In 2012.
The problem here is twofold, though I'm not necessarily saying these comments apply to you, you are apparently willing to endure some inconvenience.
First, people should always check hardware support before buying a laptop if they intend to install Linux. I'm not trying to be a neck-beaded dick (although I do need to shave), I'm just pointing out that many of the problems people have with Linux stem from well-known incompatibilities that could have been avoided with different hardware choices. Which brings me nicely to the second point...
There is a communication issue in the Linux community. We (I'm including myself here) need to stop over-selling Linux. It is not a computing panacea for everyone, and so long as hardware support lags behind Windows "selling" Linux as a drop-in Windows replacement isn't a good strategy.
Getting someone to install Ubuntu/Fedora/openSUSE isn't a victory for the community if his hardware isn't compatible and things don't work right. It would be better to tell him that he should think about purchasing a Linux-compatible computer in the future and perhaps directing him to a list of compatible hardware.
Sure. But that wont cure a fundamental problem with the X11/Xorg infrastructure.
You cannot quickly and switch desktop orientation, resolution and layout (not to mention drivers) seamlessly like on Windows without killing your entire X-session. Killing your entire session. Jeez.
At the root of this problem is an architecture which is lagging on what Microsoft could deliver in Windows 98. You cannot make Windows and reboot-jokes while you have this Achilles-heel dragging your video subsystem. You seriously cannot.
And no new version of Ubuntu can overcome this underlying issue, no matter how much fluff and candy they add elsewhere, as long as they rely on the ancient relic that is X11.
As far as I know, when Google decided to make Android and ChromeOS (a complete failure as far as any metric goes, but still worth mentioning) they decided:
1. to base it on Linux, because that makes sense and
2. not to base it on X11 because they wanted it to be flexible and they wanted their users not be limited by what architects could think of in the 1984.
For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul. I cannot see anyone arguing this.
And even if seemingly everyone agrees on this, nobody is pushing forward for it to happen. Make of that what you like.
On my Ubuntu system, I can change orientation, resolution, and layout from a little control panel without restarting the session. I have no idea if Xorg restarts; the superficial behavior is almost identical to Windows. From the user's point of view, it doesn't seem to matter.
> For end-user Linux to ever become user-friendly Xorg needs a complete architectural overhaul.
Every mainstream desktop environment seems to have handled the major aspects of display usability just fine. The only serious issues I've encountered have been one-off bugs related to drivers.
> I cannot see anyone arguing this.
Everyone agrees X is a mess. But why must we continue to use X and not Wayland?
The only thing that is really ugly in X11 is the protocol, but so is win32 api :)
2. I do believe your view of Unity is a bit odd. Canonical recognized that the state of Linux UI/DE was NOT going to make the leap from programmer. They saw this VIA user studies. That is when they decided to create Unity. And user study after user study Unity keeps coming out ahead of all the other DE in Linux and is on par with usability of current OSX. Point being, Ubuntu is going after users the right way. Unity in 12.04 shows this and the reviews speak to it.
3. Sometimes you simply have to rewrite. This is a fact (sorry Joel) in software. The challenge is to recognize when it is necessary and avoid it when not 100% necessary to achieve your business objectives.