News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by dubcanada on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:04PM (#39694183)
If there is one industry that is the most resistant to change, it's the construction industry. There are still people who have been roofing for 50 years and refuse to change a single thing they do and learned 50 years ago.

Saying a bunch of glulam will solve the issue is just incorrect. Wood is fantastic material. But using half a forest to build a 2000sqft house is certainly not the direction we should be going, we should be finding ways to build with 1/2 the amount of wood we currently use. Or perhaps melt down all of that trash and form it into a house somehow...

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by happyopossum on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:42PM (#39694713)
> There are still people who have been roofing for 50 years and refuse to change a single thing they do and learned 50 years ago.

This is at best a huge exaggeration. For one thing, roofing is not a 50-year career. If you know any 70 year old roofers, they've either been retired or moved on to other things decades ago - the toll that roofing takes on a body makes it a 10-15 year career at best.

Secondly, I've been working with roofers a lot lately - I have a very old style of roof that was common 50 years ago, and it's very hard to find people who can work on it, because everyone wants to do things the modern way.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by monknomo on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @04:25PM (#39696994)
haha, I used to have a torchdown roof and I sympathize. Finding folks to do a similar style (with integral gutters and tarred gravel, etc.) was a bit challenging. Plenty of folks that'd put down some foam and shingles though
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by rascul on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:33AM (#39703778)
> This is at best a huge exaggeration. For one thing, roofing is not a 50-year career. If you know any 70 year old roofers, they've either been retired or moved on to other things decades ago - the toll that roofing takes on a body makes it a 10-15 year career at best.

The person who taught me how to lay asphalt shingles 20 years ago has now been doing it around 50 years. I know a number of roofers who have been doing it 20 to 25 years. The toll on the body probably isn't as bad as you think.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by taion on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:48PM (#39694809)
A big part of the point of that Construction Physics Substack is to explore these factors around innovation, productivity, and process change in the construction sector. I don't think it's really quite as simple as you imply: https://www.construction-physics.com/p/why-its-hard-to-innov..., https://www.construction-physics.com/p/sketch-of-a-theory-of...

Sometimes practices do reflect real constraints, rather than just path-dependence.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by efsavage on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:47PM (#39694781)
Counterpoint: I spent several years in construction, and the assistant superintendent on the project, who was at the end of a ~50 year career, often complained that so much had changed he had no idea what was going on. The tools, machines, materials, techniques, schedules, laws, etc. all changed so dramatically he was really only able to remain expert at the human elements.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by bombcar on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:06PM (#39698166)
And things that used to be quite rare are now quite common, which can make it look "slower" depending on how you frame it. 30 years ago full wrap insulation was possible, and some did it, but it was quite rare.

Now it's standard enough that I can recognize it in new developments.

The difference between a 90s house and 50s one is way less than between a 2000s and now, even.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by HumblyTossed on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @04:10PM (#39696777)
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by pixl97 on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:41PM (#39694688)
Melting down trash that will offgas for the next few decades and putting it in close proximity to people sounds like a great way to boost cancer rates.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by akira2501 on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @03:03PM (#39695890)
> it's the construction industry.

Any industry that warranties it's work. They're far less likely to take on new and disruptive technologies if there's no guarantee they're going to be supported for the necessary amount of time.

> we should be finding ways to build with 1/2 the amount of wood we currently use.

Different houses have different requirements. Some roofs see snow, others don't. Some roofs see hurricane winds, others don't.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by lazide on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @11:51PM (#39700428)
Also - warranties their work, it’s expensive to build/replace, has high damages if it fails, and is exposed to the elements and unpredictable animals/weather.

Frankly it’s shocking they try anything new at all.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by simonklitj on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:50PM (#39694830)
Or look into building with earth, as used to be the practice: https://www.calearth.org/ and https://www.rael-sanfratello.com/made/mud-frontiers
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by GorsyGentle on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:26AM (#39700599)
Rammed earth is the one that I find fascinating. But I've not seen or heard much about it's use in the Midwest where winters tend to wet.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by simonklitj on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:33PM (#39707404)
Understandable, I’m in the desert southwest, so not a concern here.

I did recently attend a workshop by Dr. Ronald Rael (Professor of Architecture @ Berkeley), and he mentioned that as concerns building with adobe bricks, with proper roofing, rain is a minimal to non-existent issue. I am not entirely convinced, however, and have also heard of solutions such as using “plasticure” on the outside of the walls.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by benced on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @02:37PM (#39695539)
> Wood is fantastic material. But using half a forest to build a 2000sqft house is certainly not the direction we should be going, we should be finding ways to build with 1/2 the amount of wood we currently use

Wood is inherently a carbon sink. I suspect stimulating forest production via added lumber demand (similar to how Christmas tree demand stimulates tree farms) would be a net pollution win, albeit potentially at the cost of a nice looking forest somewhere.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by ducttapecrown on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @03:35PM (#39696329)
We need to stimulate demand for growing forests!
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by jcgrillo on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:23PM (#39694436)
"The house gotta breathe" is something you still hear people uncritically parroting, to the point where it's become a trope in net zero construction.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by tnel77 on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:34PM (#39694586)
I’m not sure if this is entirely fair. I know people in the trades that have updated their technique and tools every few years the same way a software engineer would. They may be more resistant to change, but local building codes and such inherently force tradesmen to adapt at a certain point.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by ejb999 on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:40PM (#39694681)
Honestly, if I had to choose between buying a house built 50 years ago, or one today - I personally would take the older one. Nothing scares me more (relative to owning a house) than buying a brand new one.

If it has been around for fifty years, it has been tested - may have some things wrong with them, but you usually know what you are dealing with and usually the skill was better and materials better. Heck, my parents house is now 250 years old, and still as solid as can be.

A brand new one where the builder was trying to save money by using the latest and greatest techie products, and may or may not how to install it properly? No thanks.

To each their own though - I know plenty of folks that wouldn't even consider buying a 'used' house.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by whartung on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @02:25PM (#39695342)
Well we recently upgraded to a new build, selling off our 50 year old house. We had to relocated to a different area, because the only houses in our area were...50 year old houses. And swapping from one 50 year old house to another one didn't make a lot of sense to us.

Mind, we had done remodeling, new kitchen, new baths, new roof, new windows, new HVAC, insulation, "more sound proof" dry wall, structural engineering changes (original owners underspec'd a new addition, and we had to get that fixed), relined the sewer. The two last things on our list were redoing the electrical panel, and landscaping.

So, it had some modern elements, but at its core it was a 50 year old house.

When we had the work done, the contractor mentioned how the house was well built. "Good bones" as he said.

Our new house is VASTLY more efficient. The foundation is 50-100% thicker than our old house (which had other issues). We have that lined plywood in the attic (one side has some material for efficiency), lots more insulation. The only "exotic" thing in there, IMHO, is the plumbing, as its the clear plastic tubing style plumbing (there's a trade name for it that escapes me), vs copper. No idea how long that will last, our old house was already re-piped with copper when we bought it (can you say "slab leak"?). But I'm assuming that the new plumbing is not simply cheaper (copper, oh my) but actually "better" for more values of "better" than not.

I saw the house go up, I got to learn house geek stuff, and this is a solid house. We already have stucco cracks, which is not surprising -- I've had 4 felt quakes so far this year, and it's only March. 3+, one was at least 4. Been rocking and rolling for some reason this year, this activity is unusual, and, hopefully, not foretelling. But the house is solid. California has codes for a reason. We use stick framing for a reason, particularly in Southern California.

I wish we didn't have to leave the area we were in, but this house is so far so good and appears very well built, more so than our older house was.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by SoftTalker on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:10AM (#39700531)
The tubing is called PEX I believe and it seems to be what is used these days, replacing cemented PVC and soldered copper.

Some codes (commercial buildings?) may require copper but I believe PEX is used everywhere it can be, it's easy to work with, durable, and connections almost never leak.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by donavanm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:02AM (#39701454)
Yes. PEX is a specific type, and general term for, modern polyethylene supply tubing. Both materials and labor costs are around half of residential copper. Unless you have a really specific reason new plumbing is going to be PEX supply and PVC/ABS waste. PEX service lifetime is in the 30-50 year range, copper is 50-100 depending on wall thickness.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by wstrange on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#39706013)
And if you are a DIYer, PEX is super easy to work with.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by SoftTalker on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:40AM (#39712388)
I'm going to try it on my next project. I've done copper, I'm OK at soldering ("sweating") but far from a pro and sometimes I get leaks which is super annoying. And depending where you are working there's a real risk of starting a fire.

PVC and CPVC has never leaked for me but the cleaning solvent and the cement is messy, once you apply the cement you have only seconds to join the fittings, and the fumes give me a headache.

PEX sounds great because you can run it around bends (up to a point) without extra fittings and you don't need cement or solder.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by Ekaros on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:55PM (#39694900)
50 years I think puts here them highly in danger zone... That means 1970s... Which have whole host of very well known issues. Now 100 or even 70 year old houses... If not ruined in 70s-90s by renovation...
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by ejb999 on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @02:14PM (#39695205)
Fair enough - but point still stands, newer is not always better (to me). Give me a house that is still standing decades after mother nature threw everything it could at it, over a shiny new one any day.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by aclatuts on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @02:13PM (#39695183)
The tried and true asbestos insulation
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by bombcar on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:10PM (#39698198)
I'll trade you my 40s house for a todayhouse any day of the week.

Sure, there are bad builders and if you're having something custom built you need to educate yourself (or hire someone trustworthy to monitor), but there are so many things much better than a 50 year old house, at least if you're in a climate that has lots of degree days.

Maybe in San Diego it doesn't matter as much.

Of course, the shittiest 50 year old houses have mostly been knocked down, so the remaining stock gets better and better ...

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by jghn on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:57AM (#39704872)
It's a tradeoff, as you allude to at the end. Our house is a mid-1800s build. Thus it's safe to say that there's some survival bias at work and it was solid enough to persevere. There are things our friends with newer houses go through that we never experience. On other hand, we have our own issues. retrofitting modern benefits is difficult, at best.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by bombcar on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:59AM (#39705638)
It also varies on location, too - around here the 1800s houses are decent "all around" except for what you'd expect for an almost 200 year old building.

But in other areas I've lived houses that old will have major issues that have to be remedied eventually (as my builder there said, the tops and bottoms are shit, the middle is great - because the river rock foundation would crumble to dust eventually, and the roofs were basket cases) - costing hundreds of thousands.

And most of them were marked historic, making it even worse.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by acheron on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:56PM (#39699464)
Yeah, when I was looking for a house several years ago I didn’t remotely consider anything new. Aside from the fact that almost all new construction has HOAs, I also assume any new house was shoddily built with poor labor as quick as possible, and the main goal is to sell it to someone else in a few years before it collapses.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by rascul on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:44AM (#39703913)
There are many 50+ year old homes that are basically held up with thoughts and prayers. Many of the building methods and materials were very questionable. I would not recommend buying an old house in the USA without a thorough inspection by someone who works on old houses regularly. Many are fine, many are death traps.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by foofie on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:24PM (#39694454)
> If there is one industry that is the most resistant to change, it's the construction industry. There are still people who have been roofing for 50 years and refuse to change a single thing they do and learned 50 years ago.

I think your comment is misguided and lacks reflection. Change for the sake of change is never good because by definition there is no upside. Construction technology is also expected to be reliable and have long service life, and traditional techniques ensure that by the fact that the are tried and true.

Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by dubcanada on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @04:24PM (#39696978)
Just the comments on my comment alone justify my comment. I never said it was negative, it just is a fact. There are plenty of good new and old methods for everything. But it is resistant to change because it has to have a long service life.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by philwelch on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:01PM (#39697460)
Timber is a crop. Wanting to build houses with less wood is like wanting to make clothes with less cotton or wool; there’s no fundamental reason to economize on a renewable resource.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by BurningFrog on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:36AM (#39700640)
That argument works for an infinite resource, not for a renewable one.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S... by fsckboy on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @11:54PM (#39700447)
>refuse to change a single thing they do and learned 50 years ago

they weren't using nail guns 50 years ago, and they surely are now.