News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by ein0p on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:40PM (#40587125)
As exciting as this is, I’ve read that this capsule faces uncertain future after 7 launches: the rocket it was launched on is retired, and while it’s compatible with Falcon it’s not clear what the advantage would be wrt SpaceX’s capsule to warrant additional testing. Imagine working on something for over a decade only to see it fly just 7 times!
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by dotnet00 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:56PM (#40587367)
It isn't compatible with Falcon, it can be made to be compatible with Falcon in the future. It wouldn't really be worth doing though, since part of the point of having two providers is dissimilar redundancy, so that any issues with one platform don't affect the other. It's more likely that if Boeing wants to keep flying Starliner after using up the stock of Atlas Vs, they'll want to integrate it on Vulcan Centaur rather than Falcon.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by nickff on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:03PM (#40588237)
One might imagine that an issue could be found on Dragon, which grounded it, but not the Falcon 9. That said, it’s definitely less redundant than one might like.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by spacemark on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:36PM (#40588638)
>Imagine working on something for over a decade only to see it fly just 7 times!

Haha, I'm guessing you don't work in the space industry. Frankly if something you work on gets to space at all you count yourself fortunate. My first job was at a defense contractor working on a big rocket. A senior engineer on our team had a picture of the Indiana Jones warehouse on the wall in his office, rows and rows of boxes. I asked him why, he said it's a reminder to not get too stressed about work - 9 out of 10 projects will never fly.

Things are changing especially in the new space corners of the industry, but for big projects requiring political will I think it's still the same.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by nordsieck on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:40PM (#40588685)
> My first job was at a defense contractor working on a big rocket.

Out of curiosity, were you working on one of the Ares rockets?

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by torginus on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:01AM (#40595965)
>Frankly if something you work on gets to space at all you count yourself fortunate.

That is unless you work on a ballistic missile

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by lostlogin on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:37PM (#40600829)
This bares thinking about. On a working holiday in the UK it was a revelation to find just how huge the defence industry really is.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by Reubachi on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:47PM (#40588756)
I have spent years building cars that ran once, twice to great effect/happiness of all involed.

Getting to space SEVEN times off one poweplant/project is nothing short of incredible.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by happyopossum on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:07PM (#40590642)
> Getting to space SEVEN times off one poweplant/project

Sure, if you ignore the 20+ year old Atlas V that actually launched it...

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by asadotzler on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:05PM (#40588262)
"The capsule" here means a decade of R&D and half a decade building production models. If turnaround is about 6-8 months, they're going to need at least two and I'll bet they build three or more because reuse and refurb won't go as well as they hope.

That means about 10 years of R&D since they got the initial contracts and then about half a decade of production for the flight articles and then a wind-down of a couple years and a skeleton crew to make the last few flights.

A 15-20 year project that sends dozens of people to space for the last years of the ISS's lifetime is not going to be a disappointment for 95% of the people who worked on this.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by ein0p on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:08PM (#40588298)
I don’t think you understand. It’s not 7 launches per capsule. There could be 7 launches in total for this.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by mbonnet on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:37PM (#40588655)
Having more than one thing capable of doing something is an advantage in a field as uncertain as spaceflight.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by rlt on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:34AM (#40597895)
Yeah, but soon we’ll have Starship and Falcon + Dragon.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by mbonnet on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:40PM (#40602714)
soon != now.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by bitcharmer on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:48PM (#40587257)
The main goal of the project has been achieved as far as Boeing is concerned :)
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by Meerax on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:12PM (#40600569)
Bear in mind they still need to return the astronauts safely to touchdown.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by glenstein on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:48PM (#40588040)
>Imagine working on something for over a decade only to see it fly just 7 times!

Huh? My understanding was that something unique about the falcon is the capability of multiple reuses, in contrast to previous missions that were one and done uses. What past experience in the history of spaceflight might someone be referring to where seven reuses registers as a disappointment?

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by asadotzler on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:09PM (#40588309)
They won't reuse any Starliners 7 times. Twice is more likely. Three times reuse, perhaps. They can't refub in time to send the same craft up twice in a year as required by the contract so they'll need at least two. If anything goes wrong with either of those, they'll need a backup. Now they've got three for 6 flights. These vehicles will get one, two, or at best 3 launches and then retired to the scrap heap while SpaceX Dragon continues to ferry people to the ISS if it gets an extension and if not then to the first private orbital stations. Boeing should never again get a NASA contract after SLS and Starliner.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by ein0p on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:56PM (#40588153)
It did not launch on Falcon. Once the current stock of rockets it did launch on runs out they will have no launch vehicle.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by nordsieck on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:09PM (#40588310)
> Once the current stock of rockets it did launch on runs out they will have no launch vehicle.

Exactly.

Just to elaborate for your parent, the Atlas V which currently flies Starliner uses an RD-180 engine that's manufactured in Russia. ULA is no longer able to procure any more such engines, and a rocket with those engines are no longer legally allowed to fly DoD payloads. Which prompted ULA to retire Atlas V in favor of Vulcan.

I think someone from ULA or Boeing (I forget which) recently said that they've begun the process of certifying Starliner on Vulcan, although I'll have to go back and make sure I remember exactly what was said.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by jdminhbg on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:50PM (#40588074)
This is about the entire lifespan of the Starliner program, not just one piece of hardware.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by vikramkr on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:57AM (#40596831)
I think the parent comment is referring to there only being 7 launches total for the entire program before being cancelled, not 7 launches per capsule.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by glenstein on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:20PM (#40604377)
That would make sense, however (correct me if I'm wrong) they do seem to be referring quite specifically to the capsule itself.