News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by alwayslikethis on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:06PM (#40664894)
Realistically, no hardware manufacturer of a significant size (let's say 100k total devices) should be allowed to dictate what software can be distributed to users. It opens up all kinds of unfair business practices.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by gwbas1c on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:44PM (#40665406)
Careful: Before web apps were common, 3rd party applications on Windows would break all kinds of things.

The hardware manufacturer needs to ensure that software doesn't break the device.

Apple and Google are going well beyond any reasonable grey area, though. Demanding a cut if I buy a book through the Kindle app is absurd and has nothing to do with ensuring that Kindle doesn't break my smartphone.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by devoutsalsa on Thursday June 13, 2024 @04:34AM (#40667278)
> Demanding a cut if I buy a book through the Kindle app is absurd and has nothing to do with ensuring that Kindle doesn't break my smartphone.

"Ensuring that Kindle doesn't break my smartphone" requires time and effort. That's funded by the cut they take.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by chrisan on Thursday June 13, 2024 @05:30AM (#40667593)
It is unfairly funded. The ensuring part requires the same time and effort for

Free apps, apps that make money off ads, apps that cost $1, apps that charge a monthly fee, apps that resell products where a 30% cut exceeds their margin.

Perhaps the stores should change to a model of choose your own adventure: pay per release or % cut. What would you say is a fair amount to charge per release - keeping in mind apple/google will want to maintain their insanely high profits from the app stores?

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by gwbas1c on Thursday June 13, 2024 @09:53AM (#40669659)
> That's funded by the cut they take.

Apple / Google do not need to take a 30% cut of every e-book ever sold to fund their review. That's absurd and illogical.

One estimate is that Amazon sells 487,000,000 ebooks a year. If we assume they cost $10 each, that's almost a $1.5 billion cut for Apple and Google.

It does not cost $1.5 billion for Apple and Google to review Kindle to make sure it doesn't damage devices.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by sqeaky on Thursday June 13, 2024 @11:34AM (#40670941)
Others have addressed why the price is ludicrous.

What if this is a service I don't? Why am I paying for it? The vendors selling in app items are certainly passing on some of the cost of this.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Zak on Thursday June 13, 2024 @06:59AM (#40668072)
Windows 9x and classic Mac OS are extremely fragile compared to Windows NT, Darwin, or Linux. Doing anything non-trivial without breaking those systems required some skill.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by pmontra on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:51PM (#40672553)
That was in large part because the CPUs they run on lacked hardware memory protection and any process could crash and take everything else down with it. No hardware support and no support for those features in the OS. That changed quickly as the CPUs improved. All the UNIXes of the time run on CPUs with memory protection and never crashed.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Zak on Thursday June 13, 2024 @03:46PM (#40673795)
As I understand it, the Intel 386 had it and would run Windows NT. Making Windows 95 (which required a 386 or better) a separate product was a business decision, not a technical one.

Without doing a bunch of research, it looks like things were more split on the Mac side; some Mac models had fancy MMUs while others didn't until the switch to PowerPC. Classic Mac OS didn't support memory protection, and Apple's quest for a replacement operating system cumulating in the acquisition of NeXT is well known.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by kbolino on Thursday June 13, 2024 @04:03PM (#40674022)
The 386 was technically enough to run NT, but the additional features of the operating system demanded additional resources, making it sluggish on the hardware most home users actually had. NT also couldn't use drivers written for DOS or Windows 3.x.

Conversely, Windows 9x could have made more aggressive use of the processor's protected mode, but it would have broken a lot of programs that worked fine on Windows 3.x. Windows 9x was still capable of running most 16-bit real mode software and generally allowed it to access BIOS and hardware, which NT couldn't allow without breaking the security model. Many "enterprise" customers even stayed on 9x instead of NT simply because it ran the software they used.

It took another few years before the hardware got fast enough and the software base moved to mostly 32-bit protected-mode code to merge the two product lines. However, there were still problems when it finally happened with XP.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Zak on Thursday June 13, 2024 @05:36PM (#40675080)
It was probably a good business decision. Microsoft is famous for commercial success despite the hacker crowd typically having unfavorable opinions about their products.

The best example that comes to mind for me is Windows 95 having a special case in its memory management to work around a bug in SimCity. From a technical perspective, that's nuts, but from a business perspective I imagine not doing that would have hurt both immediate sales and consumer trust in the brand.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by kbolino on Friday June 14, 2024 @10:05AM (#40681035)
I guess the line between "business" and "technical" reasons here is a little blurry. Keeping SimCity or any other widely used program working through "hacks" doesn't seem nearly as bonkers in the days before widespread high-speed Internet access. Even if Maxis did patch their game, most people would have no way to update their copy.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by gwbas1c on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:34PM (#40722367)
A process on Windows NT can do quite a lot of damage: Change registry values, change installed libraries...

A lot of the problems arose from shoddy installers that wouldn't clean themselves up correctly on uninstall; requiring periodic reinstalls.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Spod_Gaju on Thursday June 13, 2024 @10:27AM (#40670131)
I really don’t need Apple or Google protecting me, but thanks.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Arainach on Thursday June 13, 2024 @11:33AM (#40670921)
We all benefit from but having massive botnets and not having to worry that every app we install is copying all of our data to a server.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by elric on Thursday June 13, 2024 @12:08PM (#40671401)
Do we really, though? It sounds a lot like buying short term security at the cost of freedom.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by vkou on Thursday June 13, 2024 @12:49PM (#40671899)
We buy that all the time, and ask for a second helping. All things are temporary, and often this is a reasonable tradeoff.

The problem isn't in that transaction, the problem is conflicts of interest. Platform vendors engaged in both gatekeeping and building their own apps have an inherent conflict of interest. I think that Apple in particular (but not Apple alone) abuses it quite brazenly.

The issue isn't that the police exist (a tradeoff of freedom for temporary security, we'd all be freer if they didn't), the issue is when they start shaking me down, or otherwise brutalizing me.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by jerojero on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:04PM (#40672061)
It's true that without Apple and Google's eye we'd have more cases of malware in our devices.

But I think it's also true that people are more than capable of adapting to such landscapes because we already do that with our desktop/laptop computers. Yes, malware exists and people do get their computers infected. But I believe the reliance of a sort of "watchful eye" also makes us lazy.

I mean, the ideal situation is not one where Apple doesn't have an app store. But imo more like what Google does with android where you can install anything if you really want.

I think the cuts these companies take from having a curated store is too high though. And in the case of apple there's simply no alternative (well, there's the nascent stage of an alternative forming in Europe I guess).

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by wepple on Thursday June 13, 2024 @05:00PM (#40674723)
> But I believe the reliance of a sort of "watchful eye" also makes us lazy.

This is a common point, but similar to how there was widespread fear that seatbelts would encourage people to drive dangerously.

Security should be baked into the platform and not a task for an 89 year old grandfather to have to deal with.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by bloppe on Monday June 17, 2024 @01:46PM (#40708649)
You can bake security into the platform while still letting power users step over the guard rails. A better analogy than seatbelts would be child locks. Yes, they're great to have. Sure, maybe they should be enabled by default. But you probably wouldn't want to buy a car that had permanent child locks.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by csense on Thursday June 13, 2024 @12:07PM (#40671390)
> The hardware manufacturer needs to ensure that software doesn't break the device.

Preventing software from breaking a device is a solved problem. All you need is a CPU that supports memory protection, and an appropriately designed OS.

If you want to only run software that's been OK'ed by a third party, that's certainly a choice you can make for yourself or your organization.

I don't like that this choice is imposed on almost-all cellphone users by monopoly.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by dwighttk on Friday June 14, 2024 @06:57AM (#40679587)
What? I thought Androids whole thing is you can install arbitrary apks
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Sophira on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:24PM (#40672249)
> The hardware manufacturer needs to ensure that software doesn't break the device.

What about those of us who want to break our devices? (At least, according to the manufacturer's idea of what "broken" is.)

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by qwertox on Friday June 14, 2024 @11:49AM (#40681917)
> Before web apps were common, 3rd party applications on Windows would break all kinds of things.

I use Windows since the 90's and would only agree with you in the context of buggy drivers or malware.

Even today I don't use the Windows Store (except for one time I when I installed a Bluetooth audio "bridge") and all the "apps" I install work just fine.

> The hardware manufacturer needs to ensure that software doesn't break the device.

The software manufacturer must make sure the software doesn't break the device, whatever "breaking the device" means (sounds almost like "don't brick the wifi chip").

I mean, it's also the responsibility of the user to not install shady software.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by InitialLastName on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:41PM (#40665074)
Realistically, including avionics and medical devices where the software is restricted by regulation (in theory) and where the manufacturer is legally liable for failure of their device?

More specifically, the radio in an iPhone can almost certainly be made to operate outside of licensed/compliant limits by tweaking the software. Should they be forced to allow that but still held accountable when their device is noncompliant?

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by MenhirMike on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @11:56PM (#40665787)
> Realistically, including avionics and medical devices where the software is restricted by regulation (in theory) and where the manufacturer is legally liable for failure of their device?

Yes, absolutely. The responsible party is the operator of said equipment, and if they tinker with it, it's up to them to be compliant with FAA/FDA/HHS/etc. regulations or face proper legal reprecussions.

> More specifically, the radio in an iPhone can almost certainly be made to operate outside of licensed/compliant limits by tweaking the software.

See above. We can already do that today with WiFi chipsets that can be made to use frequencies that are illegal in a certain country. It's on the operator to ensure compliance. Alternatively, device manufacturers are free to use components that only work in a certain frequency spectrum - but that wouldn't prevent an operator from using them in another country.

We already solved those problems long ago.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by adrianN on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @11:52PM (#40665770)
It is already legal to modify cars even though they are dangerous, so a working legal framework for that kind of stuff exists. I don't see why we shouldn't be able to handle the case where somebody chooses to run Doom on their pacemaker.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by dzhiurgis on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:01AM (#40666391)
> It is already legal to modify cars even though they are dangerous

Not in places with regular inspection and mandated insurance. I.e. most civilised world.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by viraptor on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:45AM (#40666650)
That's not quite right. You can totally modify them. The restrictions are around what's allowed on public roads, not what you do with the car. (You can drive whatever you want on your land) And even then, many modifications are ok and you can get special classifications for "unsafe" cars (like vintage ones without any safety features)
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by freeone3000 on Thursday June 13, 2024 @06:04AM (#40667776)
Nearly all car mods pass inspection. Look at what is actually checked: safety and emissions. Nothing about speed, appearance, sound, horsepower, ride height, or stock state. And moreover: if you modify a car that fails inspection, it’s on you, not the manufacturer!
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by sqeaky on Thursday June 13, 2024 @11:45AM (#40671064)
You are correct in the larger sense, I am just pointing out details. Sound checks are part of checks in some places where there are sound limits on vehicles. Some "mufflers" are more like megaphones.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by shiroiushi on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:09PM (#40665244)
>the radio in an iPhone can almost certainly be made to operate outside of licensed/compliant limits by tweaking the software. Should they be forced to allow that but still held accountable when their device is noncompliant?

I can see an argument for this. Nothing forced Apple to design their hardware this way: they could have built licensing/compliance limits into the hardware itself. But they didn't want to do that because they wanted to use the same HW for all markets, and different governments have different rules about which frequency bands are allowed. Of course, this then brings up the question: if they did make slightly different HW per-market (perhaps with 1-time fuses), what happens when someone brings their iPhone from one country to another and they've modified it to ignore any new region restrictions (Apple could still use SW to force new restrictions, though they can't allow anything new because of the HW restrictions) and it's broadcasting on an unallowed band?

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by bee_rider on Thursday June 13, 2024 @12:03AM (#40665815)
Watch them start distributing their programs through cartridges (hardware) to circumvent this type of law, or something ridiculous like that.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by throwaway2037 on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @11:24PM (#40665621)
My guess about roaming between different domestic and international regions: A handshake with the tower tells the phone what is the network type, then software (firmware) controls what frequencies to use. I just cannot believe in 2024 that this problem has not been solved many times over. What exactly is you qualm / concern?
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by shiroiushi on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @11:57PM (#40665788)
The point is that someone could modify the software to broadcast on disallowed bands: this is one of the main arguments against allowing user-modifiable software on smartphones (or any radio device).
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by leetcrew on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:00AM (#40666120)
so what? broadcasting on unauthorized bands is essentially painting a "come fine me" beacon on yourself. surely the FCC (or it's Japanese equivalent) can handle these sorts of revenue opportunities without Apple's help.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by LeonB on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:11AM (#40666457)
If Johnny Nobucks makes an illegal broadcast using an Apple device - or rather if Johnny Nobucks makes an app for the express purpose of doing the illegal broadcast, and distributes it to 1 million other users on Apple devices — the FCC equivalent would faaaar prefer to sue 1 rich person (Apple) - with a chance of getting big bucks — than 1 million and 1 poor people — (Johnny no bucks and his users). But I’m pretty sure Apple would be able to put together a license model that makes them safe in this case, long before they were put in any legal danger.

Anyone who claims it’s an intractable is using it for a different purpose -/ either trying to keep their sweet monopoly - or wishing they could sue apple.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 13, 2024 @09:18PM (#40676645)
This is an interesting point. Is it not possible to buy a SDR (software-defined radio) and broadcast 4G/5G signal on disallowed bands? Also, I remember watching a video about repairing an ancient Nintendo Entertainment System. If you remove the faraday cage (metal box) around the video out signal, it accidentally broadcasts on disallowed bands. (I don't remember all the details.)
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by wibbily on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:29PM (#40665347)
> Should they be forced to allow that but still held accountable when their device is noncompliant?

I mean, routers have worked like this for ages. OpenWRT has an entire page about tweaking your radio settings, and what could happen to you if you do. Why would Apple be held liable for something you did to your device?

https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/wifi/transmit.po...

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by intrasight on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:55PM (#40665461)
>Why would Apple be held liable for something you did to your device

Because Apple is worth trillions of dollars

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by LeonB on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:13AM (#40666467)
Yup. Regulators would rather sue Apple than the end users for the same reason John Dillinger chose to rob banks - “that’s where the money is.”
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by callalex on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:16AM (#40666479)
So is Cisco/Linksys
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by Xelbair on Thursday June 13, 2024 @03:37AM (#40666989)
>Should they be forced to allow that but still held accountable when their device is noncompliant?

no, because there's this weird concept that seems to be foreign to the modern software folk - Ownership.

Owner is held liable for that, not device manufacturer.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by al_borland on Thursday June 13, 2024 @12:00AM (#40665803)
From what I always understood, the argument for the App Store was to ensure the hardware remained stable. While it's easy to say, "it's mine, I can do what I want," when that device is a persons life line to emergency services in the even something happens to them, that is not a responsibility a company should take lightly. I like to think Apple takes that seriously and acts in accordance with that responsibly. They've said as much publicly, but of course one can choose to believe them or not.

Even if someone wants to ignore this concept, where is the line drawn? Should a hardware manufacturer, or OS vendor, be allowed to make a product that blocks malware on their systems (like Windows Defender)? Windows was seen as a poor product because of all the adware that infected it in the early 2000s. That issue has largely been resolved, thanks to efforts from Microsoft. Should they not be allowed to solve the biggest issue that plagued the public perception of their product?

I realize I'm move the goalpost slightly, from hardware to OS vendor, but ultimately, it isn't Apple's hardware that's creating these controls, it's iOS, the operating system. And in the case of Google, it's clearly an OS vendor issue, as Android is installed on a wide variety of hardware from many different OEMs.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by leetcrew on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:04AM (#40666141)
seems like a false dilemma to me. the platform owner should do all those responsible things that you mention. they should also offer an escape hatch for turning all those portions off, should the owner of the device so choose. I respect Apple's attitude much more than Google and Microsoft these days, but they really go too far with locking down iOS.
Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by shiroiushi on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:23AM (#40666221)
Your Windows Defender argument seems like apples and oranges. It doesn't fully prevent adware infection anyway, but regardless, the discussion is about whether a hardware maker (or platform owner if you're going to try to extend this to OSes) should be allowed to prevent 3rd-party software selected by the user from running on their platform.

Defender doesn't do this: it's an optional security application by MS that's included with Windows. Users are free to disable it if they wish. Nothing is preventing Windows users from running whatever software on top of Windows that they like. Defender will prevent some malware from running, and many users like this for obvious reasons, and the fact that it's included for free unlike competing anti-malware software, but it's not so baked into Windows that you can't turn it off. An antitrust argument could possibly be made, along the lines of Windows including IE and putting competing software out of business, but that's a different issue than what we're discussing.

So you're right about this being really an OS vendor issue, but Microsoft doesn't force anyone to use Defender, and doesn't prevent anyone from using competing products. Google also allows using competing app stores (or even side-loading .apk files), though only a tiny fraction of users take advantage of this. Apple is really the problem here because it doesn't allow these things at all.

Re:Japan enacts law to curb Apple, Google's app dominance by zzo38computer on Thursday June 13, 2024 @08:14PM (#40676292)
I think it is reasonable for them to decide what software is available officially, in order to check for compatibility, quality, etc. However, users should be allow to load software that has not been approved and to write their own software too; and the software provided officially should not be required (if it is documented, you can write your own; if it is FOSS, then you can modify it and provide modified versions of the software). This does not excuse unfair business practices though, but it does ensure that users can easily override it if they do not like some of their business practices. The number of devices is not relevant. Even on many Linux systems there is a package manager, although you can also write your own software instead of using that in the package manager if you wish, and that should also be working with Apple, etc, just as well.