Building more nuclear power is good, but it can’t be the only solution because it’s very expensive and takes so long to ramp up. Projects in the West have been decades behind schedule. And it’s far from given Republicans would support it.
Why don’t Republicans take the initiative and get Democrats behind a national plan for more nuclear? Because their voters don’t care. So why would they support such a Democratic initiative?
It’s a weird assumption that Republicans are somehow just waiting to do the right thing, if only Democrats would come to them with a plan. It’s never worked like that.
In the USA in April 2023 a Gallup poll had nuclear support at 54%, the highest level since 2012.[54] In August 2023 Pew Research Center conducted a survey which found that 57% of Americans favor more nuclear power plants. This is up from 43% in 2020. Support for nuclear power has increased among both Democrats and Republicans. However, Americans are still more likely to favor solar and wind power than nuclear power.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_opinion_on_nuclear_issu...
I guess I’m skeptical of the hypothetical support people claim when they have no skin in the game (I.e. no local construction plans and it’s currently obvious that no plans are possible anytime soon)
On a personal level I’ve felt pro-nuclear most of my life, it’s just in the last few years I’ve become, not anti nuclear but skeptical I suppose. I just can’t see a cost benefit in today’s world given the other options available.
Nuclear is extremely expensive so if you poll on the cost of energy you will also have a different outcome.
This includes people from all the G20 countries, many non G20 countries, purely academic researchers, exploration geophysicists working for transnational energy and mineral extraction companies, etc.
Within this body of people that can math well, understand numerical models, deal with gravity, planetary positions, magnetic fields, atmospheric gases, radiometric backgrounds, continent drift, glacial isostatic adjustment, tides, etc. there is a documented and overwhelming consensus.
https://skepticalscience.com/global-warming-scientific-conse...
https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-qa/isnt-there-...
People that don't understand any of that are more likely to doubt.
What about this document, signed by over 1,100 scientists including nobel prize winners?
https://clintel.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/WCD-version-0...
It's pretty easy to figure out whether or not Republicans might support an immediate and massive expansion of nuclear power. Since you don't sound like you tolerate Republicans, let alone like you are on speaking terms with enough of them that you could ask, I'd recommend you consult some polls of Republicans on the question. According to one study by Pew, 2/3rds of them support the construction of new nuclear plants. Which is to say, Republicans are more likely to support what you call the right thing than Democrats.
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/08/18/growing-s...
Would it not be cheaper, whilst also being realistic, to pursue renewables + natural gas?
AIUI renewables LCOE is around 5x cheaper than nuclear and natural gas is often (including right now) sold at negative prices in the US because it is almost a waste product from far more lucrative shale oil operations (accounts for around 80% of gas production). Add to this gas is a near perfect complement to renewables given its fast response times to demand changes unlike nuclear. Natural Gas is also the cleanest of the fossil fuels, modern generation facilities are far more efficient than e.g. petrol or diesel engines.
I’m failing to understand why nuclear would be the only game in town? Those construction costs make it look unviable. Not to mention the NIMBY aspect which means nuclear is simply off the table in terms of options thanks to citizen desires.
If they do not argue for an immediate and massive expansion, I'm forced to conclude they either a) are lying about what they call the science, b) are lying about their belief in apocalyptic scenarios, c) don't understand math, or d) some combination of a, b, and c.
There are some next generation reactor designs that are worth investment but for immediate generation capacity wind and solar is much better.
The state can absolutely reduce costs and speed up plant construction in a way that is safe, and which is less vulnerable to bad weather, and which does not create as many energy storage problems.
Pursue wind and solar at the same time if you like, but the math climate scientists claim to understand requires them to also push for an immediate and massive expansion of nuclear.
I find it suspicious that they do not, and that they never have.
It’s an example of some strange outdated internet meme that someone posts on any energy thread - to come in and say “actually guys nuclear is great you are all just not smart enough to know”. Despite the totally insurmountable arguments of time and cost - if we started today it would take 15+ years for one plant, and it being the most expensive major form of new power we know of.
I wish the meme would either die, or folk would brush up on their arguments.
https://www.nrel.gov/analysis/100-percent-clean-electricity-...
Which are all fine. I don't know enough to question their beliefs.
But I do know enough about math and engineering to know that the only realistic way to deal with the disaster they are predicting is an immediate and massive expansion of nuclear power. But instead of arguing in favor of this immediate and massive expansion of nuclear power, which Republicans would likely support, they push stuff like this.