News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by Aurornis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:22PM (#40591291)
These articles are always weird because they ignore the most likely next steps for people who don’t want Recall:

1. Don’t turn recall on

2. Switch to Mac

Jumping straight to the Linux Desktop deep end after using Windows for years is an unlikely change path for most. These arguments ignore the fact that most Windows users have a lot of Windows-specific apps that they use, such as games.

I think the real audience for these articles isn’t Windows users at all. It’s for Linux users to pay themselves on the back for not using Windows.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by zeta0134 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:26PM (#40591336)
Speak for yourself I suppose. I can hop between Linux (KDE, Gnome, whatever) and Windows and still feel like my muscle memory for OS interactions and application shortcuts still works. There are minor differences, but things like copy and paste still work properly.

When I try to use a Mac, everything is just ... different. CMD instead of Ctrl, buttons on the other side of windows, inconsistent maximize logic between programs, whatever Finder is supposed to be doing with folder navigation. It's certainly learnable with effort, and I can move around the OS competently now with some practice, but it's just unpleasant enough that I'd rather not use it as my daily driver.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by Aurornis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:06PM (#40591668)
I wasn’t talking about long time Linux users like yourself. I was referring to people who have been using Windows for years and were looking for something to switch to.

> I can hop between Linux (KDE, Gnome, whatever)

If you’ve been using Linux long enough to be familiar with KDE and Gnome and even know the difference between them, you’re very firmly a Linux enthusiast user. It’s easy to forget that the average computer user isn’t really interested in the details of their window management. They want the OS to get out of the way and support them, not be something they’re actively invested in.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by notarget137 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:42AM (#40595440)
I think you overestimate how much people don't really care what OS they are using and familiar with. For non-expierienced people Linux will look as exactly the same black box as the previous one. It is bad for intermediate users that are familiar with the system but not enough to be an administrator.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by amlib on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:45PM (#40591508)
> Jumping straight to the Linux Desktop deep end after using Windows for years is an unlikely change path for most. These arguments ignore the fact that most Windows users have a lot of Windows-specific apps that they use, such as games.

I think nowadays you would have a much worse experience switching from windows to mac, as you said, the user wants their apps and games to carry over, but you are actually going to have a much better time getting those to carry over to linux. Specially regarding games, just the fact that Steam runs almost any Windows game effortlessly on linux is a big deal. Meanwhile, Apple has made sure to burn all the bridges they could with game developers and game compatibility in the last decade or so.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by Aurornis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:03PM (#40591648)
I think Linux Desktop users have become blinded to how much easier it is for the average person (not developer, command-line enthusiasts) to use Mac or Windows than Linux.

I have Mac, Windows, and Linux machines that I use for different purposes. None of them has been perfect, but the amount of time I’ve lost fighting driver issues, weird upgrade quirks, software incompatibility problems, and other little loose ends over the users has been a magnitude worse on the Linux machines than anything else. In the moment it doesn’t really feel like much because it’s similar to daily work with Linux servers, but looking back it’s just so much more predictable to have basic things working on Mac or Windows than on Linux.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by kodexomega on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:43PM (#40591909)
I do mostly agree with this comment, although I would like to point out that one of the only reasons that MacOS has less driver issues is because it is mainly built for one type of device, Macs. Also, the upgrade quirks might come from the overlap in between dependencies of packages that don’t update at the same time as each other or the dependency, such as the qtile window manager, which can be easily fixed with using the Nix Package Manager, and the software incompatibility could be solved by using a Virtual Machine. Although, these solutions also have some quirks so they just might end up switching back anyway.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by NikkiA on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:18AM (#40593772)
There's also the fact that 'oh, that doesn't work with macs' is an acceptable response from companies that should be making drivers.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by amlib on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @09:05PM (#40592355)
I agree linux has its shortcomings and on average is inferior to the trillion dollar backed alternatives, but I was focusing on countering the point of gaming that was made, which is for a fact much better on linux than on macos. You WILL have a better time gaming there.

Anyway, we should all be glad how far linux has improved over the years and how it is a viable alternative to many use cases now. Hardware support used to be appalling and it used to be painful to use it for basic things like internet, video, music, games etc. Even developers had a rough time, with windows being the gold standard dev environment. But look at it now, linux is the gold standard dev environment, meanwhile microsoft is having to course correct and embed a copy of linux into windows, buy github and create a multiplatform text editor to try and lure developers back.

I also think it's important people keep giving linux a chance every couple years, If it doesn't work for you now give it another chance 2 to 5 years from now, it might finally click.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by tjoff on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:33PM (#40591402)
Windows for all it's faults is a very open ecosystem, in contrast Macs aren't that appealing. Especially if you aren't running iphones and ipads etc.

I do agree that Recall isn't the reason to switch though. The abuse Microsoft has put their users through the last few years has been unimaginable, to the point where switching to anything will feel liberating. Even Linux desktop.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by an-unknown on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:40PM (#40591464)
> […] Windows-specific apps that they use, such as games.

As if many Windows games don't work on Linux via proton, to the point that Valve's Steam Deck runs on Linux and is "good enough" most of the time. Compatibility purely depends on the game and more often than not incompatibilities are caused by anti-cheat mechanisms.

And about jumping to Linux: we had Windows computers in my family, originally with Windows 7, then upgraded to Windows 8.1, and once 8.1 was EOL, they were reinstalled with Linux (KDE as desktop environment). Since these computers were mainly used for email, web browsing, and some basic "office activities" like writing a simple document occasionally, there was exactly no issue with it. KDE itself is also similar enough to a Windows desktop that it wasn't hard for anyone to learn the few relevant things that are different. I'd be quite surprised if this was different for the majority of current Windows users.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by unpopularopp on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:42PM (#40591482)
>and more often than not incompatibilities are caused by anti-cheat mechanisms

But those multiplayer online games are the most popular games on the planet. It's another topic of discussion but people want to play them

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by digging on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:38PM (#40591447)
> such as games

This is kind of an outdated argument and nearly a solved problem - the majority of Steam's library can be run near-effortlessly on Linux today. I'd expect a large portion of Windows PC gamers to be aware of that, too, at least in the US. I don't really know anyone who's tied to any Windows-specific apps that aren't games, either.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by an-unknown on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:51PM (#40591560)
Games are the easier part. There are a few examples of software which is only available for Windows and Mac or even Windows only, like professional audio software or various CAD tools. If you need one of those, you can't really avoid Windows / Mac and usually there is no proper replacement for such software that works on Linux. Of course you can have a dedicated Windows or Mac machine just for those programs, but that's still not ideal.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by oliwarner on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:06PM (#40591676)
Recall isn't the argument, it's just the latest example for the same argument: you should be able to decide what your computer does, inspect it, modify and share.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by frapaconi on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:33PM (#40591398)
Not sure if you pay attention to how Microsoft operates (think IE/Edge) but they’ll accidentally-on-purpose toggle that ON with a magical Windows Update.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by nazgulsenpai on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:44PM (#40591495)
I don't think most people will buy new hardware that Mac requires if they can just boot from a USB on their current PC...
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by gpm on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:00PM (#40591620)
> 1. Don’t turn recall on

It's on by default if you have the right (wrong) hardware as I understand it.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:17PM (#40591753)
<< games

I no longer buy this argument at all. Between the work Steam put into Proton, this is had been largely a non-issue. About the only game I needed to use VM for was Fallout 3 ( I didn't feel like messing with it for more than 15 minutes ). There are some things Windows is still good for, but that list is growing shorter.

<< I think the real audience for these articles isn’t Windows users at all. It’s for Linux users to pay themselves on the back for not using Windows.

The intended audience is the people, who most need to hear it, because they do not realize there are options other than OS1 or OS2. And that it is not nearly as hard as it was only a decade ago.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:27PM (#40591356)
> Switch to Mac

Windows desktop users are all over the planet. Only a small percent of them could ever afford this.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by timothyduong on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:57PM (#40591600)
I don't think majority really care about their 'privacy' and would not switch in the first place due to Recall.
Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @08:11PM (#40592059)
I think this is death by 1,000 cuts for Windows. While privacy might not be a major issue for many users, when you couple that with mandatory sign-in to Microsoft accounts to use your own computer, a constant stream of commercials you are forced to view on your own computer and the never-ending up-selling of unwanted, intrusive Microsoft bloatware like Co-Pilot and One Drive, more and more people are going to be inspired (or compelled) to look for an alternative.

I've been a Windows user since Windows was originally released (and was an MS-DOS user before that), but Windows 11 is the straw that broke the camels back for me. I've dabbled with Linux before, but the lack of gaming support and the hassles to configure it properly to get all my hardware to work made it to inconvenient to switch, but I am 100% going to switch when support for Windows 10 expires. As I am the one who offers tech support to numerous relatives who are less tech savvy, I will also migrate them to the most user-friendly Linux build I can find. Almost all of them, especially the older ones, use their computers almost exclusively for web-browsing and streaming videos, and this will be a virtually seamless process for them. Most of my Gen-X friends are of the same mindset (except for the ones who have been captured by the Mac ecosystem).

Certainly Windows is not going to go away no matter how terrible and odious their OS becomes, but I think many people have underestimated just how far they can push the envelope without seeing a significant migration away from MS.

Re:Microsoft Recall should make you consider Linux by thefz on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:51AM (#40594712)
"most likely" is to buy an expensive new computer while Linux can be used on the hardware one already owns?