News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by lemoncookiechip on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:42AM (#40607656)
These are all valid alternatives with real world use, but none of them are Photoshop, and that's kinda the problem we face.

Krita - https://krita.org/en/

Photopea - https://www.photopea.com/

GIMP - https://www.gimp.org/

inkspace - https://inkscape.org/

Affinity Photo - https://affinity.serif.com/en-us/photo/

Paint.Net - https://www.getpaint.net/

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by dlachausse on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:58AM (#40607785)
If you have a Mac, Pixelmator Pro is a great alternative as well.

https://www.pixelmator.com/pro/

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by cjk2 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:08AM (#40607877)
+1 for pixelmator

Annoyingly there is nothing that gets close to Lightroom at the moment :(

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by optician_owl on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:14AM (#40607923)
Capture One.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by cjk2 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:16AM (#40607944)
Yeah after posting that I'm actually downloading the trial now :)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by goopthink on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:21AM (#40607985)
ACDSee
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by heartbreak on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:36AM (#40608099)
Have you tried Photomator from the Pixelmator folks?
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by coldtea on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:41AM (#40608142)
Until recently it couldn't really compete for what people use Lightroom for aside from editing (because it didn't have photo management). They've added it since a few months now in version 3.x.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by hajile on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:53AM (#40608260)
Darktable is decent (in my experience).

https://www.darktable.org/

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:48AM (#40609273)
Capture One is head and shoulders above Lightroom.

But then so is its price, and it's a subscription model or a perpetual-and-no-updates model, which is an uncomfortable choice.

I like DxO PhotoLab a lot -- it's my preferred tool because I find its raw conversions to be much more useful if you're trying to work with cameras of multiple ages and manufacturers -- but it lacks some of the library management that a lot of people like or need (stock shooters, journalists).

Library management is not really an issue for me, and PhotoLab works well. Plus the simulations in FilmPack are, IMO, the best in the business for stills.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by Cyberdog on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:42AM (#40608155)
Everyone always forgets about Acorn. :(

https://flyingmeat.com/acorn/

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by pajko on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:13AM (#40607916)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by spaniard89277 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:01AM (#40607808)
My GF is a Designer/UX and she's been using Affinity tools and Cavalry (for animating stuff) and she's happy so far.

Figma now requires to pay for the Dev mode, but that's ok.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by oniony on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:45AM (#40608183)
I thought Adobe acquired Figma.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by janosdebugs on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:57AM (#40608292)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by ffsm8 on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:58AM (#40607781)
For non professional use, photopea is seriously great too. Literally just a website you open that imitates the older Photoshop UI (pre-creative cloud)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by ImHereToVote on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:47AM (#40608203)
Unfortunately Photopea can't have floating point precision since it is dependent on browser support.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by ffsm8 on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:02AM (#40608818)
Technically speaking, it still could. It'd just have to implement it itself via strings. But yeah, it probably doesn't do that (I can't speak about the implementation, I'm entirely uninvolved).

Though I've never actually encountered any errors because of that as my usecases are always pretty basic. Things like magic select, transparency, layers etc all work good enough that I haven't used anything besides this since I found out it ... sometime between 2015 and 2019.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by tuxalin on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:11AM (#40607904)
And alternatives for Substance Painter and Designer: InstaMaterial (free for under 100k revenue) - https://instamaterial.com/
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by Tachyooon on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:57AM (#40607771)
*Inkscape not Inkspace
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by spacebanana7 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:04AM (#40607831)
What’re the best alternatives to premiere and after effects?
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by bluetidepro on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:06AM (#40607852)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by misswaterfairy on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:11AM (#40608928)
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by bromuro on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:01AM (#40607802)
On Mac, Pixelmator Pro is the best - in my opinion.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by mechhacker on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:19AM (#40607967)
Krita has gotten really great over the years, and it started out pretty good to begin with
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by PinguTS on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:20AM (#40607972)
Adobe is much more than just Photoshop. That is the problem. Especially, if a bought into the whole movie pipeline with Premier, After Effects, and more.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:28AM (#40608031)
InDesign is also an anchor product. Affinity Publisher is actually great and catching up on some of the niche tools InDesign offers, but I think it remains true that you can’t really flip some designers until you sell them on a new book/magazine/PDF layout tool.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by reportgunner on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:22AM (#40607991)
Will the world really stop turning if we can't use Photoshop™ for a year?
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by temporallobe on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:23AM (#40607997)
Upvote for Inkscape! I’ve been using it professionally for many years now. There’s a bit of a learning curve, but once you master it, it’s very powerful software, and even script-able.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:24AM (#40608004)
I’ve used Affinity Photo for nine years now, and my feeling is that the ways it is not like Photoshop likely would barely impact most Photoshop users.

Some of the ways it is not like Photoshop are evidence of it being better-designed. I know a good few photographers who have switched, and for my photography I find it is an actively better tool. Cross-model colour curves, layer blending curves, and live filters are all useful, and the implementation of the built-in frequency separation tool is such that it’s possible to tailor it very subtly to the image so it can be used without the downsides of the Photoshop-type approach.

Affinity Photo’s biggest problem remains the lack of a Bridge/Lightroom tool. Hopefully with Canva’s money this either gets resolved or they have the clout to get app developers like DxO, Capture One and Photo Mechanic to add closer round-trip integration with Affinity products.

Affinity Designer really is a 100% credible alternative to Illustrator. Affinity Publisher is super and highly capable. So the Bridge alternative issue is a limiting factor for these too.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by coldtea on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:38AM (#40608113)
>I’ve used Affinity Photo for nine years now, and my feeling is that the ways it is not like Photoshop likely would barely impact most Photoshop users.

Most professionals or most users who use Photoshop to crop and retouch some scratch in a photo?

>I know a good few photographers who have switched, and for my photography I find it is an actively better tool

Ah, photographers. Not the real heavy users of Photoshop though, despite the name of the product - it's graphic and print designers who need the fancy stuff. For most photography needs Capture One and others will also do.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:03AM (#40608345)
Graphic and print designers do not just use Photoshop; it’s not the right tool for that job. The bulk of that work happens outside Photoshop in Illustrator or InDesign.

Affinity has matching applications (minus Lightroom and Bridge as I said).

It also handles vectors and text just fine in Photo and has integration functionality to edit between Designer (their Illustrator alternative) and Photo, and even more impressive integration once Publisher is added to the mix. But I've used Photo on its own for tasks like banner ads, header images, and a couple of full-colour flyers (it's not my main area of expertise so I generally do not)

Take a look at an Affinity video demonstrating Publisher (their InDesign competitor). Once you combine the three apps it is surprisingly powerful and a pretty credible alternative to InDesign.

Given that you can buy the entire suite outright for desktop and iPad for the price of about four months of full Creative Cloud, I think it’s at least worth considering, though the asset management side is still obviously lacking somewhat as I said.

ETA: photographer workflows can be considerably more complex than your characterisation! I have a darkroom-soft-focus simulation in live filters in one of my projects, cross-model curves (Lab curves on an RGB image without switching modes) in several, a black and white negative processing stack, HALD CLUT inference macros, and I know people doing colour neg corrections entirely in Affinity Photo (which is a task people often delegate to something like Silverfast)

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by coldtea on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:57PM (#40612895)
>Graphic and print designers do not just use Photoshop; it’s not the right tool for that job. The bulk of that work happens outside Photoshop in Illustrator or InDesign.

Graphic and print designer do digital painting, collages, retouching, adding special effects to images (say fake halftone), fake natural media, and tons of other things with Photoshop. Illustrator is for vector graphics, which they also use, but it's a different thing. And InDesign is for DTP, not for graphics work (illustration, graphic design, retouching, image manipulation, etc) for web or print.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:40PM (#40613266)
Clearly InDesign is used for print design. DTP is print design. Madness to imply it is not.

And both print and graphic designers use vector art pretty extensively. Large amounts of print/printed work is done with scalable designs for really obvious reasons.

Photoshop is not generally the final tool for a print designer; it is likely not often the final tool for a graphic designer. Things have moved on a lot.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by coldtea on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:45PM (#40614385)
>DTP is print design

I didn't refer to that kind of print design - the design of the layout and such, since it's irrelevant to Photoshop vs Affinity Photo comparison.

I refer to design for print. Graphical elements, manipulated images, etc meant to go to books, magazines, posters, and so on.

>Large amounts of print/printed work is done with scalable designs for really obvious reasons.

That's a different comparison, Illustrator vs Affinity Designer. And large amounts of print/printed work are done with Photoshop still: basically anything that's not vector. They're just done in high enough resolution to be able to be printed at all their target dpis.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by throw46365 on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:50PM (#40614909)
I am not sure then why you draw a distinction between graphic and print design, when they are in your definitions essentially identical.

But stipulating this definition, and getting back to my original point, I don’t believe there are really significant things that would limit those users in Affinity Photo either, particularly when combined with the tools from Designer and Publisher which you can switch to seamlessly. I have worked alongside designers for thirty years and understand some of what they do; I do not see Affinity lacking in fundamentals or clever features.

Aside, again, from needing to add in an asset management app.

Which would be easily affordable given how comically affordable the entire suite is. But I hope Affinity fix this next.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by llm_trw on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:29AM (#40608037)
>Photopea - https://www.photopea.com/

This is an online only tool. They will do the same thing photoshop did soon enough.

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by janosdebugs on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:42AM (#40608156)
Does anyone have a reasonably feature complete alternative for Audition? I tried several paid and free ones, none seem to make it easy to work with multitrack audio in a non-destructive fashion.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by DHPersonal on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:15AM (#40608972)
If it's for podcast editing, which is what I used Audition for in my old job, then I've seen people use GarageBand[1] or DaVinci Fairlight[2].

1: https://www.apple.com/mac/garageband/

2: https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/au/products/davinciresolve/...

Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by janosdebugs on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:46AM (#40609252)
It's for making game sounds. Fairlight looks like it could work though, thanks!
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by stephen_g on Friday June 07, 2024 @08:45AM (#40608185)
I’ve switched to Pixelmator Pro (Mac only) as a Photoshop replacement, Capture One for photo processing and Affinity Designer instead of Illustrator as of a couple of years ago. I already used Final Cut Pro for video before I switched the others.
Re:Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your cl... by washadjeffmad on Saturday June 08, 2024 @11:06AM (#40618003)
And don't discount Adobe CS. I've been working with more and more artists who've found their zen in hoarding old Macs to be able to continue running all of their custom scripts and software forever. Wherever their art intersects with the digital, using CS, they can fully avoid today's "Adobe tax".

There are also non-Adobe pipeline utilities for pretty much every process, but they're not usually taught in schools. However, if your role is to interact with people who only rely on modern Adobe, you more or less have to, as well. There's a certain pride people have in owning their tools and not being dictated to by software, so I'm generally happy to accommodate anyone who I find personally resonant.