Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by whatusername on Monday May 28, 2012 @11:06AM
(#4033661)
There is an argument that you hold the larger screen further from your face. Thus the pixel density your eyes see is different. This would imply that a 5" screen needs less PPI than the 3.5" iPhone.
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by mtgx on Monday May 28, 2012 @11:04AM
(#4033654)
Only for a certain distance, I suppose. Also, it was true for the iPhone at 329 PPI. Is it still true for the iPad 3 at 264 PPI? Apple keeps calling it retina for marketing purposes, but there's quite a gap between 329 and 264. And if 264 is "good enough", does that mean 250 PPI is good enough, too? What about 220?
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by beagle3 on Monday May 28, 2012 @03:03PM
(#4034561)
now? It's been going on forever.
Occasionally, a company manages to get the race off the number tracks - e.g. AMD, whose lower-frequency processors were way better higher-frequency than Intel's Pentium 4 processors of the time.
But in general, companies compete on (numerical) price or on (numerical) specs, and almost always have.
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by nicholassmith on Monday May 28, 2012 @10:18AM
(#4033428)
That's awesome, and I have absolutely no intention of putting a 5" display into my pocket. I survived using old school WinMo slider smartphones and don't miss having a lump of heavy, expensive phone there constantly.
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by jskopek on Monday May 28, 2012 @10:42AM
(#4033546)
The UX experience/monitor size argument has been discussed many times, and the general consensus seems to be that Apple picked a 3.5" screen because it presents the most comfortable layout.
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by mtgx on Monday May 28, 2012 @11:09AM
(#4033678)
And I disagree with that. I find 4.3" comfortable to use with the thumb. Also if 3.5" was the perfect size, Apple wouldn't make it any bigger. And yet there is a very real possiblity that they will increase the size. You get so many more benefits from a larger screen. From the beginning I've been of the belief that as long as it fits in your pocket, you will get a better experience the bigger the screen size of the smartphone is. Also you should start looking at them as mini-tablets rather than just "phones" that got "too big".
Re:LG Intros New 5-inch 1080p Display,Superior Than Apple’s ...
by jskopek on Monday May 28, 2012 @06:08PM
(#4035128)
The experience probably varies quite significantly from person to person. I remember appreciating the decrease in size when I upgraded from my 4" Nexus S to a 3.5" iPhone 4S.
I think you've got a point about a larger screen allows for more info, and apps could probably be designed around the size issues. Facebook pioneer the idea of a side menu that could be swiped open with a gesture, and that technique should allow for easy one-finger usage on even the largest screens.
I read about this display on many news sources, why link from a site that doesn't even proofread the title?!
Wasn't that already true for Retina displays? Maybe I'm missing something but why keep increasing the PPI?
Occasionally, a company manages to get the race off the number tracks - e.g. AMD, whose lower-frequency processors were way better higher-frequency than Intel's Pentium 4 processors of the time.
But in general, companies compete on (numerical) price or on (numerical) specs, and almost always have.
http://www.engadget.com/2012/05/27/lg-display-five-inch-1080...
I believe Dustin Curtis was the first person to start that discussion: http://dcurt.is/2011/10/03/3-point-5-inches
http://www.paulgraham.com/tablets.html
I think you've got a point about a larger screen allows for more info, and apps could probably be designed around the size issues. Facebook pioneer the idea of a side menu that could be swiped open with a gesture, and that technique should allow for easy one-finger usage on even the largest screens.
DPI is the new megapixel count.