The part you're right about is that "admission" to YC is structurally a lot like college or grad school admissions. The difference, though, is that our choices are immediately tested. College admissions officers do not, as far as I know, follow up on the careers of the people they accept and see how they did. Whereas if we pick a bad group, that fact will immediately be thrust in our face. This causes us to work very hard to try to pick the best people.
It was being in a sense a colleague of college admissions officers that made me think about such topics. We're the next bottleneck downstream from them, and it quickly became clear to us what a bad job they were doing:
The column 'Alumni' compares the number of Nobel prizes or Fields Medals won by Alumni to the number won by Harvard (in percent). Caltech scores 52.8 on this, and ENS 53.4. But Caltech and ENS are by far the smallest of the universities on the top 100 list (unless I am mistaken). Both Caltech and ENS enroll about 200 undergraduates a year, with ENS enrolling only about 100 of those in science and engineering. Caltech has a population of another 1200 graduate students.
One thing to note about Caltech, ENS, and Phystech, they are extremely small, extremely selective, have no legacy admissions, limited or no affirmative action, and pay heavy attention to competitive exams, in the case of ENS and Phystech, administrating them.
That said, Cambridge is a far bigger University than Caltech and others, but a large proportion of those degrees are awarded in non-science fields.
http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/lists/universities.html
Wikipedia has another list based on what universities claim themselves:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nobel_Laureates_by_univ...
So while Caltech is doing very well indeed, there are 15 universities with more affiliated awardees.
The Wiki is the one.
In Canada, one of the strongest selling points of universities is what fraction of their students got a job in a related field within X years of graduation -- so at least here, institutions do track this sort of data.
In addition, there's a lot of work done to validate admissions processes based on the success of students during their undergraduate years; universities have extensive "black books" which tell them how a student graduating from high school X compares to a student graduating from high school Y given the same nominal high school marks (here in Canada, admissions are done primarily based on high school marks -- we don't have any equivalent to SATs).
It would be interesting to see numbers on that. Informally, I noticed that back when reddit was good, anyone who was asked had either heard about it because it was YC-funded, or heard about it from someone who heard about it that way. I'm not certain, but I would probably bet that the submitters of, say "Man sentenced to NINETY THREE days in jail for taking 6 seconds to sit down! Outrageous!" or "Warrant Issued For Man Paying Fine With Pennies" didn't find out about it the same way.
The only way that web marketing is "free" is if product awareness spreads between customers, or is pushed through the founders' personal contacts. Wouldn't this imply that we could expect this phenomenon - the initial user base being in some way close to the founders - to grow as the industry approaches the asymptotes you assert it is heading for?
Awareness of Reddit did spread between users.
I think it's a fairly good bet that Reddit did a lot better with their initial group of users being seeded from folks who'd heard of you or followed comp.lang.lisp, than if they tried to launch something among their UVa friends.
I checked for an article from the Harvard Crimson about the degree to which the admission office follows up on admitted students after they enroll, although I didn't find the link just now. You've received other replies mentioning various ways, with various degrees of formality, that admission offices can and do check their results. Now that many admission offices are making very fine distinctions among applicants as admission rates plummet below 10 percent, there will probably be growing interest in validating the criteria on which admission decisions are made.
MIT admission office McGreggor Crowley, in one of his admission travel sessions in the last year, said his office has done studies of which students perform best in upper division courses at MIT. Taking really hard classes in high school is a better predictor of upper-division success at MIT than having a spotless G.P.A., for example. He asked a large audience of high school students how many had done baby-sitting, and very few raised their hands. He said if that is one thing that kept you busy in high school, be sure to mention that on your MIT application.
despite my Cs in english, pol sci, and other humanities courses, i got in ... to make it more dramatic, i also got graduate research assistantship :D
Yes, not to the customers of the app, but the interest the YC brand generates in "insider" circles, which helps bootstrap popularity I think you are underestimating.
> YC's principal value is the advice we (and the other YC startups) offer.
Yes but as before, the "brand impact" in the blogosphere (I feel dirty writing that) is still a huge thing. If that comes under the umbrella of advice, then that makes sense.
I'm not sure that's true - in the UK at least, universities often issue press releases when one of their alumni does something notable (like becoming the Prime Minster of Thailand for example, which Oxford is crowing about at the moment).
And I've seen in Australia a follow-up 6-12 months later to see if you got a job / further study. But I've never seen a substantial follow-up of the average population of a uni.
I did YC because it seemed interesting and I needed a good excuse to quit my job. [2] Tom was bored and wanted to get out of Ohio.
When we launched on Techcrunch, we were met with widespread apathy. Techcrunch readers, by and large, weren't our target market and didn't give two shits about a ticket site. We expected this to happen, and it was still cool to be featured on Techcrunch anyways :). We weren't creating a new platform or becoming the next facebook - we were just solving a simple problem (finding tickets).
The investors we met with didn't care that we were with YC (many didn't even know), they cared that we were making money in an expanding market.
Also, our most targeted/best traffic has been from places that didn't know/didn't care who YC was (e.g. Ticketnews.com, Thrillist). Same situation for our users.
Finally, as Paul alluded to, the YC name can only do so much for you, if you don't have a good product none of it matters.
[1] - I'm only talking about the YC brand name/credentials, not the program itself, which certainly had a positive impact on TicketStumbler.
[2] - When much of your family lives in Detroit and has been recently or is, unemployed, it's difficult to say your ditching a cushie 60k per year job to do a startup. Having "backing" makes it much easier.
People go to YC for many of the same reasons people went to Stanford -- past seed stage, it's still largely a credentials game. So you have to ask whether the same potential for "corruption" is present. Are they failing to transmit credentials over generations because it's a revolutionary model, or because it's only been around less than one generation?
What if someone did a sweetheart deal for a YC startup as a personal favor/quid-pro-quo/etc? What does it mean when founders who got rich from a YC company start funding new YC companies because they are YC companies? Is that "corruption" in the same sense?