News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No one buys books by yellow_postit on Monday April 22, 2024 @11:43PM (#40128240)
It’s funny seeing this comment and the article about Seattle libraries reducing digital copies both on HNews front page at the same time.

I love libraries.

It also feels like all our public institutions in the US are crumbling under assault from all sides.

Re:No one buys books by j45 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:40AM (#40128864)
Limiting or undermining literacy remains important to those who benefit from it.
Re:No one buys books by nox101 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:42AM (#40129186)
what logic leads to this conclusion? I tend to lean to the rising tide lifts all boats. who benefits from illiteracy?
Re:No one buys books by grepLeigh on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:11AM (#40129361)
UNESCO published a report on the beneficiaries of illiteracy at global, national, and regional levels (1989):

https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000085962

Re:No one buys books by animex on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:47AM (#40129565)
People who want to control the illiterate and subjugate their voting power to their own ends.
Re:No one buys books by Root_Denied on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:56AM (#40129273)
> who benefits from illiteracy?

Those already on top.

They can afford to educate their own line and hoard resources across generations doing so. They can fail as many times as it takes before they finally succeed because of this. They throw the bodies of the world at their problems until they are solved, which necessitates an uneducated populace that doesn't realize they're chattel and canon fodder to this purpose. A populace that fear collective power, that fears community beyond immediate family, that shies away from actions that would better the world in favor of actions that are less risky personally.

Re:No one buys books by yunohn on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:13AM (#40129375)
Elites are always worried about the labor crisis - “nobody wants to work”. Usually this is about blue collar work, and their desire to underpay and overwork service/laborers.

Globally, this class of people definitely wants to reduce literacy to keep a stream of manual labor inflowing.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @08:36AM (#40131229)
This is a strong claim that needs some data to back it up.
Re:No one buys books by Karellen on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @05:18AM (#40130053)
The number of vastly unequal societies throughout history who have banned the lower classes from learning how to read, or from any kind of education at all - beyond whatever narrow training will make them better perform their specific duties for those on top.

...and not just historically. Some societies where significant minority groups are banned from getting an education, in order to further perpetuate their marginalisation, still exist today.

Re:No one buys books by kennyadam on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:37AM (#40142707)
Just look at women in afghanistan, for example.
Re:No one buys books by j45 on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:43AM (#40168155)
India and the caste system has done it for the past 1-2000 years.

Literacy for more people is a relatively new thing.

Re:No one buys books by boringg on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:18AM (#40132292)
The response to your comment thread here is some pretty high flying conspiracies. The thought that those in power would try and make the country illiterate is straight up ridiculous. That would completely undermine the competitiveness of the country AND the time line to get any benefit for the "elites or whomever is behind it" would be significantly long.

Now if you are talking about a country like India - sure I could see Modi doing that. In that case it would be more about restricting growth and investment into education then dismantling an economy built on knowledge.

Re:No one buys books by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @12:58PM (#40134169)
No one is suggesting billionaires are rational.
Re:No one buys books by j45 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:13PM (#40135177)
I don't think I said anything about making people illiterate.

Undermining literacy means so they are not as literate as they could be to improve their lives.

For example, there are more than a few studies on literacy and education levels of the political spectrum for better and worse.

India is a different world. The crime against humanity that is the caste system all but forbade 1-3% of the population to be permitted to learn how to read. 95-98% of Indians were not permitted to learn how to read, and had to rely on the interpretations of the less populous castes.

Ironically it is a minority that largely broke this logjam and helped push literacy for the many forward.

I'll gladly take the downvotes for speaking the truth about caste being a divider between people and society.

Re:No one buys books by no_exit on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:44PM (#40135606)
> what logic leads to this conclusion?

Any decent book about Reconstruction and Jim Crow.

Re:No one buys books by cafard on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @07:07AM (#40130493)
The advocates of "whole-language" learning as against "phonics" seem to do a fair job of limiting or undermining literacy. Yet how it benefits them I don't see. And what is the reference of "it" in the last sentence? Literacy, or limited or undermined literacy?
Re:No one buys books by j45 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @09:43AM (#40131889)
I should have said and, instead of for.

Undermining is a form of limiting, and limiting is a form of undermining.

Re:No one buys books by creole_wither on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @12:17PM (#40133682)
A literate population that reads what you want them to read is even better.
Re:No one buys books by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @09:37AM (#40144240)
Hence book bans and torching, although it's backfiring because they're being too general to try and avoid coming across as too totalitarian, so things like bibles are being banned too. Whoops.
Re:No one buys books by ddingus on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:38AM (#40129157)
They are. Every single public resource is seen as a potential market opportunity being squandered away, or as competition other players do not want to see in play.
Re:No one buys books by atoav on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:29AM (#40129469)
Well a library is a place where a population can spend the day getting smarter while not spending money.

If you're rich, powerful and an unethical asshole those are two things you definitely do not want.

Sadly many people seem to think they are really showing the folks up there by retreating from any form of self-education once they are out of school. The opposite couldn't be more true.

Re:No one buys books by vik0 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:13AM (#40129677)
>If you're rich, powerful and an unethical asshole those are two things you definitely do not want.

This smells like a half-baked conspiracy theory. It's not like the overwhelming majority of people want to get smarter in their free time. I'm not sure how it is in the rest of the world, but in American and all (individual) European cultures, most people don't pursue self-education. I would not be surprised if this applies to most other cultures as well

You might say that's how a lot of people on this website got their knowledge, but this website is statistically insignificant compared to the world population. Plus, it's not like every single member here pursues self-education. I'm willing to wager most people come on here just to be entertained

Re:No one buys books by atoav on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:44AM (#40129840)
I didn't say rich, powerful and unethical people actively need to work against public libraries. They just don't need to support them, which is enough, given the fact that they often land in or near places of political power.

Just don't increase the funding while inflation increases and you're basically cutting funding. And then when things eventually start to look like shit tear them down. And these are not even things a rich, powerful and unethical person needs to do willingly or on purpose. It is just a thing that happens, because it isn't high on the priority list. And it isn't high on the priority list because it doesn't make them direct money.

Now if you're a politician that profits from your constituents being not too critical why should you actively support a thing that has the potential to make them more critical? Not that you actively have to be against it, it just isn't that high on your list of priorities..

This is how incentives work. And while there are people who will support measures which won't directly profit them short term, it seems to me they are an endangered species, at least in the US.

Re:No one buys books by ghaff on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:04AM (#40132127)
Public libraries are largely funded/supported locally. In my town, that mostly means out of a vote at town meeting, volunteer organizations, and an annual book sale. There is occasionally local political drama but it's mostly around people who earn some nominal salary that wouldn't persuade a lot of people on this site to get out of bed in the morning.
Re:No one buys books by dfxm12 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:11AM (#40132222)
Conservatives in the US are constantly trying to ban books [0] and defund education [1].

It's not surprising that this push comes amid the understanding that the less educated one is, the more likely they are to vote R [2]. Conservative governments placing restrictions on education to cling to power has historical precedent. Iran comes to mind as a recent example. It's not a "half-baked conspiracy theory", it's a political strategy. Hell, the Texas GOP's 2012 platform was specifically against teaching critical thinking skills [3] because these skills could undermine authority.

0 - https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/dec/09/republ...

1 - https://www.americanprogress.org/article/house-republican-bu...

2 - https://news.gallup.com/poll/609776/democrats-lose-ground-bl...

3 - https://s3.amazonaws.com/texasgop_pre/assets/original/2012Pl...

Re:No one buys books by hollywood_court on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:38AM (#40132491)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. You speak the truth.

We're experiencing this very same thing now in Alabama. Or one could simply look at Florida. Things aren't getting better here. The current GOP leadership is trying their best to be as regressive as possible.

I feel like I am doing my son an incredible disservice by raising him in Alabama, but my wife refuses to leave while her mother is still living here.

Re:No one buys books by ddingus on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:18PM (#40136777)
Show him some alternatives. I grew up in a backward place too.

The single most valuable thing I learned is what is really possible to do. I got to see that because I ended up helping people of means who took me aside and showed me a look outside the place I was living.

For many, and this is true of my peer group, just knowing what is possible really mattered.

Of course I left town, found work and married someone I thought highly of and got to work building a better life.

Your son can do that too. Make sure he knows it.

Re:No one buys books by hollywood_court on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:17PM (#40138021)
I plan on showing him alternatives so he doesn't have to learn about them they way that I did.

I moved out of my mother's home when I was 16 and I managed to graduate high school. But I left town two days after graduation and I've only been back three times in 24 years.

Had I not left Alabama, and the US, I would have likely ended up just as bigoted and close minded as most of my family. The ten years I spent outside of the US allowed me to learn a completely different perspective and finally made me realize that my mother and my other family were wrong about so many things.

My boy just turned five a few weeks ago and he's already travelled more than I did by the time I turned 21.

Re:No one buys books by vik0 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @04:18AM (#40141901)
Mind sharing where you moved and how that prevented you from going to the road, from as you say: "just as bigoted and close minded as most of my family.", to whatever you became afterward? Do you think had you moved to another place in the US, a similar change would not have occurred, or did it have to be outside the US?
Re:No one buys books by hollywood_court on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @10:29AM (#40144813)
I moved to the Caribbean for 10 years. Then on to SF and later PDX. I also spent about 6 months in both NYC and Chicago in between SF and PDX. Living in the Caribbean introduced me to so many different cultures.

I ran a bar before I became a carpenter. My neighbors around my bar included people from India, Senegal, all over Europe, and Japan. I become close friends with a much older couple from Senegal and also an Indian family. They welcomed me into their homes and fed me and taught me about their music and food and such.

I likely would not have had those experiences if I remained on the mainland.

Re:No one buys books by docmars on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:28AM (#40133047)
While there are a few fringe pockets where GOP influence isn't helping anyone, by and large, the "conspiracy theorists" and MAGA folks are attacking major news outlets, scientific journals, etc. strictly because they have been corrupted and influenced by highly partisan partnerships from the left, to bend narratives or outright lie about controversial issues and current events in their favor.

When citizen journalists on X (and other places) are putting corporate media to shame because they're willing to faithfully report what the corporates aren't, that's a clear sign there's something amiss. Breaking free of this one-sided media conglomerate is essential for critical thinking, because journalists have no place in thinking for people, which is unfortunately true on all sides, in practice.

Worse, corporate media sources use their powerful positions not just as a beacon of authority, but as a way to enforce false narratives through their close partnerships with their preferred political partners, who are working to manipulate those narratives in their favor for political gain, like winning elections at nearly any cost. Additionally, shaming and declaring citizen & independent journalists as "misinformants" for questioning mainstream narratives that have been identified as patently false/twisted, either by lying or by omission, evidenced by whistleblowers calling out these issues in interviews with independent sources, knowing their stories won't be edited for political purposes.

Similarly on X, now that it isn't captured by a political side that openly believes censorship is acceptable to elevate their own preferred narratives, information can flow freely and users on X can think for themselves (scary, I know... imagine if YOU could think freely and post your own convictions! How will humanity survive?). Since the previous "community guidelines" enforcers at Twitter have been fired, faithful counter-reporting is no longer being policed (the "now" true Hunter Biden report comes to mind conveniently after the 2020 election was over). Now Conservatives can have an equal and prominent voice there, given that Twitter/X has always been a premier source of real-time news and reporting.

If something cannot be questioned, speculating on the motives around it is essential. The 20th century saw too many tyrants dictating the flow of information for us to conveniently forget its devastating impacts on their respective societies. Not a single politician, media outlet, scientist, or "expert" is above being questioned, for any reason whatsoever. It is the only path to healthy, inclusive dialogue.

Re:No one buys books by vik0 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @04:14AM (#40141889)
>It's not surprising that this push comes amid the understanding that the less educated one is, the more likely they are to vote R [2].

I saw the article, and it does indeed show this, however, I'm not sold that education is the only criterion when it comes to how someone votes... or does anything else, for that matter

It's far too simple of a cause-and-effect type of deal for this to be the only factor, or even, for this to be a factor at all, perhaps. The world is a bit more complex than chucking everything up to how someone does something based solely on their administered level of institutional education

I've been just a tiny bit more skeptical of all of these cause-and-effect type stories ever since I read Nassim Taleb

Re:No one buys books by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @04:29AM (#40141953)
> however, I'm not sold that education is the only criterion when it comes to how someone votes... or does anything else, for that matter

It isn't, however if your education or world view is superficial, you're more susceptible to right-wing talking points, like a broad spectrum "fear of ones that are different to you". But when you're more educated, more worldly, less blinkered you won't be as afraid of the other and less susceptible to a politician that They are after your jobs and benefits, and more aware that the politicians and rich people are trying to keep you down for their own gains.

Re:No one buys books by vik0 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @11:32AM (#40145609)
Sure, and superficially what you're saying does make sense... except that it's using deductive reasoning. There are plenty of cases where people with academic credentials vote for the same people you say dumb people do. Dumb people, of course, are people who have no academic credentials, because they're only for very smart people

I recommend giving Who Voted for Hitler? by Richard F. Hamilton a read. The world is infinitely much more complex than our story-making minds would have us believe

Re:No one buys books by Jerrrry on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @11:06AM (#40145246)
Liberals are trying to ban books too.

"Education", as you have used it, is a measure of collegiate accomplishment, not of merited learned-ness.

It correlates more with socio-economic class.

The same argument can easily be made about Democrats and their inability to repair trivial household items, or empathize with those outside of their privileged groups.

You just pick a characteristic and then label it "good" measure of [x]. Ironically the same thought process is too blame for "telling too many people to goto college"

The lack of self-agency, accountability, and ability to empathize on the left is astounding.

Re:No one buys books by CalRobert on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:05AM (#40132792)
It doesn't need to be most people though. It just needs to be the smart ones.
Re:No one buys books by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @04:26AM (#40141933)
> I'm willing to wager most people come on here just to be entertained

To add to the conspiracy, endless entertainment is another way that the rich and powerful want to keep the population complacent. Add some unsubtle propaganda about how great and diverse the US is, too.

That said, the propaganda isn't as straightforward as it used to be, and foreign propaganda is sprinkled in as well with e.g. China funding and adding their section to big blockbuster films.

Re:No one buys books by Zenzero on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:56AM (#40129914)
> Well a library is a place where a population can spend the day getting smarter while not spending money. If you're rich, powerful and an unethical asshole those are two things you definitely do not want.

This is conspiracy level thinking. Nobody wealthy is sitting around scheming how to keep the proles dumb and subdued.

The assault on public institutions like libraries comes from 2 places: 1) Stop wasting my tax dollars on stuff I don't use or care about. Or 2) I bet there is an untapped commercial market that can be built, and people will love my solution more than public libraries.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @08:09AM (#40130998)
> > [Rich & powerful assholes often maintain their status by unethical means.]

> This is conspiracy level thinking.

The prevalence of assholes is a documented thing (latest numbers I've heard was over 6% of clinical narcissists, reportedly a very conservative lower bound), and who would ever be surprised that high-status people like being high-status?

I don't know about libraries specifically, but the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious.

I am of course not denying the existence of nice rich people. Though I'm afraid they tend to be selected out of ludicrous wealth. In fact, I fully expect to find many more assholes among super-rich people than I would among the general population. (But I'm not sure either: the strife we find among some of the poorest people also tend to generate assholes…)

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @08:32AM (#40131191)
The irony is that one of the largest contributions to the public library system was one of the richest guys ever. Carnegie funded over 2500.
Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @08:43AM (#40131308)
You do realise you're not contradicting anything I've just said, right?

Quoting myself, "I am of course not denying the existence of nice rich people".

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @09:07AM (#40131527)
But then you go on to say,

>Though I'm afraid they tend to be selected out of ludicrous wealth.

The irony is that one of the most ludicrously wealthy people in history was also probably the single largest contributor to public libraries. Whether or not he was simply an outlier, I think that’s an important thing to point out.

Further, some data suggests that as much as 5% of the general population are narcissists. So collectively, your point seems to be that rich people are pretty much like the rest of us, just with more money.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:03AM (#40132107)
> But then you go on to say,

I said "tend to". A tendency does not make an absolute and complete genocide. I also said "I'm afraid", which is supposed to convey some level of uncertainty. Carnegie's donation doesn't invalidate my point, even if he wasn't an outlier.

> The irony is that one of the most ludicrously wealthy people in history was also probably the single largest contributor to public libraries.

Where you see irony, I see expected statistics: the largest contributor to pretty much anything has to be ludicrously rich. Because the only way to give that much, is to own even more.

And I will add that one incentive for rich people to donate is their public image. And in many cases their "donations" are largely neutered by tax cuts or by increasing the return on some of their other investments (basically their donations causing other of their investments to increase their returns). Donations by rich people aren't always genuinely generous.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:44AM (#40132562)
What evidence would it take to change your mind? Because it seems like you'll rationalize any outcome to fit your mental model.

If the wealthy don't fund something, it's because they're narcissists. If they do, it's because of statistics. At the same time, you ignore the statistics about narcissism.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:12AM (#40132864)
> If the wealthy don't fund something, it's because they're narcissists. If they do, it's because of statistics.

I said no such strawman, and it's not my main point anyway.

My main point is: the idea that rich & powerful people will generally do what it takes to stay rich & powerful is not conspiracy thinking, it's common sense. The idea that a sizeable proportion of them will resort to unethical (even lethal) means to do so is not conspiracy thinking, it's common sense.

That's it, and I don't think Mr Carnegie here provides any significant evidence to the contrary. I mean, the same guy reportedly had strikers shot and killed, didn't he? It's hard to believe such a guy donated large amounts of money out of the goodness of his heart.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:45AM (#40133250)
You did say they want to remain high status, likely due to their over indexing in narcissism. Even if that’s not your main point, the logical leap that we seem to disagree on is that promoting illiteracy is the means to that end. Carnegie does provide evidence against that, as does all the libraries and educational buildings that are named for wealthy donors.

There’s a philosophical argument that all altruism is actually selfish in nature, so I don’t think your premise holds that the wealthy are unique in this regard. What you seem to be saying is that they are complicated just the same as everyone else, just with more resources. If your only point is that wealthy people are status-minded, I don't disagree. I disagree that they are uniquely status-minded. As William Storr's work attests, we are all status-driven apes, whether wealthy or not.

You also didn’t answer the question about what it would take to change your mind, which is usually indicative of a dogmatic, rather than reasoned, position.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:51PM (#40134874)
> You did say they want to remain high status, likely due to their over indexing in narcissism.

Quote me, or I didn’t.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:20PM (#40135290)
>The prevalence of assholes is a documented thing...latest numbers I've heard was over 6% of clinical narcissists...who would ever be surprised that high-status people like being high-status?...the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold...it's just obvious."

Feel free to clarify, but to me, this reads as, "Rich people, being narcissists, will try to maintain their high status by keeping the education level of the general populace low."

It also reads as a narrative talking point without good evidence to support it. I.e., "I can't prove it, I just know it's true."

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @05:15PM (#40137357)
Wrong reading. I never intended to make a generalisation out of 6% or even triple that amount. I just wanted to establish that rich assholes are a thing.
Re:No one buys books by bumby on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @05:53PM (#40137793)
You seem to imply they are a higher rate of rich assholes, no? The most cited research on this (Piff et al.) is highly flawed IMO and hasn’t been able to be replicated.

Or is your point that people are assholes in general? If the latter, I’m failing to see how that gets connected to rich people actively suppressing education, especially when, as you say, they are the most likely to donate money to those causes.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @03:45AM (#40141749)
> You seem to imply they are a higher rate of rich assholes, no?

It seems likely. But that's a detail, because I believe the more important effect is the contempt higher-class people can have towards lower-class people. Some of it may even come from cognitive dissonance. See, barring a few exceptions, one does not get rich just by working. One also has to exploit other people, to spoil them of a fraction of their added value. The richer you are the truer this gets, and then you have to find some way to look at yourself in the mirror despite that.

> actively suppressing education

I don't recall saying that. My exact words were: "I don't know about libraries specifically, but the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious."

> especially when, as you say, they are the most likely to donate money to those causes.

I didn't say that either. My exact words were: "he largest contributor to pretty much anything has to be ludicrously rich. Because the only way to give that much, is to own even more."

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @08:19AM (#40143490)
You certainly did say those things. They are quoted from your posts, but abbreviated to be less verbose and wandering. I used ellipses to show where words were cut, and I think you understand this so you seem to just be difficult/obtuse out of a desire to argue.

To be generous, you said they are the "largest contributors" which I agree is different than being "most likely." But the research does show they are more likely, possibly because they are in a position to do so. I think that's what connects to your point.

Just as a counterpoint to your late-stage capitalism-esque viewpoint, wealthy are also shown to over index in conscientiousness in some studies. This is a personality trait that relates to persistence which is an alternate explanation for goal-attainment (ie wealth).

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @10:29AM (#40144814)
> Just as a counterpoint to your late-stage capitalism-esque viewpoint, wealthy are also shown to over index in conscientiousness in some studies.

I fail to see how this is a counter point. Sure, conscientiousness, and I would add work ethics certainly explain some inequality. But even if they explained most of it (exploiting people does require work, and I'd expect the more conscientious capitalists are better at it), they would still come far, far short of morally justifying the level of inequality we observe today.

No billionaire ever deserved to be that wealthy.

Now we can discuss incentives, and I can accept that a good system may need to allow some people to accumulate undeserved wealth. Still, I will note that the mere existence of billionaires is a threat to democracy. (Or a blocker: our representative governments aren't very democratic to begin with, and we have studies showing that when billionaires and the people disagree over a piece of legislation the billionaires win most of the time.)

My current opinion on this is that putting a hard cap on individual wealth is a good thing. Furthermore, I think this hard cap should be well under $1B, almost certainly below $100M.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @11:34AM (#40145640)
>I fail to see how this is a counter point.

Well, that's probably because you are constantly arguing different points that aren't necessarily germane to the discussion. Remember, this was about your point that wealthy people build their wealth by suppressing education in the general populace. So this is a counter-point in that it is possible to build wealth by conscientious behavior instead. There is some research on the latter, but really only conjecture and false narratives on the former.

Wealth inequality and the state of democracy are digressions from that point. I don't think I made any statements about what level of wealth inequality is healthy for the stability of a society, let alone a moral argument for it, nor did I make any claims about democracy. Again, this just comes across as you having an axe to grind, and you'll shoehorn in talking points without addressing the central claim.

Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @03:09PM (#40148277)
> Remember, this was about your point that wealthy people build their wealth by suppressing education in the general populace.

No.

> Wealth inequality and the state of democracy are digressions from that point.

Yes.

Re:No one buys books by bumby on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @05:22PM (#40149850)
I think you've lost the thread. Here's the comment you were originally responding to in the context of our back-and-forth:

>Nobody wealthy is sitting around scheming how to keep the proles dumb and subdued.

To which you replied:

>"the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious."

To which I replied:

>"The irony is that one of the largest contributions to the public library system was one of the richest guys ever."

It was all about the conspiracy that the wealthy actively suppress education until you went off the rails on a completely different rant.

Re:No one buys books by kiba on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @09:55AM (#40132002)
Why would that be obvious? It seems more likely that they don't care about libraries.
Re:No one buys books by loup-vaillant on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:04AM (#40132136)
Can you precise what "that" is referring to?
Re:No one buys books by bumby on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @12:24PM (#40146303)
I think "that" = "the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious."

("the idea" is what you claimed is obvious)

Re:No one buys books by teitoklien on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:29AM (#40130329)
> Nobody wealthy is sitting around scheming how to keep the proles dumb and subdued.

They dont sit around scheming, they work, walk around doing it in action.

Company executives keep adding ingredients to processed food to make them addictive knowing it’ll hurt health outcomes and lead to more death.

Company executives continue to sell medicine that they sell for $20 or $10 in Europe or India, but charge americans $5000 or higher for the same medicine in the same package.

They shut down any research paper that outs them, by suppressing the findings, like Facebook or Junk food companies do whenever a research is conducted on their products.

We should celebrate our pioneers and innovators, but we shouldn’t ignore it blindly when MBA execs and Beancounters actively sabotage and hurt their own customers and the masses. Businesses are awesome, but it shouldnt be used to give a no questions asked green flag to anyone who runs businesses.

There are people actively lobbying for policies that lead to more american deaths, bankruptcies, families breaking into shambles, and the government watching from the sidelines and even sometimes helping to make it all happen.

Yes, there are people who do want to subdue the masses and keep them dumb, just as long as it helps them buy 1 more yacht or few more 0s in their bank balance.

I say it as a free market capitalist who is ardently anti-communist.

Re:No one buys books by stetrain on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:53AM (#40133377)
> This is conspiracy level thinking. Nobody wealthy is sitting around scheming how to keep the proles dumb and subdued.

Of course not. They're scheming about how to monetize education, knowledge, and research.

> 1) Stop wasting my tax dollars on stuff I don't use or care about. Or 2) I bet there is an untapped commercial market that can be built, and people will love my solution more than public libraries.

(2) Gets a lot easier if you first advocate for (1) to make the public libraries worse.

Re:No one buys books by ogurechny on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:38PM (#40135537)
> Nobody wealthy is sitting around scheming how to keep the proles dumb and subdued.

There are corporate divisions doing A/B tests, etc. to find out what works for the lowest common denominator, and how to profit more from someone's ignorance. Many people here are directly involved in making it happen.

Re:No one buys books by throw__away7391 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:20AM (#40130297)
Ah yes, just last week me and my fellow billionaires at our secret biannual conference in Geneva were discussing how we can prevent people from reading books at the library. See, people reading is a threat to our power, one which we take very seriously. It is not going to be easy, especially seeing how many of us have donated millions of dollars to libraries and a few even have wings of libraries named after us, but the threat is too severe now, drastic measures must be taken.

Now seeing how people are on to our plot, the urgency is clear. I am proposing that over the next few decades we work secretly behind the scenes to gradually reduce funding for various local libraries which have seen visitors decline since the rise of the Internet.

Re:No one buys books by jacobyoder on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:38AM (#40130357)
> few even have wings of libraries named after us

Public libraries? With easy access?

Re:No one buys books by throw__away7391 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:50AM (#40130415)
I don’t know if you have ever been to a public library, but basically all of them are prominently adorned with the names of their largest donors.
Re:No one buys books by atoav on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @01:57AM (#40141106)
How many of those could you have built if you had taxed billionaires with a normal tax rate?
Re:No one buys books by throw__away7391 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @12:47PM (#40146743)
I believe this is called "moving the goalposts".
Re:No one buys books by cafard on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @06:49AM (#40130410)
Thank goodness then that socialists got a jump on building libraries back in the day: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnegie_library
Re:No one buys books by yardie on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:28AM (#40132399)
Carnegie: “I’d like to avoid being remembered for having a bunch of labor strikers shot and killed. How can I launder my reputation?”

PR: “sir, with enough money you can make the public believe whatever you want.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitewashing_(censorship)

Re:No one buys books by cafard on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @12:05PM (#40133541)
Quite.

Do you refuse, on principle, to visit the Frick when in New York City? For that matter do you avoid the Rockefeller Center?

Re:No one buys books by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @09:36AM (#40144220)
Straw man argument; the person you're replying to did not mention any boycotting. See also "Mr. Gotcha".
Re:No one buys books by ddingus on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:14PM (#40136728)
Yes, I see it playing out the same undesirable and unfortunate way. Great comment.
Re:No one buys books by leonroy on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:02PM (#40140013)
Didn’t Andrew Carnegie, the very definition of rich and difficult to work for spend a huge chunk of his fortune funding 3000+ libraries?

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnegie_library

Re:No one buys books by defrost on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @11:29PM (#40140207)
The criticisms were telling though, Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain) and many others claimed he had a rich mans agenda, seeking fame rather than improvement, paying for buildings and not books, maintaining segregation rather than open access, paying for bricks was "cheaper" than paying taxes, etc.

Not undercutting the role of libraries, just pointing out that philanthropy from the wealthy can be a mixed bag of indirect control and agenda pushing at times, wrapped up in tidy looking tax avoidance multi layered "charity" arrangements.

Re:No one buys books by gameman144 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @11:16AM (#40145378)
It's always fair to criticize, but it's also very plausible that Carnegie paid for buildings instead of books so that his charity would improve things for the longer term.

Also, as long as the outcomes are good, I personally don't care one iota whether a person is doing them for the wrong reasons.

Re:No one buys books by atoav on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @12:45AM (#40140680)
Then he isn't rich, powerful and an unethical asshole.

People can be rich and try to do the right thing even if there seems to be no direct economic incentive to do so — and I applaud them if they do realize that money alone doesn't create a meaningful life. Yet I don't need to wonder whether a normal tax rate on billionaires would do even more for the libraries.

Re:No one buys books by gameman144 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @11:24AM (#40145499)
> Yet I don't need to wonder whether a normal tax rate on billionaires would do even more for the libraries.

I agree that tax rates should be higher, but I have absolutely no faith that politicians will do a better job stewarding money toward good causes than a billionaire who cares about them (and/or wants to brag about their philanthropy for clout)

Re:No one buys books by EricE on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:33PM (#40150670)
>I agree that tax rates should be higher,

Why? Why isn't reducing waste ever an option?

Re:No one buys books by gameman144 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:58PM (#40151471)
Reducing waste is a great option! I'm not of the opinion that raising taxes is some objectively correct solution or anything, my personal viewpoint is just that taxing more across the board to invest in infrastructure and long-term economic strengths is the way to go.
Re:No one buys books by isleyaardvark on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:56AM (#40143299)
It's a shame the current robber barons are worse than the old ones.
Re:No one buys books by grepLeigh on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:57AM (#40129277)
OverDrive (and Libby) were acquired by KKR, the behemoth PE firm responsible for bankrupting Toys R Us. KKR also acquired one of the Big Five publishing houses last year. I'm worried about public library funds being squeezed by an extractive PE playbook.

I wonder what kind of negotiating power a regional library has in that situation. Do state library agencies have more leverage than regional libraries? Do large states like California have more leverage in negotiating digital licenses than smaller states? Would a national library system have even more leverage? I'll ask a librarian tomorrow and report back.

Re:No one buys books by lstamour on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:13AM (#40129674)
OverDrive is a strong player but they’re still a commodity. Publishers and libraries can use other lending platforms if and when they emerge as stronger competitors. This article serves as a good overview: https://openeducationalberta.ca/ciicm/chapter/public-library...

The problem is the publishers - they don’t always sign on to provide books to every new platform and don’t always release to every platform. But other platforms do exist: https://bookriot.com/comparing-public-library-ebook-platform...

Bibliocommons, a vendor of library catalogue software, is unique in this space too. They can wrap other services for lending e-books so you “checkout” the same way across any service that provides books. Once upon a time, they even provided books to libraries to lend directly, as they had signed an agreement with S&S and built their own lending platform.

But today the most prominent example of a library building its own ebook platform is probably SimplyE from NYPL. It’s an open source platform other libraries can run. Under the hood, I believe it continues to use OverDrive and other vendors, via OverDrive APIs that Bibliocommons originally pushed for, as well as freely available public domain books.

I suppose there is one thing to be thankful for - individual publishers haven’t tried to start their own competitor and force libraries to use a publisher system to lend books like academic publishers do. I don’t see that happening any time soon. The music industry tried it a few times but people like having content aggregators, so the only way that would succeed is either through easily implemented standards so every library can have an app like SimplyE or further consolidation of the publishing industry, which has been prevented so far, but that could always change in future.

Re:No one buys books by r0ks0n on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @08:02AM (#40130940)
kkr is kanker in dutch
Re:No one buys books by runamok on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @12:21PM (#40133737)
Oh no, worst news I have heard in a while. My wife and I LOVE Libby.