News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by june6throwaway on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:05AM (#40598301)
Nearly all of Canadian's current political turmoil can be easily root-caused in a single graph.

https://i.ibb.co/28YD8P5/net-migration-Canada-yearly-06-to-2...

I'm curious for someone to make a steelman case as to why they think this is acceptable.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by throwup238 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:09AM (#40598339)
> I'm curious for someone to make a steelman case as to why they think this is acceptable.

Maple syrup reserves are running low and Canada will need bodies for the upcoming war over New England’s supply.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by june6throwaway on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:19AM (#40598485)
At least Americans can find some humor in our slow cultural degradation.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by blululu on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:54PM (#40599655)
Y’all make fun of us for everything from our lousy patchwork health care system to sucking at hockey. Seems only fair to send a little flack back across what’s left of the border.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by throwup238 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:58PM (#40600417)
You'll be fine as long as no one starts replacing the cheese curds with paneer.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by crindy on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:18AM (#40598470)
Since you asked for someone to steelman, I’ll chime in to say this graph looks great to me.

As Canada has grown rich, our fertility rate has gone down. I have no moral problem with that, but it does cause a problem: as the population ages, the ratio of workers (who pay tax) to retired people (who carry a tax burden) shrinks. The options are increasing the taxes on workers, cutting the benefits to the retired, or increasing the working age population via immigration.

As to grocery stores, housing prices, etc. I think these problems are more related to a lack of competition. A free market can handle an influx of consumers.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:29AM (#40598627)
> Since you asked for someone to steelman, I’ll chime in to say this graph looks great to me. As Canada has grown rich, our fertility rate has gone down. I have no moral problem with that, but it does cause a problem: as the population ages, the ratio of workers (who pay tax) to retired people (who carry a tax burden) shrinks.

This is not even close to the only problem. Our housing stock has not kept up with population growth, which is a big reason why housing prices have been so out of control here. It's not due to a lack of competition so much as regulation and population growth that has outpaced building capacity.

So I'm not sure I can agree that that graph looks fine. It's true that we need immigration to balance falling fertility rates, this needs to be balanced by the available resources so the cost of living doesn't spiral out of control. Labour shortages can often be addressed in others ways, like automation.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by crindy on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:37AM (#40598737)
Yeah, there are clearly other problems with the Canadian market. Didn’t mean to imply there weren’t!

Housing stock I really do think is down to regulation - it’s crazy hard to build here in Vancouver, even right near mass transit stations.

Should we have increased the ability to compete in housing and groceries before the influx of immigrants? Maybe. But I don’t think having them here makes these issues harder to address, and it might increase the pressure to actually take action. Every party is talking about cost of living now.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:20PM (#40600001)
Regulation cannot be completely discounted, but the bigger issue is labour. If you can even find someone willing to build you a home, they won't even entertain doing it until years into the future. There is no capacity to build more homes.

At least not without paying construction workers a whole lot more in order to compel the software developers away from developing software and into building houses, but then that only drives the cost of housing even higher!

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:43PM (#40600264)
More labour is one way, but there are also orthogonal ways of retargeting the existing building capacity more effectively. For instance, financial discincentives against building low-density luxury housing and more incentives towards building higher density housing would alleviate demand pressure over the span of a few years. We also used to know how to build affordable housing.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:03PM (#40600472)
Why is that disincentive not already present? Multiple people building a town home should be able to outbid one person building a single family home every single time, and the sky is the limit for a large condo building. Their combined capacity to pay more than outstrips the additional cost to build the structure. It is clear what is a better deal for the construction crew.

I expect the answer is because nobody actually wants to live in such dwellings. They might accept rent in a place like that if they see it as a stop-gap until they can move into their "dream home", but it is not the home they are willing to commit to and build (obviously there are exceptions).

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:10PM (#40601212)
Zoning regulations limits what you can construct in any given location, so it's not even about who has more financial capital, but political capital in many cases.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:22PM (#40601322)
Not so much an issue anymore, though. Want to build a tiny house? No problem. Multiple houses on a single lot? Go for it! These would have been unthinkable 10-20 years ago, but have been given the green light in more recent times. Council knows that they can't get away with ignoring housing any longer. Of course, it's easy to accept because they also know almost nobody is going to do it.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by margalabargala on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:31AM (#40598652)
I would be interested to have the person you replied to steelman why, specifically, they believe that the contents of that graph would lead to social decline and political turmoil.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by mytailorisrich on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:23AM (#40598536)
The only long term option is to increase productivity with education and technology because you can't increase population (however you do it) forever. We should also stop emphasising the total GDP (which can be and is boosted by adding more people) and focus on the GDP per capita instead (which seems to be falling in Canada according to the various graphs posted here).

The claim that immigration is the only option is a fallacy peddled because it's the lazy short term option and "Après moi, le déluge" [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apr%C3%A8s_moi,_le_d%C3%A9luge

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by crindy on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:33AM (#40598686)
Yeah, I should have mentioned productivity growth - it is of course another solution to the problem. I think it’s harder for governments to implement policy that increases productivity growth than immigration, though.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by voisin on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:46PM (#40601569)
> The options are increasing the taxes on workers, cutting the benefits to the retired, or increasing the working age population via immigration.

I think the third option could be further broken down: 3a) increase the working age population via a well planned immigration strategy that includes necessary infrastructure spending (medical residencies, housing, etc etc) to support that immigration 3b) open up the floodgates with absolutely no planning for the consequences whatsoever and then blame everyone else for the ensuing inflation and societal stress.

Unfortunately our current government chose 3b.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by soco on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:18AM (#40606816)
This is what also Merkel's Germany plan was, and the results are... so-and-so. I wonder how come nobody thought about said strategical planning? I know planning is hard but it's not nuclear science and they should have counted with the pushback as well. And by the way, did anybody learn any lesson?
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by Vermeulen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:23AM (#40598544)
No - this is the graph: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GO1eps3WgAEzQYa?format=jpg&name=...

Immigration is the only thing providing GDP growth. Otherwise the Canadian economy is clearly broken

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by june6throwaway on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:58AM (#40598978)
Since that graph measures per capita, I think the obvious (and grim) one might come to here is that immigrants to Canada, on average, aren't as productive in the Canadian economy as native citizens.

What do you think?

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:32PM (#40600144)
No doubt you hit the nail on the head, for two reasons:

1. Immigration is a federal matter, commerce is (mostly) a provincial matter. In practice, this means the federal government brings in the people it thinks should be most economically useful for the economic need that is present, but the provinces put up red tape to disallow them from being most useful. The canonical example here being the trained medical doctor left to drive a taxi.

2. Immigrants tend to want to settle amongst each other. Which is no doubt important socially, but the communities are most often not located where there is the economic need. This leaves individuals to be under-utilized, if even jobless, all while employers can't find anyone to hire. Since provincially-regulated employers can't find anyone to hire, the federal government sees a need for even more people and use one of the few tools they have. You can guess what happens next.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:36AM (#40622283)
Is this true for well educated immigrants too? It seems like this might be affecting a limited population, if the educated immigrant goes to Canada, they are aware of what immigration means and might be open integrating instead of living in an immigrants community
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:13AM (#40624210)
Well, if we look at the Statscan economic region that consistently posts the lowest unemployment rate (and where the news regularly reports on the exceptionally high number of job vacancies), only 2,140 immigrants arrived there from 2016-2021 (latest census data). Whereas 1,328,240 immigrants arrived in Canada over the same period.

Is it possible that only 0.16% of immigrants are educated? Well, maybe, but if that's the case it is insignificant enough that it is basically meaningless. Said economic region is home to 0.8% of the population, so immigrants are disproportionately not going there despite the data showing the greater economic need.

Education does not remove the human experience. I expect it is plain hard to be one of almost no immigrants to show up somewhere, even if you come with awareness. You aren't likely to find a familiar culture, or other people going through the same experience, so it can easily become isolating. Immigrant communities beget immigrants because they offer something to immigrants. Life isn't just about work it turns out.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by hnhg on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:13AM (#40598402)
The root cause might be stagnant productivity. Faced with this, politicians can boost GDP by increasing the population. The root cause would therefore be using GDP growth as the success metric, stagnation in the said metric and an inability to facilitate its growth with anything other than increasing the amount of people in the economy.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:11AM (#40598367)
A significant fraction of those people would be dead if they didn't immigrate.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:16AM (#40598437)
Citation that a "significant fraction" of those who immigrated were facing certain death?

Also, implicit in your post seems to be an assertion that the moral responsibility for their deaths would fall on us rather than the people causing the deadly circumstances in their home countries, and that we are thus we are obligated to help in this specific way. There are a lot of problems with this argument.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:55AM (#40598930)
> Citation that a "significant fraction" of those who immigrated were facing certain death?

"A significant fraction of those people would be dead if they didn't immigrate." -- bryanlarsen, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40598367

> Also, implicit in your post seems to be an assertion that the moral responsibility for their deaths would fall on us

There is no such assertion. Any more logical fallacies up your sleeve before we move on?

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:10PM (#40599133)
Cute, now maybe look up the definition of "citation" which requires a source for the claim.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:14PM (#40599174)
I did cite the source, at least as the dictionary defines those terms.

You're going to have to fill us in with your own personal, non-standard definition that you are using, I guess.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:19PM (#40599240)
Ah, so you're being deliberately obtuse. Not interested.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:27PM (#40599333)
I suppose asking for a citation could be considered deliberately obtuse. What is even the point of talking to someone else by proxy? If you really have an interest in what someone else had to say, why not go talk to them directly? If you want to have a discussion with the actors in front of you, why not talk to them instead?

Oh, right, you're not interested. But then why be here at all?

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:05PM (#40599073)
Canada has admitted over one million refugees since 1980. Refugees are admitted under 3 criteria:

- danger of torture - risk of life - risk of cruel and unusual punishment

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:14PM (#40599175)
The post you replied to showed a graph of almost 1.2 million migrants in 2023 alone, a roughly 5x jump from historical norms of 10+ years ago. You then said "a significant fraction of those people" would be dead otherwise, but now you're saying we've admitted 1 million refugees since 1980. 1 million since 1980 seems totally reasonable but I just can't square up that number with what you said in response to the original graph.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:19PM (#40599236)
5% is a significant fraction, especially when "death" is the 5%.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:28PM (#40599342)
I understand what you're saying, but I think that descriptor is very misleading in this context. The original post was discussing a very large uptick in absolute numbers and the subsequent increased demand on resources that would entail. Your response about a very small subset of those numbers just isn't very relevant if you're only talking about 5% of that increase.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:07PM (#40599822)
"Significant fraction" always speaks to a small, but not unnoticeable, value. 5% is reasonably considered a significant fraction.

Where have you come up with this idea that it somehow suggests a significant number?

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:36PM (#40600187)
I know you struggle with context given our other threads, so I'll connect the dots: the "problem" from the original post was a large increase in immigration placing a strain on resources. If someone replies that a "significant fraction" of those immigrants were facing certain death, AND this "significant fraction" accounts for only 5% of the increase the original post was talking about, then that reply is at best a complete red herring; that 5% subset is simply not the source of the "problems" alluded to in the original post, eg. if you kept immigration levels at historic norms and only allowed additional refugees, you wouldn't have the "problems" the original post was alluding to.

That reply is only relevant to the original post if "significant fraction" consists of a meaningfully large percentage of that increase that is allegedly causing the problems.

Therefore, the phrasing of that reply in-context is misleading at best.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:38PM (#40600206)
And, to continue with your fallacy for the sake of humour, I know you struggle with logic given our other threads, so I'll help you out here in a now non-humorous way: There is nothing to suggest the comment was of relevance. You are searching for something that never was.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:46PM (#40600297)
Banana. HN is just for posting random words and thoughts completely disconnected from any context, right? Potatoes are yummy.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:59PM (#40600429)
Seems that way. Someone even asked for a "citation" in another comment, meaning that they wanted to know from where a comment was originally copied. Think about that one for a minute. You have to wonder sometimes.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by june6throwaway on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:18AM (#40598469)
The vast majority of Canadian immigrants come from India, China, and the Philippines, none of which I'd consider countries too dangerous to live in.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:44AM (#40598810)
The book One Billion Americans by Matthew Yglesias makes a very compelling case for immigration.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by debacle on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:10AM (#40598352)
What does the total population graph look like?
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:47PM (#40599578)
Looks pretty steady:

https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/canada-popula...

That projected 39 million for 2024, but we're already over 41 million right now [1]. So if the graph that started this thread is correct, in 2023 the Canadian population grew 3% just from immigration.

There's no question we need immigration given the low fertility rate, but there is definitely a limit to how much immigration is stable vs. disruptive, eg. if you doubled your population in one year the country would be unrecognizable and there wouldn't be enough resources to meet everyone's needs. For instance, housing capacity has been growing a lot slower than 3% per year for decades now, which is definitely a factor in our very high housing costs. We're definitely in a pickle.

[1] https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/71-607-x/71-607-x2018005...

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by freitzkriesler2 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:27AM (#40598591)
You're not wrong and you'll get down d00ted for it.

Canada let too many people in and the issues stem from infrastructure not able to handle it.

Can it be fixed? Absolutely! Will it? Probably not at any rate of speed that will fix the immediate pain.

Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by mynameishere on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:18AM (#40598459)
Some variation of that in nearly every "Western" country. East Asian countries have similiar challenges with low birth rates, but aren't targeted for demographic replacement for totally mysterious reasons
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket by mtmail on Thursday June 06, 2024 @11:21AM (#40598511)
Are the reason really mysterious, or was that a hint that the reasons are not being talked about?