Yes, aka gambling.
> But they are losing you
That is true AND it is not what you paid for. Just like health insurance isn't paying for health but rather for coverage of bills related to loss of health. Being healthy is a win for health but not a win for buying health insurance. Being alive is a win for living but not a win for buying life insurance.
You're qubbling. You paid for replacement of the income and goods and services you can no longer provide, in the event of your death. Sure, that doesn't replace you in the eyes of your beneficiaries (assuming we're not taking the extremely cynical viewpoint about that), but of course nothing can replace you in that sense.
However, if your beneficiaries are financially secure enough that they do not need the insurance payout, i.e., if they're not depending on you for income or goods and services, then you should not be buying life insurance: you should be spending the premiums on something with a positive expected rate of financial return. The only reason to buy insurance in the first place is if your beneficaries are depending on you and will need something to replace you financially if you are no longer there.
This is indistinguishable from insurance, particularly when the beneficiary of insurance isn’t the subject (key-person insurance, for example, which you can view life insurance as a form of).
You’re saying that because these are morally different - which I don’t actually believe, given that options trading is another equivalent form of hedging/speculation, but I will grant - these are different things. But “fire which I use to cook dinner” and “fire which I use to torch a car during a riot” are both fire; the goal is different, but the object used is not. Let’s say I hedge a bunch of political risk by betting on politics. How is that different from buying a custom insurance policy from Lloyd’s or engaging in a bunch of interest rate swaps?
Drawing a distinction between betting and insurance on those lines is the same thing as saying “being long in a stock is morally good, being short in a stock is morally bad”, and I don’t think that position holds up.
To me it sounds like you're saying whenever you like it, you will call it insurance, and whenever you don't like it, you will call it gambling. "It" is not apriori anything, until you have decided what you want to call it. That makes it all the same thing, pretty much.
As other commenters mention, the main way this works is by making it impossible to "win" at insurance. You aren't hoping for the rare payout event to happen, like you would be when gambling. Having your house burn down, or getting into a car accident, or needing treatment for cancer, or dying are all really bad even if insurance reimburses the monetary costs involved.
This is probably why the concept of "insurable interest" exists; without it, it would be possible to use insurance products as gambling.
If I’m the landlord of a pub in Glasgow, and Scotland get to the finals of Euro 2024 (we won’t, but work with me here), betting on Scotland losing the final is a reasonable hedge against the profits you’ll lose when everyone goes home depressed after the final rather than buying another round. Is that a contrived example? A little bit, but it’s structurally reasonable. (If you’re a sponsor of the Scotland team, gambling on the result could be hedging media risk).
Can you leverage yourself up? Yes, but you can do that in the stock exchange or futures market too. They’re all the same thing.
Insurance might be a kind of “hedging” but in a limited way that makes it not gambling.
Buying a position out of nowhere is gambling. Buying a position to directly counteract the position you already have is not gambling.
If you short 50 shares of a stock when you already owned 80 shares, you are doing the opposite of gambling. You are reducing your position.
I don’t think gambling is inherently immoral; I think mismanaging risk (in either direction) is one of the ways people mess themselves up and therefore encouraging people to take bad risks is immoral. This is not quite the same thing, though it’s close - but the difference between these two positions is what led to prohibition.
Don’t get me wrong, bookies are awful in many ways, but so are bars and crypto exchanges and E*Trade. The right approach in all cases is harm reduction.
If someone has an equal number of short and long shares in a single company, they are not gambling. Surely we can agree on that, right? We don't have to use the word gambling, we can say they're not investing either. Their money does not change at all based on the stock market or any other external factors.
Now what if they have more short or more long shares. We can say that gambling or investing is happening, right?
What do we call the process of moving from a net-nonzero position toward net zero? Isn't it the opposite of gambling? Or the opposite of investing?
But come on, counterparty risk with big institutions is such a small thing. Are you going to tell me that putting your money in a vault is gambling because someone could steal it? Is subscribing to Netflix gambling because the servers might go down?
Having a net-zero position is the closest to not gambling anyone can get.
How about this, can we agree that having short or long stocks is a high number out of 10 on the gambling scale, but just counterparty risk with an enormous company is a 2 out of 10? What do we call the process of reducing your number from high to 2?
That’s not how the English language works. Insurance is a noun (I have insurance) but gambling is not (you can not possess a gamble). In your analogy, you would “cook” your food or “commit arson.” The purpose of your action is intrinsically tied to the words we use to describe it.
Gambling is engaging in a game of chance to get a favourable outcome. Insuring is paying money now to mitigate the risk of losing more money later. The fact that both are financial activities doesn’t mean they’re the same thing.
I have no interest in the Humpty Dumpty principle of word usage. My point was not about the names we use for things, but about the things themselves. You can't make what has been called "gambling" in the discussion up to now the same thing as what has been called "insurance" in the discussion up to now by changing the words you use to describe them.
> You’re saying that because these are morally different
I have said nothing whatever about the relative morality of gambling vs. insurance. I have only pointed out that they are not the same thing, they are opposites--gambling is taking on risk, insurance is transferring it.
That's true, but it doesn't mean insurance and gambling are the same thing.
> These are the same thing dressed in different names.
No, they're not. In gambling, I accept the risk involved in a wide variance in payoffs, for the entertainment value involved (since I can imagine that I might be a big winner); on net I am paying money for entertainment. In insurance, I transfer the risk involved in a wide variance in payoffs, for the peace of mind of not having to worry about being bankrupted if a rare but catastrophic event occurs; on net I am paying money for peace of mind (since I don't have to imagine that I might be a big loser).
> Consider term life insurance instead
But your next of kin only gets a payout if you die during the term. If you don't, nobody gets any payout and all the premiums you paid are lost. Which, since insurance companies make money selling term life insurance, is the expected average result. So on net, you do not make money buying term life insurance--but, as above, you might still do it if the peace of mind involved is worth it to you.
> your next of kin does just actually get a fat check.
But they are losing you--and even if we go to extreme cynicism about that, they are losing whatever income and other goods and services you provided, for which the check will hopefully be enough to compensate them. So it's not a pure gain with no offsetting loss, even leaving out the premiums paid.