News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Friday March 01, 2024 @09:27AM (#39562082)
If everyone pitched in just a tiny bit, picking up a single piece of "someone else's" trash... we'd live in a significantly nicer world. There's a very stubborn "I didn't do it, not my problem" mindset in the US specifically.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by dotnet00 on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:02AM (#39562392)
The "I didn't do it, not my problem" mindset arises because of people with a "I did do it, but it still isn't my problem" mindset. The person who cares enough to clean up a mess in a local park is eventually going to give up when they notice that it's always the same people leaving the mess in the first place and that cleaning up for them is only emboldening them further.

Ideally what would happen is that people would be self-conscious enough to figure out after one or two slip ups that someone else is having to clean up for them, and feel bad enough to avoid doing it in the future.

This has become one of my bigger hard learned lessons. I used to go out of my way to be as considerate as possible to everyone I interacted with, trying to predict issues and mentioning them early to make things easier for others even if it might inconvenience myself. The idea was that people would reciprocate enough that it'd make things easier for myself too.

But over the years I've had to stop accepting that, because as it turns out, most people really don't care. Being extremely accommodating and planning ahead to fit someone's constraints won't mean that I get the courtesy returned. They'll just continue to push me around at their own convenience.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:06AM (#39562439)
> after one or two slip ups that someone else is having to clean up for them, and feel bad enough to avoid doing it in the future.

I've lived long enough to know that this won't happen in my lifetime, it requires an entirely different societal mindset... something closer to shame/collectivism a country like Japan has (they still have litterers of course, but a much smaller number)

Chronic litterbugs don't care, they're often low enough on the hierarchy of needs that this kind of morality isn't on their radar at all.

If everyone pitched in, you might pick up a single piece of trash occasionally... so you'd avoid the "I just cleaned up this whole park yesterday" problem, because in theory you'd have a larger number or people doing a little work rather than a smaller number doing most of it.

I regularly pick up trash in my neighborhood, so I get it though... it's impossible for one person to keep up with.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by ryandrake on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:05PM (#39563848)
> Chronic litterbugs don't care, they're often low enough on the hierarchy of needs that this kind of morality isn't on their radar at all.

Don’t forget the deliberate litterbugs. There are plenty of people out there with a “for every bottle you pick up, I’ll litter three” attitude. Belligerence against anything seen as a public good is on the rise. I know someone who believes having a clean, trash-free neighborhood is a “liberal” thing. Blows my mind.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:26PM (#39564148)
I've seen "this graffiti makes rent cheaper" too, good point
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:30PM (#39565022)
Assholes abound. Don't let them control your life, is my philosophy.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by HEmanZ on Friday March 01, 2024 @02:02PM (#39565440)
I see you’ve met some of my relatives.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by dotnet00 on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:25AM (#39562627)
Yep, although there's also just an issue of people not seeing their surroundings as something they own. I've seen this in collectivist societies too.

For example, in India, there's a pretty jarring contrast in big cities, between pristine modern buildings with immaculate interiors situated on a street literred with garbage. While Indian society loves to label littering as shameful, because no one sees the street as something they also partly own, their idea of cleaning only extends to keeping their own building immaculate.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by creato on Friday March 01, 2024 @03:38PM (#39566522)
> Chronic litterbugs don't care, they're often low enough on the hierarchy of needs that this kind of morality isn't on their radar at all.

I used to think trash around my neighborhood was from just a general mass of people not caring about littering. It sounds like that's what you think too.

Then, one day, I saw a homeless guy dumping every single trash can on the street out completely, tearing open the bags, looking for maybe 2 seconds, and then moving on to the next trash can.

Call me harsh, but that behavior should merit a serious prison sentence. I think people overestimate the damage something like this causes to the environment, but underestimate the damage it does to society and the way people think about each other.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by bombcar on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:40PM (#39567664)
This is the kind of societal harm that does warrant (apparently) harsh punishment, because if it gets out of control there is just no way to resolve it.

It doesn't have to be prison-prison; but something like that does call for maybe a Nordic-style prison that isolates society from the low-level but consistent harm.

It's all very tragedy of the commons.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by saagarjha on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:47PM (#39569910)
I do want to say that we, as a society, place people in the position where they are more likely to do things that hurt everyone far more than it would be to lift them out of whatever position they’re in. It’s hard to make progress on this because, like, the homeless person knows just as well as anyone else that they shouldn’t make a mess, and the person who can’t afford to eat knows just as well as anyone else that they shouldn’t steal toiletries from stores. And many people in those situations do actually avoid doing that, which is great. But what would be even better is removing factors that make it more likely that people will behave poorly or justify it to themselves. I feel really good about trips I make on the train rather than the car but it’s partially because I have the time and money to do this pretty easily.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by jstarfish on Saturday March 02, 2024 @07:24AM (#39572094)
> Call me harsh, but that behavior should merit a serious prison sentence.

Not harsh, just lacking creativity and losing sight of what prison is for.

For every piece of litter dropped, the sentence should be to pick up 10 more. Make criminals fix the problems they cause.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by wolverine876 on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:45PM (#39565222)
> The person who cares enough to clean up a mess in a local park is eventually going to give up

Maybe some, but certainly not all!

> The idea was that people would reciprocate enough that it'd make things easier for myself too.

Here is the flaw in your plan; it was a flaw in my plan too. In more naive days, I thought that too. Then at some point we realize what you did: people don't do good things, and you aren't going to change most of them.

That's when we can take a big step forward, and learn what true altruism, generosity, and most of all, what love is: It's caring for and doing good for people who don't 'deserve' it; who act like jerks and idiots, who even do bad things. Anyone who has done good in their life learns this lesson. That is love, the only love in any meaningful sense.

That truth is well known, but not always widely discussed. Look at the Gospels in Christianity, and everything that says we are all sinners. Look at stories of prophets in every culture: ignored, attacked, lynched. More contemporaneously, do you think people who do great good, like Washington or Gandhi or MLK, did not realize what you did about human nature? All those people, those religions, those philosophers - they all know. When Jefferson wrote 'All men are created equal, and are endowed with inalienable rights', he knew who he was writing about. When the framers of the Constitution wrote about forming 'a more perfect union', they knew that would be done would be 'of the people, by the people, and for the people' (as Lincoln said later) - and they knew about people.

And it's about you too. You're a sinner, and an asshole, and ignorant too, just like me. If that's not love, if love excludes those people, who loves you and me? Remember that ancient prayer: 'Forgive us our trespasses ...'.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by dotnet00 on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:24PM (#39567523)
I appreciate your intent, but as much as I might try, I don't have endless energy or patience.

Last year I was forced to drag my belongings between 3 apartments, each time with zero forewarning, in the summer heat, to rooms with no AC (despite my initial room having been AC, and my still having to pay the higher rent for it), while I had to prepare for my first ever research conference and later was recovering from the worst flu I've ever had, they even dragged me to a roommate conduct meeting which had nothing to do with me, right in the middle of moving. The person the meeting was actually about didn't even attend.

Each time, I had to go to the dorm office and talk to the head administrator in person to get any useful information on what was going on, and was only offered to be compensated after the third time when I came in to the administrator's office, looking half dead from the flu.

I refuse to 'love' people who would put complete strangers through all that suffering without seeming to put in even the smallest effort to empathize and try to make things easier (eg by explaining the things in the email, which they told me in person). I'm not a prophet or saint, nor do I aspire to be one. The only people entitled to my completely unconditional love, generosity, tolerance etc are my immediate family, and friends to a slightly lesser extent. With most other people I'm happy to be polite and help them in small ways by default, but going out of my way to be helpful stops as soon as it becomes obvious that they don't even think about reciprocating in even the smallest of ways. It simply isn't worth the stress I put myself through, and besides not being fair to me, it isn't fair to everyone who does try to reciprocate.

I've had many other similar experiences of my kindness being shamelessly exploited by people who haven't earned it, to the point that they became a bonding moment with my father as he too has had lots of experience with that and had come to a similar approach to treating human interaction. He often got accused of being insincere because of how much effort he put into keeping things smooth for people who reciprocated compared to those who didn't.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by wolverine876 on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:50PM (#39567763)
Hey - none of us have endless energy or patience. We just do our best.

I don't mean to be dismissive about your experience; we all have a hard road, and some much harder than others. Still, if we're talking about it honestly: Why should the admnistrator and other people have compassion for you if you don't have it for others? I'll bet that, not being saint and under all that stress, you weren't perfect in what you were doing. I'll bet the administrator and others were also under many different stressors like you were; who was understanding them?

The only way there is compassion in the world is when it's between stressed people acting less than their best, often much less. If it's restricted to near-perfection, it wouldn't exist; the word 'compassion' wouldn't have any usage or meaning.

But that doesn't mean I do it well all the time. And I'm a jerk too and I hope people have compassion for me.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by jstarfish on Saturday March 02, 2024 @07:16AM (#39572045)
> I'll bet that, not being saint and under all that stress, you weren't perfect in what you were doing.

Foul. I applaud your boldness (the world needs it) but if you're going to play Bad Cop then you have to bring something more to the table than the rationalizations of a gambler. Otherwise this is coercion.

My favorite example: "I'd bet you wouldn't suck my dick, you homophobe." Your answer determines whether you go to bed tonight as a loser, a villain, or a cocksucker.

When you get these sorts of accusations wrong, you're being cruel to an otherwise-innocent person and causing them to doubt themselves. This causes harm. Skepticism and compassion can coexist-- it's called certainty. Call your shots or don't take them.

> The only way there is compassion in the world is when it's between stressed people acting less than their best, often much less. If it's restricted to near-perfection, it wouldn't exist; the word 'compassion' wouldn't have any usage or meaning.

Yep. Forgiving minor trespasses, turning the other cheek and all that hippie Jesus shit makes for a pretty chill life. Even he lost his temper.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by wolverine876 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:52PM (#39578038)
> if you're going to play Bad Cop then you have to bring something more to the table than the rationalizations of a gambler.

I think that's an important point to raise. However, I had thought I dealt with that well. I wrote,

Why should the admnistrator and other people have compassion for you if you don't have it for others? I'll bet that, not being saint and under all that stress, you weren't perfect in what you were doing. I'll bet the administrator and others were also under many different stressors like you were; who was understanding them?

The GGP already said they weren't a saint - I used their language - and my assertion wasn't that they did something awful, but that they simply were imperfect - a pretty certain guess for anyone.

Still, I generally agree - one needs evidence, not a fabrication.

> Forgiving minor trespasses, turning the other cheek and all that hippie Jesus shit makes for a pretty chill life. Even he lost his temper.

Are you being sarcastic? Also, I don't think we need to forgive only tresspasses that are minor, and I don't see it as a 'chill life', but as important and even essential behavior by all of us (IMHO - I'm not forcing anyone to do it).

> Otherwise this is coercion.

A minor point, but where do you see 'coercion'? What am I coercing them to do and how?

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by duxup on Friday March 01, 2024 @09:40AM (#39562203)
Yeah the "someone else should do it" kinda thing is a weird self re-enforcing kinda thing too. Seems to just stoke anger and inaction.

Like I show up at a playground at say 8 am, maybe the trash left there was from 8 hours ago ... now someone gets upset that the city didn't do a thing that is probably a rebellious expectation (can't patrol all the parks overnight every 8 hours) and they shove their hands in their pockets and pout.

I'd rather folks just pick some stuff up and toss it in the bin nearby and we're all good.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by drivers99 on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:35AM (#39563446)
There was a video advocating for picking up other people's litter (that I can't seem to find) I really liked that said (paraphrased) "in order for a piece of litter to exist, it takes 1 person to litter and 1000 people to not pick it up. And in order for it not to exist, it takes just 1 person to pick it up."
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by easyas124 on Friday March 01, 2024 @09:44AM (#39562248)
I'd rather the litterbugs just not litter in the first place. (Sure, accidents happen, but I've seen ten times more outright antisocial trash dumping than forgetting a candy wrapper by mistake.) People get upset because it is entirely possible to live in a world where you don't have to clean up after people who don't take responsibility for themselves, and I think a lot of people are tired of it.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by kgermino on Friday March 01, 2024 @09:56AM (#39562338)
There's loads of littering by me but I don't think people realize how much of the trash blowing around isn't left out by individuals (intentionally or accidentally) but an artifact of our trash collection process.

A lot of the litter by me either falls out of the bin/truck during collection, is dug out of trash cans by squirrels, or spills out when the wind opens the can lid or even blows it over completely. There's things we can do to mitigate that but it'll never be perfect so you'll always see "someone else's trash" blowing in the wind.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:12AM (#39562494)
There's the whole other aspect of people who don't care to properly bag trash (which attracts more vermin that also spread litter). It's a very frustrating situation.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by kgermino on Friday March 01, 2024 @11:39AM (#39563498)
Oh I hate that! It's far from a perfect solution - bags tear, you can't bag recyclables, sidewalk and park trash cans will always have loose trash - but it's huge and too many people don't know or care to do it.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by duxup on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:04AM (#39562409)
My trash pickup day is Wednesday, and it is always the windiest day.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by duxup on Friday March 01, 2024 @09:48AM (#39562275)
I've never really found "those people shouldn't do that" does much to change things or make the world a better place.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by lostlogin on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:44PM (#39569610)
Best proof of this is seen in shared kitchens.

A sign saying that keeping the place clean is a shared responsibility is sure to get things back on track…

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by easyas124 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:35AM (#39578960)
This is a slippery slope towards nihilism. When we expect less and less of our fellow humans, where do we wind up?
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by dpkirchner on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:06PM (#39563853)
Sometimes "someone else should do it" can be translated to "someone that is being paid to do it should do it." I don't want to affect someone's livelihood, however it's a different story if they're ignoring the task.
Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @09:28AM (#39616289)
> I don't want to affect someone's livelihood

press f to doubt

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by dpkirchner on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @08:02PM (#39623838)
I know this was a low effort meme reply made in bad faith but I'm serious -- it's a consideration. I'm privileged and extremely lucky to work in a high paying industry. For me to volunteer to clean up roads means someone for whom that is the best job won't be hired.

There are some jobs that probably won't ever pay well, so there's not much moral hazard in doing them for free, of course.

Re:The 'Atlanta Magnet Man' is saving our car tires, one bik... by micromacrofoot on Friday March 01, 2024 @10:11AM (#39562475)
What tends to irritate me, is that sometimes people will make a reddit post where they took a photo of trash to post "what's wrong with people"... and they just walked away from it.

If you can stop for a moment to take a picture, you could pick a piece of it up too... but there's also the "ah I don't have time to do it all so I won't do anything"