News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by ashvardanian on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:31PM (#39493920)
I believe the internet has gone full-circle - from curated lists and RSS feeds, to automated ranking, and now going back.

Almost all top-tier professionals I meet prefer very niche data-sources they trust (mostly individuals and personal blogs - not even organizations), occasionally augmenting them with automated crawls.

There is a lot of space for hybrid approaches and we are going to see a new generation of browsers and search engines. I don't think Google can stop that.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:21PM (#39494371)
I tried making an app where you repost interesting news onto your own sorta-RSS feed, which your followers could then re-repost and so on. No global "trending" or visible follower counts, just peers, imo the exact right about of social networking. But nobody used it.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by from-nibly on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:29PM (#39494444)
Sounds like distributed tumblr. I think the world needs that really bad right now. Tumblr is going to fail soon it's totally zombified as far as the software goes.

But this is basically how Tumblr operates except it's centralized.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:33PM (#39494467)
Erm, it's not distributed though, but it could be. I've been told about Tumblr before, but it has popularity contests (trending topics, high-profile accounts), which I intentionally avoided because it changes the whole thing. You follow your IRL friends and that's it.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by noirbot on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:53PM (#39495070)
That seems like it presumes that your IRL friends have good taste/similar interests though. The reason people follow big accounts is because the big accounts often have some specific niche of thing they post in that's curated in a way that resonates with people. Most of my IRL friends maybe only share 1-2 major interests with me. My friend who may repost interesting board game news would also share things about kayaking or crypto investing that I don't care about.

If my IRL friends run into something they think I'd be interested in, they'll just send it to me directly. What's the value in getting the combined firehose of all their reading?

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by prox on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:26PM (#39495268)
I think there should be two tiers in any account, the private space (private spaces where you talk to friendgroups) and a public space where you have a rather anonymous nickname and which isn’t directly connected to your private space.

Usually it’s one or the other and you need multiple accounts (say on Instagram for example)

It feels like businesses figured out accounts and then moved on, while I think there is still room for so much growth and customization.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by noirbot on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:22PM (#39497618)
Aren't those tiers just functionally accomplished by other technologies better suited? For instance, a Slack/Discord/Matrix with themed channels for people to talk and share relevant stuff about some hobby or topic for sharing among a group of friends, and then a public Twitter/Instagram/Tumblr that your friends may or may not follow and may be anonymous?
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:40PM (#39506787)
It works kinda like Discord, you have some fake name handle, but IRL friends know what your handle is.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:37PM (#39506779)
It does mostly presume that you have things in common with your friends. At least it's not everything they read, only what they repost. Also, if something was reposted from 8 hops away by someone you don't know, you still see the OP's handle and can follow it.

The only value this brings is that it's much easier to hit "repost" on things you like than it is to go send links to everyone. People do this already, it's just awkward, and friends get annoyed from chat notification spam.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by noirbot on Sunday February 25, 2024 @10:22PM (#39507327)
The question is what percentage of my friends have more than 50% of my interests? I read plenty of interesting stuff on HN that isn't interesting to a lot of my non-programmer friends. So I post it in the "software-dev" channel of my dev friends' Discord. I don't post it in the server I share with the folks I play video games with, or my friends I cook food with.

Channels of info are only as valuable as the signal/noise ratio is. That's the whole point of RSS in some ways. You follow a lot of specific curated news sources that may be low-volume but high relevancy. "All the stuff my friends enjoy enough to repost" is likely below 50% relevant to me, just because I have a lot of friends who do a lot of stuff that I don't also care about, or don't care about that much.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Monday February 26, 2024 @02:11PM (#39515583)
I was imagining enough volume that 50% would actually be pretty good. Like, I only click on 5% of top HN articles on a good day.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by noirbot on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:46PM (#39520256)
I kinda doubt my friends read enough good stuff to have 50% of their stuff be more than 1-2 things per day, which is pretty bad volume. What percentage of what you read would you re-share in an average day? You also have to remember that some of that overlap of stuff is stuff you also probably got from the same place they did. If my friend and I both read HN, me resharing something from the homepage of HN has a low chance of being something they haven't already seen too.

My opinion is mostly based on the number of slack and discord channels in servers with my friends that I have to have muted because they have plenty of chatter about articles I don't care about. Filtering by topic is much more valuable than filtering by which human shared it most of the time.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by TheRealPomax on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:50PM (#39494614)
Nobody used it? That is indeed the exact right amount of social networking.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:45PM (#39506815)
Heh, I mostly feel the same, but a little communication with friends is a good thing imo.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by eastbound on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:05PM (#39494713)
> But nobody used it.

Stats are addictive. They are also the first step towards justifying spending time on it.

Have some stats.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Sunday February 25, 2024 @10:09PM (#39507257)
The one stat so far is how many times a thing has been reposted. Problem is, it's very hard to market an app that's only useful to a whole group of people. Someone random joins and knows nobody.

I read about how other companies overcame this, and even Tinder, which only requires users to be in the same area, had to be kick-started by hosting large college parties ($$$) and getting all the attendees to download it.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by NetOpWibby on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:25PM (#39494396)
Try it again
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hot_gril on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:27PM (#39494436)
Oh I will at some point. It's been 4 times already.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by TheCowboy on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:00PM (#39494187)
I'd love for RSS to make a comeback but one problem is a lot of niche data sources can be on platforms that don't provide a public feed, so you have the inclination of companies to put up walls in an attempt to capture user attention as a counter force.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by crtasm on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:26PM (#39494874)
Plus we used to be able to use tools that scraped and turned sites into feeds, but now most of the sites I'd like to do that on are "protected" by javascript challenges etc.

I will visit your site more if you let me get updates in my preferred fashion!

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by RexM on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:00PM (#39494176)
I want an easy way to find these quality sources.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by FirmwareBurner on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:15PM (#39494318)
There's no "easy way to find quality sources", that's mutually exclusive nowadays. Whatever is mainstream and easy to find gets automatically gamed through SEO junk, advertising, astroturfing, and becomes poor quality again in no time. Like how much do you trust CNET and Linus Tech Tips?

The best quality sources are always involving thorough human vetting of trusted and impartial people on platforms which have higher bar to entry and require some friction to find, aka word of mouth.

Which is why curated and moderated user platforms like HN, some sub-Reddit, blogs, mailing lists, community forums, are so important and also why Google search is just so useless nowadays for finding anything other than model number datasheets and product online shopping.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by tbatchelli on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:04PM (#39494704)
> There's no "easy way to find quality sources", that's mutually exclusive nowadays. Whatever is mainstream and easy to find gets automatically gamed through SEO junk, advertising and astroturfing, and becomes poor quality again in no time.

So true, a what unsolvable problem. SEO in particular, and greed in general, kills the ability of knowledge networks to organically grow, at least past the niche state.

Putting time in building your own network of trusted sources pays off handsomely. But it takes time.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by EvanAnderson on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:41PM (#39494991)
Back in '05 when I started self-hosting tt-rss I thought it'd be cool to add some "social" features to it. Specifically, I'd like to see new feed suggestions from people for whom I have followed feeds in-common.

My idea was dismissed by the tt-rss author (and at the time and I still had aspirations to submit patches). I gave up on submitting patches, forked the code for my personal use, and never got around to the "social" idea.

I don't know if mainstream feed readers still do OPML[0] exports or not. I'd enjoy seeing OPML files from people whose blogs I read.

Actually, I'd like it if people on HN published OPML files. Maybe I should. Hmmm...

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPML

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by stareatgoats on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:48PM (#39495414)
> I don't know if mainstream feed readers still do OPML[0] exports or not

Most of the feed readers (at least the open source ones) I have seen lately have offered OPML exports.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by bsdice on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:39PM (#39494963)
There is no easy way, because you have to be able to identify the greats of a field to find relentless quality. You have to become a nerd of greatness, armed with an RSS reader. Example: You can probably tell what Jeff Beck, Stefan Hauk, Jacob Deraps have in common. Sreten of M539 Restaurations? Marco Reps or Shariar of The Signal Path? Igor Bogdanov. Chips and Cheese. The Orbital Mechanics Podcast. The War Zone. Some post once a year or even less.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by t-3 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:49PM (#39495045)
One of the many things I love about seamonkey is that it has built-in RSS support and will pop up an icon at the end of the URL bar when an RSS feed is defined on a site. Combined with the built in RSS/Email/NNTP reader, it makes it very convenient to find feeds just by clicking links on sites like this one.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by arromatic on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:05PM (#39494224)
Same , wish there was a directory of rss . In past it was googles task to provide quality sources when searching and google excelled at this but somehow google is failing at this now.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by jseliger on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:43PM (#39494566)
There are people like me, who write blogs that routinely include links posts. Subscribe to those blogs, check out the stories that interest you, and subscribe to those sites in turn. I have a couple hundred sites in NetNewsWire.
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by lamontcg on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:34PM (#39494475)
Seems like this would be a good feature for Kagi search if it isn't there already?
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by hkt on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:15PM (#39494325)
I'm pretty sure every site on this directory has RSS:

http://ooh.directory/

Not the complete answer, but a part of it.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by lonk11 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:35PM (#39494481)
Just a directory of feeds could be of limited use. You don't know the signal-to-noise ratio of each feed for you.

You subscribe to tens or hundreds of feeds and, boom, you have another problem - how do you prioritize which feed to read .

With https://linklonk.com I'm trying to solve both problems: discovering feeds to follow and prioritizing content from all feeds.

You start with content you liked - submit links you liked and you will get connected to all feeds that included this link.

For example, there are a bunch of feeds that included this link https://simonwillison.net/2024/Feb/21/gemini-pro-video/

Those are:

- https://simonwillison.net/atom/everything/ - the original blog

- https://kagi.com/api/v1/smallweb/feed/ - a feed of "small web" links, I didn't know it existed, but one of the users must have submitted this feed.

- https://hnrss.org/newest?points=1000&count=100 - HN links that got more than 1000 points

- https://lobste.rs/rss - submissions to Lobste.rs

- https://lobste.rs/t/ai.rss - submissions to Lobste.rs with "ai" tag.

The point is, if you upvote this link on LinkLonk (https://linklonk.com/item/481037215144673280), you automatically get subscribed to all of these feeds. This is a way to discover new feeds through content you liked.

Now, being connected to hundreds or thousands of feeds might seem crazy. But we have a solution to that which also relies on what content you "liked". LinkLonk knows how often you liked content from each feed you are connected to (which is essentially the signal-to-noise ratio). So it ranks new content based on that. If you like 50% of posts from https://simonwillison.net/atom/everything/ then new posts from Simon Willison will be shown above other links from, say, https://lobste.rs/rss.

The more you like - the better the ranking of fresh content becomes.

In this world you don't have to actively manage which feeds you are subscribed to or not. You only rate content.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by jsemrau on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:41PM (#39493995)
the pendulum of choice
Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by asciimov on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:33PM (#39495317)
> I believe the internet has gone full-circle…

One of the most annoying things about the internet is avoiding the great enshittification cycle. I want things to be popular enough that there is traction but not popular enough that the Ad people are salivating to squeeze another dollar out of it.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by AJ007 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:54PM (#39495454)
I think you are right. My usage of RSS was nearly non-existent for many years. Now it is daily. I was shocked to find even local news sites publishing full articles in their RSS feed. Most sites still have feeds.

There is now infinite content available in traditional commercial feeds. You just have to accept it is non-chronological, non-subscribed noise pollution: Facebook, Instagram, Youtube, Twitter, etc. That suddenly makes RSS extraordinarily attractive -- perhaps even more so than it was 15 years ago.

Re:Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023) by dugite-code on Sunday February 25, 2024 @12:53AM (#39498062)
Youtube still has RSS feeds thankfully, although they did kill the subscription OPML export