There’s a whole bunch of other failure modes that aren’t captured by the 10C rule. It’s more for estimating chip failure due to things like electromigration. You can observe this if you run a desktop CPU overclocked for many years. I had a 2600k that I had to keep bumping the OC down on, and jt eventually bit the dust after a decade.
But in general, the way you tend to end up with wearout is through electron migration ("electron wind") which is damage to interconnects from electrons slamming into metal atoms over and over and slowly ripping apart the wires. Modeling electron migration correctly is really hard, but (from memory) a general relationship is that voltage linearly increases failure rate and temperature exponentially increases it. The constants for these models are determined empirically and, of course, are NDA'd.
In general, I wouldn't worry about it. The MTTF for semiconductors is already very high even under awful temperatures 100+ C, and so as long as you cool it properly you'll be fine.
> would it be expected that a non-zero amount would fail?
The failures you describe here are going to be due to setup time violations. These issues shouldn't be transient (assuming identical temperature and voltage) since the performance characteristics of an individual device don't really change over time. Of course, the issues can seem transient as the failures may not actually always cause noticeable corruption (maybe you generate a wrong FPU result but that specific path is only exercised under rare uarch conditions).
So, it's a non-answer, but: yes and no. Maybe your chip is perfectly okay and never has any violations at the parameters you selected. Maybe it does. Neither you (nor in fact the manufacturer, though they do have a better chance since they know the process/design) can ever really be sure--all that's left is empirical burn in testing and hoping for the best :)
If voltage is raised we enter the realm of electromigration, though not sure how relevant it is for such a minuscule OC.
As for stability, yes. If the voltage is not sufficient there will be stability issues which will require further raising it, thus raising temps and requiring more power which you can't be sure if you could deliver. And then of course electromigration.
This was mostly happening during the transition to lead-free solder. Today, component should fail earlier than BGA.
We had cards in the worst of the worst environments and they ran fine for years on end.
Reboot the system, device just disappears, never to be never seen again. It generally starts after ~6 year mark.
Sometimes device starts to corrupt things silently, but not always. However they too disappear after some time.
Oh, sometimes GPUs do that, too.
Thus expected lifetime quickly becomes long enough that it's effectively not an issue for CPUs and GPUs if you provide sufficient cooling.
Both yes and no.
I still have an old AMD Athlon XP system, which works at 2200MHz (200x11), which is completely out of spec for that generation of AMD systems (2200MHz parts had 166MHz bus), and it still performs as on day one since it's not overclocked and cooled well.
On the other hand, we change parts which fry because they feel like it even they are not even close to their thermal limits, because they're kept in well cooled data center.
Sometimes, things go bzzt even without extreme heat. It's really interesting. Something is working at full throttle with no problems, you update a couple of things, reboot, and the device is gone for good.
Same for the RAID card. The processor has a couple of failure modes (no cache or no card), both directly related to RAID processor itself. Again same for the Ethernet cards we fry. They lose their MAC addresses, all pointing to in silica problems.
What effect would running an overclock like this permanently have on longevity? Is it even worth thinking about "longevity" of chips?
Obviously stability suffers but for example... how much? Author was able to get a Geekbench 6 benchmark to pass. If they tried 100 times, would it be expected that a non-zero amount would fail?