But if you do that, it means the vehicle goes from having 0 sideways acceleration to experiencing 100% of the centripetal acceleration to move an object on a circular path (a = v^2 / r) instantaneously.
As an occupant of the car, that means you go from sitting comfortably to suddenly being thrown sideways.
It's much more comfortable if you ease into the turn, with the track design considering the rate of change of acceleration. If the designer didn't consider jerk you would definitely notice.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euler_spiral
Usually for any curve you go straight-clothoid-arc-clothoid-straight
For trajectory AND for pitch and roll
How representative are these stated preferences actually of the population. I'd imagine that the individual preferences vary greatly from person to person and also change with age.
We’re all up against the wall during this ascent!
My thoughts are that I'd prefer to spend as little time as possible in an elevator and would rather spend that time doing other things.
If I don't feel the elevator moving, then it's moving too slowly and wasting my time.
I've always wondered why this is, why curves in general are perceptually similar if scaled correctly, while a straight line is so clearly different. Perhaps it is because our perceptions developed to distinguish between inertial and non inertial reference frames?
You can get an idea when you try to understand why the function
y=0 for x<0 y=x^2 for x>=0
has two derivativea but not three.
But the issue is infinitesimal, so very hard to tell.
Jerk you can “linearise” if you think of a car (with no air friction) and its accelerator. Somehow…
Why not, though? Why does third order "look like" second order but second order is starkly different to first order?
Secondly, presumably the distinction of "straight" vs. "curved" is quite deeply programmed into the brain's pattern recognition machinery. The degree of curvature is a quantitative parameter on top of the qualitative categorization. This may or may not have something to do with the fact that a modern human sees straight lines everywhere (something that very much was not the case in the ancestral environment).
These are mathematical derivatives, I think of them as the slope of the thing it's derived of, aka the change in the thing that it's a derivation of.
I think I don't have a sophisticated mathematical understanding, but my basic mechanic understanding makes it feel simpler than your question is acting.
That doesn't help me recognize a cubic from a quadratic when looking at a small piece of it, but I can imagine an elevator ramping up it's lifting power or similar. It kind of feels like the tricks to conceptualize 4D as 3D position plus a temperature at each spot.
Related, I sometimes wonder how many derivatives you need to go down in order to find the one that is discontinuous when you decide to make a motion. For instance: pressing the first key to type this reply, my finger didn't instantly jump from zero to non-zero acceleration (or jerk/snap) I assume. How many terms in the Taylor series for moving a muscle?
Because higher derivatives are insignificant. That's the entire concept of Taylor series approximation. If you change a high derivative of a function, the value of the function won't noticeably change - why would you care?
> The terms jerk and snap mean very little to most people, including physicists and engineers.
Almost 20 years ago we defined jerk into our standards for lift applications. I know jerk is an important parameter for any modern rotating machine that includes gears.
While in lift applications it is known as the roller coaster effect, people in different parts of the world have a different taste on when they want to use a lift. I know I over simplify when I say, that American people want to have the gut feeling when riding a lift, especially an express lift in those high buildings. In difference in Asian countries the lift ride must be smooth as possible. They don't like to have the feeling of riding a lift at all. In Europe it is something in between. Lift manufacturers have to respect those (end) costumers otherwise the are not chosen.
The same in any rotating machine with some sort of gears. Because jerk and those higher orders contribute to the wear and tear of gears. As you want to have longer lasting gears many modern machine manufacturers limit those parameters to reduce wear and tear. So, with a little software change I can demand a higher price because service and maintenance can be reduced.