News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jefftk on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:05AM (#40523876)
> I find it hard to believe that the Tesla and Auto Manufacturer positions aren’t knowingly deceptive.

The auto manufacturer approach is also showing progress. In CA and NV you can buy and operate a Mercedes with Drive Pilot, which is Level 3 certified. In the right (very restrictive conditions which essentially come down to "sitting in highway traffic on your commute") you legally do not have to pay attention to the road and can read/watch/work/etc.

https://www.mbusa.com/en/owners/manuals/drive-pilot

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by shkkmo on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:00AM (#40524580)
That 'level 3' is still basically lane keeping and auto cruise control, the driver still has to be ready to immediately takeover, if you don't the car will stop in it's current lane with it's blinkers on.

This is about the peak of what you can get with automated lane keeping and braking. I don't see any route from this point to anything like level 4.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jefftk on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:08AM (#40524654)
"Immediately" can mean a bunch of different things in a driving context! Here it means "within ten seconds". Which is both short and long: it's long enough that many of the things you might want to do that take your attention are fine (reading, watching a movie, working) but not long enough that you can sleep.

> This is about the peak of what you can get with automated lane keeping and braking.

Are you saying that within 5y, say, we won't see a level three system that's able to handle full highway speeds?

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jvanderbot on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:37AM (#40524968)
> level 3 is still basically ...

well yeah, that is the definition of level 3. That's not going to change.

They are limited by:

> Our technology relies on a digital high-definition map that provides a 3D image of the road and the surroundings with information on road geometry, route characteristics, traffic signs and special traffic events

IMHO Tesla's "F--- it all just use NN" approach does get around the pre-generated 3D map requirement. Even if it is not much more than Level 3.5 at the moment. Pretty funny to see it accelerate to 65mph in a parking lot b/c it thought it was on the nearby highway though.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jefftk on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:14PM (#40526173)
> it is not much more than Level 3.5 at the moment

It's not even level 3, and couldn't be certified as such. It's not reliable enough for the person in the driver's seat to focus their full attention elsewhere.

>> level 3 is still basically lane keeping and auto cruise control

> well yeah, that is the definition of level 3

No, it's the definition of level 2: https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update ("example features: lane centering and adaptive cruise control at the same time")

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jvanderbot on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:29PM (#40526375)
I mean, that's very official looking. And the differentiating criteria for level 3 is "You must take over when asked" and everything 2 or below is "You must brake, steer, or accelerate as needed to ensure safety".

Am I missing something? Lane keeping, cruise control and offset keeping is level 3. That's what this feature offers according to a few posts up.

It makes no difference to the conversation. I'll stop poking the bear here.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:31PM (#40525636)
There's still plenty that can go wrong in a hurry even if you are just streaming along in lane. All it takes is for something non-routine to happen such as a car ahead reacting to an animal, or swerving as the driver reaches for something or spills coffee on themself, or a wheel come off a car (I've seen it happen to a car in front of me), or a car crosses the center median in opposite direction (which left my ex-boss hospitalized for 6 months).

I'd personally never trust an autopilot unless it's either backed by human-level AI which has also had years of driving experience, or it's in some very highly constrained environment (maybe airport bus going from gate to plane). Out on a highway or public road system is the most unpredictable environment possible.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by CharlieDigital on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:10PM (#40526132)

    > All it takes is for something non-routine to happen such as a car ahead reacting to an animal, or swerving as the driver reaches for something or spills coffee on themself, or a wheel come off a car (I've seen it happen to a car in front of me), or a car crosses the center median in opposite direction (which left my ex-boss hospitalized for 6 months)
Inherent in this statement is the assumption that in such types of events, a human would necessarily do better than the machine. Each of these are extremes and I doubt that most human drivers would be able to react to avoid an accident or damage most of the time.
Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday May 30, 2024 @02:11PM (#40526884)
It depends how quickly it happens, and how well they are paying attention. We all know those accident prone drivers who are never "at-fault" - just very bad at avoiding them!

However, the human has the major advantage of having a brain and being able to understand the consequences and potential outcomes of something in real-time as it is unfolding. I doubt most autopilots would understand the situations I mentioned - certainly not unless they were specifically pre-programmed/trained into the system. Would an autopilot even see what is going on inside a car if a driver is bending down below dashboard, or fighting with passenger, for example?

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by CharlieDigital on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:54PM (#40529660)
Here's the thing: the technology will get faster and better.

Your average driver is already at the limits of human capabilities with no room for improvement unless they go train to drive like F1 racers. So comparing humans to the current state of tech seems silly given that the tech will assuredly one day be faster than a human.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:28PM (#40530291)
I don't think response time is the issue here - at the moment the computer doesn't have the intelligence or ability to learn of the human, so the human is going to be safer in situations the computer was not programmed to handle. I expect we will eventually get human level AI (but maybe not very soon), and if that is used for autopilot then the computer could have the safety edge with faster reaction time if in-car hardware is fast enough.
Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by marssaxman on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:15PM (#40539721)
> the tech will assuredly one day be faster than a human

I'll be happy to take it seriously after that happens. In the meantime, I'm sticking with my belief that unreliable automation is worse than no automation.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by heavenlyblue on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:22PM (#40540403)
> Your average driver is already at the limits of human capabilities with no room for improvement unless they go train to drive like F1 racers.

You just dreamed up this statement and immediately believed it.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by rurban on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:01AM (#40543779)
The F1 example is totally wrong. The F1 controller runs at 10kHz hard real-time, the car controller at 500mHz, a human driver can react at maximum 30ms. A F1 driver is nothing compared to its controller, whilst the normal car driver has comparable reaction times.

You cannot train a F1 driver for highly dynamic events at 20k rpm and 4000 NM forces at the axles, you need automated controllers for that. You can train him for simple things, like gear switching (5ms) and hitting the breakpoints right. But an AI will be at least 10.000 better than a human on this.

You need a slow human brain for the stupid mistakes instead.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by jjav on Saturday June 01, 2024 @01:03PM (#40547366)
> Your average driver is already at the limits of human capabilities with no room for improvement unless they go train to drive like F1 racers.

This is nowhere near true. The skill range from average driver (who knows nothing about car control or reacting correctly) to F1 drivers is vast. There's a huge gray area between these extremes that would be improve safety is people chose (or were forced to) get some training.

Even something as basic as taking a car control clinic once a year would improve the average driver skill and safety by a huge amount.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by Spooky23 on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:45PM (#40530664)
People tend to muddle through.

If we had the same lawyers available that Tesla does, humans too would be not responsible for much of anything.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by moomin on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:01AM (#40532212)
Question is: who’s liable for the accident in these circumstances? Because to date the legal circumstances are such you would be heavily advised to keep your autopilot off.
Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by f1refly on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:10AM (#40532259)
Mercedes takes liability for it. That's their marketing pitch for the feature.
Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by mattpallissard on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:55PM (#40548181)
Humans can make assumptions about humans better than machines. For example there was a trailer with a tire that blew out in front of me. It was rapidly slowing. I checked my mirrors and was being tail-gated too closely to hit the breaks. There was a car in the lane right of me, and lane right behind me.

I merged hard right before it was clear. I assumed the car on my right would do the same, and the driver further behind would break in time. They either made the same assumptions as me or took my queues and acted accordingly and everything turned out ok.

It is pretty amazing how people can coordinate on-the-fly.

Re:How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a... by watwut on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:37PM (#40537225)
Sure. But the important thing is that manufacturer trusts its own system enough to take legal liability on himself. And that matters.