News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by sokoloff on Thursday February 22, 2024 @09:58AM (#39468031)
> The decision comes after officials found that the scores were the single best predictor of students’ academic performance and that not considering them could be a disadvantage for those who have already faced daunting challenges.

Neither half of this sentence is surprising. Some people love to hate on standardized testing, despite it having been repeatedly shown to have high predictive capability.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by anon291 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:06AM (#39468152)
It's almost as if those of us who used critical reasoning before the decision was made to scrap these tests were right. A lot of introspection needs to be done to determine why these decisions were made. At the time of the decision, the admissions committees claimed the exact opposite was true, that the tests are poor predictors and disadvantaged already-disadvantaged students. Now they're claiming the opposite. Based on what data? Why did we allow the admissions committees of so-called 'elite' institutions to be so easily swayed? Are these institutions really worthy of their 'elite' status? It would seem to be called into question if they can't answer a question as straightforwards as this.

Especially institutions like MIT... one would expect that they have a solid understanding of data analysis.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by megaman821 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:19AM (#39468342)
I think the groups championing stuff like this had a lot of clout a few years ago. Unfortunately for them, concrete positive results never materialized. In the meantime, the Supreme Court ruled negatively on race-based admissions and DEI offices are facing public backlash. If there really were any ideas with pursuing, those groups squandered their chance.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:29AM (#39468518)
> I think the groups championing stuff like this had a lot of clout a few years ago.

Alternative explanation: the pandemic happened. "When the coronavirus pandemic scrambled testing, Yale and many other colleges dropped requirements that applicants submit standardized tests such as the SAT or ACT."

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by jvanderbot on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:37AM (#39468655)
That is indeed a possibility. However that was not the popular narrative. I'd be interested to see if that was the reason given and how often
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by asoneth on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:17PM (#39470102)
I thought the popular narrative was that this was primarily driven by the pandemic? The debate about the value of standardized test scores has been raging for decades and up until the pandemic most elite colleges and universities still required them. (Upon reflection, there was a prior movement at some schools to boost declining enrollment by making tests optional, but that seemed more driven by profit-seeking than morality.)

The primary explanation I have heard both in the news and from friends in admissions departments for so many elite schools going test-optional at the same time was for the pandemic, and most of the ones I am aware of explicitly called it a temporary measure as Yale did.

Now I could buy that the testing debate may have played a role in why some schools have been dragging their feet to return to requiring tests post-pandemic because anti-test folks are exploiting this opportunity. But having worked in academia I also would not discount the immense inertia in university admissions playing an equally large role.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:45AM (#39468771)
> However that was not the popular narrative. I'd be interested to see if that was the reason given and how often

"For nearly four years Yale’s undergraduate admissions process has been test-optional. The experience, originally necessitated by the pandemic..." https://admissions.yale.edu/test-flexible

"I am writing to announce that, due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, our office will be suspending our usual SAT/ACT testing requirement for the coming application cycle." https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/we-are-suspending-our-...

"When Dartmouth suspended its standardized testing requirement for undergraduate applicants in June 2020, it was a pragmatic pause taken by most colleges and universities in response to an unprecedented global pandemic." https://admissions.dartmouth.edu/apply/update-testing-policy

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by anon291 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:03PM (#39473937)
I'm sorry... no. The pandemic also messed with ... grading. Why is a one day exam considered enough of a danger to merit ignoring it, while mandating continued schooling? Many disadvantaged students obviously were going to be more disadvantaged with online schooling. We could have easily found ways to administer tests safely (outdoors, fewer people in larger, well-ventilated buildings, etc). No... no attempts were made to even encourage that, realizing that making this opportunity available would mean more disadvantaged kids able to attend these schools.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:07PM (#39474598)
> We could have easily

Easily, yes, that's the stereotypical HN comment. Everything is easy. I could do it in a weekend...

> outdoors

That's much easier said than done in many parts of the country.

> realizing that making this opportunity available would mean more disadvantaged kids able to attend these schools.

Sooooo... why are they stopping then?

Have you considered the possibility that maybe during a global pandemic, with all kinds of terrible crap happening, administering the SAT wasn't a very high social priority, and it was easier for everyone just to skip it?

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by kcrwfrd_ on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:46AM (#39468798)
I’m out of the loop on the Supreme Court decision, could you briefly fill me in?
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by ezymandias on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:16PM (#39471672)
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by nimbius on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:44AM (#39468768)
chances are excellent the decision to abandon standardized testing came directly from the colleges bean counters instead of its laureates.

running a college is very lucrative, with most institutions being nothing more than taxpayer subsidized sports team franchises. Yale isnt one of these, so its only alternative to boost revenue is to relax admissions criteria.

chances are also great that cloistered elites found this idea so dyspeptic as to demand the bar be raised oncemore. Yale is also a critical litmus for the social signaling of americas capital class.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:05PM (#39470790)
Yale definitely is that. Elon Musk put it bluntly in https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1526975113597489154?lang...

Yale is the epicenter of the woke mind virus attempting to destroy civilization.

Paul Graham's response to this was:

Bizarre as that last sentence sounds, I have to say that when I asked someone with a lot of experience in freedom of speech issues which universities to avoid, Yale was the first he mentioned.

When my son was applying to colleges, Yale and Stanford were at the top of his list of schools not to consider because he didn't like DEI.

Maybe someone is finally waking up to the fact that this is becoming a long-term reputation problem for the university?

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by anon291 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:01PM (#39473917)
Now consider that the Supreme Court Justices are basically all from Harvard / Yale.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:19AM (#39468343)
> A lot of introspection needs to be done to determine why these decisions were made.

Not really. It started with the pandemic, which messed up everything, including testing.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by ejb999 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:46AM (#39468786)
It didn't start with the pandemic, it just continued during it.

This article from the Washington Post, in October 2019 (before the pandemic started) reported that as of then, 40% of accredited schools had already dropped this requirement.

>>> Nearly 50 accredited colleges and universities that award bachelor’s degrees announced from September 2018 to September 2019 that they were dropping the admissions requirement for an SAT or ACT score, FairTest said. That brings the number of accredited schools to have done so to 1,050 — about 40 percent of the total, the nonprofit said.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/10/18/record-n...

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:51AM (#39468860)
The article is about Yale, and it did start for Yale with the pandemic.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by bombcar on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:34PM (#39472793)
I think we have a both/and situation - there was a strong current to remove SAT/ACT score consideration already in play and the pandemic was enough to force it through at Yale and others.

What schools did not drop the requirement during the pandemic would be more interesting.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:53PM (#39473070)
> What schools did not drop the requirement during the pandemic would be more interesting.

It might be interesting... if you named any.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by bombcar on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:59PM (#39473154)
It's hard to find (as in a one second google search didn't find it, but man found a lot of lists of SAT/ACT-free admissions) but I did find this:

https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-lis...

At least one on there (MIT) we know dropped and brought it back, so it's clearly not a list of those that always required it.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by Ajay-p on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:03PM (#39469895)
A lot of introspection needs to be done to determine why these decisions were made.

These decisions were purely political and social in nature, and it will happen again as soon as there is another opportunity. University administrators, under political and a little bit of social pressure, ignored science and data in pursuit of diversity, equity, and inclusion. The bulk of Ivy League schools have determined that some groups of people cannot make it without help, and it is up to those universities to correct this wrong by reducing as many roadblocks and responsibilities as possible.

I doubt there will be any introspection because many of the people who made these disastrous decisions are still in power and will likely be so for some time.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by yau8edq12i on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:19AM (#39468344)
It's a bit more nuanced than what you're describing. I suggest listening to this (or reading the transcript): https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/17/podcasts/the-daily/the-wa...
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by PeterHolzwarth on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:34AM (#39468606)
I understand your good intentions, but a poor response is one that says "go spend time listening to this podcast." That's someone else's article-length response. If you think that podcast/article made interesting points, briefly summarize them in your comment and provide the link for those who want to dig in a bit more.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by verteu on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:31AM (#39468567)
Doesn't seem very nuanced to me. The transcript directly supports anon291's claim.

Transcript: "So this in-depth study looking at college admissions that was released last summer ended up finding that the richest applicants have huge advantages in college admissions, and a lot of people have assumed that the SAT must be one of the advantages that richer applicants have."

Then they controlled for the obvious confounders, and the assumption was wrong. (Big surprise: Wealthy people attend better schools.)

I, too, am curious why schools changed their admissions policies before studying the matter closely.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by ejb999 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:49AM (#39468842)
>>I, too, am curious why schools changed their admissions policies before studying the matter closely.

Probably for the same reason Oregon decided to decriminalize most drugs thinking it would reduce usage and harm (it didn't).

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by burnerburnson on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:33AM (#39468596)
We didn't allow them to do anything. They're just not accountable to us.

If you've been following Harvard's anti-Semitism drama over the last 4 months, it appears they're not really accountable to anybody. Neither US Congress nor their wealthiest donors have been able to force action from them.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by sokoloff on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:14PM (#39470045)
It's not at all obvious to me that (or why) Yale or Harvard ought to be accountable to us. They're private universities and, as far as I know, they appear to be following the laws that they're subject to. (Following the law is a form of accountability, but a very weak form.)

If they want to suddenly condition admissions on a hash function of the applicant's name, I think that would be absurd, but I don't think I ought to have any say in that matter.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by verteu on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:38AM (#39468667)
But Harvard's president was forced to resign?
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by azinman2 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:46AM (#39468785)
Due to a citation scandal, that wasn’t as big a deal as it was presented in context.

The wrong reason to go…

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:08PM (#39470821)
A better reason to go was that her research was crap based on bad statistics.

Things like the citation scandal are a signal for the kind of problem that lead to that.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by nradov on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:27AM (#39468490)
Who is "we"? We are generally not in a position to allow or disallow anything. Most of those elite institutions are private non-profit corporations. They can do pretty much whatever they want (within certain legal bounds) and are accountable only to their own Boards.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by anon291 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:00PM (#39473906)
"We" are the people who continue to associate these schools with academic excellence. Yes, I agree they can do what they want. My local evangelical bible school can also do what they want but no one associates them with academic excellence.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by credit_guy on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:33PM (#39471145)
> Especially institutions like MIT

MIT dropped the standardized test requirement only during Covid (in 2020 and 2021). One could argue that in those time keeping the requirement would be tantamount to endangering people. Maybe they made that argument, maybe not, but the fact is that they were the first to reinstate the requirement, so not clear why you decided to pick on them.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:21AM (#39468390)
When did the officials find this out?

It's only been known for close to a century. It is the reason why standardized tests were accepted in the first place. It has been confirmed in many ways since. If they were ever ignorant of this fact, it is because they were willfully choosing to be ignorant of it.

Research also found that IQ tests are a better predictor of job performance than other available measures, such as interviews. This was first established in the military, then in the 50s and 60s was confirmed for a variety of jobs. Unfortunately the case Griggs v. Duke Power Co. make it illegal to use IQ tests, because it results in hiring fewer blacks.

But IQ tests can still be done indirectly. For example coding boot camps can use what is essentially an IQ test to decide who will be a student, and then graduation from said boot camp serves as a signal to companies that this inexperienced person is smart, motivated, and willing to learn. That signal is likely to be more valuable to the company than the training itself.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by PeterHolzwarth on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:37AM (#39468662)
I appreciate your point, but the nuance to remember is that IQ tests are also influenced by education (or, as you point out minorities, access to education as well). IQ tests do have value only within the context of what they essentially require to be able to take them and have a shot and demonstrating your innate problem solving and reasoning ability, etc.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by verteu on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:40AM (#39468701)
> IQ tests are also influenced by education (or, as you point out minorities, access to education as well).

Presumably, so is job performance?

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by silverquiet on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:47AM (#39468805)
I suspect we'll get to scientific racism sooner or later in this thread.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by mbg721 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @11:04AM (#39469087)
The cure to that would be letting colorblind standards work over time, but that's politically unacceptable because too many people derive their income from nonsense like "merit is a white colonial construct". Quit treating people differently based on race, and racist kooks will be irrelevant.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:12PM (#39470870)
I agree with the spirit of this comment, but note that quitting treating people differently requires fixing the school system so that minorities don't consistently start off in second rate schools.

It isn't just one side that finds talking about real solutions politically unacceptable.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by sokoloff on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:08PM (#39472403)
I think it's more precise/actionable to say that quitting treating people differently "includes" fixing discrepancies in the primary and secondary school systems, rather than "requires" it.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:34PM (#39473587)
I strongly disagree.

But saying that it is required, I'm drawing attention to the fact that it must be done to succeed. I believe it must be done because, starting with Piaget's work, we have evidence that children go through important developmental stages. Some lessons missed at specific ages, can be missed forever.

If I had merely said included, that makes it easy to walk away thinking that it is just one of many things that advance the goal. Which takes away from a must, to a nice to have. And then we can excuse not doing it based on the price tag. While imagining that the other things we're doing somehow will add up to a real fix. A piece of imagination that we make easier by discounting the evidence of standardized tests which demonstrate exactly how badly we, as a society, are failing.

My whole point is that, since the popular rejection of school busing, neither party has been willing to try to honestly tackle this problem.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by samatman on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:48AM (#39468832)
> IQ tests are also influenced by education

[citation needed]

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by yanslookup on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:50AM (#39468853)
> because it results in hiring fewer blacks.

You wrote this yet you still are here championing the usefulness of IQ tests?

The concept of "IQ" is fake science, invented by bigots to provide cover for bigots.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by hirvi74 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:51PM (#39472141)
I definitely question the legitimacy of reducing human qualities like intelligence down to a single number or composite score.

However, IQ was not initially invented for bigot reasons. IQ may have been used by bigots, but the initial inception of IQ was for a very legitimate purpose.

My understanding is the Binet created the first IQ tests because as French society was rapidly industrializing, more rural people were moving to cities. Some of the children of these rural people had ages that were unknown as were their educational abilities.

So, the tests were basically used to calculate the "mental age" of these children so that the children could be appropriately placed in the correct classrooms. For example, an 9 year old child with a mental age of 6 would more than likely not benefit from being thrown into the same classroom as other 9 year olds. Likewise, a 6 year old child with the mental age of 12 might not benefit from being in a classroom with other 6 year olds.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by gamblor956 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:52PM (#39470607)
Griggs did not make the use of IQ tests illegal. It simply required businesses to prove a job-related business necessity for requiring such a test. (And this was codified into law by the Civil Rights Act of 1991.)

Some businesses are able to prove a job-related business necessity for IQ tests, and do require applicants to take those tests for certain positions. Most businesses can't show a business necessity for any positions, and so don't require IQ tests.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:57PM (#39470681)
To prove a job-related business necessity for IQ tests, you need a large group of people who have been through IQ tests, and whose performance you can measure. The US military has collected this data and can use that.

Your average company with < 100 employees almost certainly CANNOT have collected this kind of data. And larger companies will have trouble putting large groups through an IQ test with no apparent purpose, and so are unlikely to have ever collected the data needed to attempt to make the case. The practical effect is that such tests are usually illegal to use. Even though we know that they are very often useful.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by gamblor956 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:24PM (#39471771)
That's still false. You don't need to have a large group of people go through IQ tests to prove a business necessity, you need to prove that IQ specifically is relevant to the specific job in some way.

And the thing is, that it's very difficult to show that IQ (as measured by an IQ test) is relevant to a specific job versus something like experience, education, etc., because "IQ" is a made up number that doesn't actually test intelligence or problem-solving abilities.

Businesses test applicants all the time. But instead of a useless IQ test, they test job-specific performance through things like coding tests, draft patents or legal documents, etc.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by btilly on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:21PM (#39473434)
You ALMOST get it, but then entirely missed the point.

You need to demonstrate that the test is consistent with a business necessity. If you have a large enough people who have taken the test, and enough data on how they perform, you can make that demonstration. You've got the data, and it is enough to cover the military despite people like you who think that it "doesn't actually test intelligence or problem-solving abilities." Because, whatever it actually tests, it predicts real world performance well enough to pass legal muster.

The US military is the only organization that I'm aware of which has an IQ test with enough data that they can pass legal muster. Very specifically I'm talking about the AFQT, which is the core of the ASVAB. See https://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/asvab details on the ASVP. And see https://asvabmilitarytest.com/asvab-compared-other-iq-tests to see that it really is an IQ test to tell if you're smart enough to be in the military. And not just whether you can join, but which jobs inside of the military they will allow you to pursue.

The military has documented that this is an effective way to find people who can do things like fill out paperwork properly, and follow orders in the field. The reason why other businesses can't do the same is not because the test is useless, but because they don't have the data to demonstrate how useful the test actually is.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by gamblor956 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @09:43PM (#39476339)
You're simply wrong. It's not a data set size issue. The issue is that most businesses can't show a sufficient connection between an IQ test and the responsibilities of a job to establish a business necessity for having the IQ test.

If they can show a business necessity, they don't need to show that the IQ test actually predicts job performance.

Notably, the army's test is not an IQ test. It is an aptitude test which is a very different thing. An aptitude test specific things are that directly and strongly related to the job (or jobs) for which the applicant is applying.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by westhanover on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:19AM (#39479670)
It is an IQ test, they will tell you that. IQ predicts job performance and wealth. Sorry if that offends you but it is reality. Good luck fighting it!
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by itsoktocry on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:22AM (#39468404)
It demonstrates how wishy-washy and irrational these entities are.

They jumped on the "standardized testing is racist" train against their own interests. As soon as that was no longer politically expedient, they reversed course. This took place in a matter of a few years, hardly enough time to gather requisite data. But that was never the goal.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by lapcat on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:25AM (#39468455)
> They jumped on the "standardized testing is racist" train against their own interests. As soon as that was no longer politically expedient, they reversed course. This took place in a matter of a few years, hardly enough time to gather requisite data. But that was never the goal.

That's not what happened. From the article: "When the coronavirus pandemic scrambled testing, Yale and many other colleges dropped requirements that applicants submit standardized tests such as the SAT or ACT." Now that the pandemic is over, they're reassessing.

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by silverquiet on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:21AM (#39468383)
> scores were the single best predictor of students’ academic performance

I wonder what the best predictor of high scores is?

Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by megaman821 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:22AM (#39468403)
Probably parents' level of educational attainment.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by ytx on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:33AM (#39468585)
since we're not talking causality, maybe it's students' future success that predicts parents level of educational attainment!
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by slily on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:43AM (#39468738)
IQ isn't real according to some, so clearly we need an inferior proxy.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by francisofascii on Thursday February 22, 2024 @11:06AM (#39469119)
The state standardized test scores kids take in middle school.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by reducesuffering on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:48AM (#39468815)
It should be concerning that Yale as an institution is dumber than the majority of people here who called this out as such.
Re:Yale will again require standardized test scores for admi... by drewcoo on Thursday February 22, 2024 @12:52PM (#39470627)
>> The decision comes after officials found that the scores were the single best predictor of students’ academic performance and that not considering them could be a disadvantage for those who have already faced daunting challenges.

> Neither half of this sentence is surprising. Some people love to hate on standardized testing, despite it having been repeatedly shown to have high predictive capability.

What's surprising is what's not in the sentence.

How could an Ivy League school's administrators have not figured that out before the policy change?

What actually caused the policy reversion, because it wasn't the sudden discovery of obvious facts?

How much of a black eye is this for Yale's reputation? They're clearly playing a game of nobody being responsible . . . because who could have known! That indicates that it's not nothing. What's the impact of this?

These are also some questions an actual journalist should have been asking. I guess we don't have those anymore, though. Does "access journalism" extend beyond politics to academic administrators now? H.L. Mencken spins in his grave.