News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by staunch on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:12PM (#4009047)
It sounds like the senior guys didn't take her complaints very seriously because she had been in a relationship with the guy. It was only when another woman complained about the same guy that they got rid of him.

It also sounds like the firm is controlled by men who tend to favor men for promotions and compensation.

Ultimately I think lawsuits like this are what will move the industry forward. It forces complacent old powerful men to take young women seriously.

Hopefully she gets paid for her trouble and KPCB significantly improves their environment for women.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:53PM (#4009279)

  In the suit, Pao alleges that she was sexually harrassed 
  for years by Ajit Nazre, a former partner with the firm 
  who left last year. The two took a business trip together 
  in February 2006, the suit says, during which Nazre made 
  sexual advances toward Pao and she rebuffed them, causing 
  him to become “brusque and distant.”

  Nazre continued to pursue Pao and the two had a brief 
  relationship, which she broke off soon after, according to 
  the suit. 
"And the two had a brief relationship". Wait, so then it wasn't harassment? During that time I'm sure she thought his persistence had paid off. It is all too reminiscent of this satire:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBVuAGFcGKY

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by brown9-2 on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:14PM (#4009408)
You seem to have missed this part of the article:

but after breaking things off with him, multiple Kleiner Perkins partners and an outside human resources consultant allegedly ignored Pao’s complaints about repeated harassment and retaliation, and rejected her requests to transfer away from Nazre.

Having once been in a relationship with a person does not open the door to continued harassment after the relationship is over.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by kevinpet on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:33PM (#4009525)
It does not excuse the behavior, but it may very well be that coworkers who broke off a relationship are more likely to falsely accuse each other of harassment and/or overreact to innocent or trivial incidents. It may not be true in this case, but if it's true in general, it is a reasonable factor in evaluating how they reacted to her complaints.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jacquesm on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:10PM (#4010010)
You mean she was asking for it?

Where did you pull the false accusation / innocent or trivial incidents from?

And if may not be true in this case why bring it up?

She asked to be transferred away from him because of this and they ignored her, how much more insensitive could it get.

Even when you're in a relationship 'no' still means 'no' and 'leave me alone' still means just that.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by kevinpet on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:44PM (#4010221)
Yes, because I can recognize factors that may reasonably influence whether you should take someone's complaints of harassment at face value, I am clearly advocating rape.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jacquesm on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:55PM (#4010280)
I'm not asking you to take them at face value, I'm asking you simply to consider them at all without immediately jumping to possible alternative explanations of the same set of facts that are a lot more complicated than the original one, that she claims that she was harassed and then ignored and that was the end of it.

Occam's razor and all that.

Harassment does happen, and in cases like this the person that steps up has enough problems on their hand without being dealt more crap.

The prior situation has no bearing on what she claims happened, it either did or it did not, and even if it did not the complaint should have been taken serious.

So we're not even getting to 'taking the complaints at face value', we're simply establishing that she claims that her complaints were ignored. That's a pretty low bar to have to jump over, if someone claims sexual harassment and you ignore them then you're simply wrong, regardless of whether or not the complaint is true.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @09:15PM (#4010968)
Do you agree that Occam's razor slices differently for others? For example, if you agree that women are human beings, you also agree that they are just as prone to any human to misrepresent the facts in their favor. And Ms. Pao stands to make a great deal of money from this suit if it goes through.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by essayist on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @09:23AM (#4012901)
I'm not a VC, but, to be comprehensive, you'll need to put the negative impact of the suit publicity - whether she wins or loses - on her career against what she might gain by winning.

If you sue McDonald's for food poisoning frivolously, have the bucks to do so, and are somehow immunized against a countersuit, there's no downside.

Pao, win or lose, is going to have a very different VC career than if she never filed suit. That's a pretty big downside.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by scythe on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:42PM (#4010872)
The harassment incidents to me honestly don't seem to be the most relevant part of the lawsuit. HR ignores your complaint, yes it is wrong; people make mistakes occasionally, it isn't a lawsuit situation, it's a "send another complaint" situation (or "contact the director"). HR repeatedly or even systematically ignores complaints and you start to have to do something about it.

But the unequal pay, promotions, projects, and participation? That is a rather unequivocal situation.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by badclient on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:20PM (#4009441)
Certainly it introduces a new complexity to the case, no? I'd go as far to say significantly more complexity, especially if their break up was anything like the average break up today and the ensuing drama--where depending on the time of the day, each partner could be found guilty of harassment if they chose to pursue.

On the larger topic of sexual harassment, I often wonder if there should be a word for sexual harassment just as we have one for rape(where stop means stop). With sexual harassment, seemingly normal conversation could be construed as criminal.

Alas, don't shit where you eat.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by larrys on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:26PM (#4009783)
"Certainly it introduces a new complexity to the case, no?"

Was thinking the same thing. Also a psychological component, intermittent reinforcement. She had rebuffed him and then agreed to have sex 2 or 3 times. Who knows over what period that happened and whether there was any rebuff in between the sexual events. After all, he persisted and to away with it at least one time after being rejected.

(Not agreeing his behavior was proper obviously just pointing this out.)

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by brudgers on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:29PM (#4009791)
"Certainly it introduces a new complexity to the case, no?"

No.

Which means, no.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by _debug_ on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @04:02AM (#4012047)
Except it meant yes, for a while.

When she first said no, and he persisted, and then she acceded, she trained him into believing that persistence pays off. So when she says no again, it seems to me that it is almost mathematically predictable that he will re-double his persistent efforts to win her back.

'no means no' does not apply when it sometimes means yes. With added flakiness, 'no means no' means : 'no means yes once in a while, and no means no when I feel like it, and you're a rapist and I'm still an angel if you cannot figure it out'.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by aplusbi on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:50PM (#4009609)
It does make the situation more complex, but sexual harassment isn't black and white. There is a huge difference between investigating a harassment claim and determining that no harassment took place and completely ignoring it.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by badclient on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:54PM (#4009632)
I am curious if she pursued this criminally. And if she did, I think it is important to take into account the view of the DA/cops.

If she is not bringing up the criminal angle, chances are she never pursued it or the DA passed on the case. That is not great news for her case.

Typically you do the civil case after the conclusion of the criminal one, especially if you are confident he will be found guilty.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by NoPiece on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:34PM (#4009813)
Sexual harassment is against the law, but it isn't a crime (at least in California). A DA wouldn't be involved unless it went well past sexual harassment into assault or stalking.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by starwed on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @11:30PM (#4011395)
To be blunt, you have no idea what you're talking about here.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by throwawaytemp on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:22PM (#4009455)
Or she felt pressured and felt that a short relationship might be the answer to her woes. Or she might have felt a thousand other plausible thing that do not detract from the substance of this case; she and other women were discriminated against in substantive, measurable ways and when she sought help for she was sidelined.

Here's the actual text of the lawsuit;

    In February 2006 Plaintiff and another Junior Partner,
    Ajit Nazre, went on a business trip to Germany. Mr. Nazre
    had the same job title as Plaintiff, but had been with
    the firm since 2003, two years longer than Plaintiff, and 
    directed some of her work, including the Germany trip.
    Mr. Nazre made inappropriate sexual approaches to 
    Plaintiff on that trip. She rebuffed his advances.
    Mr. Nazre responded to her rebuff of his advances by
    becoming brusque and distant. He also had strong 
    influence over how other partners at the firm would view
    Plaintiff, specifically Ray Lane, a Managing Partner and
    Mr. Nazre's sponsor and mentor. From March to October
    2006, Mr. Nazre continued to pressure Plaintiff to have
    a sexual relationship with him. Mr. Nazre falsely told
    her that this wife had left him. When Plaintiff refused
    his advances, Mr. Nazre engaged in offensive, obstructionist
    and difficult behaviour toward Plaintiff. Plaintiff eventually
    succumbed to Mr. Nazre's insistence on sexual relations
    on two or three occasions. In October 2006 Plaintiff 
    informed Mr. Nazre that she would no longer have a personal
    relationship with him. Mr. Nazre started a consistent
    pattern of retaliation against her.
This suit will make a lot of people uncomfortable and that's a good thing.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by badclient on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:42PM (#4009569)
Plaintiff eventually succumbed to Mr. Nazre's insistence on sexual relations on two or three occasions.

The fact that she is pursuing this as a civil case already tells us that they didn't have enough for a criminal one. If the above was indeed true, it is a criminal case.

Or she felt pressured and felt that a short relationship might be the answer to her woes

_Feeling_ x does not automatically entitle you to winning a case for sexual harassment nor does it make for much evidence.

I'll wait for the evidence, so far I haven't seen it... which is reasonable given the suit was just filed. Similarly, it is reasonable to assume innocence.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by chc on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:20PM (#4009754)
> _Feeling_ x does not automatically entitle you to winning a case for sexual harassment nor does it make for much evidence.

The parent was merely responding to the suggestion that if the two had slept together, that excuses behavior that would otherwise have been harassment. Having slept with someone definitely doesn't entitle you to sexually harass them. The merits of the claims have yet to be seen, but you can't just dismiss them out of hand by saying, "Oh, but she slept with him."

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by throwawaytemp on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:14PM (#4009724)
If we subtract the questions of innocence and guilt the fact remains that KPCB failed to address these concerns in a responsible manner and chose to make attempts at silencing her in various ways.

Her written review included the words;

    The number of issues and clashes with your peers and
    other partners that were discussed last year has
    decreased quite a bit, but acceptance by this group
    is still not evident.
It is important to assume innocence, but allowing the presumption of innocence to cloud the clear merits of this case is a mistake.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by badclient on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:19PM (#4009752)
the fact remains that KPCB failed to address these concerns in a responsible manner and chose to make attempts at silencing her in various ways

Without knowing more details, how can you state the above so confidently?

You cite a few sentences from a review which are pretty hard to interpret without context. You are hinting that the word "acceptance" points at a conspiracy by The Group against women or this woman. I have no idea how you can be convinced of that merely by reading the contents of the initial filing.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by throwawaytemp on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:58PM (#4009957)

    Without knowing more details, how can you state the above so confidently?
It's safe to assume that Ellen is a smart woman who realises the risk this poses to her career, and any smart person wouldn't wish to burn the progress they have made over years for some mythical "pay day." That's why I can say with some amount of confidence that KPCB failed to address concerns in a responsible manner and let things come this far.

To quote from the filing;

    Upon information and belief, Ray Lane and John Doerr discussed
    how to respond to to Plaintiff. Ray Lane met with Plaintiff.
    While acknowledging that Mr. Nazre's behavior was inappropriate
    Mr. Lane pressured Plaintiff to drop the matter because of
    Mr. Lane''s close ties with and mentorship of Mr. Nazre.
    Though Plaintiff had formally cmplained about Mr. Nazre's behavior,
    Mr. Lane encouraged Plaintiff to engage in a personal relationship
    with Mr. Nazre and even to marry him. Mr. Lane said, however,
    that in such case, either Plaintiff or Mr. Nazre would have to
    leave the firm because two spouses could not work together at KPCB.
    Mr. Lane said he and Mr. Nazre had discussed Plaintiff's report
    of sexual harrassment.
    
    KPCB was aware of and did not take reasonable steps to prevent
    retaliation and gender discrimination. KPC management was aware
    of and did not prevent Mr. Nazre from engaging in repeated
    retaliatory behavior for nearly five years. Following her formal
    complaint described above, Ray Lane insisted that Plaintiff
    have a one-on-one lunch with Mr. Nazre outside the office
    to discuss their relationship. Plaintiff saw no choice but
    to comply with the demand of a Managing Partner. Unsurprisingly,
    Mr. Nazre made inappropriate comments and engaged in unprofessional
    behavior, and seemed to be further empowered by KPCB to further
    retaliate against her.
... and we wonder why there aren't more women in tech.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by sp332 on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:51PM (#4009617)
The fact that she is pursuing this as a civil case already tells us that they didn't have enough for a criminal one.

That just tells me the DA didn't want to touch this one.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by protomyth on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:39PM (#4010187)
Which really doesn't give much of an indication of the merits of the case. DA's have budgets (i.e. X number of cases to pursue) too and may think their priorities would best be served by this case remaining in a civil court.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by Steko on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:17PM (#4009426)
"Wait, so then it wasn't harassment?"

How on earth are they mutually exclusive? A nontrivial number of rape victims become bullied/manipulated into relationships with their assailants. Not sure if you're saying that excuses the crime.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by mavelikara on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @03:52PM (#4009621)
"From March to October 2006, Mr. Nazre continued to pressure Plaintiff to have sexual relationship with him. Mr. Nazre falsely told her that his wife had left him. When Plaintiff refused his advances Mr.Nazre engaged in offensive, obstructionist and difficult behavior toward Plaintiff. Plaintiff eventually succumbed to Mr. Nazre's insistence on sexual relations on two or three occasions. In October 2006 Plaintiff informed Mr.Nazre that she would no longer have any personal relationship with him. Mr. Nazre started a consistent pattern of retaliation against her."
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by afarrell on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:19PM (#4010057)
That doesn't sound like a relationships so much as intimidating someone into having sex...
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @09:08PM (#4010950)
Much more reasonable interpretation: he didn't leave his wife for her, so she got angry and threatened to destroy him. A jilted lover story line makes a lot more sense than a "harass into having sex two or three times" story. No physical force is alleged, no police report was filed, no kidnapping occurred. This is something she only felt bad about after things ended. It sure isn't what normal people perceive as "harassment" if it was reciprocated with "two or three" episodes of sex (because who's counting!)

Future civilizations are going to look at our bizarre notions regarding sex like we looked at the notions of the Victorians.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by diyang on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @09:34PM (#4011037)
Disregarding how "much more reasonable" this interpretation is, there's a lot of space between "no physical force" and "something she only felt bad about after things ended". Jumping to the latter conclusion and implying promiscuity on her part ("because who's counting!") is completely unfair.

We should presume that Mr. Nazre is innocent and not attack his character. We should also do the same for Ms. Pao.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @10:19PM (#4011187)
I'm not implying promiscuity. I'm implying that it can't actually be "harassment" if she lost track of how many times they had consensual sex.

Doesn't "yes" mean "yes", not "yes but I might sue you later"?

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by starwed on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @11:37PM (#4011412)
What the fuck have people in this thread been drinking? It could be harassment if they'd had sex a hundred times, or no times, if they'd been married, or if they'd never met before. The sex isn't the issue here! Pause for a second, and think critically about the issue, rather than spewing crap onto the internet.

If you ask someone to stop such a pattern of behavior and they don't, that's harassment regardless of your personal history.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @02:38AM (#4011858)
Reread the suit. She claims he harassed her "over a period of years". But during that period, she slept with him consensually! If you don't see how that detonates Ellen Pao's claim that his advances were unreciprocated (i.e. that they were "harassment"), not sure what to say.

Is "harassment" just "I felt mad at him years later" or is there any precise definition you're working from? Because if you define harassment as "unwanted advances", they objectively weren't unwanted back in 2006.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jarek on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @03:05AM (#4011924)
I'm really sorry I have to explain this, but the fact she slept with him a couple of times doesn't mean his advances weren't unwanted before or after (or, for that matter, those times they were successful).

To really dumb this down, this isn't like a child asking parents for a toy repeatedly and once the toy is given everyone involved is fine and has moved on. This is like an annoying salesperson calling you repeatedly and justifying it with the one time you caved in and bought something from them.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @04:34AM (#4012124)

  his advances weren't unwanted before or after (or, for 
  that matter, those times they were successful).
The successful advances were unwanted? Are you kidding? This is a reductio ad absurdum of feminism and may well be the most ludicrous thing ever posted on this site. Now no means no...and yes means no too! Now it's harassment even when she says yes. Retroactively, even if it wasn't at the time.

You sure you want to take that position?

Let's take it a little further. Suppose, as seems highly plausible, Nazre has steamy emails, texts, or pictures sent by Pao during that period.

Does that obviate the charge of harassment? Because I'd bet that will come out in discovery. I suppose the argument at that point will be that she was harassed into sending the pics.

  This is like an annoying salesperson calling you 
  repeatedly and justifying it with the one time you caved 
  in and bought something from them.
Utterly wrong analogy. Falls down on every level. You don't sue Staples after you buy something from them. Staples didn't steal the money from you (rape), you gave it consensually. Buying something isn't sleeping with someone. Sleeping with someone "two or three" times isn't slipping up once. Suing them six years after isn't suing when the event happened.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by starwed on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @05:28AM (#4012292)
At this point you are so deliberately ignoring what the conversation is even about that I think you must be a troll.

Well, I hope you're a troll. The alternative is too depressing. :(

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @07:42AM (#4012576)
What is this conversation about?

Read the complaint. Ellen Pao, an extremely wealthy woman, has issues with virtually every partner at KPCB, one of whom she sleeps with and subsequently charges with sexual harassment years later. By her own admission, over a period of six years she continually complains about other partners and her compensation, title, and responsibilities. On the one hand she demands a transfer; yet on the other hand she wants the "harassers" to include her in meetings and emails and spends a full paragraph on the outrage of not being invited to a dinner party and another on ostensibly being excluded from a get together with junior associates.

She marries a man who made millions off of discrimination lawsuits. To top it off, she then launches her own discrimination lawsuit after seven years at the firm which made her so much money.

These are facts. They come from her filing: http://techcrunch.com/2012/05/22/kleiner-perkins-sexual-hara...

If anyone believes these charges at face value they are simply credulous. She is looking for "monetary restitution", a multimillion dollar payday comparable to what her husband has squeezed out of others in his multiple discrimination lawsuits.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jarek on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @01:13PM (#4014051)
> The successful advances were unwanted? Are you kidding?

No.

I see you have difficulty distinguishing between harassment and advances, unwanted or otherwise. You do, however, appear to know or are ready to presume a lot about this case, including things that are on a man's phone, so there is nothing more I wish to add to our discussion. Thanks for engaging me!

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by temphn on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @09:42PM (#4016329)
Just want you to know that there will be people who utterly reject your worldview (in a phrase, "yes means no") and all it entails. In your mind consent can be retroactively revoked years after the fact (to wit: "the successful advances were unwanted"). This is Kafkaesque and a frontal assault on the rule of law.

Fortunately, in a digital age, the past is not something Ellen Pao can rewrite at will. Future rule of thumb for anyone so unfortunate as to be caught up in an office romance: get her to put it in electronic form. Just one photographic expression of affection is enough to demonstrate to all and sundry that yeah, at the time, yes did mean yes. Since even admissions of consent no longer seem to preclude bogus charges, it's the only way to avoid being railroaded in a spurious lawsuit with people like you cheering on the travesty of justice.

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jarek on Thursday May 24, 2012 @12:01AM (#4016717)
I'm not saying wantedness can be rewritten. All along I've been saying that wantedness cannot be measured by success of the advances. If I ask you 100 times for a $20, and on the 101st time you give up and give me $20, my requests have been ultimately successful but I doubt at any point they would have been wanted. This lawsuit isn't about the $20, it's about the requests.
Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by jarek on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @03:08AM (#4011932)
> No physical force is alleged, no police report was filed, no kidnapping occurred. This is something she only felt bad about after things ended.

This lawsuit isn't against the guy. This lawsuit is against the firm about their claimed lack of suitable response for her reports of harassment and a request for transfer. (And then there's the parts about systemic discrimination.)

Re:Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Di... by oh_sigh on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:32PM (#4009153)
How you can determine this based entirely on the complaint? The firm has not had a chance to defend themselves.

How do you know they favor men? Maybe there is a bigger pool of talented men than women in this field?