News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by riedel on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:38PM (#40577026)
Fun fact is that afaik component values are often distributed in a bi-modal way because actually +-5% often means that they sorted out already the +-1% to sell as a different more expensive batch. At least it used to be that way. Wonder if it is still worth doing this in production. So I guess one could also measure to average things out otherwise the errors will stay the same relatively.
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by dmurray on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:56PM (#40577180)
If you can measure them with that precision, would it make sense to sell them with that accuracy too? So if you tried to manufacture a resistor at 68kΩ +/- 20%, and it actually ended up at 66kΩ +/- 1%, couldn't you now sell it as an E192 product which according to TFA are more expensive?

Selling with different tolerances only makes sense to me if the product can't be reliably measured to have a tighter tolerance, perhaps if the low- quality ones are expected to vary over their life or if it's too expensive to test each one individually and you have to rely on sampling the manufacturing process to guess what the tolerances in each batch should be.

Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by retrac on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:08PM (#40577300)
Resistors with worse tolerances may be made out of cheaper, less refined wire, which will vary resistance more by temperature. The tolerance and resistance is good over a temperature range. For more reading looking up "constantan".
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by RetroTechie on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:26PM (#40577473)
Most resistors don't use wire, but some film of carbon (cheaper, usually the E12 / 5% tolerance parts) or metal (E24, or 1% and tighter tolerances) onto a non-conducting body. Wires mean winding into a coil, which means increased inductance.

I suspect in most cases the tolerances are a direct result from the fabrication process. That is: process X, within such & such parameters, produces parts with Y tolerance. But there could be some trimming involved (like a laser burning off material until component has correct value). Or the parts are measured & then binned / marked accordingly.

Actual wire is used for power resistors, like rated for 5W+ dissipation. Inductance rarely matters for their applications.

Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by Gibbon1 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @04:28PM (#40578616)
Accuracy depends on the technology used. Carbon comp tends have less accuracy then carbon film. And it's not true that higher accuracy is always better.

Some accurate resisters are essentially wound coils and have high inductance and will also induce and pick up magnetic interference. Stuff like that matters often a lot.

Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by projektfu on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:27PM (#40577484)
Thanks, always good to remember that the tolerance of a resistor is not just a manufacturing number but also defined over the specified temperature range.
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by dylan604 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:16PM (#40577373)
Depends on where in the production line they are being tested. If they are tested after they've had their color bands applied, then you wouldn't be able to sell it as a 66kH since the markings would for a 68kH
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by wongarsu on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:17PM (#40577386)
The issue is probably volume. Very few applications need a resistor that's exactly 66kΩ, but a lot of applications need resistors that are in the ballpark of 68kΩ (but nobody would really notice if some 56kΩ resistors slipped in there).

For every finely tuned resonance circuit there are a thousand status LEDs where nobody cares if one product ships with a brighter or dimmer LED.

Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by projektfu on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:15PM (#40577360)
Unless the components are expensive, that proposition seems dubious. It's much more economical to take a process that produces everything within 12% centered on the desired value and sell it as ±20%. 100% inspection is generally to be avoided in mass production, except in cases where the process cannot reach that capability, chip manufacturing being the classic example. For parts that cost a fraction of a penny, nobody is inspecting to find the jewels in the rough.
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by riedel on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @04:13PM (#40578486)
Actually it seems to be really the case that multimodal distribution are rather the result of batches not having a mean. So it is rather the effect of systematic error [1]. I guess it is really a myth (we did low cost RF designs back in 2005 and had some real issues with frequencies not aligning die to component spread and I really remember that bi modality problem, but I guess okhams razor should have told me that it makes no economical sense)

[1] https://www.eevblog.com/2011/11/14/eevblog-216-gaussian-resi...

Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by projektfu on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @09:24PM (#40580547)
Yup, forever the reason for the trim pot.
Re:Why do electronic components have such odd values? (2021) by bluGill on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:51PM (#40577140)
I'm not sure where the line is, but at some point things like temperature a matter and so a low % resister cannot be high % that passes tests.