
That's probably the reason for using an LLM - you need to write dozens (one for each nominal entity, and a new one each time they nominally update their objectives/etc.) that are essentially indistinguishable, but directly copy/pasting would be noticed.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by luzojeda on Monday June 24, 2024 @07:47PM (#40782488)
Same. Anecdata I know yadda yadda. But I don't know one single person that is hyped about _consuming_ art or any content generated by AI. Only people producing content with generative AI and expecting a financial benefit are the excited ones. And I might guess they are not that keen into consuming AI generated content as well. It's all about who is the sucker that pays for all the slop.
Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by cageface on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:03PM (#40783100)
I'd go further and that lately, for the average person, tech is causing at least as many problems as it solves. The public internet is a chaotic mess of scams and ripoffs. Social media is a cesspool that many people still feel obligated to participate in. Dating apps are an exercise in masochism, etc etc.

What actual problems are we solving for these people?

Re:A journey into Kindle AI slop hell by unraveller on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:25AM (#40787691)
Highway to the danger boom, baby. You see much more arrogant posts referring to their superior human skills over AI.

The hubris of forcing all social interactions to take place in big tech walled gardens that want to replace you with A.I. is titillating.