Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by khaki54 on Saturday June 08, 2024 @08:10AM
(#40617023)
Is it as simple as people don't want to get speeding tickets? Certainly any stand out colors increase your chances of being noticed and tracked by law enforcement everything else equal.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by AlotOfReading on Saturday June 08, 2024 @09:02AM
(#40617280)
The dynamic that drives almost all other vehicle decisions is the concept of "least offensive". The choices made don't reflect opinionated beliefs about what a car should be, but are made from the perspective of minimizing the number of people who won't buy it because it doesn't meet some important requirement on their list.
There are many people who will not buy a colorful car. There are very few people who won't buy a car if the color is too plain. Therefore people value the colorful cars less because there's a smaller customer base and the market shifts to producing vehicles in plain, minimally offensive colors.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ghaff on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:40AM
(#40617825)
A lot of people go into a car dealership because they need a car right now because of an accident or an impending expensive repair. If the only option on the lot is in hot pink, that might be enough to make the buyer go to the dealership the next town over but white/silver/gray options may be "good enough" even if that's not what the buyer would pick out of the catalog all other things being equal.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by mojomark on Saturday June 08, 2024 @09:12AM
(#40617333)
If you want a great deep dive on this offbeat topic (with interview directly from the person who selects/fabricates/implements car paint colors at Subaru), I highly recommend this Freakonomics podcast episode:
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by gizajob on Saturday June 08, 2024 @09:49AM
(#40617534)
Is it maybe because nobody owns them, because they’re all on finance, and so will be traded in for new in three years time and so it’s best that they be as generic as possible for the next buyer?
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by PaulRobinson on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:52AM
(#40617917)
Resale value is a massive part of this.
Corporate buyers (fleet owners, hire car companies, and so on) don't want to deal with drivers complaining about a colour they don't like - in the UK giving certain colour cars to employees who support certain football teams is going to just cause pushback. Neutrals just make life a lot easier.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by IshKebab on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:24AM
(#40617741)
Yeah this must be half the reason. You don't want to buy an orange car because you'll possibly sell it one day and that likely restricts your market.
I think the other reason is probably that car manufacturers charge crazy amounts for non-default colours, so presumably everyone is buying the stock colours and those have to be fairly generic.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ComputerGuru on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:03AM
(#40617986)
I just want to say that you are likely giving the average American consumer a ton of more financial foresight and rational thinking than they likely possess. People buying trucks to use as commuter vehicles at exorbitant interest rates, brand new off the dealer’s lot and falling for the various add-ons and upsells are likely not prioritizing their ten-year profit and loss sheets.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ToValueFunfetti on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:22AM
(#40618122)
"People buying new trucks" already restricts you to 5% of the vehicle transactions in a given year, with ~25% of purchases being new and ~20% of those being trucks. Factor in the rest of the criteria and I don't think you're really capturing the average transaction at all.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by matt-attack on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:32AM
(#40625124)
It’s got nothing to do with cars and the focus on them alone will lead to the wrong confusion. Grey -scale palettes have taken over the world. Look at houses, home interiors, even fashion. It’s everywhere.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by chiph on Saturday June 08, 2024 @09:50AM
(#40617542)
My rule of thumb is that the smaller the car, or the faster the car - the brighter the color should be. The first criteria is related to safety - being seen by larger vehicles is important to not being hit by them. And the second criteria is all about ego ;)
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ghaff on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:48AM
(#40618337)
Someone I know had a new house built fairly recently. I don't think there's a splash of anything that is not some shade of gray in the entire house. It would... not have been my choice.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by dangus on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:13AM
(#40617680)
No, I wouldn’t compare this to interior design trends, especially since it’s the complete opposite trend going on right now with colorful postmodernism.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by FooBarBizBazz on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:27AM
(#40617757)
I'd disagree. The public is rainbows; the private is gray. Google is rainbows, and the exterior cladding of the new apartment block is not unusually rainbows. But new kitchens, living rooms, and bathrooms are all gray.
And I do think it connects to cars. There's been a recent trend (maybe now a year or so passe, but still relatively strong) for Nardo Grey.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by rainsford on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:22AM
(#40617731)
The fleet explanation only really makes sense for a handful of vehicle makes and models. I can't imagine fleet sales of Mazdas make much of a dent in their market, but most Mazdas are still pretty bland colors.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by dangus on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:12AM
(#40617672)
I think I read somewhere that the average new car buyer is about 50 years old now. Everyone else is generally buying used.
When I think about the cars with lively colors that were available in the 2000s I think about a lot of cars designed to be “first cars” for youth buyers. Brands like Scion and makes like the Neon. But nobody is going to make cars like that when their buyer has much more toned down sensibilities.
I also buy the argument that so many cars sold on leases will influence the options available. No dealer wants to lease out an odd package of options like a pink manual transmission CRV with the top trim package and have to turn around and try to sell that after the car is returned.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by nytesky on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:34AM
(#40617784)
We keep our cars at least a decade. Any color other than white or black will date the car fierce and many age poorly (I mean Teal went cool to lame in a snap — and I loved it in ‘92).
Honestly I felt that gunmetal grey would also age/date a car, but it does have staying power.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by jmugan on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:24AM
(#40617743)
My impression is that people want colorful cars, it's just that for some reason they aren't being produced. Maybe its like aisle airline seats. I saw for Volkswagen that to get a nice color you had to upgrade.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by bryanlarsen on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:26AM
(#40617754)
I was really hoping that the build to order trend would combat this. Dealerships aren't going to have a purple car on their lot for obvious reasons. But why doesn't Tesla let you order a purple car?
Yes, it complicates Tesla's logistics, but there are people that want purple cars and that's a market opportunity for Tesla and other BTO manufacturers.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by flutas on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:14AM
(#40618056)
In China, Tesla actually lets you fully wrap your car when ordering and it comes pre-installed.
I really want to see something like that come to the US, as it means you could have the bland color underneath to preserve the resale value argument, while having the color you want.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by GarnetFloride on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:35AM
(#40617792)
Don't forget about that earthquake in Japan in 2011 knocked out the only factory making automotive paint for a while. They focused on black and white until it was back up and running.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by AuryGlenz on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:59AM
(#40617960)
I couldn’t get my Camaro in the color I wanted because of this.
That color was grey, though, so…
What I really would have liked was an orange, but they only had an orange that was more red than orange - along with two other red options. I also would have gone for a nice deep green, but they only had a bright lime green that’s very similar to my two year old’s Power Wheels.
For me the reason I ended up with a neutral color (white) is because I didn’t like the color options given to me. The first manufacturer that figures out a process to let people choose from hundreds of colors will make bank.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by VoodooJuJu on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:53AM
(#40617931)
Yeah, but sadd colors [1] have been preferred by Puritans for hundreds of years.
Puritan-descended cultures are today still one of the most dominant cultural forces in America. And with the persistent preference for sadd, it seems less like a trend and more like a deeply-embedded cultural preference.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by mewpmewp2 on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:49AM
(#40617895)
Colorful cars when it is not the norm seem like you would be making some sort of statement, seem less professional, not classy. Maybe seem childish. Just a riskier option. Possibly harder to resell, might get tired of it, etc.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by greenthrow on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:51AM
(#40617913)
It seems like colors are starting to come back. GM, Ford and Toyota have begun offering more bright/playful colors on their cars in recent years. For a while now I think people have been afraid to get a "weird" color not only because of resale value but also because people don't want their choice of car to reflect poorly on them in their eyes of others. White/grey/silver/black have been the "safe" choices for a long time, but I think now we're starting to see that change to them being the "boring" colors, and I think that will help fuel the shift to colorful cars returning.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by standardUser on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:02AM
(#40617975)
I don't think people care about cars nearly as much these days, in part because they don't have to. Cars last a long time and repairs can almost never be done without a shop, so it's suddenly a lot less engaging to be "into" cars. Now it's more like buying a new refrigerator - a major purchase that is expected to do it's one job very well and for so long that you don't even have to think about how long that might be.
So, maybe it's not surprising that cars are becoming the same color as appliances.
There's also a noticeable pro-transit, meh-cars sentiment among Millennials/younger people that is in stark contrast to previous generations who seemed to place a lot of personal and cultural significance on their car. But between rideshares and more urban living, Millennials are probably the first generation to have less need of a personal car since there's been cars.
Come to think of it, I can't think of anyone I know who owns a car that was not chosen in the same way we'd choose an appliance. There's no sports cars, nothing luxury beyond the average luxury sedan, no pickup trucks or jeeps or anything other than practical 4 door vehicles of various sizes with lots of safety features and good gas mileage (if not electric).
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ghaff on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:22AM
(#40618119)
I wouldn't say that my circles are especially car enthusiast oriented. But pretty much everyone I know--including myself--chose our vehicles pretty deliberately in support of outdoor activities.
I did have a small sporty vehicle as well but that didn't make sense once I didn't have a commute any longer.
But I don't live in a city and rarely travel to one in which case my priorities might be different--though even the people I know who do live in the city pretty much all own vehicles for weekend activities.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by brightlancer on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:40AM
(#40618263)
> There's also a noticeable pro-transit, meh-cars sentiment among Millennials/younger people
I read this a lot but I don't find the data that supports it. There appears to be a very loud group of millennials online who won't shut up about how awful cars are, but I can't find data supporting this among the age cohort.
(Also, generation theory is great for napkin math but so misleading that it shouldn't be used for serious work. In doing a quick search to see if maybe I had just missed obvious data, I found studies using different year brackets for "Millennials", which makes this all apples and oranges.)
> Come to think of it, I can't think of anyone I know who owns a car that was not chosen in the same way we'd choose an appliance. There's no sports cars, nothing luxury beyond the average luxury sedan, no pickup trucks or jeeps or anything other than practical 4 door vehicles of various sizes with lots of safety features and good gas mileage (if not electric).
I spent most of my adult life in Georgia, in Atlanta specifically and also in the ginormous metro. I've known plenty of folks who drove pickups and jeeps, sports cars and muscle cars. And tons of SUVs. More than luxury sedans, folks would buy luxury SUVs. There were regular sedans, but those tended to be older and/or the second car. I can't think of anyone who went out and bought a new Camry.
Re:Cars Are Way Less Colorful Today Than They Were 20 Years ...
by ghaff on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:10AM
(#40618029)
Probably to some degree. For existing older houses, of course you play the cards you're dealt to some degree. But for a new build that you have a lot of flexibility with, I assume most builders would counsel against putting one bathroom or a minimalist kitchen in an otherwise high-end house--even if you're a single person who doesn't cook.
There are many people who will not buy a colorful car. There are very few people who won't buy a car if the color is too plain. Therefore people value the colorful cars less because there's a smaller customer base and the market shifts to producing vehicles in plain, minimally offensive colors.
https://freakonomics.com/podcast/car-colors/
Also this: https://www.hagerty.co.uk/articles/automotive-history/vw-pol...
Corporate buyers (fleet owners, hire car companies, and so on) don't want to deal with drivers complaining about a colour they don't like - in the UK giving certain colour cars to employees who support certain football teams is going to just cause pushback. Neutrals just make life a lot easier.
(Site blocks EU citizens)
I think the other reason is probably that car manufacturers charge crazy amounts for non-default colours, so presumably everyone is buying the stock colours and those have to be fairly generic.
I live in a rather hot place where most cars are white, once again because everyone gets a white car because of the sun.
https://www.purewow.com/home/beigification-beige-color-trend
https://www.businessinsider.com/millennial-gray-home-interio...
And I do think it connects to cars. There's been a recent trend (maybe now a year or so passe, but still relatively strong) for Nardo Grey.
https://www.blackbirdspyplane.com/p/why-do-new-cars-look-lik...
There's a lot of gray.
Here are a few resources/articles that get into that discussion:
https://www.architecturaldigest.com/story/gen-z-interior-des...
Check out how colorful IKEA's resugent retro designs are:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRSJqGficVw
Postmodern design (trending in 2022 and beyond):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NA5Pj0_yCaQ
Auto makers sell mostly black and white vehicles, and because of that, they think that's what people want.
The reason, though, is that fleet buyers (especially governments at all levels) only buy black or white vehicles, because they're easy to brand.
Ten people buying red cars with green stripes aren't going to register when the city Public Works department buys 1,000 plain white ones.
Then the auto makers stop making red cars with green stripes, and the regular people end up buying black and white because that's what's available.
However their neighbours at Honda only seem to have desaturated colours that may as well be grey...
When I think about the cars with lively colors that were available in the 2000s I think about a lot of cars designed to be “first cars” for youth buyers. Brands like Scion and makes like the Neon. But nobody is going to make cars like that when their buyer has much more toned down sensibilities.
I also buy the argument that so many cars sold on leases will influence the options available. No dealer wants to lease out an odd package of options like a pink manual transmission CRV with the top trim package and have to turn around and try to sell that after the car is returned.
Honestly I felt that gunmetal grey would also age/date a car, but it does have staying power.
Yes, it complicates Tesla's logistics, but there are people that want purple cars and that's a market opportunity for Tesla and other BTO manufacturers.
I really want to see something like that come to the US, as it means you could have the bland color underneath to preserve the resale value argument, while having the color you want.
That color was grey, though, so…
What I really would have liked was an orange, but they only had an orange that was more red than orange - along with two other red options. I also would have gone for a nice deep green, but they only had a bright lime green that’s very similar to my two year old’s Power Wheels.
For me the reason I ended up with a neutral color (white) is because I didn’t like the color options given to me. The first manufacturer that figures out a process to let people choose from hundreds of colors will make bank.
http://www.benspaintsupply.com/2011/05/japan-tragedy-affects...
Personally I'm hoping it's sooner then later because I want to see more color in design.
Puritan-descended cultures are today still one of the most dominant cultural forces in America. And with the persistent preference for sadd, it seems less like a trend and more like a deeply-embedded cultural preference.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sadd_colors
If those colors were actually available in new vehicles, then there would be no article about the variety decline.
Anyway, Jeep has been great about offering bright colors, and I love my fuchsia Jeep, and my yellow Jeep. Life is too short to live greyscale.
And other people tend to love the pink Jeep. I wrote about some of the reactions I’ve received: https://opposite-lock.com/topic/52688/tuscadero
A far greater effect are Home Owners Associations, city ordinances etc.
So, maybe it's not surprising that cars are becoming the same color as appliances.
There's also a noticeable pro-transit, meh-cars sentiment among Millennials/younger people that is in stark contrast to previous generations who seemed to place a lot of personal and cultural significance on their car. But between rideshares and more urban living, Millennials are probably the first generation to have less need of a personal car since there's been cars.
Come to think of it, I can't think of anyone I know who owns a car that was not chosen in the same way we'd choose an appliance. There's no sports cars, nothing luxury beyond the average luxury sedan, no pickup trucks or jeeps or anything other than practical 4 door vehicles of various sizes with lots of safety features and good gas mileage (if not electric).
I did have a small sporty vehicle as well but that didn't make sense once I didn't have a commute any longer.
But I don't live in a city and rarely travel to one in which case my priorities might be different--though even the people I know who do live in the city pretty much all own vehicles for weekend activities.
I read this a lot but I don't find the data that supports it. There appears to be a very loud group of millennials online who won't shut up about how awful cars are, but I can't find data supporting this among the age cohort.
(Also, generation theory is great for napkin math but so misleading that it shouldn't be used for serious work. In doing a quick search to see if maybe I had just missed obvious data, I found studies using different year brackets for "Millennials", which makes this all apples and oranges.)
> Come to think of it, I can't think of anyone I know who owns a car that was not chosen in the same way we'd choose an appliance. There's no sports cars, nothing luxury beyond the average luxury sedan, no pickup trucks or jeeps or anything other than practical 4 door vehicles of various sizes with lots of safety features and good gas mileage (if not electric).
I spent most of my adult life in Georgia, in Atlanta specifically and also in the ginormous metro. I've known plenty of folks who drove pickups and jeeps, sports cars and muscle cars. And tons of SUVs. More than luxury sedans, folks would buy luxury SUVs. There were regular sedans, but those tended to be older and/or the second car. I can't think of anyone who went out and bought a new Camry.
... can this be extended to homes? And I don't mean only paint colours, but also size, layout etc.
It is because if you buy one item in huge quantities it is cheaper. Then the car manufacturers negociate a small number of colors.