News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by londons_explore on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:14PM (#39956128)
> If your roof is 20 years old and one hailstorm is going to take it off,

It amazes me that people in the US would even consider installing a roof that would only last 20 years.

In the UK, you wouldn't consider reroofing anything that your grandparents remember being installed. Ie. Stuff doesn't get reroofed till it's 100 years old. Even then, you'll normally inspect and only replace the damaged bits.

My 350 year old house still has part of its original roof and slate tiles etc.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by EligibleDecoy on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:27PM (#39956223)
It’s called “money.” That is the reason. Slate roofs are common in the UK, and using synthetic slate is $7-12/sqft, whereas bitumen/asphalt shingles which are common in the USA cost $0.50-$1.00/sqft. Average home in the USA is 2,200 sq ft with a roof size of 1,700 sq ft. So $1,700 vs $11,900 is quite a difference (and that was being most generous, excluding installation costs, etc) So basically, average person who owns a house has a big house, and big roofs are already expensive. Regardless of wanting to get a high quality roof that would last more than 30 years, that requires capital - more than the average owner really has access too. Sources: https://www.architecturaldigest.com/reviews/roofing/slate-ro... https://www.architecturaldigest.com/reviews/roofing/shingle-... https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/average-square-footage-... https://www.rubyhome.com/blog/roofing-stats/
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by sologoub on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:55PM (#39956425)
Materials may cost that, but you are not getting a roof replaced for $1,700. Maybe $17,000 and even then it’s pushing it on the coasts especially. Labor and other overhead costs have really gone up and contractors don’t want to deal with small jobs. Sad really.

I’ve never seen slate roofs in California, so not sure if these are to code here. We looked at metal and other materials, but the problem is the weight is different, so now you are engaging an engineer to evaluate structure, submitting plans, dealing with code updates. Or just new asphalt shingles every 15-20 years. The payoff isn’t there and folks don’t tend to keep houses for generations, unlike in the UK.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:27PM (#39956994)
There is very little acceptable roofing slate available in the USA. PA has a few quarries that provide it, but according to roofers (in PA) that I talked to, it is still nowhere close in quality to, say, Welsh slate. Too many voids which when coupled with much more severe freeze/thaw cycling in much of the USA leads to early failures.

I think you may be overestimating the extent to which UK houses are held for "generations.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by bombcar on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:13AM (#39958839)
And even if you import Welsh slate, you may have to import workers, too.

Because if you're trying to use building materials that the local contractors are not familiar with, you're going to have a bad time.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by londons_explore on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:22AM (#39958902)
Slate isn't the only material with decent longevity. Ceramic and concrete tile should both last 100+ years.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by sologoub on Sunday April 07, 2024 @11:24AM (#39961380)
In my comment I said we looked into metal and other materials, but all increase weight, requiring engineering evaluation of the house and likely reinforcing the structure. Ceramic and concrete tiles are common here, but have the same problem. Don’t know about slate, but for the tiles you mention underlayment still needs to be replaced every 20-30 years at least requiring these to be removed and reapplied. Since labor is the major cost driver, it’s basically like paying for a new roof.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by vba616 on Saturday April 06, 2024 @07:07PM (#39956495)
>that requires capital - more than the average owner really has access too

It sounds odd to my ear to matter-of-factly state that the US is deprived due to being capital-poor.

I mean, I'm not disputing anything specific, but where do middle-class people have better access to consumer finance than the US?

If you'd asked me what single fact represents American homeowners to people interested in economics around the world, I would've guessed it's the access to 30-year fixed rate mortgages.

As far as I know this is a deliberate policy in the US, that has not been emulated by those envious of the American economy, but why I haven't a clue.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by bobthepanda on Saturday April 06, 2024 @07:43PM (#39956743)
Insuring all those fixed rate mortgages is very expensive. The US has never actually had to do so, the closest being the 2008 Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac recapitalizations which cost $238B in loans that were finally paid off in 2022.

In Europe a lot of the government fiscal crises were a result of small countries having to backstop giant cross border banks that happened to be headquartered there, and there is little appetite for tighter fiscal union.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by datascienced on Sunday April 07, 2024 @01:42AM (#39958420)
Who is on the losing side of interest rates going up while 30 year fixers are presumably paying something like 2%?
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by Brian_K_White on Saturday April 06, 2024 @09:41PM (#39957403)
Also the cheap materials roof weighs less, and so the whole building under the roof can get away with being built cheaper.

In order to have a better roof, you probably must have a better entire house under it also.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by bradley13 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @05:04AM (#39959422)
This. Houses in the US are tinker-toys. They don't gave the structural strength to support a decent roof.

Where I live in Europe, roofs are usually ceramic shingles, which should easily last 50-100 years or more.

Of course, the down side of higher quality building standards is cost. Building a houses here costs a minimum of half-a-million, and quickly hits a million...

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by maxerickson on Sunday April 07, 2024 @06:25AM (#39959798)
US roofs are commonly built to deal with snow loads of ~50 pounds per square foot. I don't think it's gonna be a big deal to support tile using the same techniques (it would just need to be accounted for).
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by bradley13 on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:22AM (#39968578)
50 lbs/ft2 is pretty much the upper limit in the continental US. Most of the Midwest is around 20lb. Maine and Alaska go significantly higher. Pretty much the entire South is 10lb or less.

I've lived various places in the US. With the exception of one older house, the roof trusses were a joke: so-called 2x4's (really much thinner than that), widely spaced, held together with a few nails and little or no cross-bracing. They might theoretically hold up to the weights listed, but I sure wouldn't stand under them during a test.

Where I am now, in Europe, the roof trusses are roughly 6"x10" laminated timber. That will hold a snow load.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by maxerickson on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:56AM (#39969234)
I was talking about the techniques being up to the task. What you observed in houses not built to handle higher loads doesn't really inform that question.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by Brian_K_White on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @08:21PM (#39985689)
Snow doesn't matter. Rafters designed for a cheap roof plus snow need to be stronger to support slate or tile plus snow. It's a static addition to whatever else.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by Brian_K_White on Sunday April 07, 2024 @06:18AM (#39959767)
Plus you can repair individual shingles essentially indefinitely. There really is no predictable life.

A tar roof has an unavoidable time limit on the whole thing.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:32PM (#39957034)
The UK has a massively milder climate than most of the USA, which provides significant assistance to things lasting.

As I noted in another comment below, roofing slate is essentially unavailable in the USA due to geology - what does exist is of much lower quality than a good welsh slate. Still, in some ways I agree with you: roofing materials in general in the USA are far less durable those used in the UK and Europe, for reasons that I don't entirely undestand.

That said, it amazes me that huge numbers of people in the UK live in essentially uninsulated and almost uninsulatable buildings. Sure, winters are mild, but anytime you have the heat on in the millions of homes built post-WWII, a huge amount of is just leaking through the brick walls. US stud framed construction has its problems if done carelessly, but it does have the benefit that its easy and obvious to insulate your walls to some degree, and not hard to do it to Passivhaus standards.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by rootusrootus on Saturday April 06, 2024 @09:20PM (#39957288)
> The UK has a massively milder climate than most of the USA, which provides significant assistance to things lasting.

That makes sense. Roofs last a pretty long time in the PNW as well, for similar reasons. Mostly we just get rain. Not a lot of particularly hard freezes, our idea of big hail is 1/4 inch, etc. It's pretty routine for a garden variety "25 year roof" to actually do all 25 years, and even 30.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by firesteelrain on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:30PM (#39957018)
US has a lot of different weather patterns than the UK. UK sits at a latitude similar to that of states like Washington, Montana, and North Dakota. The choice of roofing materials is also influenced by building regulations and codes, which can vary between countries and even within regions, dictating the use of certain materials for fire resistance, insulation, and other safety and performance standards. Cost-effectiveness is a factor. Like Florida with crazy hurricanes, no reason to be spending money on something besides asphalt architectural style shingles. Some people do get metal roofs. But if its going to get blown off, then why?
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by GenerWork on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:45PM (#39957100)
>Like Florida with crazy hurricanes, no reason to be spending money on something besides asphalt architectural style shingles. Some people do get metal roofs. But if its going to get blown off, then why?

Tile and metal roofs last much longer than asphalt roofs in Florida, and while it's definitely more up front, they're generally more resistant to extreme weather (tiles are very heavy and metal is generally fastened down very well) and may get you an insurance discount. It's also for aesthetic reasons, as tile roofs are a very classic Florida look, and the stereotypical Key West house has a metal roof.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by firesteelrain on Saturday April 06, 2024 @09:17PM (#39957276)
Tile roofs are a more Spanish style look and crazy expensive.

Otherwise I agree with you

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by Brian_K_White on Saturday April 06, 2024 @09:51PM (#39957445)
per year
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by IggleSniggle on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:51PM (#39956402)
If you think that's wild, consider that the standard practice in Japan is to buy land and build new...even if that means tearing down the building that is currently built there. As a result, buildings are built more according to the rules of fashion, and building to last longer than the current occupant would seem like a foolhardy waste of money.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by kalleboo on Saturday April 06, 2024 @07:35PM (#39956684)
Although one thing to keep in mind is that earthquake-proofing building standards are also renewed about once per generation. I would absolutely refuse to let my family live in a house built before the post-Hanshin 2000 reforms (just look at the houses collapsed in the recent Noto earthquake, most of them predated even the earlier 1981 reforms)
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by zwayhowder on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:22PM (#39956187)
My house is about 100 years old and still has the original concrete tile roof, with a stack of spare tiles under the house ready if needed.

An extension that was done in the 1980s has had to have its roof replaced once already due to what I have to assume was poor workmanship by the builder.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by majormajor on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:28PM (#39956232)
Different types of storm are one thing.

I think the biggest difference, though, is that the stereotypical single family US home of the 19th/20th century US expansion is on a large plot of land and has - so far - been one to get remodeled/expanded/revised several times in a hundred years. Houses are generally treated as mutable things, and people also often expect to move within a few decades, spending more to put in something that will hold up a hundred years instead of twenty seems foolhardy to many. If you sell it the buyer will likely want a cosmetic refresh; if you keep it, you likely will too.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by duped on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:52PM (#39956406)
No one is building homes to last 150 years in the United States, and very rarely do people want to buy homes built a century ago.

Where I live we call a century-old home a "tear down" because it's probably in horrible condition. There are a handful in my neighborhood but they get sold at a discount, usually for new construction.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by rootusrootus on Saturday April 06, 2024 @09:18PM (#39957277)
That's wild. I live in one of the oldest cities west of the Rockies (granted, that isn't -that- old) and there are whole neighborhoods of century homes, and they're considered desirable. In the last 10-20 years a bunch have been gutted and upgraded -- new pipes, wiring, windows, etc. Maintains the charm but modern efficiency, convenience, and safety. Sure, some become tear-downs, but a pretty high percentage are sticking around. That old growth doug fir is awesome.

I just sold a century home myself, after my mother passed. There was a little bidding war for it, even in this market. There's a character to the century homes that you cannot get in a new home at anywhere near the same price point.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by hikingsimulator on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:21PM (#39956182)
The weather in the US can be wild compared to what Western Europe is used to. England doesn't have to deal with the same events.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by rvba on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:57PM (#39956432)
Those Ukrainian concrete buildings can take a bomb and still stand...
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by vba616 on Saturday April 06, 2024 @06:58PM (#39956445)
That sounds very nice. What would a competitive rent for your house be? Is it near London?

For Americans who don't know anything about housing in the UK, there is an interesting article at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_house

Being Wikipedia in 2024, I wouldn't assume it's not all AI hallucinated references, but still, it's interesting.

Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by HeyLaughingBoy on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:43PM (#39957093)
Has your 350 year-old house been hit by hail, some of which is the size of golf balls, in enough volume that the ground is as white as if it had snowed? Because that's a not-uncommon occurrence here in the midwestern US.
Re:Insurers Are Spying on Your Home from the Sky by londons_explore on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:19AM (#39958576)
Ceramic tile and concrete tile roofs will survive that, and are also common in the UK. (Although tend to be only ~150 years old by now)