News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by datavirtue on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:03AM (#39676077)
He knows what they mean. It's the age old programmer forum response where everyone knows what the OP meant when they were asking but some pedant with a neurological problem hijacks the thread. Ignore him.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by bsder on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:24AM (#39676180)
Maybe, but the one I generally flag is "cold cuts".

Humans have been curing meat forever. The question is whether "cured meat" is an issue or whether "modern curing of meat" is the problem.

When you ordered a ham from my old local meat market, it was a hunk of freshly butchered pig that was brined, cured and smoked. If it had any sugar, I sure couldn't taste it. You took it home, put it in the oven for a couple hours, and sliced it. It tasted wonderful by itself or with just a bit of fresh horseradish.

That ham is quite a lot different in terms of ingredients from the "sliced ham" you will get from your local grocery deli as a "cold cut".

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by 2muchcoffeeman on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:01AM (#39676343)
While the definition of different “processed foods” leaves a lot to be desired, there’s always going to be foods that are at the edge of one definition.

Further attempts to refine the definition also bumps up against pendants like yourself regardless of what definition they use.

But just like porn, we all know what definitely falls into one category or the other. With foods that straddle definitions, just apply some common sense and moderation. Go ahead and eat your ham. If you share it with family and friends you’re probably ok. If you ate the whole thing yourself in a couple days, maybe that’s bad. Same for everything else. Eat them in appropriate quantities and you’ll be fine.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by card_zero on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:28AM (#39676991)
Hey, no pedant trapping. Anyway wanting a definition of a thing you're told to be scared of, as well as a proposed mechanism of harm, isn't being a pedant.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by bsder on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:01PM (#39681934)
You should write a paper. Because apparently classification isn't all that easy:

"Machine Learning Prediction of Food Processing" https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.22.21257615v...

"Interestingly, even in presence of detailed ingredient information, the consistency across nutrition specialists in assigning NOVA classes was found to be low [39]"

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by imjonse on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:28AM (#39676726)
What percentage of cured meat and cold cuts consumed worldwide (or in your locale) would you say are modern vs. traditional?
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by bsder on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:08PM (#39682024)
Almost certainly modern industrialized dominates ... by far.

And this has issues in more than just "highly processed". Listeria is also an issue.

Finding a deli that makes their own meat is practically impossible nowadays.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by grecy on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:21AM (#39676436)
It is now a confirmed fact that bacon causes cancer.

I don't think bacon consumption has gone down since then.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by card_zero on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:21AM (#39676961)
It's nitrites or nitrates, specifically.

So now I have stopped eating pastrami, and my reuben sandwiches are ruined, and I'm unhappy about that. They've evolved into an abomination involving chicken tikka and blue cheese, in an attempt to get some kind of taste out.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by stakhanov on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @07:45AM (#39678387)
If you make your own sausages and deli meats, you can just skip the nitrites; they are not really needed for the taste, just for the red color. So your sausages will come out grey/brown, but will taste just as good.

Nitrites are a bit of an economic factor, due to accelerating the curing process, and also help in mitigating risks around food safety. So they're primarily relevant to entities doing this sort of thing at industrial scale, who are subject to government standards on food safety. Home cooking to the rescue!

...on a related note, I don't really understand why small-scale organic/regional producers of aren't already doing this. At least where I am, in a rural part of Germany, we have farmers markets and other sales outlets that pride themselves on doing pretty much everything in the organic/regional playbook that could possibly set them apart from the mass-market, and who charge very high prices. Surely, they could do me the favour and just skip the nitrites? But, for some reason, they don't.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by bsder on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:29PM (#39682310)
> If you make your own sausages and deli meats, you can just skip the nitrites; they are not really needed for the taste, just for the red color.

That's not completely correct if you don't cook the meat quickly afterward.

Apparently the safety issue is mostly botulism. Certain meats (especially sausages) create anaerobic conditions while curing that allows botulism to grow. Nitrites prevent that.

It is possible to cure meats without nitrates (see: Prosciutto di Parma), but it's not a straightforward, blanket thing.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by stakhanov on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @02:24AM (#39688585)
Botulism is extremely rare, though. According to Wikipedia, it's 145 cases anually in the U.S., and 15% of those are foodborne.

Compare that to millions of cases each year, in the U.S., of foodborne illness, in general.

That's why I'm saying: It's a risk calculation, and government standards on food safety definitely prefer to err on the side of mandating too much processing of food over allowing too much foodborne illness.

Maybe, some of those risk calculations need to be revisited, and there needs to be a societal-level debate about how many cases of tummy-ache we are willing to trade off for how many basis points of cancer risk.

Incidentally, it stands to reason that the same kinds of things we do to kill off pathogens also kill off a lot of the microorganisms that may be useful to the body. To the extent that we're talking about additives, if we ingest them, then it seems likely that they might also kill off (or inhibit the growth of) useful parts of the microbiome already in the body. Of course, all of this I say in a mode of "cocktail party speculation" rather than peer-reviewed science, but there are just tons of unknown unknowns there, when it comes to the microbiome, and it actually offers one possible action mechanism (surely there are more than one), about how exactly it is that relying mostly on highly processed foods would be unhealthy for you.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by bsder on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @07:17PM (#39698712)
> Botulism is extremely rare, though.

Precisely because we have engineered our foods and processes for safety.

None of this is new: "When Every Ketchup But One Went Extinct" https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/history-of-heinz-ketch...

"Their earlier ketchups “were medium bodied with average acidity,” Smith writes. In 1906, they replaced this ketchup with a shelf-stable, preservative-free ketchup that had twice as much salt, sugar, and vinegar as other commercial ketchups"

Is a ketchup with extensively boiled tomatoes (which kills quite a bit of their nutritive value), double the salt and double the sugar better than one with small amounts of benzoate?