News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by pippy on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:18PM (#4066247)
This is bigger than what many might think. I'd still be using Linux now if I didn't have to edit xorg.conf just to change the screen resolution. (Yes I'm aware of the http://xkcd.com/963/ comic).

The gap between programmer and user is Linux's biggest fault. For example Unity, developers recognised an issue with the UI. Instead of doing user studies and tweaking it for the better they canned Gnome and reprogrammed it. Now they're in the same situation but with an entirely different codebase.

Having a large company with a product that has to work will add consistency, and hopefully force Linux to start tweaking instead of redeveloping.

I might actually install it on my next machine.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by fingerprinter on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:35PM (#4066318)
1. As someone else noted, literally years since you ever had to touch config file by hand. Use Ubuntu, you'll love it.

2. I do believe your view of Unity is a bit odd. Canonical recognized that the state of Linux UI/DE was NOT going to make the leap from programmer. They saw this VIA user studies. That is when they decided to create Unity. And user study after user study Unity keeps coming out ahead of all the other DE in Linux and is on par with usability of current OSX. Point being, Ubuntu is going after users the right way. Unity in 12.04 shows this and the reviews speak to it.

3. Sometimes you simply have to rewrite. This is a fact (sorry Joel) in software. The challenge is to recognize when it is necessary and avoid it when not 100% necessary to achieve your business objectives.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Monday June 04, 2012 @09:52PM (#4066936)
I use Ubuntu, and every time I switch between external displays and my laptop's display, I have to move an xorg.conf file. My external displays are on NVidia Twinview, my internal display is on an Intel GPU. I have no choice but to move my NVidia xorg.conf out of the way when I want to use the internal display, and then move it back when I get home and hook up to my monitors.

In 2012.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by glesica on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:05AM (#4068917)
This isn't really a commentary on Linux itself though. Optimus can cause issues on Windows, too. It's new tech and Linux support is at the bottom of vendors' "todo" lists.

The problem here is twofold, though I'm not necessarily saying these comments apply to you, you are apparently willing to endure some inconvenience.

First, people should always check hardware support before buying a laptop if they intend to install Linux. I'm not trying to be a neck-beaded dick (although I do need to shave), I'm just pointing out that many of the problems people have with Linux stem from well-known incompatibilities that could have been avoided with different hardware choices. Which brings me nicely to the second point...

There is a communication issue in the Linux community. We (I'm including myself here) need to stop over-selling Linux. It is not a computing panacea for everyone, and so long as hardware support lags behind Windows "selling" Linux as a drop-in Windows replacement isn't a good strategy.

Getting someone to install Ubuntu/Fedora/openSUSE isn't a victory for the community if his hardware isn't compatible and things don't work right. It would be better to tell him that he should think about purchasing a Linux-compatible computer in the future and perhaps directing him to a list of compatible hardware.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by simcop2387 on Monday June 04, 2012 @11:56PM (#4067246)
Yep that sounds like the horror that is Nvidia-Optimus. There's some kludges out there to do it all on the internal display, i don't know how well it works for mixing the two. I assume you've already looked at Bumblebee to see if it might help your situation?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:22AM (#4067449)
Bumblebee works if you actually want to use the internal and external at the same time, but I only ever use one or the other. Also, you lose 3d acceleration if you use it, AFAIK.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by wazoox on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:21AM (#4068996)
Something's wrong with your system. I use Slackware, I have a dual screen setup and no xorg.conf, all was configured with the catalyst panel. My colleague has some Acer Laptop running Ubuntu, and he sometimes connects an external 19" screen he has on his desktop, and he certainly hasn't any xorg.conf (and that's fortunate because he's utterly non-technical).
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:29AM (#4069031)
There's nothing wrong with my system. Neither you nor your colleague have Nvidia Optimus systems, which is why you're not having any issues. My problems are definitely not the norm, but the "Xorg.conf isn't used anymore" meme needs to die; there are still real problems to be addressed. Unless we identify them and deal with them, they'll still be there.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:20AM (#4067443)
Are you using the latest Ubuntu ? They said they improved on multi-monitors support on 12.04. I did not test myself, though.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:23AM (#4067451)
Yup, 12.04. It's because I'm using the NVidia driver for my externals, and Intel for my internal. No choice in the matter at the moment.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by esbwhat on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:28AM (#4067608)
You try bumblebee at all?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by daeken on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @03:06AM (#4067697)
Bumblebee solves the problem of using them together, and doesn't allow you to actually get 3d acceleration on the Nvidia chip. I just want to be able to easily switch between the two cards, but that won't happen, so the Xorg file moves will be necessary.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by josteink on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @08:38AM (#4068371)
1. As someone else noted, literally years since you ever had to touch config file by hand. Use Ubuntu, you'll love it.

Sure. But that wont cure a fundamental problem with the X11/Xorg infrastructure.

You cannot quickly and switch desktop orientation, resolution and layout (not to mention drivers) seamlessly like on Windows without killing your entire X-session. Killing your entire session. Jeez.

At the root of this problem is an architecture which is lagging on what Microsoft could deliver in Windows 98. You cannot make Windows and reboot-jokes while you have this Achilles-heel dragging your video subsystem. You seriously cannot.

And no new version of Ubuntu can overcome this underlying issue, no matter how much fluff and candy they add elsewhere, as long as they rely on the ancient relic that is X11.

As far as I know, when Google decided to make Android and ChromeOS (a complete failure as far as any metric goes, but still worth mentioning) they decided:

1. to base it on Linux, because that makes sense and

2. not to base it on X11 because they wanted it to be flexible and they wanted their users not be limited by what architects could think of in the 1984.

For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul. I cannot see anyone arguing this.

And even if seemingly everyone agrees on this, nobody is pushing forward for it to happen. Make of that what you like.

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @09:57AM (#4068621)
> You cannot quickly and switch desktop orientation, resolution and layout (not to mention drivers) seamlessly like on Windows without killing your entire X-session.

On my Ubuntu system, I can change orientation, resolution, and layout from a little control panel without restarting the session. I have no idea if Xorg restarts; the superficial behavior is almost identical to Windows. From the user's point of view, it doesn't seem to matter.

> For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul.

Every mainstream desktop environment seems to have handled the major aspects of display usability just fine. The only serious issues I've encountered have been one-off bugs related to drivers.

> I cannot see anyone arguing this.

Everyone agrees X is a mess. But why must we continue to use X and not Wayland?

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by krunaldo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @09:46AM (#4068586)
uh? You can change resolutions on the fly and orientation on the fly. This have been available for ages via xrandr and other things. Via API-calls or through the xrandr cli utility.

The only thing that is really ugly in X11 is the protocol, but so is win32 api :)

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by sciurus on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:33PM (#4066554)
Is there public information on the user studies Canonical has conducted on Unity or other desktop environments? It seems like that information would be very useful to other free software projects. All I can find are reports on empathy and rhythmbox.

http://design.canonical.com/the-research/

Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @10:00AM (#4068635)
The last published usability report on Unity seems to be from April 2011. http://design.canonical.com/2011/04/unity-benchmark-usabilit...
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ekianjo on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:22AM (#4067447)
I do not think that Canonical would share such data. That kind of research costs money, and they want to keep it to their advantage, most probably. You don't see Microsoft or Google release their user studies results either. Hardly surprising.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by aidenn0 on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:13PM (#4066482)
I dropped Ubuntu since after weeks of research and discussion, etc the only way I could get it to output acceptable screen resolution on my monitor was to hand enter a MODELINE. a !@#$@#$%@#$ Modeline; I couldn't remember the last time I typed in a modeline before this.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by simcop2387 on Monday June 04, 2012 @11:59PM (#4067257)
What kind of monitor? I'm curious to know to avoid them when I want one that doesn't need that kind of thing. The only times recently I've had to do that is for two specific cases, an arcade monitor that was built before EDID was a pipe dream, and a TV that likes to report that it has a native resolution of 320x240. Both of which would have to be worked around on any platform so I don't find it a problem.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:45PM (#4074782)
It is a Sun branded monitor with really broke-ass EDID, and I was using it just fine before having manually (but with a GUI) set the resolution and refresh rate.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by tene on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:23PM (#4066270)
It's been many years since I've had to touch xorg.conf to change screen resolution. I can do it on the command line (xrandr) or through gui tools. Do you have significantly unusual hardware?
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jff on Monday June 04, 2012 @06:43PM (#4066355)
I don't even have an xorg.conf. Things "just work", and if they don't, I use xrandr at the command line to fix things live. It's really gotten a lot better than the bad old days of hacking around with XF86Config.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by ricardobeat on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @12:43AM (#4067352)
Swapping xorg.conf for xrandr isn't a big win for most users. It is getting better, but things still fall apart like a sand castle when something goes wrong.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jlgreco on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:36AM (#4067630)
Considering there are plenty of GUI frontends for xrandr, of course it is better for most (all?) users.
Re:Valve Says "Yes" To Steam Linux This Year by jff on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @01:29PM (#4069694)
And even the command-line tool is far simpler than fiddling with xorg.conf. When I plug my laptop into its docking station, I run a little script to switch over to my two external monitors in portrait mode:

  #!/bin/sh
  xrandr --output LVDS1 --off
  xrandr --output VGA1 --mode 1920x1200 --rotate left
  xrandr --output HDMI1 --mode 1920x1200 --left-of VGA1 --rotate left
I could probably automate it, but this is easy enough that I don't care.