News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by seper8 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:35AM (#39766247)
Paris is honestly a terrible place to live, riddled with homelessness and crime. It's become mostly a place where women really can't feel safe. Even the area around the Eiffel Tower, icon of the city, is incredibly sketchy, filled with pickpockets, illegal migrants peddling wares, contrasted with high fences and bullet proof glass. And to complete the picture, there's a lot of police hanging out wielding large assault rifles...

I pass by there multiple times a year and it has gotten so much worse. The ever growing banlieus are like the bronx, areas where ambulances or fire brigades don't go without police support and kids only finish high school.

One year there was a particularly big influx of migrants and it truly felt like I was driving through a zombie movie while trying to get through the Parisian periferie. Tent encampments all around the highway, people sleeping meters from cars which are passing by at 80kmh.

And this is coming not from a sheltered person, at least I've seen quite some parts of Africa, Asia and the Middle East. But where a big part of the world is getting objectively better, especially in Asia, Paris is truly feeling more like a third world country every year.

So please don't try to use the words "stay Paris" to suggest they are doing something right.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by TwoFerMaggie on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:19AM (#39766943)
Having lived in an actual third world country for a couple decades, I personally can't take statements such as "xx is becoming more like a third world country" seriously. I get the sentiment behind it though.

If I compare, for example, my experience living in cities in China vs cities in Europe, I would argue that the relative freedom of movement forces residents in Europe to confront the inequality in their everyday lives.

In China, on the other hand, such inequality can be easily covered up by either confining the migrant workers (an artificially created underclass of people without hukou[0] registration in the city but still seek opportunities there) in urban villages[1], or sometimes, simply cracking down on and expelling them through policy changes with little resistance[2].

I don't doubt the fact that you're not a sheltered person, but even the average urban residents in China can be oblivious to the plight or even the existence of such an underclass. I'd argue that one can be quite sheltered even if they live there, which is also by design. And this is actually quite common in relatively wealthy Asian countries, see this example [3] in Singapore of how people talk about maids.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_village_(China)

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/27/china-ruthless...

[3] https://youtu.be/QH9fX4KIhZg?si=Yp5KjI59Owc09fvd&t=1007

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by rangestransform on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:08AM (#39767693)
I don’t want to be confronted with inequality every day
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by TwoFerMaggie on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:21AM (#39767877)
(forgive me if it's sarcasm and I missed it)

Nobody wants confrontation because it's uncomfortable. But inequality like this is literally the inescapable reality migrant workers live in. Your average locals might be able to turn a blind eye to it, they can't.

Seems at least a little bit hypocritical to enjoy the life made easier by (often imported) cheap labor while not wanting to be aware of their troubles, or you know, live with them in close proximity.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by bombcar on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:46AM (#39768212)
The people who have to live with them are not the rich or the people making the decisions by any means - it's just the middle class who has to put up with it.

The rich don't take the metro, they are driven from place to place.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by Phil_Latio on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @03:06PM (#39770696)
This is stupid argument. He/She was talking about something relative, that is, relative to what it was 5, 10, 15, 20 years ago. You can't come along and pick some worse example from another place.

With the same logic you could say wages don't need to increase for the next 20 years, or police can be defunded because more crime is not so important, because the 3rd world is off way worse...

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by TwoFerMaggie on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @03:44PM (#39771164)
> with the same logic you could say...

The comment I replied to said "it's feeling more like a third world country", I replied "no it's not even close to an actual third world country". I don't see how you could then derive that I meant "therefore it's not important".

Are third world countries the only place where things need fixing?

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by Phil_Latio on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @05:55PM (#39772462)
The post you replied to said it is GETTING WORSE. Paris is getting worse in his lifetime, in his expirience. You can't then come along and say

> I would argue that the relative freedom of movement forces residents in Europe to confront the inequality in their everyday lives.

Imagine you see China today, let's say Shenzhen skyline. 20 years in future you go there and all lights are out, windows are broken and homeless people everywhere, streets are filled with dirt and woman are scared to go out when it gets dark. If I then tell you "well, looks like some poor people moved there, everyone is moving closer together, that's why we see some problems here"..... Nooo! It would be some massive government failure that is responsible.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by TwoFerMaggie on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:02PM (#39773874)
I quoted the phrase "it's feeling more like a third world country" verbatim, which is the part I have issue with. I also said "I get the sentiment", meaning that I understand what they were trying to express (that it's getting worse). I don't know what you were disagreeing with though?

> You can't then come along and say

Of course I can. That is also my experience. According to OP many third world countries they visited seem to be handling this better than places like Paris, but imo it's just because they have the power to sweep the problem under the rug. I don't think that is the solution we should aim for.

Oh and btw

> You can't come along and pick some worse example from another place.

I didn't pick them, OP did. I literally would not have replied to OP had they not invoked the "turning to 3rd world country" drivel.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by Phil_Latio on Thursday March 21, 2024 @11:15AM (#39779573)
You don't get it.

> but imo it's just because they have the power to sweep the problem under the rug

OP talks about decline in a certain place. It has NOTHING to do with sweeping problems under the rug. Why not? Because the "under the rug sweeping" didn't happen 20 years ago either! So why did things get worse, instead of better? Because of bad policies, number #1 being bad migration policies which is not merit based. This happend in whole western Europe and turns cities into what OP described, while eastern Europe cities remain what was Paris 20 years ago. So please stop denying OP or anyone to say "wow, it got so much worse here over the years"....

Now the reason I write in an angry way and the reason I'm so upset, is that there is no solution to these problems. Quite the opposite, it will only get worse. But that's another topic. So sorry if my words were a little aggressive.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by keiferski on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:46AM (#39766433)
I wouldn't describe Paris as a super nice place by any means, more "gritty but cool," but the area near the Eiffel Tower is a tourist zone and always has been. Average Parisians rarely go there. I wouldn't call Times Square a nice place either.

Your comment would be more convincing if you said Le Marais, Belleville, or the 13th were getting bad.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by orwin on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:18PM (#39769485)
(the 13th and the 17th are getting better imho, but it's probably because I don't live there anymore :))
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by sakex on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:59AM (#39766628)
I have the same feeling, growing up in Paris and then moving to Switzerland. Paris seems more and more dangerous and dirty. And people seem to become less and less happy.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by gadders on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:52AM (#39767468)
Last time we drove out of Paris after staying with friends, my wife spotted a large farmers market that she wanted to stop at.

It turned out to be a homeless encampment filled with immigrants to France.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by foldr on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:02AM (#39767602)
Some people just don't like cities. Google pretty much any major Western city and you can find comments complaining that it's dirty, riddled with crime and has too many immigrants. Paris is a real place, not a theme park.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by jokethrowaway on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:07PM (#39769348)
Paris was much better 20 years ago; sure it still smelled like pee (no idea why it was and it is such a problem in Paris and literally nowhere else) but nothing was wrong.

I've been in 2019 and that's the last time Paris will ever see me: immigrants touching you trying to sell you stuff, people defecating in front of the supermarket in broad daylight, homeless camps, I've had a drugged up homeless jumping on me.

Shame, because the bakeries are top notch.

Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by intalentive on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @12:42PM (#39769019)
Western cities weren't always like this. They don't have to be like this.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by testingParisGPE on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @03:55PM (#39771275)
Encampments have an big and long history in Paris even after the 2nd world war... It's not great, just people looking for a better place to live and survive.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by foldr on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:49PM (#39769900)
If you take a reasonably long historical perspective, Western cities are a hell of a lot cleaner and safer now than they were in the past. Sewerage goes a long way.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by bedobi on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:45AM (#39767339)
tell me you're racist without saying "i'm racist"
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by Ylpertnodi on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:08AM (#39767691)
At first read I was recoiling, but several reads later the poster said nothing racist. What did I miss?
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by bombcar on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:47AM (#39768227)
You missed that anything against "illegal migrants" must be racist, at least according to some. There cannot be any other reason.
Re:Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions int... by rmbyrro on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:08AM (#39766784)
What does it all have to do with the subject here, if I may ask?