Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:14PM
(#40599175)
The post you replied to showed a graph of almost 1.2 million migrants in 2023 alone, a roughly 5x jump from historical norms of 10+ years ago. You then said "a significant fraction of those people" would be dead otherwise, but now you're saying we've admitted 1 million refugees since 1980. 1 million since 1980 seems totally reasonable but I just can't square up that number with what you said in response to the original graph.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:19PM
(#40599236)
5% is a significant fraction, especially when "death" is the 5%.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:28PM
(#40599342)
I understand what you're saying, but I think that descriptor is very misleading in this context. The original post was discussing a very large uptick in absolute numbers and the subsequent increased demand on resources that would entail. Your response about a very small subset of those numbers just isn't very relevant if you're only talking about 5% of that increase.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:07PM
(#40599822)
"Significant fraction" always speaks to a small, but not unnoticeable, value. 5% is reasonably considered a significant fraction.
Where have you come up with this idea that it somehow suggests a significant number?
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:36PM
(#40600187)
I know you struggle with context given our other threads, so I'll connect the dots: the "problem" from the original post was a large increase in immigration placing a strain on resources. If someone replies that a "significant fraction" of those immigrants were facing certain death, AND this "significant fraction" accounts for only 5% of the increase the original post was talking about, then that reply is at best a complete red herring; that 5% subset is simply not the source of the "problems" alluded to in the original post, eg. if you kept immigration levels at historic norms and only allowed additional refugees, you wouldn't have the "problems" the original post was alluding to.
That reply is only relevant to the original post if "significant fraction" consists of a meaningfully large percentage of that increase that is allegedly causing the problems.
Therefore, the phrasing of that reply in-context is misleading at best.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:38PM
(#40600206)
And, to continue with your fallacy for the sake of humour, I know you struggle with logic given our other threads, so I'll help you out here in a now non-humorous way: There is nothing to suggest the comment was of relevance. You are searching for something that never was.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by naasking on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:46PM
(#40600297)
Banana. HN is just for posting random words and thoughts completely disconnected from any context, right? Potatoes are yummy.
Re:Why Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
by randomdata on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:59PM
(#40600429)
Seems that way. Someone even asked for a "citation" in another comment, meaning that they wanted to know from where a comment was originally copied. Think about that one for a minute. You have to wonder sometimes.
- danger of torture - risk of life - risk of cruel and unusual punishment