News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by breadwinner on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:39AM (#39562758)
In what capacity is Musk suing OpenAI? Musk may have co-founded the company, but then he left (to avoid any potential future conflict of interest with his role as CEO of Tesla, as Tesla was increasingly becoming an AI-intensive company). Is he a shareholder, if not what gives him any say in the future of the company?
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by wyantb on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:48AM (#39563616)
Breach of contract seems to be the major one - from https://www.scribd.com/document/709742948/Musk-vs-OpenAI page 34 has the prayers for relief. B and C seem insane to me, I don't see how a court could decide that. On the other hand, compelling specific performance based on continual reaffirmations of the founding agreement (page 15)...seems viable at a glance. Musk is presumably a party to several relevant contracts, and given his investment and efforts, I could see this going somewhere. (Even if his motivations are in fact to ding Microsoft / spite Altman).

IANAL

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by gamblor956 on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:15PM (#39564806)
The "reaffirmations" referred to on page 15 don't mean anything. Altman merely said he was "enthusiastic" about the nonprofit structure, not that he was limiting OpenAI to it. And notably, the "I" is that quote is bracketed, meaning that Altman did not actually say "I" in his response to Musk (in legal documents, brackets in quotes mean that the quote has been altered between the brackets). Furthermore, despite the headline to that section claiming "repeat" reaffirmations, based on the facts as presented by Musk's own lawyers, Altman only potentially reaffirms the nonprofit structure once...

And the other individuals aren't even quoted, which is strong evidence that they didn't actually say anything even remotely in support of "reaffirming" the nonprofit structure (especially given that his lawyers were heavy handed with including quotes when they could be even remotely construed in favor of Musk's position) and that Musk is unilaterally characterizing whatever they actually said to support his claims, however reasonable or unreasonable that may be.

Due to the money at stake, and given that both Musk and Altman have serious credibility issues that would make a trial outcome impossible to predict, I expect this to be settled by giving Musk a bunch of stock in the for-profit entity to make shut up.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by paulddraper on Saturday March 02, 2024 @12:26AM (#39570077)
> B and C seem insane to me, I don't see how a court could decide that.

If it's part of a legal document, they're certainly the ones to decide that (relying on precedent, expert testimony, logical reasoning, etc.)

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Thrymr on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:47AM (#39563604)
He is suing for breach of agreement, namely the founding agreement that formed OpenAI as a nonprofit.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by username332211 on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:59AM (#39562979)
He's a donor to the OpenAi non-profit organization.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by breadwinner on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:04AM (#39563047)
A donor usually is only able to say how his donation will be used. For example, if you donate to Harvard University, you can say the money will be earmarked for scholarships, but you don't get a say on how the university is managed. You can at best say you will no longer donate based on how the university is managed.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Retric on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:30AM (#39563390)
A donor can sue and win in cases of fraud. Being a 501 (c) isn’t some shield that means any behavior is permitted.

In this case there’s a specific agreement that’s allegedly been breached. Basically they said results of AI research would be shared openly without benefiting any specific party, and then later entered into a private agreement with Microsoft.

I don’t know how binding any of this is, but I doubt this will simply be dismissed by the judge.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by dragonwriter on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:24PM (#39564106)
> Being a 501 (c) isn’t some shield that means any behavior is permitted.

Its pretty much—especially a 501c3—the opposite, a substantial set of restrictions in behavior, on top of those which would face an organization doing similar things that was not a 501c3.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by s1artibartfast on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:19PM (#39564037)
You can say how it is run if you found the University and put your conditions in the legal Charter of the organization. It is a problem if the university Chancellor later decides the primary purpose of the university is to save puppies without going through the correct process to change the charter.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by username332211 on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:41AM (#39563518)
I certainly hope "turning the non-profit into an LLC" is slightly different legally.

If not, I certainly hope the courts establish a clear precedent so that The Red Cross can do an IPO. Or even better, the state SPCAs. "Our unique value proposition is that we can take anyone's dog away."

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by ajhurliman on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:18AM (#39563226)
What about: "I want you to earmark this for open source AI research, and not R&D specifically aimed at making profits"
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by simpletone on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:44AM (#39563558)
> but you don't get a say on how the university is managed.

Depends on how big and important of a donor you are. If you are a billionaire donor, not only do you have a say in how the university is managed, you have a say on who does the managing.

> You can at best say you will no longer donate based on how the university is managed.

Tell that to the former presidents of harvard, upenn, etc.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by whythre on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:12AM (#39563149)
You can sue for basically any reason in the US. If Musk is able to prove they are mishandling the money, which I think is debatable, then the case can proceed.

Just because you donate money doesn’t mean the charity or nonprofit (or whatever OpenAi is), can do as they like. They may still be committing fraud if they are not using the money in the way that they claim.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by solardev on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:20AM (#39563248)
Don't you have to have some sort of standing in the lawsuit? If you don't directly suffer harm, I thought you'd have to convince the government to prosecute them instead?

(Not a lawyer, obviously.)

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by JohnFen on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:35AM (#39563443)
You can file a lawsuit for anything. If the lawsuit has serious fundamental flaws (such as lack of standing), then it will be dismissed pretty quickly.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by psunavy03 on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:45AM (#39563566)
Well you can also be spanked by the courts for frivolous litigation, and if it's truly frivolous, you may have a hard time finding an attorney, because they can be sanctioned for bringing such a suit as well.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by deaddodo on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:06PM (#39563857)
It takes quite a bit of frivolous filing to get hit with any sanctions or fines.

A single frivolous lawsuit happens here and there, it's when people/organizations are clearly malicious and abusing the system by filing continuous suits against others.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by whythre on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:51AM (#39563657)
This can happen in theory, but it is pretty rare. What you or I might call frivolous is often entertained in the court of law, and serial abusers of the court system may still issue hundreds or even thousands of attempts at lawsuits. This may be for monetary gain or to use the specter of the lawsuit as a cudgel to influence or intimidate.

This can also be exacerbated by ‘friendly’ (corrupt) courts that allow or even encourage this behavior.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by lucianbr on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:38AM (#39563481)
If Musk donated money to a nonprofit and now the nonprofit is using the money to make profit, that sounds like he was defrauded to me. They took his money under false pretenses. Not a lawyer either, so it may turn out technically he does not have standing, but naively it sure looks like he has.

I don't understand the framing of your question, is it "since he donated, he didn't expect anything in return, so he is not harmed no matter what they do"? Kinda seems like people asking for donations should not lie about the reason for the donation, even if it is a donation.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by baking on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:05PM (#39563843)
OpenAI has received $60 million in donations throughout its existence. $40 million came straight from Musk and the other $20 million came from Open Philanthropy. Musk has said that he donated $50 million, so he may have given $10 million to Open Philanthropy to fund their donation.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by solardev on Friday March 01, 2024 @03:22PM (#39566358)
> If Musk donated money to a nonprofit and now the nonprofit is using the money to make profit, that sounds like he was defrauded to me.

I am not sure if a donation to a nonprofit entitles him to a say in its management. Might have to do with how he donated the money too? https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/restricted-fund.asp

But even if a nonprofit suddenly started making a profit, seems like that would mostly be an IRS tax exemption violation rather than a breach of contract with the donors...? But again, I'm not a lawyer.

And OpenAI also has a complex structure in which the nonprofit controls a for-profit subsidiary, or something like that, similar to how Mozilla the nonprofit owns the for-profit Mozilla corp. I think Patagonia is similarly set up.

> I don't understand the framing of your question, is it "since he donated, he didn't expect anything in return, so he is not harmed no matter what they do"? Kinda seems like people asking for donations should not lie about the reason for the donation, even if it is a donation.

I guess donors can make restricted gifts, but if they don't, do they have a LEGAL (as opposed to merely ethical) right to expect the nonprofit to "do its mission" broadly? There are a gazillion nonprofits out there, and if every donor can micromanage them by alleging they are not following their mission, there would be millions of lawsuits... but then again, the average donor probably has somewhat less money and lawyers than Musk.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Retric on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:37PM (#39567631)
It’s not just a question in what you say the money is for it’s also a question of what the charity says the money is for.

A self defined cancer charity spending large sums on public information during the early days of the COVID outbreak likely has wiggle room. That same charity spending most of it’s money on scholarships for music students doesn’t. The second case suggests they raised money under false pretenses and would therefore face serious legal issues.

In practice large organizations that generally do what they say probably aren’t a risk. But the claim is essentially OpenAI abandoned its mission without returning the funds or what they used them for, which is a problem.

To be clear charities can pivot over time. If they active their primary mission or collect new funds under a different mission that’s generally fine. But a wildlife sanctuary can’t just use it’s land to build a collage.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by whythre on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:49AM (#39563621)
Harm can be all sorts of things, but taking money under false pretenses would qualify. Certainly doesn’t ensure Musk wins, but it’s enough to at least take a shot at beginning proceedings.

As for lawsuit vs criminal prosecution, the waters there are somewhat muddied. Consider the OJ case, where he was acquitted in the criminal trial and then found liable in the civil trial. Really bizarre stuff.

Personally I do think more things should be pursued criminally, but instead we seem to just be content to trade money through the courts, like an exorbitant and agonizing form of weregild.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Thrymr on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:50AM (#39563636)
Musk is claiming that he was a party to the founding agreement of OpenAI, and they violated that agreement.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by FrustratedMonky on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:54AM (#39563701)
Which is funny.

If you are shareholder of the non-profit, do you not get to share any of the fat gains by the profit side?

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Taylor_OD on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:11PM (#39563911)
The filing is listed with all the reasons for the suit here: https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/mu...
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by jcranmer on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:31AM (#39563399)
The essential theory of the case is that OpenAI is misusing the funds Musk donated to it.

reads prayer for relief

> For a judicial determination that GPT-4 constitutes Artificial General Intelligence

Okay, WTF? I'm going to have to read the entire complaint now.....

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by manquer on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:09PM (#39563893)
AGI as defined narrowly by OpenAI, Microsoft et al for their contracts, not what scientists would define it as .

While I don’t think we are close to AGI, we also have to acknowledge that term is forever changing meaning and goal posts , even 10 years back a Turing test would be considered sufficient, obviously not anymore .

The scientific, public understanding is changing constantly and a court would have difficulty in making a decision if there is no consensus , it only has to see if the contractual definition has been met

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by SonOfLilit on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:58AM (#39563762)
I assume this is because OpenAI committed to do certain things if and when they build AGI.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by bloggie on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:06PM (#39563858)
I think OpenAI has been using the excuse that GPT-4 is not AGI, and therefore can remain closed-source.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by empath-nirvana on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:02PM (#39563815)
Man is that a big juicy meatball if you're a judge, though. Who would not love to hear that case.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Hamuko on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:04AM (#39563046)
Would he have standing by having a company competing in the same space as OpenAI?
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by breadwinner on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:05AM (#39563061)
He would have the opposite of a standing, right? It seems he wants to slow down OpenAI so that his competing company can catch up.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Gormo on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:30AM (#39563389)
Or, looking at it the other way, he is complaining that a non-profit organization he donated funds to has allocated those funds to engage in for-profit business that directly competes with his own. Viewed that way, he ought to have extra standing.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by Hamuko on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:20AM (#39563255)
I mean, if I run a fridge company and another fridge company is doing something nefarious, I'd have more of a claim for damages than someone that runs a blender company, right? That's at least my layperson's interpretation. Since Musk is suing for "unfair business practices".

I also found this: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...

>Representative of its remedial objectives, the [Unfair Competition Law] originally granted standing to "any person" suing on behalf of "itself, its members, or on behalf of the general public." This prompted a public outcry over perceived abuses of the UCL because the UCL granted standing to plaintiffs without requiring them to show any actual injury. In response, California voters approved Proposition to amend the UCL to require that the plaintiff prove injury from the unfair practice. Despite this stricter standing requirement, both business competitors and consumers may still sue under the UCL.

Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by stubish on Friday March 01, 2024 @07:49PM (#39568736)
No, you can reasonably expect an open source company to open their source. Allowing you and everyone else to benefit from the work. The lawsuit is because all of the competing companies should not need to be wasting money catching up, when the goal was for everyone to be building from OpenAI's work.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by sixQuarks on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:42AM (#39563534)
He funded it in the first place, so it could achieve AGI. Why would he want to stop that? Because the whole point of donating was to make sure it was an open sourced AGI that anyone could have access to. grok as a response to open AI going both Woke and for profit.
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by krisboyz781 on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:00PM (#39563793)
Woke this and that. You and Elon are SALTY. Go use Grok since everything is so woke. Elon didn't start Tesla yet took over the company. That's just the cost of doing business
Re:Musk sues Altman seeking a return to open source and non-... by tiahura on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:11AM (#39563138)
If only there was a document that you could refer to to inform your post.