Generative art is ideal for this type of stock art use case where 90% is simply good enough for the vast majority of situations.
I feel like the gig economy (things like Fiverr) are unfortunately going to get absolutely crushed by generative art systems since most of their customers aren't that particular and are likely fine with anything that DALL-E / SD can pump out.
Predictably this is already happening, it doesn't take much browsing in categories such as tattoo design to spot the hallmarks of AI generated artwork. To add insult to injury they often pretend they aren't using AI, so they can up-charge for more intricate artwork that would take more effort if they weren't really just adding more synonyms for "detailed" to their Midjourney prompt.
Fiverr does have a dedicated category for AI art, but they don't seem to be making any effort whatsoever to keep AI art out of every other category, so it's pointless.
Which is kind of interesting. My first tattoo has its roots from it. Where I used ChatGPT together with DALL-e to express the concept I wanted on my body, and not a direct translation of it.
Worked out pretty well, got a lot easier to discuss how and what things would work and how to apply them.
Why would the style be uniformized? It is neither observed to be happening with generative art, nor is it desired.
It's wild that this is a thing when the tattoo artists job is literally to create the artwork for you
They're artists after all, not artisans.
I guess the moral of that story is, you can probably get away with it if you're not specifically marketing to people who know what AI looks like and will tear you to shreds if they see it.
I worry any attempt at that will strangle all creative endevours. Copying others style is not a new thing. It is the stuff culture is made of.
And Glaze does not try to interfere with labeling.
Models and adversarial data are equally powerful - you can find an adversarial example for any current model, but you can also train a model that can handle any existing adversarial data.
Any image is a good example of /something/ - at worst it's only an example of itself and irrelevant for any other class. Don't know if there's a name for this principle but it's kind of like a Church-Turing thesis for data.
1) Hire artist to copy the style for 10 images
2) Train model on those
problem solved.
If you choose "using your images specifically" to steal your style as the hill you want to die on, then you're going to find it's a very useless line of defense.
Maybe that would be Fair Use, but things like purpose, weak transformation (in the hired artists copies), competition against the original, and business motive would all suggest it relies on non-Fair Use copying.
I don't know why you think something that involves direct copying shouldn't be a 'hill to die on' for a copyright infringement claim?
What I'm saying is that if you believe that your personal style is your valuable asset and choose to protect it by saying people can't train on your images; you ought to be aware that it's trivially easy to build a model that replicates your style and does not require your images.
Clean room design has nothing to do with this. It is perfectly acceptable to overtly copy a style.
Of course this is mostly only possible if you limit yourself to looking at digital art. A JPEG of a gigantic abstract art oil painting is pretty different from the real thing.
The circumstances of its creation, and the whole entire world of like, booru websites that you have to explain to boomers in suits with VP titles who are trying to invest in this space is just surreal.
It's like a reverse of when they were raising their kids and giving us "the talk" as children. Now we have to give them "the talk" about what the word "doujinshi" means... for science!
It's astonishingly simple to train both LoRAs and Embeddings nowadays -- if you combine it with tech like ControlNet, you can more or less have direct control over the illustration as well (see this example I converted to Hollie Megert's style with barely any effort [1] using the model from [0]) -- but FWIW I was playing with the WhatsApp AI stickers recently and human-made illustrations still have a "je ne sais quoi" that sets them apart, vaguely reminiscent of "realistic" animation vs. "squash and stretch". I would not be worried as an artist*, but I would be worried if I am making assets for corporations in Corporate Memphis [2].
[0] https://waxy.org/2022/11/invasive-diffusion-how-one-unwillin...
[1] https://i.imgur.com/ZwtKug5.jpeg
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_Memphis
* In fact, I think I'd be excited, it can be a great tool, and people who lack artistic sensibility might find it almost as hard to use as to make art themselves. However, I do think there needs to be some kind of protection from having your 'style' commoditized without consent, using unauthorized images of your own art.