> Critics say the cooperation between RealPage and apartment managers has emboldened landlords to raise prices even if it means more units are left empty when tenants are forced to leave. Without RealPage, the plaintiffs argue, landlords would be hesitant to jack up rents; instead, they'd focus on keeping their buildings full.
So it sounds like in some point this is depressing utilization of existing stock.
And given that it is (literally) rent-seeking and no one else can build an apartment there that they would rent, it seems like it's exacerbating any supply issues we're experiencing.
The argument is that free markets are (somewhat) efficient and mean that we use our finite resources (like land) in the manner which generates the greatest economic benefit. Normally if you rent-seek by trying to jack up a price above what the market would dictate, someone will come along and out-compete you. The trouble is that it's difficult or impossible for someone to to produce a substitute good here, if there's no empty lot on the street and all the prices are artificially high then how can I come along and compete on price offering apartments on the same street?
But empty units are empty units and too many of them means you need to lower prices or you are losing out on money because you don't make anything from empty homes.
And whatever effects this has (I'm curious to see what comes out off the lawsuit), you're just not going to be able to say "wow, look at how much landlords in San Francisco are making.... gosh, I want to double my rents!" if you're in a place without a tightly constrained housing supply.
Having a tenant comes with cost and risk. Why charge 1200 for 100 apartments when you can charge 3500 for 34 apartments? Maybe even 3000 is still just as profitable
Every extra 100 you charge an existing tenant is pure profit, while reducing price to take on more tenants means more maintenance costs, managing staff costs, etc.
In an economic vacuum this may work itself out, but IF there is a widening wage gap where the you have 30 tenants who can afford up to 4500 a month and you have to drop the price, and then the next 50 potential tenants can only afford up to 1800.. there is financial incentive to squeeze more and more out of the 30 year after year rather than try to accommodate all 80.
Hopefully I'm painting the picture properly
If the mortgage is covered by extortionate rents on your other properties then historically the empty unit is appreciating in value.
Renters are in a position where they have no shelter if they don't acquiesce. Landlords have a multitude of options that make it easier for them to horde empty homes.
That appreciation is happening whether the unit is rented or empty.
The scenario the landlord sees for a given unit is (assuming zero mortgage costs just to make the math simpler [1]):
Empty unit: $0 in rent + $Y in value appreciation
Rented unit: $X in rent (X>0) + $Y in value appreciation (where Y is fixed between the two scenarios because both cover the same rental unit).
For the landlord, $X + $Y is greater than $0 + $Y.
The landlord's greatest total income is when all units are rented, as then all units are returning $X+$Y.
[1] including mortgage and tax costs adds two subtractions to the formulas above, which will result in a real net loss for an empty unit, as the mortgage and taxes must be paid, irrespective of the rented status of the unit.
Imagine the Landlord owns 10 properties and sets the rent to $2k/mo on all of them with 1 property remaining empty. Maybe that last property could be rented out at $1.7k/mo but from the landlords perspective that puts downward pressure on the rents of his other properties.
If one of the landlord's existing tenants moves into the cheaper property it's even worse. He loses $300/mo and now has to consider reducing the rent on an additional property. Should he find a new tenant at $1700/mo, he still feels like he's losing because he believes the rent should be higher.
From the landlord's perspective, it's better to squeeze if he has sufficient cash flow. Especially given the belief that lowering the rent will negatively impact the value of the property.
While you're correct that mortgage and tax are fixed costs that need to be met, you haven't considered that landlords have multiple options to offset those costs. When interest is low they'll use equity release and interest only mortgages.
I used small numbers for the sake of example, scaled up to a city it'd represent 10% of the city's housing stock sitting empty.
the landlord is making more money, people are being squeezed for all they got, and less people have homes.
this is a huge drag on the economy and adversely affects every single person in a region except the rent seeking landlords. Even if you own it is a negative as your CoL is going to go up as stores need to charge more to pay employees more so they can afford homes.
So seems like "we" (ie people who read the article before commenting) do in fact know how big a drag it is in certain markets.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/08/nyregion/apartment-vacanc...
I'm not claiming that this kind of service is good, or that having a trial is bad. I'm actually really interested in the judicial opinion because I could see it going either way. What I am saying is that it just doesn't feel plausible that this software is single handedly moving the market in a big way.
People really do want to point to a single boogeyman for housing unaffordability. And that's too simplistic. Nationally we're short millions of units at a time when we're wealthier than ever. Low supply and high demand means rising prices.
Fix it by making units easy and cheap to build.
High demand in NYC is definitely not high demand in buffalo. But people need to be where the jobs are, and they aren’t in buffalo.
https://www.rate.com/research/buffalo-ny
Better than NYC, but still low. For reference, the state defines anything below 5% vacancy as a 'housing emergency'.
Keep in mind that Buffalo used to have a lot more housing than it does today, it was more than one million people in 1970, and today, its just 800k or so.
Keep in mind that Buffalo used to have more than one million people 50+ years ago, and now only has around 800k.
I don't believe that's the only measure of economic drag. For instance if, having no choice, people are spending a higher percentage of their income on rent, then it leaves less to spend on other economically stimulative activity, like frequenting a local coffee shop, buying clothes, etc.
Especially when that regressively scales with income (i.e. people who make less pay a larger percent of their total income).
And especially when the siphoned capital isn't being reinvested in new housing (because landlords and investors would rather collude and boost profit margins on existing stock).
Yeah, I'm the one that goes to city council meetings and hearings and reads book after book, and talks with the state economists here in Oregon and I don't understand it?
It doesn't take "a crazy supply" of apartments to create competition.
It's why apartments cost less in Las Vegas than Los Angeles - there are more to go around relative to the demand.
An owner choosing to let a unit sit vacant for an extended period is probably more worried about "tenants rights" (squatters) and how difficult it is to evict. You can't blame software if an owners chooses to destroy his real avg rents by letting units sit vacant longer than necessary. 3 months of vacancy to score a 1 year lease, but the opex bills keep coming... no thanks.
Renting is supposed to have risks, without these risks it probably wouldn’t even be allowed in modern society. Landlords are well within their right to find creative ways to mitigate them, but it can’t involve breaking the very same set of societal rules their tenants are following, there is nothing creative about that. If only criminals targeted criminals, but they always go after the easiest victims.
There’s a very healthy, active and open market for apartment rents in most cities. If you are posting from somewhere with heavy rent controls, government market manipulation, or extreme demand, blame those instead! it’s still a market.
I’m not excusing bad actors, but real page is not a scapegoat
Just like the rent-market can have price manipulation, so can the stock-market and any other market. It’s absolutely possible for a trading platform to do this through price recommendations, and it would be illegal.
The two things being compared here are completely different though. It’s not very useful. Whats the real-life stock equivalent to RealPage? Who even rents stocks?
Additionally RealPage is forceful with its price “recommendations”. Imagine if a trading platform forced you to buy/sell a certain percentage of your stocks at their suggested rate, and file an appeal to opt out.
It's not magically predicting. It's called colluding. And yes colluding is very effective and profitable for the colluder - even if the collusion is being laundered through a program.
We already did this ages ago -- most cities have already made all the changes you are requesting, years or even a decade ago. Your talking points are like 10 years behind the times, housing is already legal in 99% of the US right now. (basically everywhere that isn't SF / Bay Area). And you can see brand new 5+1s all over every city, as proof of it. (so much so, that press even writes about it - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-ameri... )
Yes, neighbors complain and complain, and it's easy to focus on them, cause they're loud and annoying. But they don't win -- they complain, and then the investors win anyway, and still get to build almost anything they propose. (I'm in the Midwest, and I can count on one hand the number of times an investor lost a proposal -- they get to develop anything they want 99%+ of the time)
> People are so desperate for some bogeyman to blame. Institutional investors! RealPage! Short Term Rentals!
Well, because those are actual issues, and "NIMBYism" isn't. "NIMBYism" is maybe 2% of the overall housing problem, while private equity, investors, illegal hotels ("Short Term Rentals"), pricing collusion ("RealPage"), and such are, collectively, probably ~50%+ of the problem.
There's dozens of problems at play with crazy-high housing prices. "NIMBYism" doesn't even rank among the top ten of them.
No, they did not. This is divorced from the reality of most cities.
Yes, they did, and you can see it in the metrics.
If "new housing" is "not legal", how are we at a 30-year-high in new residential construction? - https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-housing-starts-surge-1... and https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-20/us-housin...
Note that we're also at a nearly 50-year record-high on urban apartment construction as well https://www.axios.com/2023/09/07/apartment-building-construc... -- the kinds of dense multi-family units that urbanists insist cities "haven't legalized".
Building apartments where it was already legal to build apartments is great, and we're seeing it help curb rents in a lot of places, but there's so much more to it than that.
Someone asked this question in the Oregon subreddit, about why the demand for housing has gone up so much even if the population has not.
https://oregoneconomicanalysis.com/2023/10/26/household-form...
When I buy stocks, the price is set across the country, anyone can get a quote and see what it is at the moment. Is that collusion?
Capitalism doesn’t work when monopolies and cartels gain sufficient power to eliminate the price setting function of competition.
Remember the no-poaching cartel among tech companies in Silicon Valley? and the companies were cheating on their cartel agreement? and the infamous email Steve Jobs sent complaining about the cheating?
A landlord has no power.
IDK, we'll see what comes out of the lawsuit, I guess.
If more housing gets built, prices fall though, like in Austin.
I think you may be misunderstanding the definition of price fixing.
The fact that the parties mutually benefit from their collusion, which is why they sought to price fix in the first place. It's an agreement like any other.
Please, just read up on the definition of price fixing. It'll clear these questions up for you.
Hence, it is not enforceable and the members will cheat on it, because the incentives are a Prisoner's Dilemma. Read about the PD, it'll help clear things up for you.
In general, I don't find price fixing that difficult a concept to grasp, which makes it challenging for me to break it down any further for you.
So, unfortunately, I don't think there's anywhere else to go from here. But, thanks for the discussion.
But everyone knows, movies are not fungible, because they are not interchangeable. I can buy oil, or unleaded gasoline, and it's basically the same everywhere, it is "replaceable by another nearly-identical item, mutually interchangeable" -- oil and gasoline are fungible. But "Movies" are not fungible, because "Lord of the Rings" is not a replacement for "50 First Dates", which is not a replacement for "The Matrix", even though they're all movies.
Housing is not like Oil, housing is like Movies. It's not fungible, because a 2bedroom row-home in Foster City, CA is not "nearly-identical/mutually interchangeable" with a 4bed,2bath home in suburban Louisville, nor a 1bedroom condo in the Chicago Loop.
Even when the housing is all in the same zip code, much of it is still not fungible with it's alternatives, because housing is so regularly different and unique in a myriad of different ways. ("this one is on a hill, that one is in a valley, it has a higher risk of flooding. This one is in School District A, this house across the street is School District B, this house is in a city with income taxes, this house on the next block over is in a township with no income taxes, that house will need a new roof sooner, this house is in a HOA neighborhood, that house is near the bus line, this house is close to the freeway onramps, that house has fiber but this one is only Comcast Coax, etc")
There's even a formula for them:
https://www.amazon.com/Save-Last-Book-Screenwriting-Youll/dp...
Definitely interchangeable.
Similarly with genre books. As a kid, I decided to read all of Ian Fleming's James Bond books. But after 5 or 6, I noticed that they all followed a formula, and got bored with them and never continued. with the series.
Yes, all houses are different, but the differences are largely superficial. You'd be happy living in any of thousands of homes in your locality.
* Gold is fungible. Any bar of pure gold (of identical mass) is exactly interchangeable and has an identical value with any other bar of gold.
* Diamonds are not fungible. Every individual stone is unique and must be properly graded by a licensed jeweller. Two stones of the same mass are highly unlikely to have the same value.
For example, when you trade your old car for a new car, you pay the difference in value.
Value of properties in a neighborhood correlates to the crime rate in that neighborhood - and that’s true nationwide, and because of certain political protections there’s no way to “divorce” the two - which presents a thorny problem.
But consider an actual hypothetical cartel that is explicitly defacto and dejure price fixing. Suppose the members of this cartel instead create a new LLC. Suppose that new LLC now performs the role of price-fixing with the condition that not conforming will lead to expulsion from the price feed system. Has this transformation taken a cartel that is explicitly colluding and made it into one that is not colluding?
If so, we now have a mechanism to turn every cartel into a non-cartel via the umbrella LLC. And the latter costs $300 to set up in Delaware. So the anti-cartel law has a $300 bypass. Reasonable, I suppose if you believe that that law has reached the end of its utility.
Or one of the members of the cartel can agree to sell at $300, and then offer a kickback under the table to get the business, or offer some other cash equivalent incentive.
Cartels only work if the government is used to make it illegal to cheat on the cartel.
you're talking about labor cartels, but the article (and op) are talking about real estate cartels. one operates with government involvement, the other does not.
edit: my original point was that simply the threat of someone undercutting a cartel is not enough to be able to state that cartels cannot exist without government involvement/coercion.
Not exactly. Cartels based on voluntary cooperation are unstable and tend to not last very long. Stable cartels are based on coercion of some sort - some mechanism to keep the members in line. The law is the usual means to achieve that.
The same collusions occurs in multiple American categories. Americans think the free market lowers prices, but at the scale of macro business interests, it's in large conglomerates interest to raise prices under collusions, as they all win.
But that software won't get you LA rents in Houston. The macro picture is still supply and demand and we have to intervene there if we want housing to be more affordable in the places people want to live.
People are so desperate for some bogeyman to blame. Institutional investors! RealPage! Short Term Rentals!
Fixing those things would not hurt, to be clear, but lack of supply is the underlying issue, and it's often driven by local NIMBYism.
I went to a hearing to support the construction of 40 "units" (aka homes) in my city last week and got jeered at by a crowd of older, wealthy retirees who were SO ANGRY about those being built.
That same sort of scene (often with no one to speak in favor) is replayed day in and day out all across the country.
This isn't to say 'markets solve all problems' but legalizing a variety of housing is very much a step that your local city council can take.
It's a worthwhile issue to be involved in, because housing is at the nexus of so many other things - the economy, the environment, people's ability to live where they fit in best and much more. These groups are good:
* https://new.yimbyaction.org/
* https://welcomingneighbors.us/