News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by Dylan16807 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @02:49AM (#40622524)
The difference is not vibes! Reducing your position is the opposite of increasing your position, and those things are very objective.

If someone has an equal number of short and long shares in a single company, they are not gambling. Surely we can agree on that, right? We don't have to use the word gambling, we can say they're not investing either. Their money does not change at all based on the stock market or any other external factors.

Now what if they have more short or more long shares. We can say that gambling or investing is happening, right?

What do we call the process of moving from a net-nonzero position toward net zero? Isn't it the opposite of gambling? Or the opposite of investing?

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by adw on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:42AM (#40630568)
They are absolutely gambling; there are various ways that position can blow up. (Consider counterparty risk.)
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by Dylan16807 on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:26AM (#40631689)
What counterparty risk? You own stocks and you owe stocks. How can that go wrong?

But come on, counterparty risk with big institutions is such a small thing. Are you going to tell me that putting your money in a vault is gambling because someone could steal it? Is subscribing to Netflix gambling because the servers might go down?

Having a net-zero position is the closest to not gambling anyone can get.

How about this, can we agree that having short or long stocks is a high number out of 10 on the gambling scale, but just counterparty risk with an enormous company is a 2 out of 10? What do we call the process of reducing your number from high to 2?