Is that true? How are you measuring it?
A mini pc can be a good compromise but not the best at either.
- AM4 motherboard
- 5800X3D
- Aftermarket low profile CPU cooler
- 3600MHz 16GB RAM
- RTX 4060 Low Profile
- 2TB NVMe SSD
And it’d be smaller and much more powerful than a PS5. If you get the parts secondhand, it wouldn’t be that much more expensive either, especially once you factor in PS+ and how cheap Steam games are.
The only hairs in the soup are SteamOS and Nvidia drivers.
SteamOS doesn’t yet have a standalone install. You can work around that by installing ChimeraOS and having it launch Steam Big Picture on passwordless boot.
Nvidia currently has relatively poor open source drivers, but nvVLK is rapidly improving, with probably good performance in a year or so. Your other option is hoping AMD or a board partner release a low profile card, but I don’t see that happening. Or the dark GPU horse that is Intel.
You could also go for a larger case, which would allow you to fit a bigger GPU. Something like an AMD 6800 XT would deliver a 120FPS experience at 1440P and high/ultra settings, and do so quietly with an undervolt.
I would be interested also because AMD has better support in Linux and their mobile GPUs are hard to find in laptops.
There's not that much demand for a mediocre-to-poor GPU that's more powerful than iGPUs of current era.
Ultimately we will see if/when the Strix Halo gets released, how priced it will be and how successful. I would likely buy a laptop with it.
Historically yes. You got 16gb or whatever on the card near the compute core. So what if you put 16gb of the same memory on the package with the APU instead?
Shout out to PCIe for unhelpful latency characteristics and barely adequate atomics support as my primary objection to discrete GPUs.
It's also plausible that games will become less demanding of the state of the art in GPU. If a playstation APU can play them beautifully, maybe a higher spec PC one will manage the same despite the OS and libraries overhead.
I think dedicated GPUs are probably on their way out.
This is just not true—I do the vast majority of my gaming on my laptop and only switch to the dedicated GPU for super graphics-intensive games like city skylines.
As usual, this attitude conflates "FPS-obsessed entitled divas" with "gamers"
The fundamental problem here is that GPUs require more memory bandwidth than CPUs, the platforms are created for CPUs, resulting in a pretty hard cap on APU GPU performance using the same platform. Generational GPU performance gains on APUs happen when the platforms update to faster memory.
The big break in this will be Strix Halo, coming from AMD either next year or late this year, as it will support 256-bit LPDDR5. Even using the fastest LPDDR5 available on the market, this will still just barely match the memory performance of Radeon 7600, the weakest current-gen discrete GPU AMD has on the market.
I do know that overclocking VRAM (or at least GDDR6) barely increases performance, but that’s mostly because it’s usually already been pushed to the edge at stock. My old 3070Ti could easily overclock 10-15% higher, but the memory had to self-correct significantly more errors so the actual improvement was a wash.
I’m also curious if gaming handhelds would benefit from switching their entire memory architecture over to VRAM, like both consoles have done in this generation.
GPU performance is proportional to both bandwidth and compute.
Also Apple laptops do have large memory busses. The Apple M1 Max chip for example has a 512bit memory bus.
You can do better than that simply by putting some HBM or GDDR6 on the APU itself. Then you don't need to change the socket or have to add memory channels, and you don't need that much of it because you still have the ordinary memory slots to provide some DDR5 where the OS can keep all its dreck bloat. 8-16GB of the stuff would be enough to rival any of the current midrange discrete GPUs.
Wow, I had no idea integrated GPUs had come this far. This is fantastic news.
The Ryzen Z1 Extreme uses AMD’s high-end Zen 4 APU configuration, with eight Zen 4 cores and six RDNA 3 WGPs.
The ROG Ally uses it and you can dedicate 50% of the memory to the GPU and it performs quite well.
The RX 7600, AMD's lowest-end current-gen graphics card, has several times more CUs and memory bandwidth, so I think there's some room for improvement without undercutting their dGPU business.
The Z1 Extreme is essentially the same chip as the 7840U, AMD's highest tier U-series (15~30W) chip. In other words, it's a general-purpose design, not specifically gaming oriented.
so it is better to think that only a part of the cpu is dedicated for running the game, so you'd need more cores than otherwise.
I get it, it’s a CPU/SoC. But the end users care about FPS. Dedicate more of your die area to GPUs, and you’d crown the competition.
Steam Deck, and the PS5/Xbox chips are the sole exceptions; I wish those chips were available to consumers to buy.
Give me a quad core, or hexa core at most, with top of the line integrated graphics. The extra 4 cores are wasted die space for gamers.