News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mydriasis on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:20AM (#40696514)
Work is hard and stressful. If we're sweet and kind to one-another, we get through it more easily, no matter how smart each of us is individually. Being kind is an investment, and its dividends pay out enormously as your organization grows. Like the article says, it's infectious. I believe that. I believe that if I show kindness, especially to people who are new to the organization, they'll mirror it right back, and try to show it to everyone else, too.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mgaunard on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:57AM (#40696708)
Will you be kind as well to the people who repeatedly fuck up and don't care about delivering good processes or products?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by Kye on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:04AM (#40696752)
What would being unkind accomplish here?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by thih9 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:13AM (#40696818)
It's not about being unkind, it's about not being kind; these are not the same.

Being kind to a person that behaves as described in the grandparent comment could communicate that you find this kind of behavior helpful. Fine if that's really the case; problematic for everyone if not.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by Kye on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:15AM (#40696829)
Kindness and enabling are also not the same thing.

This entire discussion needs to come to a screeching halt while people get together and hammer out some definitions. It's clear we're all working from different and contradictory assumptions about what these words mean.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by jzb on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:53AM (#40697089)
I think people are conflating “kind” with a range of other behaviors. You can be kind while addressing poor performance, etc. You address the behavior, you might even have to fire someone, but those are not incompatible with kindness - if you’ve given someone ample opportunity, and clarity, then you’ve been kind. It’s unkind to let someone get to the point of firing without being clear that their job is at risk. It’s not unkind to take action when their performance threatens the organization, team, etc.

I think most people would agree Fred Rogers was kind - but I have to imagine he had to fire people from the show over the course of its run.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by chupy on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:10AM (#40696793)
What would be kind accomplish there?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by andrewshadura on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:13AM (#40696814)
Not make things worse, for example? Or maybe it can help convey the message across and make things better?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by antisthenes on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:14AM (#40696823)
Not being an asshole in your own eyes. If that's not worth anything to you, then Idk, guess we live on different planets.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by maccard on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:15AM (#40696827)
Yes. They’re still human and they deserve to be treated with respect. But part of being kind is being direct and honest, and holding people to account. If you ignore it, or let it fester you’re being unkind to other people
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by the_snooze on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:20AM (#40696862)
There's a lot of kindness in clarity, even when it comes to bad news. Imagine a doctor has to deliver a terminal diagnosis; it would be very unkind to avoid or sugarcoat the news, just as it would be to trivialize the issue by joking "don't bother buying green bananas."
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by Kalium on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:15AM (#40697242)
There's a great deal of nuance to how kindness is defined. It's very easy for one set of actions to be either very kind or very unkind, depending on definitions.

Listening, being respectful, and being empathetic may drive one person to bite their tongue and silence feedback that someone is performing poorly out of fear of hurting them or the morale of the team. Another may be driven by the very same things into giving candid feedback.

This article does not do a good job of exploring the difference. It just asserts "Being nice is the new punk".

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by BeetleB on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:32AM (#40697369)
Yes. Not being kind leads to defensiveness and not owning up to their errors.

I've worked in very competent teams and very incompetent teams. There were two types of incompetent teams. The type that always denied making mistakes, and the kind that owned up to their own incompetence. Being kind leads to the latter.

It still sucked being in an incompetent team, but when they admit their weakness, they get out of your way and defer to you. When they don't admit it, you'll face barriers all the way.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by pcloadletter_ on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:12AM (#40696810)
Yes. A person's performance on the job does not change how I treat them as a human.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by therobots927 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:20AM (#40696863)
Yep. You have to be. You can provide feedback to them or their manager if possible but the reality is that the employment status of your incompetent coworker is not under your control.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mgaunard on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:08AM (#40697194)
You're speaking under the assumption that "you" can't be a team lead or manager able to make the bad performer redundant.

Moreover as an IC there is a lot you can do; most importantly you can quit if you feel the team you're in is being mismanaged.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by therobots927 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:27AM (#40697325)
Well yes but you certainly can’t become a lead if you’re getting mad at people. At least in many situations you can’t. And yes you could quit, but the job market isn’t the best right now. And sometimes the jobs that pay more require dealing with less competent people so sometimes there are tradeoffs.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by demondemidi on Sunday June 16, 2024 @12:36PM (#40698304)
Yes. I will. And I upvoted you because I think it is HN duty to help you out, and not bury you.

If someone is fucking up, they are in the wrong position. People need to work for a living, and shouldn't be under duress constantly. It is up to them and their manager to find a position that is rewarding and engaging for them.

If they don't care, they are also in the wrong position.

It is no reason to not treat them with kindness. You don't have to blow them, but you don't need to be UNkind, as several have said below.

The only people I don't treat with kindness are people who are legitimately trying to hurt me and people I love, or promote hateful ideas with glee. People who are failing at their job need help.

And if they still annoy you, then I think the problem might be in how you view the situation. Compassion helps with anger. Try to think about why you are so angry, and if it really matters or helps to be so angry. Especially if you are not the manager. If you are the manager, consider that maybe the job isn't for you. You shouldn't be pissed at work all day!!

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mgaunard on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:46AM (#40704622)
Why would you invest time and effort in solving someone else's problems? As a manager your responsibilities are to the shareholders.

A business is not a charity.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by demondemidi on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:12AM (#40717442)
Because we are all humans doing our best and we are forced to work our lives away by an elite ruling class.

(I don’t know you but you sound like every white male teenager who discovers Ayn Rand.)

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mgaunard on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @09:44AM (#40728230)
That sounds like a borderline insult, but I'm not familiar with American literature so I can't really feel targeted by it.

If you're a leader with a strategic role, time is your most important and limited resource. You just cannot afford to spend time on something that doesn't further the goals of the business, even if you're a hippie or a communist.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by flatline on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:54AM (#40696696)
Sweetness and kindness are not necessarily the same thing. Just like how “nice” can be a toxic trait.

His list of points is fine. It’s mostly the servant leadership mentality, which I’m all for. But sometimes to be an effective leader you have to make hard decisions. You’ve got to know your personal boundaries and know when to yield and when to hold them, or other less sweet people are going to steamrolling you, or you’re going to get overloaded by taking on too much, etc. And sometimes you have to be direct and blunt and not so sweet to show true kindness. Confrontation is hard and it’s not something most people really want, but I believe it’s sometimes necessary to embody kindness. For yourself, your teammates, the customer, the organization. Because at the end of the day if you are not effective, that’s going to hurt everyone.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by jorisboris on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:22AM (#40696871)
Sad to say that my experience is exactly opposite

When I’m kind to people, especially in other departments, they don’t mirror it: they’re stressed, they’re pressured by their boss or it’s just not the culture of that department… even after months of cooperation

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by anal_reactor on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:03AM (#40696741)
I love reading discussions of people to whom following the social norms comes naturally and they can't fathom the idea that behaving in a way that makes other people feel good is something I need to consciously put effort into.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mydriasis on Sunday June 16, 2024 @04:53PM (#40700016)
It also requires conscious effort for me. It takes a lot of energy, but like a lot of things, the more I do it, the easier it becomes.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by callmeal on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:03PM (#40701706)
>I love reading discussions of people to whom following the social norms comes naturally and they can't fathom the idea that behaving in a way that makes other people feel good is something I need to consciously put effort into.

It takes less effort, becomes easier, and in time will come naturally to you as well.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by ttoinou on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:34AM (#40696576)
So you want to be kind only for utilitarian motives, not because it’s a good thing in principle ?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by guy4261 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:42AM (#40696632)
Good that does not sustain itself is quite sad - you can see the efforts going down the drain. Aligning good and sustainable (utilitarian) is worthwhile imho.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by CoastalCoder on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:59AM (#40696722)
It sounds like you're saying it's far better to be kind for altruistic reasons. Is that right?

Some persons (me included) suspect that humans rarely if ever act with true altruism; that it's actually a nicely dressed up form of self-serving hedonism.

And so for us, the challenge becomes how to get ourselves to act good / kind despite that. One way is to find ways to intentionally tie kind behavior to our own self-interest.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by beepbooptheory on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:35AM (#40696953)
gp is refering to a morality that is deontologically grounded, not just one based on altruism. Here it is not necessarily for one "reason" or the other, but rather acting the way some ideal person would in a perfect world (famously for Kant within the "kingdom of ends" where every person is an "end to themselves").

It's a rather huge theoretical distinction that at least in the West goes all the way back!

In general, one shouldn't confuse ethics itself with the whatever one might think is the most viable ethical system! It isnt a product to market. Utilitarianism is no less silly the anything else, and has its own ridiculous edge cases and all that.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by CoastalCoder on Sunday June 16, 2024 @12:10PM (#40698070)
Thanks for introducing me to the concept of deontological ethics!

It's been fascinating to read up on something about which my thoughts were only half-formed.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by bitshiftfaced on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:37AM (#40696600)
What does it mean for a thing to be good in principle?
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by glenstein on Sunday June 16, 2024 @02:57PM (#40699230)
I don't understand why they got down voted because this question has a rather obvious answer. Do you motivate a person to behave a specific way because it's instrumentally good for a higher purpose, or because the behavior itself is inherently valuable? That's a perfectly coherent, it makes a real distinction, and it's a legitimate question in this context.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by OmarShehata on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:44AM (#40696644)
fun experiment: let's try to have the most charitable interpretation of this comment ^

My best is: they are saying it is worth taking a step back and making a prioritized list of our values. If we do this, we may place "being kind" over "being productive"

I think their warning here is about: what happens in a situation where being kind is NOT productive? Will you just drop it?

I think I agree with the broad strokes of this. My rebuttal is: the comment above this was just pointing out, for people who do not value kindness over productivity, that they are not in opposition. That you don't have to pick one or the other. You can have both.

We can get mad and turn away from people who do not share our values/priorities. Or we can show them ways that our value systems do not clash and it can be win win

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by ttoinou on Sunday June 16, 2024 @09:37AM (#40696967)
Great sum up ! You can have both, but for me being productive is more important than not offending others
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by alluro2 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @03:06PM (#40699290)
That's not a very kind interpretation of the parent comment - a bit reductionist, don't you think?

I personally don't believe it's possible to "give out" kindness, compassion, friendship solely from an utilitarian position. It would either be fake, and people feel the difference and the desired effect does not follow, or your utilitarian position is a front, in order to justify being kind to unkind people around you judging you.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by mydriasis on Sunday June 16, 2024 @04:52PM (#40700001)
No.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by demondemidi on Sunday June 16, 2024 @12:31PM (#40698255)
Exactly! When I look forward to working with people, we get more done and I don't come home burned out and discouraged. Even if the work is hard, at least you are in it together.
Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by atmavatar on Sunday June 16, 2024 @01:18PM (#40698607)
You have to be careful, though: there is no shortage of people who will happily take advantage of someone who shows them kindness.

While I believe you should show a baseline level of kindness to people when you first meet them much like you should give people a baseline level of respect, there are actions which can and should lose both.

Re:Do not try to be the smartest in the room; try to be the ... by eleveriven on Sunday June 16, 2024 @04:05PM (#40699701)
Kindness fosters a sense of trust and camaraderie among team members