News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by acjohnson55 on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:19PM (#40160376)
Reading the comments here is giving me the disturbing realization that the war in Ukraine is extremely valuable to the US because the US gets to collect immense amounts of data to inform perspectives on how modern technology is revolutionizing warfare with minimal risk to American troops. And that's with technology in the hands of an extremely motivated ally against one of our top rivals. This opportunity doesn't come very often, and I can imagine there are a lot of parties interested in it persisting at least until the value in the observational data starts to tail off. Along with other concerns, this may be a reason to parcel out exactly what tech gets given to Ukraine at which times.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by jjk166 on Thursday April 25, 2024 @02:24PM (#40161205)
It's worth considering that while the equipment in use in the ukraine conflict is obviously relevant, the nature of the conflict is radically different from what the US would face. Ukraine is literally on Russia's doorstep, allowing Russia to send its units in and pull them back for repairs with relatively limited logistical strain. This allows it to use massive numbers of cold war surplus assets that would not be viable anywhere else on earth. Ukraine started the war with an extremely small air force and has received only very limited support in that regard, meaning it has spent the entire war without air control. This both limits Ukraine's capacity to use tactics which rely on air support and gives Russia the ability to operate its air forces in relative safety. US doctrine is completely based around air superiority. Ukraine had an extremely limited standing army and military industrial capacity prior to the war, and has relied heavily on non-professional troops who volunteered or were conscripted after the war started and received only moderate training, and it is dependent on foriegn support for advanced arms and munitions. The US has both the strongest standing army and the most advanced military industrial complex in human history. The issues Ukraine is struggling with now - pushing into areas Russian troops have spent months fortifying while having to conserve artillery shells, holding off an unending trickle of 60 year old soviet tanks, and having to jerry-rig long range drones to attack targets in Russia - are challenges that simply wouldn't exist if the US were fighting a war. If our goal was really to get useful data that would be applicable to US conflicts, we'd be giving the Ukrainians the means to fight the way we fight.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Thursday April 25, 2024 @11:19PM (#40165662)
I agree Ukraine never had a chance against the far superior Russian military. The reason the US and NATO did not officially send ground troops, although many of their people are on the ground, is that it would trigger full war between NATO and Russia which would go thermonuclear. If that ever happened, Russia's larger and more advanced nuclear arsenal (ballistic missiles) would give it an advantage. Their large land mass, twice that of the US, would give them a better survival chance after the fallout.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by racional on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:11PM (#40171869)
I agree Ukraine never had a chance against the far superior Russian military.

A very weird thing to say, given Russia's humiliating defeat (in terms of the objectives it believed it would surely and painlessly achieve) in 2022.

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Friday April 26, 2024 @05:59PM (#40174779)
If you study the basics of war fighting, you will understand that deception on the battlefield is important for success. I do not know how you have any inside information about what people in the Kremlin believed and were planning. I suspect you are parroting whatever NATO media told you.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by fennecbutt on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:00PM (#40175271)
The only thing the Russian military is superior in is numbers, and it's very clear that they care very little for the men who fight and die for their country, even less so than America discarding their veterans; at least America's army doesn't send them in to be actual cannon fodder.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by racional on Friday April 26, 2024 @06:08PM (#40174836)
No inside information is needed. It's entirely obvious and transparent what happened.

I suspect you are parroting whatever NATO media told you.

Yeah, yeah.

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by Balgair on Thursday April 25, 2024 @03:56PM (#40162237)
It was always going to be a terrible tragedy with Ukraine. Vlad committed something much worse than a crime, he committed a mistake (to paraphrase Talleyrand).

NATO+ countries aren't fighting him, they are using Ukraine as a proxy, while Vlad is fighting with his own army. NATO has been waiting nearly 80 years to attack Russia directly. They very motivated to make sure that Vlad continues making errors. As such, the longer this war takes, the better for NATO. And, unfortunately, the worse for Ukraine.

I think data collection is for sure one aspect, but I think Russian casualties is the largest motivator

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by sangnoir on Thursday April 25, 2024 @05:23PM (#40163209)
> And, unfortunately, the worse for Ukraine

In what way would having the whole of Ukraine annexed like Crimea be better for Ukraine?

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by Sammi on Thursday April 25, 2024 @07:14PM (#40164222)
Are charitable reading would be that that was not what was said.

It was not said that Ukraine would be better off it it stopped fighting. Only that Ukraine will be worse off the longer the war takes.

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by bllguo on Thursday April 25, 2024 @07:15PM (#40164231)
gee what a mystery. how about no more bloodshed for starters.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by fullspectrumdev on Friday April 26, 2024 @03:01AM (#40166619)
The bloodshed would not end. The Russians are hell bent on ethnic cleansing, as can be evidenced by Bucha and several other places I’ve actually been to.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Thursday April 25, 2024 @02:07PM (#40161018)
I have been watching the warfare via several Telegram channels and observe how important drone warfare now is. I watched 5 $10M Abrams tanks destroyed by $500 FPV drones. Close combat on troops is also conducted with drones with remarkable precision. We don't know how much of the targeting and execution by Russia is automated verses manual, but many experts in this field agree that Russia's technical capability is at parity and sometimes exceeds NATO's such as hypersonic missiles.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by exhilaration on Thursday April 25, 2024 @04:42PM (#40162751)
I thought Russia's hypersonic missiles were a failure, with the Ukrainians shooting them down with 30 year old Patriot missiles? There were a lot of articles about it last year, here's one:

https://www.defenseone.com/technology/2023/09/what-ukraines-...

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Thursday April 25, 2024 @08:11PM (#40164569)
That was fake news. https://www.theinteldrop.org/2023/05/14/confirmed-ukraine-ly...

Additionally, Iran claims that Israel did not intercept any of the hypersonic missiles they fired at Israel.

NATO does not possess any hypersonic missiles. Some people might say that NATO is keeping them secret, but that makes no sense. Nations exhibit their technologies as a deterrent.

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Friday April 26, 2024 @12:46AM (#40166026)
Further explanation of how it is impossible for a Patriot missile to intercept a Kinzhal. https://sputnikglobe.com/20230510/fact-check-ukraine-didnt-s...
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by blue_pants on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:36AM (#40166245)
Those are not credible sources.

From the theinteldrop link: "several sources within the Russian military and defense industry told the newspaper Izvestia on Saturday"

From the sputnikglobe link: "Moscow-based military expert Alexey Leonkov told Sputnik"

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by kornhole on Friday April 26, 2024 @09:24AM (#40169089)
What makes these sources not credible in your mind? I have not observed them reporting anything incorrectly. They are citing military experts who know the technical capabilities of these weapons and defense systems. If you want to refute what they say, show how a slower Patriot missile could target and intercept a much faster mach 5 missile. It is basic physics without getting deeply into rocket science.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by fennecbutt on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:02PM (#40175285)
"Military experts" != engineers and physicists (usually).
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by hackerlight on Friday April 26, 2024 @03:15AM (#40166681)
Palmer Luckey says Russia's Kinzhal is not a hypersonic glide vehicle so it's not that hard to intercept, unlike what China can field.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by attentive on Thursday April 25, 2024 @05:56PM (#40163568)
I have an impression that no modern technology is tested there but rather supplied with ready to be decommissioned 50 year old antics.
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by gantron on Thursday April 25, 2024 @06:15PM (#40163742)
You're mostly correct that the older tech is the bulk of what's been sent, but there have been lots of batches of newer tech that the US has delivered. [0]

These newer companies (Anduril, Skydio, etc.) do it for a few reasons. Some are obvious: they get paid and their systems have a chance at influencing real-world events that the leadership & rank-and-file employees might care about personally.

But from a pure product development perspective, fielding these systems is a valuable test opportunity. You've built a great drone but you're not sure how it'll perform in a GPS-denied environment with S-band radio completely unusable? Russian Electronic Warfare teams are happy to curate that environment for you.

[0] https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2024-01-08...

Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by shrimp_emoji on Thursday April 25, 2024 @06:54PM (#40164074)
Did you get the disturbing realization that Russia gets data on the materiel too?
Re:Air Force picks Anduril, General Atomics to develop unman... by acjohnson55 on Thursday April 25, 2024 @11:10PM (#40165613)
Of course they are, but to me at least, it seems like their cost-benefit is very different from the US. I don't think the war is worth it to them just to learn more about warfare.