News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by loceng on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:39PM (#40092216)
Also understand the VC industry is inherent with learning from the ideas submitted to them as part of curating deal flow; and it's common for them to justify it with a mantra that ideas are supposedly not worth anything, and it's all about execution.

When and who to share ideas with - and any market traction you may have as proof points there's an opportunity - is possibly the most important part of executing, and where you may be shooting yourself in the foot if sharing that with people in the business of funding ideas.

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by bschmidt1 on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:32PM (#40093390)
> VC industry

Well said, and you reminded me to be more careful about what I share haha

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by andrewstuart on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:03PM (#40093623)
>> ideas are supposedly not worth anything

If ideas are worth nothing then a great team executing well should be able to create a billion dollar company selling dog droppings.

Anyone who says ideas are worth nothing is flat out wrong.

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by dang on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:30PM (#40093778)
I think the claim is rather that idea is not the high-order bit in an early-stage startup funding decision; founders are.

There's no success without eventually finding a good idea, especially since 'successful in the end' is practically the definition of 'good idea', or close enough to be inseparable.

So it's not so much "ideas don't matter" as "starting ideas don't matter", as long as you're the type of founder who can excecute on an idea, change it as needed, and drop it when necessary.

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by andrewstuart on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:47PM (#40094268)
A great idea is incredibly valuable. In fact the idea is the key to great success.

However, it is true that without great execution, timing and luck, a great idea will go nowhere.

Trouble is there are many people who have heard "ideas are worth nothing" and failed to understand that the full sentence is "ideas are worth nothing without execution" - that is certainly true, but it is a totally different statement to "ideas are worth nothing".

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by loceng on Saturday April 20, 2024 @08:38AM (#40096929)
Good ideas are arguably emergent from "time spent on problem" - where time spent on problem is also considered a key metric.

If people do want to play the VC industrial complex game - then at least understand the pros and cons of it; otherwise it's good to understand it so you know how to better position yourself.

Re:Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend... by mcmoor on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:09PM (#40094020)
I mean, there are shit (literal?) businesses our there with stellar marketing and therefore stellar revenues. It's famous that a charming person can sell you almost anything, even your own things.