News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by narag on Monday March 11, 2024 @08:40PM (#39674817)
How do we know that galaxies are accelerating away from us and not moving at constant speed?

There's a more basic question: How do we know the galaxies are moving? It seems (I haven't seen any other response, like... ever) that we have one and only one way to measure the speed of galaxies: the red shift.

It's impossible to triangulate those huge distances and the time scale would also be a barrier, so no way of confirming the red shift calculations with a different method. That means that if the red shift was caused by any other effect, say the light "degrading" after millions of years of travelling the void, all the calculations would be invalid.

I've asked about this many times and the answers are in the line of "we don't know any other reason for the light to red shift" and "the current theoretical frame is consistent", even if there isn't any other measure to be consistent with.

There was a prediction (expansion is related to Big Bang) that the far away galaxies, being younger, would have a different composition. This prediction seems to be failing, but advances in instrumental could give us a more precise answer in the future.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by garrettgarcia on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:09AM (#39676113)
The American astronomer, Halton Arp, had a theory he called "intrinsic redshift". My limited understanding is that he saw evidence of "very close" and "very far away" structures that are connected to each other in space, which makes no sense. He theorized that redshift may also be indicative of the age of a galaxy, rather than only indicating velocity.

The interpretation of redshift as velocity is also the primary reason cosmologists think the universe is expanding.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by the-mitr on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:37AM (#39676763)
His book Seeing Red which raises several interesting and troublesome questions for the standard big bang model is worth a read.
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by __turbobrew__ on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:11AM (#39676124)
Degrading light sounds like an interesting idea to me, you could call it the “cosmological damper” if you will. Thought experiment: imagine you have light particles in a perfectly circular orbit around a black hole. Does the light ever fall into the black hole or does it orbit for eternity?
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by oneshtein on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:00AM (#39676607)
There a whole set of theories, called "Tired light" theories, which tries to explain Cosmological Red Shift by degradation of photons with time. Buy they require whole set of different cosmological principles: a medium for light propagation is required to dump lost energy into, no Big Bang. But even with a tired light theory, galaxies are accelerating toward attractors, see https://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.02483v1.pdf https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpV0GQo3P0c
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by thehappypm on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:58AM (#39690810)
Can photons collide? My understanding is they can’t.

If they could, Hawking radiation would interfere with the eternal orbit.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by raattgift on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @03:13PM (#39696030)
> Can photons collide?

Yes, at high energies and with electrons or atomic nuclei nearby.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-photon_physics

> Hawking radiation would interfere with the eternal orbit

For tractability Hawking radiation tends to be studied using a non-interacting scalar field (often massless), rather than the fields of the Standard Model (which are very much interacting, and have a variety of masses).

Hawking started that in his "Black hole explosions?" (1974) which (if you're not allergic to sci-hub) you can read at <https://sci-hub.se/https://www.nature.com/articles/248030a0>: "consider (for simplicity) a massless Hermitean scalar field \phi which obeys the covariant wave equation ... in an asymptotically flat space time containing a star which collapses to produce a black hole.". In the short paper, he's very much not considering photons or pions, and really doesn't need to in order to make his point.

The thermal spectrum of a real black hole will be in all the Standard Model fields, and except very late in the eventual evaporation will be dominated by very low energy photons originating at a fair distance outside the event horizon.

What do you mean by "eternal orbit"?

Real black holes do not extend to the infinite past. If a black hole ultimately Hawking-evaporates, in finite time there's nothing left to orbit. Late in the evaporation, there will also be a lot of very high energy gamma rays and heavier particles excited in their respective quantum fields of the Standard Model. These will all tend to participate in high-energy multi-particle interactions rather more complicatedly than the end result of Hawking's 1974 description.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by raattgift on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @03:22PM (#39696162)
Many black hole solutions of the Einstein Field Equations of General Relativity admit a photon sphere or equivalent(s) where light can orbit the black hole, but not usually stably, and in physically reasonable black hole solutions there is no stable circular orbit for light at all, so no eternal orbit. (The orbit can be quite long on human scales though, before the light eventually leaves the area around the black hole, or spirals into the black hole).

As a first step, you could can check out <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_sphere> and <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innermost_stable_circular_orbi...>

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by at_a_remove on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:25AM (#39676184)
You're not going to get a simple answer because the answer is quite complex.

Astronomy is the paleontology of photons. You should take an astronomy course if you really want to know, but essentially a "ladder" was built of distances, starting with the very near and slowly building outward using various techniques and discoveries of physics as they became available. This is called the cosmic distance ladder. You start with stellar parallax, then after that you go farther with "standard candles" (particular types of variable stars). But then you have to get even further out, where you can no longer see an individual star, and then you rely on specific breeds of supernovae. Only then do you get to redshift, and compounding tons of data from step three seems to verify the redshift estimates. By the time you get to the Hubble constant, it was a huge rift between two communities over what was still a factor of two difference.

It's quite fascinating, but I can't really dump out an entire book into a comment.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by narag on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @11:56PM (#39687961)
Don't worry. I don't want a simple answer. I just want one answer. I did know everything you mentioned and mostly everything in the Wikipedia article someone else linked.

But my objection is still unanswered: that for long distances the ONLY measure of speed is the red shift.

The only other measurable magnitude is the apparent size of the galaxies: assuming that galaxies are more or less the same average size, you get that the more distant a galaxy is, the more red-shifted it gets.

But again, this coincidence is also consistent with the light getting "degraded" somehow. I don't (can't) dispute that there are good reasons against this interpretation, but I haven't seen one. Ever.

Every time I ask this, the discussion gets muddled: historical reasons, too complex to explain... apparently it seems more logical to declare the whole Universe is expanding, the space itself is expanding than there's something about the light travelling immense distances that we still don't know. Well, maybe. But people trying to explain that are doing a lousy job.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by codethief on Saturday March 16, 2024 @11:41AM (#39726873)
> It's quite fascinating, but I can't really dump out an entire book into a comment.

Speaking of which, do you happen to know a good book which illuminates this whole story step by step? I have yet to find one which doesn't start with "Let us assume an FLRW metric…"

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by k7sune on Monday March 11, 2024 @09:50PM (#39675324)
“Degrading” sounds very intuitive to me. Can the frequency of the light waves simply slow down over a very long distance/time? Or maybe the speed of light simply slows down over an unimaginably long distance? We don’t have any model to describe such behavior, but everyday objects around us all slow down one way or another, what makes light so different?
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by Sprocklem on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:42AM (#39676267)
IIRC, this was one of the explanations proposed when the existence of a red shift was first noted: that the light is somehow slowly losing its energy over very long distances, becoming “redder” as it did so. It ultimately lost out to the dark energy / space-time expansion theory, although I do not recall why. Presumably there was some observation that precluded “degrading” light from being the sole explanation.
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:42AM (#39676778)
There are several challenges for "tired light", or indeed any theory that's an alternative to expansion of the universe.

The theory has to explain why the light gets redshifted, but does not get blurred, and the spectral lines do not get broadened. This severely restricts the type of interactions possible. Also the theory has to explain the consistency between redshifts within our own galaxy, to that of far-away galaxies.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by pigpang on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @04:52AM (#39677434)
My theory is that redshifting caused by gravitational background noise. I did calculation somewhere on HN or Youtube few months ago and numbers are of same magnitude.
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by thehappypm on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:56AM (#39690794)
Tired light is tricky to be possible because light doesn’t experience time or distance since it travels at c. Light itself from its frame of reference is emitted and received simultaneously. That’s not to say other perspectives can have different views though!
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by hnfong on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:33AM (#39676476)
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by javajosh on Monday March 11, 2024 @11:30PM (#39675878)
>It's impossible to triangulate those huge distances

Galaxies are BIG. Andromeda is faint, but the same angular size as the moon. It's 2.5Mly away, but it's also 150kly across. Over a long enough time line you could do triangulation on it. In fact it's moving toward our galaxy, but very, very slowly compared with its diameter at 110kps. But yeah, in theory you could do triangulation on it over a very long period of time.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by mr_toad on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @08:57AM (#39678923)
For triangulation to work you need to move, not your target. Triangulation is only used for objects within about 1000 parsecs, where we can triangulate using the movement of the Earth along its orbit.
Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by ganzuul on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:42AM (#39677081)
> "we don't know any other reason for the light to red shift"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del_metric

There are versions of this which do provide another reason for red shift.

Personally I keep this in mind as a means to free my thinking from a single narrative.

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by mr_toad on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @08:49AM (#39678850)
> It's impossible to triangulate those huge distances

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_distance_ladder

Re:Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate by narag on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @11:35PM (#39687849)
Funny, because that article says exactly the same.

"Short" distances are calculated by parallax, taking Earth's orbit diameter as the base.

From there, it's a extrapolation of the spectrum of known types of objects. Not triangulation. Moreover, IIRC individual stars can't be discerned in other galaxies, even the nearest ones, except maybe supernovas.

So at the distances that red shift manifests, no triangulation, only red shift.