Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by bushbaba on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:21PM
(#40410183)
It’s not that expensive at YouTube scale. We are talking fractions of a penny per GiB transferred.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by Ferret7446 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:50PM
(#40410330)
"not that expensive" is relative; it's still a lot of money. Sure, it's not trillions of dollars, but it's still billions of dollars. YouTube has historically not returned a net profit (and I haven't heard of that situation changing).
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by Retric on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:08PM
(#40410433)
Do you have a public source for that? From what I’ve heard YouTube has been profitable year years at this point.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by AlbertCory on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:28PM
(#40410530)
> Do you have a public source for that?
YT financials and P&L were not broken out in audited financial statements back in the day.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by rreichman on Monday May 20, 2024 @12:32AM
(#40412276)
Still aren’t. Alphabet only publishes YouTube revenue.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by AlbertCory on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @06:34PM
(#40447568)
... and therefore, saying they're "profitable" is meaningless.
Allocating costs for things from Google that they use (e.g. the Ads system) is difficult. The problem with any subsidiary.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by Delmololo on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:51AM
(#40412976)
Yt basically got unusable without premium though.
I have premium, my wife accepts all of those ads
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by 7bit on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:45AM
(#40416087)
Still on Ublck Origin and I don't see any ads and all the videos.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by k12sosse on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:28PM
(#40417848)
I did that for a while and then even just hearing my wife suffer through it made me upgrade to the family plan. Now I invited some other family members and we are all enjoying that premium bitrate no-ad lifestyle.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by DeathArrow on Monday May 20, 2024 @01:52PM
(#40418086)
I have uBlock Origin.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by Delmololo on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:12PM
(#40418328)
That doesn't work on my LG tv
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by deprecative on Monday May 20, 2024 @11:48PM
(#40423892)
Skill issue.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by johnnyanmac on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @03:00AM
(#40425041)
PiHole if the LG TV is an invariant. Otherwise, I believe casting from your ad blocked device should make the TV itself ad-free (Though for YT, "casting" may in face just be "using the app").
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by will1am on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:44PM
(#40418681)
It's impossible for me to watch without premium too
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by sam0x17 on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:21AM
(#40413127)
> YouTube has historically not returned a net profit (and I haven't heard of that situation changing).
I'm sure that's what Google's accountants would love us (and the IRS) to continue to believe.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by vasco on Monday May 20, 2024 @05:38AM
(#40413764)
Not sure, one could say they use their dominant search position and revenue to serve video at a loss and distort the market, making it very hard for anyone without an existing money printing machine to bootstrap a profitable video site. See vimeo.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by alickz on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:08AM
(#40413927)
that was my assumption when i read they weren't profitable
and also that streaming and storing video at that scale is almost a natural monopoly, with how much it must cost and how hard it would be to compete without existing resources
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by Aissen on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @08:54AM
(#40427849)
Infrastructure at scale is not as expensive as cloud vendors would have you think. Reaching scale and being a first-mover gives a significant advantage, because deploying a CDN with caches well connected with(in) every major ISP around the world takes time.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by superb_dev on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:35PM
(#40410264)
Yeah, YouTube is big enough to put their own cache nodes directly in ISP datacenters
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by WookieRushing on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:40PM
(#40410289)
Yup! This is the reason why its so cheap for them. Other companies in similar positions have cache nodes in the ISPs and this dramatically lowers the cost
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by mikepurvis on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:09PM
(#40410442)
Which would help for the crazy popular meme videos, but I bet the long tail on YouTube is insanely big, even if you did have the “watch next” engine getting in on the game steering you toward content already present in your nearby caches.
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by selcuka on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:38PM
(#40411241)
YouTube is estimated to have 1 exabyte [1] of data. Petabyte level storage is not unheard of [2], and a gateway server with 5PB storage would cover ~0.5% of all YouTube videos, which should be sufficient to serve a very high percentage of the most popular videos.
They can still afford to serve the occasional obscure video from the origin servers.
[1] https://www.qqtube.com/blog/how-much-storage-does-youtube-ha...
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by bobmcnamara on Monday May 20, 2024 @12:17AM
(#40412223)
Bingo, and also in Internet Exchanges - every ISP at KCIX the exchange has direct handoff to YouTube, Google, NetFlix, Cloudflare, ...
Re:Ask HN: Video streaming is expensive yet YouTube "seems" ...
by pavelstoev on Sunday May 19, 2024 @11:50PM
(#40412099)
Next iteration of this will be video generated on demand with GenAI running closer to the request, ideally at the request.