Of course, the same apps with security questions are probably the ones not hashing your actual password in the first place.
Think about last names, as well... there's huge variety in length, spelling, etc. -- it's poor customer service to force the customer to spell it out letter by letter -- so it's necessarily just displayed there on their screen.
The problem is that most sites won't let you set your own question. More about my idea on security questions: http://lucb1e.com/!65
One of the worst sites I saw demanded that I select my security question from a list. Sweet gosh, I have absolutely no idea which of your brain-addled security choices I selected.
"...but the account is being used for malicious purposes." - me
"Sorry, sir but until you tell me what you named your first dog I cannot stop it." - AOL
Do you mind if I quote you (with link) on my blog?
Google, too. I suggest you run through the recovery process yourself (on a dummy account, or your own) to see the kinds of questions asked. Questions like "when did you last access the account?" are easily answered; as is "name 5 regular contacts"; and so on. I could (but would not) perform the recovery process (and gain access to) acquaintances accounts, given how simple the questions are.
The key is just knowing "enough" in aggregate to pass their bar.
"...left curly brace. No, it's like the parenthesis, but squiggly. Are you using a regular keyboard? Hold shift and type the left square bracket. The square one. It's to the right of the P..."
Nightmare.
"No, the backslash. The one that leans backwards, no, I mean, to the left. Above the Enter key." Surprise, the backslash is not above the Enter key on Canadian bilingual keyboards.
What kind of company asks you to tell them your password by phone?
I don't remember for sure. I think it was a utility company.1Password gladly generates "pronounceable" passwords (e.g. "thax-lers-ponc-werv"). I usually think a bit about whether digits or symbols are required (some services and websites - Skype notably) don't like them.
A 20-char passphrase with spaces, dashes, or character-based (e.g. "S") word-boundary delimiter is often good enough to provide excellent (80+ bits) entropy.
Imagine I'm trying to crack into your site, and you lock any account after 5 failed logins in a row.
If I have access to (or can guess) a few thousand usernames, I can try the 4 most common passwords on all of those with no problems. I'll probably get some hits, no?
Or heck, I can try the 5 most common passwords, and not only will I have a few hits, I'll also have plenty of time to dig around without any attention from you, because you'll be struggling with a massive customer service nightmare, as thousands of your customers find themselves all locked out the same morning.
Edit: see my response to shard. No offense intended, and I hope none was taken :)
for more relevant info google "hunter2"
I bought a house last month, and the biggest thorn in my side throughout all of the financial arrangements was security questions (I'm not even joking). Here's a Facebook status update I posted (I had already been complaining about security questions a bunch):
"Just got challenged with a security question, which was "Thank you for your loan application." Wtf, that is not a question. And I've never filled out any security questions for this website, so I have no idea what it's expecting me to enter.
"I swear, security questions are out to get me."