News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by muhfuhkuh on Monday June 04, 2012 @05:47PM (#4066130)
So, no more install.sh scripts that you have to chmod +x, no more "undefined symbol" errors from games expecting old library files, no dependency hell (though, admittedly, I don't encounter those as much anymore).

That I can definitely get behind!

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by pippy on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:18PM (#4066247)
This is bigger than what many might think. I'd still be using Linux now if I didn't have to edit xorg.conf just to change the screen resolution. (Yes I'm aware of the http://xkcd.com/963/ comic).

The gap between programmer and user is Linux's biggest fault. For example Unity, developers recognised an issue with the UI. Instead of doing user studies and tweaking it for the better they canned Gnome and reprogrammed it. Now they're in the same situation but with an entirely different codebase.

Having a large company with a product that has to work will add consistency, and hopefully force Linux to start tweaking instead of redeveloping.

I might actually install it on my next machine.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by fingerprinter on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:35PM (#4066318)
1. As someone else noted, literally years since you ever had to touch config file by hand. Use Ubuntu, you'll love it.

2. I do believe your view of Unity is a bit odd. Canonical recognized that the state of Linux UI/DE was NOT going to make the leap from programmer. They saw this VIA user studies. That is when they decided to create Unity. And user study after user study Unity keeps coming out ahead of all the other DE in Linux and is on par with usability of current OSX. Point being, Ubuntu is going after users the right way. Unity in 12.04 shows this and the reviews speak to it.

3. Sometimes you simply have to rewrite. This is a fact (sorry Joel) in software. The challenge is to recognize when it is necessary and avoid it when not 100% necessary to achieve your business objectives.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:52PM (#4066936)
I use Ubuntu, and every time I switch between external displays and my laptop's display, I have to move an xorg.conf file. My external displays are on NVidia Twinview, my internal display is on an Intel GPU. I have no choice but to move my NVidia xorg.conf out of the way when I want to use the internal display, and then move it back when I get home and hook up to my monitors.

In 2012.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by glesica on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:05AM (#4068917)
This isn't really a commentary on Linux itself though. Optimus can cause issues on Windows, too. It's new tech and Linux support is at the bottom of vendors' "todo" lists.

The problem here is twofold, though I'm not necessarily saying these comments apply to you, you are apparently willing to endure some inconvenience.

First, people should always check hardware support before buying a laptop if they intend to install Linux. I'm not trying to be a neck-beaded dick (although I do need to shave), I'm just pointing out that many of the problems people have with Linux stem from well-known incompatibilities that could have been avoided with different hardware choices. Which brings me nicely to the second point...

There is a communication issue in the Linux community. We (I'm including myself here) need to stop over-selling Linux. It is not a computing panacea for everyone, and so long as hardware support lags behind Windows "selling" Linux as a drop-in Windows replacement isn't a good strategy.

Getting someone to install Ubuntu/Fedora/openSUSE isn't a victory for the community if his hardware isn't compatible and things don't work right. It would be better to tell him that he should think about purchasing a Linux-compatible computer in the future and perhaps directing him to a list of compatible hardware.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by simcop2387 on Monday June 04, 2012 @11:56PM (#4067246)
Yep that sounds like the horror that is Nvidia-Optimus. There's some kludges out there to do it all on the internal display, i don't know how well it works for mixing the two. I assume you've already looked at Bumblebee to see if it might help your situation?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:22AM (#4067449)
Bumblebee works if you actually want to use the internal and external at the same time, but I only ever use one or the other. Also, you lose 3d acceleration if you use it, AFAIK.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by wazoox on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:21AM (#4068996)
Something's wrong with your system. I use Slackware, I have a dual screen setup and no xorg.conf, all was configured with the catalyst panel. My colleague has some Acer Laptop running Ubuntu, and he sometimes connects an external 19" screen he has on his desktop, and he certainly hasn't any xorg.conf (and that's fortunate because he's utterly non-technical).
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:29AM (#4069031)
There's nothing wrong with my system. Neither you nor your colleague have Nvidia Optimus systems, which is why you're not having any issues. My problems are definitely not the norm, but the "Xorg.conf isn't used anymore" meme needs to die; there are still real problems to be addressed. Unless we identify them and deal with them, they'll still be there.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:20AM (#4067443)
Are you using the latest Ubuntu ? They said they improved on multi-monitors support on 12.04. I did not test myself, though.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:23AM (#4067451)
Yup, 12.04. It's because I'm using the NVidia driver for my externals, and Intel for my internal. No choice in the matter at the moment.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by esbwhat on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:28AM (#4067608)
You try bumblebee at all?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @03:06AM (#4067697)
Bumblebee solves the problem of using them together, and doesn't allow you to actually get 3d acceleration on the Nvidia chip. I just want to be able to easily switch between the two cards, but that won't happen, so the Xorg file moves will be necessary.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by josteink on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @08:38AM (#4068371)
1. As someone else noted, literally years since you ever had to touch config file by hand. Use Ubuntu, you'll love it.

Sure. But that wont cure a fundamental problem with the X11/Xorg infrastructure.

You cannot quickly and switch desktop orientation, resolution and layout (not to mention drivers) seamlessly like on Windows without killing your entire X-session. Killing your entire session. Jeez.

At the root of this problem is an architecture which is lagging on what Microsoft could deliver in Windows 98. You cannot make Windows and reboot-jokes while you have this Achilles-heel dragging your video subsystem. You seriously cannot.

And no new version of Ubuntu can overcome this underlying issue, no matter how much fluff and candy they add elsewhere, as long as they rely on the ancient relic that is X11.

As far as I know, when Google decided to make Android and ChromeOS (a complete failure as far as any metric goes, but still worth mentioning) they decided:

1. to base it on Linux, because that makes sense and

2. not to base it on X11 because they wanted it to be flexible and they wanted their users not be limited by what architects could think of in the 1984.

For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul. I cannot see anyone arguing this.

And even if seemingly everyone agrees on this, nobody is pushing forward for it to happen. Make of that what you like.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @09:57AM (#4068621)
> You cannot quickly and switch desktop orientation, resolution and layout (not to mention drivers) seamlessly like on Windows without killing your entire X-session.

On my Ubuntu system, I can change orientation, resolution, and layout from a little control panel without restarting the session. I have no idea if Xorg restarts; the superficial behavior is almost identical to Windows. From the user's point of view, it doesn't seem to matter.

> For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul.

Every mainstream desktop environment seems to have handled the major aspects of display usability just fine. The only serious issues I've encountered have been one-off bugs related to drivers.

> I cannot see anyone arguing this.

Everyone agrees X is a mess. But why must we continue to use X and not Wayland?

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by krunaldo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @09:46AM (#4068586)
uh? You can change resolutions on the fly and orientation on the fly. This have been available for ages via xrandr and other things. Via API-calls or through the xrandr cli utility.

The only thing that is really ugly in X11 is the protocol, but so is win32 api :)

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sciurus on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:33PM (#4066554)
Is there public information on the user studies Canonical has conducted on Unity or other desktop environments? It seems like that information would be very useful to other free software projects. All I can find are reports on empathy and rhythmbox.

http://design.canonical.com/the-research/

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @10:00AM (#4068635)
The last published usability report on Unity seems to be from April 2011. http://design.canonical.com/2011/04/unity-benchmark-usabilit...
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:22AM (#4067447)
I do not think that Canonical would share such data. That kind of research costs money, and they want to keep it to their advantage, most probably. You don't see Microsoft or Google release their user studies results either. Hardly surprising.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by aidenn0 on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:13PM (#4066482)
I dropped Ubuntu since after weeks of research and discussion, etc the only way I could get it to output acceptable screen resolution on my monitor was to hand enter a MODELINE. a !@#$@#$%@#$ Modeline; I couldn't remember the last time I typed in a modeline before this.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by simcop2387 on Monday June 04, 2012 @11:59PM (#4067257)
What kind of monitor? I'm curious to know to avoid them when I want one that doesn't need that kind of thing. The only times recently I've had to do that is for two specific cases, an arcade monitor that was built before EDID was a pipe dream, and a TV that likes to report that it has a native resolution of 320x240. Both of which would have to be worked around on any platform so I don't find it a problem.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:45PM (#4074782)
It is a Sun branded monitor with really broke-ass EDID, and I was using it just fine before having manually (but with a GUI) set the resolution and refresh rate.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by tene on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:23PM (#4066270)
It's been many years since I've had to touch xorg.conf to change screen resolution. I can do it on the command line (xrandr) or through gui tools. Do you have significantly unusual hardware?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jff on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:43PM (#4066355)
I don't even have an xorg.conf. Things "just work", and if they don't, I use xrandr at the command line to fix things live. It's really gotten a lot better than the bad old days of hacking around with XF86Config.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ricardobeat on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:43AM (#4067352)
Swapping xorg.conf for xrandr isn't a big win for most users. It is getting better, but things still fall apart like a sand castle when something goes wrong.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jlgreco on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:36AM (#4067630)
Considering there are plenty of GUI frontends for xrandr, of course it is better for most (all?) users.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jff on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:29PM (#4069694)
And even the command-line tool is far simpler than fiddling with xorg.conf. When I plug my laptop into its docking station, I run a little script to switch over to my two external monitors in portrait mode:

  #!/bin/sh
  xrandr --output LVDS1 --off
  xrandr --output VGA1 --mode 1920x1200 --rotate left
  xrandr --output HDMI1 --mode 1920x1200 --left-of VGA1 --rotate left
I could probably automate it, but this is easy enough that I don't care.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:17PM (#4066246)
But you get all the DRM junk. Better to deal with chmod +x than with DRM restrictions.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:59PM (#4066421)
Is that sarcasm? 'Cos while Steam restricts you in a few ways (e.g. no giving free copies to friends) the experience is so superior I continually choose to buy games on Steam over any other method.

Hell, one of the biggest reasons I patronize the Humble Indie Bundles is because I can get the games into my Steam account.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:17PM (#4066501)
I liked Humble Indie Bundles precisely for their DRM free Linux releases. Other good DRM free source is GOG (though requiring Wine). Steam is of no interest to me because of DRM promotion. It's a choice the company has to make. You can see DRM free releases being successful, so those who stick with DRM need to be discouraged.

There is a positive side of Valve's interest in Linux though. It'll encourage others to pay more attention to Linux, and eventually more DRM free games will be available too.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:36PM (#4066564)
You can see DRM free releases being successful, so those who stick with DRM need to be discouraged.

I don't think that follows.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:40PM (#4066578)
DRM needs to be discouraged by its definition IMO. I was saying above, that if that raises an objection that making a financially successful game without DRM isn't possible, then such objection is not true. Or if you want to phrase it in a positive way - those who don't use DRM need to be encouraged.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by Tuna-Fish on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:29PM (#4066886)
The thing is, for some games (competitive internet multiplayer), some forms of DRM are a net positive, and arguably strictly necessary. After easily used cheats started to be widely distributed for CS, the game experience for the typical player went trough the floor, and the community voluntarily and without any kind of financial incentive created and enforced a type of DRM.

Steam takes that to the next level -- because they can add fines of real money (losing your account), and actual permanent bans (of credit cards and real identities) as the cost of cheating, the gaming community embraced it and cheers for it.

So, we are in a situation where the vast majority of the player base considers DRM not just acceptable, or good, but a strictly necessary part of the product. The things that are commonly considered the evils of DRM (ability to take away ability to use product) are instead considered a primary selling point. How's that for food for thought.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @10:42PM (#4067054)
I think your argument can be rephrased in a way, that multilayer games require third party arbiters (server admins, GMs and so on), who should be able to ban violators of game rules, reconcile conflicts and so on. I fully agree, but I don't see why it should be equated with using DRM for the actual software.

And to single player games this issue doesn't apply at all.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:24AM (#4067316)
> I think your argument can be rephrased in a way, that multilayer games require third party arbiters (server admins, GMs and so on), who should be able to ban violators of game rules, reconcile conflicts and so on. I fully agree, but I don't see why it should be equated with using DRM for the actual software.

GMs do not have the power to that job, unless they have something that's approximately equal to DRM. Catching a subtle cheater is a much, much bigger job than cheating. If someone cheats every day, you'd be lucky to catch him once a month. To actually stop cheating from happening, you need penalties that are high enough to make that once a month count -- so permanent global (so they won't just move on to the next server) bans (and ip bans don't cut it), or failing that, monetary punishment.

Tell me how your third party arbiters achieve that without essentially implementing DRM?

> And to single player games this issue doesn't apply at all.

Except when there is publicly visible scoring/achievements system that you want to keep pure. >90% of new games on the market are either mp or do that.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:41AM (#4067347)
I still think using any kind of DRM is an unethical overkill for controlling the MMO..G and the like. Firstly, the game can be designed better avoid (some) exploits. Secondly automated mechanisms can be built on the server side to prevent cheating (monitoring unnatural stats boosting, unrealistic mods and so on). I agree, that it's not easy to do it manually. So, write server side protection code for that. It's not DRM, and not some kind of client targeted kill switch. If the user is caught - ban will follow. Let them register again, and get another ban if they want to waste their time. And if that cheating is so hidden that it's not even unnatural IG - who cares (i.e. it's still not fair, but at least such user doesn't have big impact).

From the player perspective, I'd choose a multiplayer game based on the community. Sometimes community can identify cheating just by observing something unnatural, and those users will quickly be boycotted. So GMs are needed to intervene when human decision is necessary. They not necessarily have to detect the issue themselves first.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by streptomycin on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:27PM (#4066715)
Is that sarcasm? Steam is DRM. If Valve decides they don't like you, they can delete all your games. If Valve goes bankrupt, they can delete all your games. If Valve gets bought by another company, they can delete all your games. If you like paying full price for a game rental with a variable return date, then Steam is great.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by MartinCron on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:52PM (#4066784)
For what it's worth, Valve has pledged to issue a patch to unlock everything if they ever shut down the steam service.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by streptomycin on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:58PM (#4066803)
FWIW, it's not a legally binding pledge, it was just some guy saying, "yeah, we'll do that".

(Correct my if I'm wrong, that's what I remember from reading about it before, but something could have changed recently.)

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by btilly on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:15PM (#4066845)
I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice, etc.

If they have publicly promised it, and people have taken action upon it (for instance buying games that they wouldn't have bought otherwise), then if they fail carry through on it you have grounds to sue for promissory estoppel. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estoppel#Promissory_estoppel for more on that.

Winning said lawsuit is not a sure thing. But the pledge may wind up being more binding than it would appear on the surface.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by streptomycin on Monday June 04, 2012 @10:28PM (#4067021)
A quick Google found http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=368489

"Unless there was some situation I don't understand, we would presumably disable authentication before any event that would preclude the authentication servers from being available."

So, that's pretty clearly not a guarantee of anything. And furthermore, as another poster there said, the thing Valve employee doesn't understand is bankruptcy. Unless there is a legally binding agreement, they won't be allowed to just give away such a valuable asset. Bankruptcy doesn't mean they fire everyone, shut down everything, and burn down the buildings. It means they sell off the profitable parts and try to keep them running. And the ability to control tons of DRMed games people have installed is very valuable.

A real, legally binding promise would be something like KDE had with Trolltech. Trolltech explicitly (real contract, real lawyers, etc) guaranteed, even in bankruptcy or change of ownership, that if they stopped making open source releases, then Qt would become available under the BSD license. (This was more important back before Qt was already GPLed, as it is now)

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by MartinCron on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:01AM (#4067259)
I agree that a legally binding commitment would be better than what we have, but what we have is better than no pledge at all.

I personally love and trust Valve, but I understand that others may have a different risk tolerance.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by eli_gottlieb on Monday June 04, 2012 @10:21PM (#4067008)
In which case someone can crack the games we've got on our hard-drives, which is a situation we're already in.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:10AM (#4067420)
Steam is DRM.

Please point out where I said it wasn't.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by streptomycin on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @10:37AM (#4068784)
You didn't. You even explicitly mentioned that it is restrictive. But you seemed to think it wasn't a big deal. Thus, my post.

But if you're going to be snarky and pedantic about it, please point out where I said you said Steam isn't DRM.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by MartinCron on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:16PM (#4066490)
I know a lot of people are against DRM in any and all forms, but the Steam implementation is pretty much the definitive case study in how to do this stuff the right way.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:33PM (#4066553)
If you mean there is some convenience - why do you need the overhead? Just install the game without any extra client which restricts you. It's a case study for DRMed approach, which isn't the way to go.

For example requiring one to connect to their server prior to playing (implicit requirement of having an Internet connection) is a ridiculous restriction.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by MartinCron on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:44PM (#4066764)
It's not just the convenience in installation. It's the whole experience from purchase to download to re-download. Everything just works. Buying CDs and punching in codes feels so quaint.

Clearly, if you hate DRM for philosophical reasons, you will hate Steam. If you're pragmatic, you may love it.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by dkersten on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:41PM (#4066910)
Everything just works.

I do use steam. A lot. Unfortunately, everything sometimes doesn't just work. For example, I've been left without access to my games a number of times due to internet problems (either in general or just with my gaming desktop) and while offline mode could get around that, I need to be connected to the internet to put it into offline mode and its rare, if ever, that I'll know about internet problems in advance.

So not everything just works for me.

Besides that, though, Steam is the first store in which I've ever impulse bought games - and I've done so multiple times now and probably the majority of all games I own are through Steam. They just make it so easy to find games I want, check the forums for criticism, buy the game, download it and then connect to friends. That experience is one they've done very well and why I still use it despite having had problems. Luckily my account has never been locked - thats a horror story I don't want to experience...

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:19PM (#4066853)
Surely, I'm not interested in buying CDs and punching in codes :) I prefer to download a purchased game, install it, and run without any DRM.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:41PM (#4066582)
If you mean there is some convenience - why do you need the overhead?

What overhead? You mean the 100MB RAM and 0.1% CPU the Steam client takes? Wow, that really is a high price to pay for the ability to re-download any game I own on any PC, and the automatic updates.

requiring one to connected to their server prior to playing is a ridiculous restriction.

Steam offers offline mode. You only need connect to their server when you download the game. Now, some games are more restrictive, but those are not made by Valve- only offered on their platform. That was someone else's choice.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:46PM (#4066596)
Yes, it's their (game creators') choice but offered as an option by the distributor (Valve). I'm simply not interested in encouraging such kind of behavior. Those who have a stronger stance on DRM free releases deserve more attention.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:52PM (#4066610)
Offered as an option? Hardly. Such games typically are distributed via Steam, and later phone home to their publishers- not Valve. Valve is not providing a ultra-DRM service, they just don't prevent it.

It is a good model, IMO, and similar to what Amazon does when an e-book is priced at $14.99 ("This price was set by the publisher"). Let other companies do what they like, and let the market decide for itself.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by nikomen on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:59PM (#4066420)
Contrary to popular belief, game companies have salaries to pay and are interested in protecting their IP so they can continue to pay those salaries.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:14PM (#4066484)
Contrary to popular belief, not using DRM really shows respect by game creators for their users. I simply won't buy any DRMed game. Luckily some publishers like GOG emerged, who promote DRM free games, and have such major contributors like CD Projekt Red who aren't scared to show respect for their users by selling DRM free games. They (CD Projekt Red) managed not only to pay salaries and improve their products, but also attracted a lot of potential customers for their future titles. GOG is behind in providing Linux versions yet, but I'd rather get DRM free game to run under Wine, than DRMed native one.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by Locke1689 on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:52PM (#4066612)
Hold the phone everybody -- shmerl won't pay for DRM'd games. Better pack it up folks, we're done here.

In all seriousness though (and this is a question that everyone should ask themselves semi-regularly in a product-consumer situation): why do you matter? If you don't have a compelling answer to this question, it may be that you don't.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:55PM (#4066623)
Your choice matters. In this case I'd call it "vote with your wallet". Preferring non DRMed games shows support for their developers, as simple as that.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by Locke1689 on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:01PM (#4066642)
No. For Valve many peoples' choice matters. My individual choice to purchase or not purchase TF2 is of negligible concern. Now, if my individual choice is indicative of a wider trend of people purchasing TF2, then maybe my choice would matter.

The problem with people arguing about DRM is that fundamentally most people don't seem to care. Video games are a billion dollar industry, but non-DRM'd games are not.

You can vote with your wallet, but the data seems to indicate that your wallet is too small to matter.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:15PM (#4066678)
The argument "since most don't care - you shouldn't either" is flawed. If you are sure something is right - it doesn't matter how many care to do what's right.

> Video games are a billion dollar industry, but non-DRM'd games are not.

It only should increase the incentive to avoid buying DRMed games, and specifically support those who aren't scared to release theirs DRM free.

For example look at the latest Humble Indie Bundle. Linux users pay highest average for the set. It shows that they encourage developers to produce Linux games more than users of other OSes (obviously since Linux games scene is lacking). You can argue, that Linux games market is miniscule, and if so, why even bother to send your message in such form? But you still see people showing appreciation, and developers can take note of this.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:40AM (#4067635)
Usually for every Humble Bundle, the Linux share of the total is not so minuscule, something like 15-20% if I remember correctly.

If we assume every bundle gets a total of a million dollars, shared between 5 games or so, that makes 200 000 per game, minus the donations to charity and the fees to the Humble Bundle organization. Let's say 150 000 dollars per game in the end. 15%-20% is 23 000 to 30 000 dollars, just for the Linux Port. If you are an small team of indie developpers, I'd say that is not negligible at the end of the day.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by forrestthewoods on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:53AM (#4067528)
By "major contributors like CD Projekt Red" I assume you mean "owners". Good Old Games was created and is owned by CD Projekt so it's not exactly fair to simply call them "major contributors". :)
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:31PM (#4069330)
Thanks for the information, I didn't know they are the owners. That's even better, it shows how a serious and successful games production company can promote DRM free approach. They used to rely on DRM before, but I guess they reconsidered at some point, and turned it completely around.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by b0rsuk on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @06:18AM (#4068091)
You're setting up a false dichotomy. DRM isn't required for game developers to get paid. It's not "DRM or developers don't get paid". Games sell even without any kind of copy prevention mechanism. If you are worried, you can still use Kickstarter (or grant) model. In that model, it's irrelevant if the game is copied out of control after release. Devs have already been paid.

In my opinion Kickstarter (or grant) model is infinitely better, because it doesn't insist on treating a game like a physical object. The "selling software" model is horribly flawed. Writing software is like research - a big cost and effort once, then very little cost to benefit from it. It is fair to have effort of research/software development proportional to reward the researchers/devs are getting. With "selling software/drugs" it's not proportional.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:32AM (#4072430)
Here is a good interview with Marcin Iwinski (CEO of CD Projekt Red) about DRM:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielnyegriffiths/2012/05/18/th...

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by commandar on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:19AM (#4067588)
Steam doesn't necessarily mean DRM-laden. Some games use Steamworks DRM, true, but many simply use Steam as a delivery mechanism. ARMA2, for example, can be run directly from its directly in the Steamapps folder.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:33AM (#4067621)
Chmod +x and install.sh scripts have rarely been a problem recently. It's not that complicated and most people familiar with Linux know about these basic commands.

Dependencies is still a problem, however. There are still a few cases where I had to spend significant time to make a game run correctly because of dependencies. And the online resources on this matter are scarce.

But even on a Linux backend, it's possible to introduce specific formats encompassing all needed libraries. That's what being done on the Open Pandora, where a single PND file contains, in a zipped format, the executable, all the needed libraries, and the data for the game. That way, you avoid the problem altogether.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jiggy2011 on Monday June 04, 2012 @05:50PM (#4066141)
Nope , just wait 10 minutes for Steam to load , check DRM and do all updates and your ready to go!
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by muhfuhkuh on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:10PM (#4066472)
Believe me, I'd wait a few more seconds for it to do that than it erroring out to a prompt with "UNDEFINED SYMBOL: GTK_BUILDER_NEW", or worse, crash with a core dump where I'll never find it or know what to do with.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sliverstorm on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:43PM (#4066589)
But think of the freedom you get with those UNDEFINED SYMBOL and core dumps! I'll take DRM-free core dumps over playable games, any day!
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by shmerl on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:22PM (#4066864)
DRM free core dumps surely should be more fun than DRMed ones. ;) But seriously, having or not having DRM is not really directly related to how often it will crash.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by dkersten on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:50PM (#4066930)
In the past I've had games crash because of the DRM. At least, thats what it sounded like from error messages and google searches. Tages and securom how I loathe thee!
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sukuriant on Monday June 04, 2012 @08:19PM (#4066692)
</sarcasm>
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by Splines on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:34AM (#4069048)
That's one of my biggest annoyances with Steam. It takes so long to load.

I'm tempted to install another partition of Windows with nothing on it except steam and the drivers necessary for me to play games, to see if it'll make starting steam any faster.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jiggy2011 on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:03AM (#4072632)
I've tried. It doesn't.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by MrScruff on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @08:02AM (#4068283)
Perhaps tongue in cheek but it's normally easier to type sh install.sh