News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by petercooper on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:29AM (#40235402)
I get a significant medical every two years for various reasons. Some things are always worth measuring (weight, blood pressure, blood work) but conservatism is the status quo with proactive scanning beyond the essentials for good reason.

Without the right preparation and counselling (or, at minimum, a systematic, logical approach to risk), people can get thrown by findings and struggle to weigh up the risks. Is that new cyst on your kidney a problem? Is that small brain aneurysm (with a very low risk of rupture) going to play on your mind? Might you opt for an operation with a higher mortality rate than simply ignoring it? Even worse: when that 'thing' they found isn't really a 'thing' at all but you got treatment for it anyway.

This tech is great to have available and for motivated individuals to have the option to use, but as something to benefit the mass market, I suspect it'll take a lot of time to shift the needle, and not for technological reasons. I think things like a-fib and blood pressure detection on wearables is more likely to have an impact in the medium term.

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by boxed on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:20AM (#40235917)
These are all problems with doctors overreacting and oversharing.

Collecting the information on a large scale to know what you are looking at next time seems like the sane approach.

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by michaelt on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:47AM (#40236249)
There's also a statistical problem.

Let's say 1% of patients have X, and you've got a test for X which is 99% accurate. You screen 10,000 patients; 100 have X and you identify 99 of them. 9,900 don't have X, and you raise 99 false alarms.

But if you expand screening to cover Y which 0.1% of patients suffer from, and your test for Y is equally accurate, you'll identify 10 patients with Y - and get 100 false alarms.

So the rarer the thing you're screening for, the better your test needs to be - unless you want to be buried in false alarms.

As I understand things, this is why we don't generally screen for prostate cancer in the under-50s.

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by thfuran on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:08AM (#40236513)
And sometimes the test itself can have rare adverse outcomes even ignoring the issues with false positives.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by zo1 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:14AM (#40236568)
I may be off base. But it sounds like the accuracy rate of those tests is off if it's based on an assumption that you'll only test people who have risk factors.

I would have thought that by now, being the year 2024, we've gotten better than just guessing and statistically inferring stuff.

This is where the big disconnect is, and why so many are starting to distrust the medical field. We assume doctors can diagnose stuff and not just go around making educated guesses. No wonder it's a giant government-enforced cartel that restricts competition.

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by boxed on Friday May 03, 2024 @02:10AM (#40244639)
That's not a statistical problem, it's a problem of doctors not knowing statistics. My point is that you could do these scannings on a broad scale and not look at the result per patient. Don't give it to their doctor to look at by default as that is the problem. Use it for basic science FIRST.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by bsder on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:10AM (#40236526)
Nope. The problem is that there are four quadrants in statistics, not two.

There are "found it and you have it", "found it and you don't have it", "didn't find it and you have it" and "didn't find it and you don't have it". Optimizing one of those quadrants deoptimizes the others. If you aren't looking for something specific because your Bayesian probability got bumped by other symptoms, you're going to pop the green jellybean. https://xkcd.com/882/

As someone who has been going through a lot of CT scans recently, I can tell you that they find a lot of inconsequential things. I can imagine that MRIs find even more. My doctors have been what seems to be unduly impressed with my ability to just shrug the reports off except for the specific thing that I need to get fixed. Apparently, most people freak out and they have to spend a lot of time talking them down. My response: "The CT scan results are basically saying "Sucks to get old, brah." There's only one alternative, and it's not very preferable. Now, let's get the thing we're monitoring fixed."

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by tiahura on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:19AM (#40236608)
As an ambulance chaser who reads imaging reports everyday, I can confirm: if you're over 30, you've got at least one cyst somewhere in your body.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by boxed on Friday May 03, 2024 @02:11AM (#40244650)
> My doctors have been what seems to be unduly impressed with my ability to just shrug the reports off except for the specific thing that I need to get fixed. Apparently, most people freak out and they have to spend a lot of time talking them down.

Why would the doctor even tell the patient that irrelevant stuff then? Seems like malpractice.

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by admissionsguy on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:51AM (#40235586)
It seems obvious that one would do repeat measurements of the cyst and look for any changes, in particular rapid growth, rather than jump onto the operating table.

Doing a procedure with higher risk than the asymptomatic condition itself probably should not be covered by insurance, but if someone wants to self-fund it, let them (same if they want to chop off their hand).

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by bluGill on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:21AM (#40235938)
That measurement may be an xray which means that repeated measurement has a chance of causing cancer! Xray isn't the only measurement we have that carries risk to the body if we do it - just one I expect everyone is aware of.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:44AM (#40236214)
And then, even if the measurement was entirely neutral and risk-free to the body, there's still the question whether one can afford the cost (time, and possibly also money) of monitoring the abnormality.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by admissionsguy on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:37AM (#40236115)
Yeah but doing an MRI is strictly better than not doing an MRI. There is no way more information is bad unless some serious irrationality comes into play.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by markus92 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:17AM (#40236590)
Gadolinium-based contrast (which you'll need for any scan worth their salt) is not completely risk free, so not entirely true. And claustrophobia is a bit more common than people think.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by thfuran on Thursday May 02, 2024 @11:38AM (#40237469)
A significant majority of MRIs use no contrast agent.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by markus92 on Saturday May 11, 2024 @06:15PM (#40330982)
But any tumor protocol does.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by r2_pilot on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:48AM (#40236283)
More information can lead to unnecessary procedures(by way of insistence either of patient or doctor) which have their own complications.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by itishappy on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:52AM (#40236333)
> There is no way more information is bad unless some serious irrationality comes into play.

I have some bad news to deliver about humans...

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by thfuran on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:11AM (#40236538)
Doing an MRI isn't free, so it isn't strictly better than not doing one.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by Symmetry on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:41AM (#40236174)
This sort of thing does require a certain tolerance for ambiguity if you want to look at the raw results yourself rather than having a doctor do it for you.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by trackofalljades on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:39AM (#40235479)
This is just photography not radiation or magnetism, so some of those examples wouldn't come up...but I imagine skin cancer and some other preventative concerns might be addressed?
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by lm28469 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:41AM (#40236173)
> This is just photography not radiation or magnetism

Ackchyually light is an _electromagnetic_ _radiation_

The question stays valid though, how many benign things would be treated, how many of these treatments would have net negative results, and at what cost for the already crumbling health system of most western nations

Re:Full Body Scans for the People by cies on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:04AM (#40235727)
If people die before reproducing because they cannot weigh risks, that should result in a population that is better at weighing risk in the long run.
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by gipp on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:19AM (#40235902)
Cool, see you in a million years when that incredibly noisy effect converges
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by disattention on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:21AM (#40235930)
Strangely pro-eugenics take...
Re:Full Body Scans for the People by cies on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:24AM (#40235953)
Not at all. Hardcore against eugenics.

Just in favour of people knowing what goes on inside their body (transparency) and against the narrative "its better for you not to know".