So maybe it's easy if you study that stuff for a year or two. But you can't just walk in and expect to pass, or bullshit your way through it.
I agree with you on legal writing, but there appears to be a certain amount of ambiguity inherent to language. The Uniform Commercial Code, for instance, is maddeningly vague at points.
Also, sometimes sample exams are made extra difficult, to convince students that they need to shell out thousands of dollars for prep courses. I recall getting 75% of questions wrong on some sections of a bar prep company's pre-test, which I later realized was designed to emphasize unintuitive/little-known exceptions to general rules. These corners of the law made up a disproportionate number of the questions on the pre-test and gave the impression that the student really needed to work on that subject.
Keep in mind even today[1] ( in California and few other states) you don't need to go law school to write the Bar exam and practice law, various forms of apprenticeship under a judge or lawyer are allowed
You also don't need to write the exam to practice many aspects of the legal profession.
The exam is never meant to be a high bar of quality or selection,it was always just a simple validation if you know your basics. Law like many other professions always operated on reputation and networks, not on degrees and certifications.
[1] Unlike say being a doctor, you have to go to med school without exception
Well, in a lot of the so-called soft sciences, you can easily beat a test without subject knowledge. I had figured that the bar exam might be something like that -- but it's more akin to something like biology, where there are a lot of arcane and counterintuitive little rules that have emerged over time. And you need to know those, or you're sunk. You can't guess your way past them, because the best-looking guesses tend to be the wrong ones.
(For what it's worth, I realize that this mostly has to do with the Common Law's reverence of precedent-as-binding, and that continental Civil Law systems don't suffer as much from it. But I suppose those continental systems have other problems of their own.)
Laws are not logical constructs, they are political constructs, why expect logic from them.
Laws are passed or repealed because it is popular or politically advantageous to do so, not necessarily because it is moral or common sense.
On top of that politicians pass stupid legislation without understanding what they are doing all the time, the infamous Indiana pi bill is a simple example, it almost became law and was stopped by sheer luck, a mathematics professor attending that day on a unrelated matter.
Laws are conflicting, confusing, ambiguous and misleading most of the time, that is expected, the legislating them is a messy process. The third arm of any government judiciary sole purpose is to handle this mess.
---
P.S. I cannot say whether continental legal systems are more robust, but perhaps healthier democracy results in better laws.
All democracies are flawed, U.S. democracy is not particularly healthy, it is not say an proportional multi-party representative system with fair distribution of power amongst all citizens.
From the founding it has been a series of compromises, the history is littered with representation fights such as for suffrage, Jim crow and voting rights, slavery, electoral college, number of states or the filibuster or anti Chinese laws and so on and on.
Don't get me wrong last 250 years have been incredible progress and great leaders put their lives down to make it better, hopefully it will be even better in the future, the struggles do show in the laws it is able to pass, repeal or update.
Reminds me of the mandatory trainings you take for work every year. Normal logical thinking can get you through most of them.
A key item which jumped out at me right away is that in addition to the logic, the possible answers would include things which the scenario didn't address. Like, a wrong answer might make an assumption that you couldn't arrive to via the scenario. More tricky were the answers which made assumptions which you knew to be correct (based on a real event,) but still wasn't addressed in the scenario. If you combined these two elements (getting the logic right, and eliminating assumptions which you couldn't make from the scenario) then you could do well on those.
The sections I wouldn't have passed were those which required specific law knowledge. So, some sections were general, while others required knowledge of something like real estate law. I don't remember if these questions were otherwise similar to the ones I could pass.
An LLM is taking this test as essentially an open book.
> The more your argument is structured, akin to a computer program, the better.
You certainly make legal writing sound like a flavor of technical writing. Simplicity, clarity, structure. Is this an accurate comparison ?
That's still cognate with the concept of computer code.
It may also be surprising to some to understand that legal writing is prized for its degree of formalism. It aims to remove all connotation from a message so as to minimize misunderstanding, much like clean code.
It may also be surprising, but the goal when writing a legal brief or judicial opinion is not to try to sound smart. The goal is to be clear, objective, and thereby, persuasive. Using big words for the sake of using big words, using rare words, using weasel words like "kind of" or "most of the time" or "many people are saying", writing poetically, being overly obtuse and abstract, these are things that get your law school application rejected, your brief ridiculed, and your bar exam failed.
The simpler your communication, the more formulaic, the better. The more your argument is structured, akin to a computer program, the better.
As compared to some other domain, such as fiction, good legal writing much easier for an attention model to simulate. The best exam answers are the ones that are the most formulaic and that use the smallest lexicon and that use words correctly.
I only want to add this comment because I want to inform how non-lawyers perceive the bar exam. Getting an attention model to pass the bar exam is a low bar. It is not some great technical feat. A programmer can practically write a semantic disambiguation algorithm for legal writing from scratch with moderate effort.
It will be a good accomplishment, but it will only be a stepping stone. I am still waiting for AI to tackle messages that have greater nuance and that are truly free form. LLMs are still not there yet.