News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by jmclnx on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:46PM (#40612785)
I still believe it was due to Humans. Megafauna disappeared around the time Humans reached the Americas, way too much of a coincidence to me. These mammals were there before the Ice Age and I think the coming of the ice age was just as hard on then as the retreating ice.

The difference were humans.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by hi-v-rocknroll on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:58PM (#40614133)
Yep. I can't prove it but I know it's true. Us humans have caused too much environmental harm to list, but here are the top hits:

- Chopped down all the trees on Easter Island

- Overharvested laserpicium in Cyrenaica (Libya)

- Hunted passenger pigeons to extinction

- Hunted bison nearly to extinction

- Overfished sardines off Monterey Bay California

Tragedy of the Commons is the default setting for most all of human history, while sustainability like ancient Japan and modern regulations in most countries are the exceptions. And, anthropogenic climate change is indirectly leading to untold mass extinctions on a global scale.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by longitudinal93 on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:49PM (#40613330)
It's the same story in Australia. Several large slow creatures that disappeared shortly after the arrival of humans. I think trying to pin the blame solely on the weather is simply because it's much more in sync with the "stewards and custodians of the land" narrative that is currently so fashionable.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by MaxHoppersGhost on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:12PM (#40613508)
My thoughts as well. If the native Americans had the technological ability to extinct the Buffalo they would have done it. Just as they killed off many more fragile species and other tribes. Life in pre Colombian America was just as nasty as it was in post Colombian America.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by earthboundkid on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:26PM (#40613601)
> If the native Americans had the technological ability to extinct the Buffalo

I think it's more the case of if they didn't have the ability to create a balance. Things like the creation of the Amazon rainforest and the domestication of corn, potatoes, tomatoes, quinoa, llamas, etc. were because Native Americans figured out how to do those things. It's likely though that the first Native Americans just didn't know that stuff yet and accidentally ate all the mammoths or whatever because they didn't yet have a tradition of "only eat the mammoths when the third moon rises after Orion returns" or whatever. Those kinds of cultural traditions are social technologies, and they enable ways of life that would otherwise collapse in a few decades.

In the Pacific, Hawaiians and others had seemingly useless taboos like "women can't eat bananas" but following the taboo rules sustained a huge population (estimates for Hawaii vary, but it was at least a significant fraction of the current population without international shipping!).

In the Amazon, manioc is a great staple crop… as long as you serve it exactly right so you don't slowly poison yourself. They figured that out, but I'm sure there were many generations that got it wrong before they got it right.

So I don't think the framing should be "plains Indians didn't know how to kill off the buffalo." Rather a) plains Indians didn't have horses pre-European contact, so that whole way of life didn't exist until modernity and b) balancing with nature is a learned cultural achievement.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by bitcurious on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:15PM (#40613878)
> Things like the creation of the Amazon rainforest

Kind of a ridiculous myth when you consider the diversity of life uniquely adapted to the various micro environments of the amazon rainforest. It would be multi-million-year terraforming project.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by earthboundkid on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @11:59PM (#40654343)
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by colechristensen on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:48PM (#40613734)
No, it's not about any woo woo natural balance. Mammoths were really easy to kill and if they were anything like their elephant cousins would have taken 10-15 years to reach sexual maturity. Their population would also be considerably lower and larger animals are more sensitive to change because they reproduce slower and their are fewer of them.

Buffalo on the other hand reach sexual maturity at 2-3 years, there were many more of them. They replaced their populations faster.

The first humans in North America didn't extinct buffalo because they couldn't, they would have had to have much more population and civilization progress before that became a risk.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by Log_out_ on Saturday June 08, 2024 @01:31AM (#40615489)
You are right. But you are trying to educate a political vital mythos away, that just can not die. The noble savage always wins, as it is a coreconcept of the back to nature "movement".
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by earthboundkid on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @11:58PM (#40654328)
It's not "noble savage" to note that Native Americans domesticated numerous crops used globally today and that such domestication was a technological achievement, much like the domestication of the horse in central Eurasia or the cultivation of rice in Asia. It's basically the opposite idea: rather than being "naturally" in balance with nature, Native Americans figured it out the same way humans figured everything else, through trial and error, and at the cost of countless lives. It is closer to the stereotype to believe that Plains Indians had some kind of timeless way of life, instead of recognizing they occupied a temporary historical niche that lasted between the introduction of the horse and the near extinction of the buffalo. Introducing history to our understanding of Native American achievements and failures is the only way to treat them as equally human as every other culture.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by doubloon on Friday June 07, 2024 @11:23PM (#40615031)
citation needed.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by warcher on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:18PM (#40613549)
I have yet to come to a satisfying explanation for the origin of that fetish.

I suppose in the absence of any historical record you can make up whatever story you like, but the self flagellation that comes with it is so weird.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by tazu on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:51PM (#40613754)
Isn't is just the noble savage fallacy as usual?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by warcher on Saturday June 08, 2024 @12:57AM (#40615397)
Yeah but what’s with the masochism attached to it?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by WithinReason on Saturday June 08, 2024 @02:48AM (#40615776)
My theory it's due to the plethora of nature documentaries making humans into villains. It worked.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by askvictor on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:00PM (#40613429)
I thought it was accepted that Australian megafauna went extinct due to humans. But could also be a combination of factors e.g weakened by a climatic shift then finished off by newly arrived human predators
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by sudofail on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:55PM (#40613385)
Or simply because we don't have evidance of Homo Sapiens in the Americas until ~20k years ago, 30k years after megafuana extinction.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by mkl on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:18PM (#40613894)
The extinction doesn't seem to have happened 50k years ago in North America. That seems to have been made up by whoever wrote the headline. The date of 50k years ago does not seem to appear anywhere in the linked academic paper, does not correspond to climate change at the start of the current interglacial, and does not correspond to evidence of the arrival of humans in North America. Even the body of the phys.org article doesn't say the extinction happened then.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by colechristensen on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:52PM (#40613763)
There were wooly mammoths alive in 2000 BC, 600 years after the Great Pyramid was built. There is evidence of humans and mammoths being in north America together.

https://www.livescience.com/woolly-mammoths-in-north-america...

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by dexwiz on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:04PM (#40612977)
What about the inverse? Humans expanded to the Americas after megafauna populations were reduced. Its easy to look at things like poaching and assume humans have always been the dominate species. But megafanua like moose or brown bears are still dangerous, even today.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by cjbgkagh on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:51PM (#40613343)
We don’t spend much time dealing with mega fauna like moose or brown bears anymore so are generally unprepared for it. But if it was a bigger part of our lives I’m pretty sure we would dominate even with cavemen level tools.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by dixhsgfd on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:26PM (#40613937)
I think a lot of the megafuauna have bones found near humans and other signs of hunting and the inverse meaning human bones with animal bites isn’t as common.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by dexwiz on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:51PM (#40614088)
Yeah, I am playing a bit of devils advocate here. Things like glyptodon would have been easy targets in theory.

I do wonder if human processing of animals makes their bones more likely to find. Most of what we find about ancient humans comes from trash pits. Animals don’t always bring food to the same place, and scavengers can further distribute and decompose parts.

There have been cases of human bone caches made by animals, like in the Sauida Arabian lava tube. But that seems like a relatively ideal condition for long term preservation.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by ramblenode on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:57PM (#40614442)
> But megafanua like moose or brown bears are still dangerous, even today.

They are dangerous to individual humans but they are a resource to groups of humans.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by chrisco255 on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:56PM (#40612888)
Actually they're not really clear on the timelines of extinction and arrival so it's not an open and shut case.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by RajT88 on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:06PM (#40613828)
I am reserving judgement.

But extincting megafauna sure sounds like something we would do.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by mdavidn on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:02PM (#40612946)
The same fate befell the moa, a large flightless bird native to New Zealand.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by mkl on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:33PM (#40613976)
And New Zealand's other big birds (e.g. giant geese, harriers, eagles, swans [1]), after humans arrived.

And elephant birds and giant lemurs in Madagascar, after humans arrived.

And many large animals in Australia (giant wombats, kangaroos, marsupial "lions", etc. [2]), after humans arrived.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Extinct_birds_of_New_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_megafauna

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by lostlogin on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:51PM (#40613353)
The Haast Eagle too. They hunted Moa, and as you’d expect from an eagle that hunted 200kg birds, it too was a monster.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haast%27s_eagle

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by benced on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:10PM (#40613029)
At this point, I regard most efforts in this direction as silly and ill-fated attempts to exonerate us. I'm not entirely sure why either.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by TeaBrain on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:17PM (#40613891)
Exonerate who? None of us were around 50k years ago.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by rfwhyte on Friday June 07, 2024 @06:20PM (#40613562)
Another fact that supports this perspective is that the North American megafauna survived through numerous cycles of ice ages prior to the arrival of humans. There was nothing particularly unique or special about the last ice age, the only real difference was the presence of humans.

One thing I find particular interesting though, is that there are likely two unique extinction events. One around 50KYA, that coincides with what I personally believe was the first peopling of the Americas, and another around 16KYA, which coincides with the arrival of North Americas current indigenous population.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by IncreasePosts on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:49PM (#40614402)
My problem with humans did it, even though it seems most likely, is there weren't very many humans, and the Americas are so large. Wouldn't some isolated populations continue to exist? Also, where are all the megafauna remains in middens?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by WithinReason on Saturday June 08, 2024 @02:45AM (#40615761)
Humans might have migrated because the Ice Age ended. Correlation ≠ causation.