News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by Lalabadie on Saturday March 16, 2024 @02:10PM (#39728095)
I've been working with my first client who, I've come to recognize, is _very_ susceptible to believing exaggerated claims. This is someone who would enthusiastically dive into a cult if the right person told him it's nicer there, but instead he's tech entrepreneurship, so AI is always three weeks away from allowing him to replace all his employees.

In the meantime, everyone in the design team keeps sending back content that he's requested from ChatGPT instead of an actual copywriter. Because everyone here, like everyone on HN, can easily tell the difference, but he can't/won't.

What seems to be very difficult with someone like this is, they participate in hype cycles because not doing so leaves them feeling like _everyone knows something_ and they don't. They don't want to be the idiot left behind when something good happens, so they dive into every enthusiastic movement or belief that comes in range. They don't have the ability or will to suss out that each wave is made up of people exactly like them.

TLDR: High energy, low critical thinking.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by cushpush on Saturday March 16, 2024 @02:30PM (#39728260)
>AI is always three weeks away from allowing him to replace all his employees.

  Well isn't that a temporal oddity
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by ozymandias1337 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:43PM (#39728867)
They are constantly shifting the goal posts.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by asdff on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:18PM (#39728663)
There are enough people like this where for better or worse, keeping up with these hype trains has become a solid investment strategy. Imagine getting in early enough on BTC, or DOGE, or AMC, or GME, or NVDA, or whatever comes next instead of cynically scoffing it off (for valid reasons) on its fundamental merits. You'd be singing a different tune I'm sure after it explodes and you've cashed out leaving the zealots on whatever subreddit holding the bag.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by 10000truths on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:44PM (#39728874)
Relying on the greater fool theory to make your money only works until it doesn't.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by pixl97 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:50PM (#39728919)
The boom/bust cycle. As they say, the hardest part of the market is timing.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by VelesDude on Saturday March 16, 2024 @11:03PM (#39731559)
Exactly. Also for that half dozen successes listed before, there could have been thousands of options available at the time that only look silly in retrospect.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by andrewflnr on Saturday March 16, 2024 @05:41PM (#39729729)
I don't know, if you get out early enough and only invest a portion of your previous winnings into the next cycle, it only has to work long enough for you to build a decent nest egg. But I suppose the average cycle chaser doesn't think like that...
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by asdff on Monday March 18, 2024 @02:07PM (#39747821)
You can replace greater fool theory with any sort of investment strategy and your sentence is still very valid. The key is to just not over leverage yourself where you will get burned with one strategy. Never invest with money you can't afford to lose.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by JKCalhoun on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:35PM (#39728789)
I've wondered from time to time why I never could find it within myself to become a street preacher.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by 082349872349872 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @05:25PM (#39729613)
Surely you could find it within yourself to become the Life of Brian boring prophet? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqaQ_Bhgmrc
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by dotnet00 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @07:54PM (#39730521)
I don't think NVDA fits in with those, their rise makes typical business sense, and has made sense most of their existence, unlike the others.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by wavemode on Sunday March 17, 2024 @01:26AM (#39732133)
"Solid investment strategy" implies one could make money applying this idea consistently. There's a hundred new "next big thing" ideas every year - most of them amount to nothing.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by Lalabadie on Sunday March 17, 2024 @07:56PM (#39739141)
My first impression about this is that your examples lean a lot on survivor bias.

However, with deep enough pockets, you can indeed invest in a thousand hyped things, avoid the worst ones, and see if one or two of these sucker magnets is a moonshot.

And suddenly we're describing traditional venture capitalism. To get rich, you just need to start by being rich!

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by passion__desire on Saturday March 16, 2024 @02:51PM (#39728412)
the best way to spot a bullshitter is to ask them

A series of 5-7 why drill down questions expanding on a particular word you don't understand or do understand.

And if they aren't quick to respond or don't answer don't know or aren't out of their depth , you know they are bullshitting.

technique borrowed from Feynman's "why magnets work video"

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by JKCalhoun on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:37PM (#39728814)
I assume this video: https://youtu.be/MO0r930Sn_8

Even from within the first few seconds you can tell Feynman is already annoyed with the interviewer. It's possible that there is some history here: there may have already been a long run of questions and he's now become tired of it.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by gwervc on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:16PM (#39728641)
That works with almost every topic. Two-three questions you're in the bachelor degree level depth, 4-5 master one, 5-6 phd, 7 only God knows.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by antisthenes on Saturday March 16, 2024 @04:36PM (#39729280)
You can definitely get to the God level if you start with the question of why are elementary forces and constants the values that they are ;)
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by euroderf on Saturday March 16, 2024 @04:58PM (#39729416)
"Tell me what are your three favorite dimensionless constants, and why."
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by nuancebydefault on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:26PM (#39728723)
I _think_ I can very easily spot BS. That has its downsides... I very easily get very annoyed with BS.

I know a few people who as good as constantly BS. It's a puzzle to me what drives them, and why it seems like they even don't know they are BSing. Is there some psychological explanation, I'm curious.

I was thinking about giving examples to state my point, but in fact every somewhat sane person must have had those 'WTF are they saying' moments.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by pixl97 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @04:01PM (#39729000)
I think part of it is that BS is commonly quite effective. Good BSers are commonly good at getting information out of people and feeding it back to them as a kind of echo chamber. Most people will not pose adversarial information (that is say something purposefully wrong) to see if the BSer agrees with it and parrots it back. The BSer confirms the other persons worldviews at the same time spouting whatever crap it is they are selling. Very common tactic in grifters.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by sufficer on Saturday March 16, 2024 @06:58PM (#39730201)
One example I can easily recall is some guy bsing about his arena rank in wow. I wasn't good, but I asked enough questions to determine he was absolutely bsing to the point of laughter.

Like the kind of kid that says he has a GF that lives in another city or state or even Canada lol

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by mistermann on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:48PM (#39728898)
They can simply counter with "bad faith", "you're being pedantic", etc. Wins literally every time.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by JanisErdmanis on Saturday March 16, 2024 @05:29PM (#39729641)
Feynman did not bulshit the answer as the interviewer does not have a capacity to understand the phenomena any deeper and he gives all valid reasons why. If instead he would have jumped to writing down a Hamiltonian and constructing a partition function from which magnetization could be derived for a magnet it would have killed the interviewer in obscurity.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by Scubabear68 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @08:30PM (#39730732)
Yes! This is what I use on technical interviews. I generally ask candidates to describe systems they have worked on in depth from an architecture perspective. This very rapidly spots the BS hand wavers from those who know how their systems work. As a side effect it can also serve as a gauge on how mature or junior they may be.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by frickinLasers on Saturday March 16, 2024 @09:38PM (#39731128)
I don't interview well.

I wrote a program from scratch, tweaked it throughout my PhD, used it to get results for my thesis. I am quite confident in the robustness and accuracy of the program.

I couldn't explain my code to an interviewer (partially because it wasn't production-ready code, but mostly because I don't interview well). I'm glad I didn't get the job. Moved on to work with people who know I'm not a hand waver.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by jsight on Sunday March 17, 2024 @12:14AM (#39731877)
TBH, I've found there are people that can give great sounding answers that don't correspond all that well to reality.

There are also people who struggle to answer, because reality is more complex than what they can easily convey to someone who doesn't already know the domain.

There are pros and cons to both groups.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by scrollaway on Sunday March 17, 2024 @05:18AM (#39733046)
Hey if you want a mock interview in some as-real-as-possible scenario, find my post on whoishiring and email the careers@ email with your cv, I’ll make sure to get you an interview and get feedback to you.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by huytersd on Sunday March 17, 2024 @04:10PM (#39737606)
I would fail this hard. Even if I write an entire system from scratch I forget the details in under 3 months.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by wolverine876 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @05:45PM (#39729768)
It could be that their agenda is different from yours. Their agenda, as leader, is to keep all the balls in the air, keep everyone energized, everyone feeling trusted, the whole enterprise moving fast. A way to do that is to just keep charging forward with enthusiasm, at any target that's available. The movement and energy and trust is the thing.

The what and how is not for your client; it's not for the CEO (or not for a certain kind of CEO). That's for you and the employees. The CEO's job is to lead, inspire, motivate, provide resources.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by smugglerFlynn on Saturday March 16, 2024 @06:52PM (#39730184)
I am yet to find a highly skilled person who gets excited by “moving fast” aka charging towards bullshit targets backed by unrealistic time/quality expectations. And getting highly skilled people bored or demotivated is the best way to drop all the balls that “leader” tries to juggle.

Seriously, I think this whole Marvel movie style leadership will be seen as a huge red flag and anti-pattern in 10-15 years, just like we now look down on those Henry Ford style managers of the 20th century.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by hilux on Sunday March 17, 2024 @12:33AM (#39731957)
> TLDR: High energy, low critical thinking.

During Silicon Valley boom cycles, these fast movers ted to do a lot better than people who stop to weigh the pros and cons, moral and ethical considerations, environmental impact, etc. etc.

Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by huytersd on Sunday March 17, 2024 @04:07PM (#39737578)
Joining a cult is a lot of fun as long as you can keep your wits about you and leave whenever you choose to. I’ve been in two, always used a fake name and only spent a couple of years in each. You will never be able to match the level of community or feeling of purpose outside of a cult.
Re:Research shows that people who BS are more likely to fall... by elicksaur on Sunday March 17, 2024 @11:53PM (#39740384)
>like everyone on HN

The amount of people on this site who say AI has Yx’d their productivity is far too high for this to be an accurate generalization.