News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by pavlov on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @03:48PM (#39446696)
> ‘"One elephant per year of glycine into an ocean 12 times the volume of Earth's oceans is not sufficient to sustain life," said Neish. "In the past, people often assumed that water equals life, but they neglected the fact that life needs other elements, in particular carbon."’

Titan’s underground ocean is 12 larger than the Earth’s oceans? I had no idea. Wow.

If this result holds, it’s a shame because the gas giant moons always seemed like the only chance of discovering some interesting extraterrestrial life within my lifetime (or the next few dozen generations — the stars are incomprehensibly distant and nearly impossible to visit).

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @05:39PM (#39447935)
Can't we send two elephants per year? Do they even have to be elephants, or can we send plain glycine?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by sph on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @06:18PM (#39448268)
How many elephants per olympic-sized swimming pool? Per (american) football field?

I have never seen any of those things in real life, yet journalists making stupid comparisons. I guess the field must be full of people that were deathly afraid of maths and numbers.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by ryukoposting on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:43PM (#39448876)
Wait, wouldn't a football field be a unit of area? How many elephants per cubic football field?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by qsi on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:20PM (#39449133)
A football field is an area, so a cubic football field would be a six-dimensional volume.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by eru on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:09AM (#39450368)
They are talking about a (cubic football) field. Cubic football is played in three dimensional 'fields', not on flat patches of grass.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by ezzaf on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:37AM (#39450502)
How do you make a cubic football roll?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by eru on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:49AM (#39450576)
You don't. Why would that be a requirement?

In regular football the spherical ball spends more time in the air than rolling, too. And in popular variants like Australian rules football or Rugby the ball is egg shaped, and that doesn't seem to cause any problems with enjoyment of these sports.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by waldrews on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:19PM (#39448721)
Elephants can swim really well, but the G-forces at liftoff would be tough on them. Plus you've gotta supply them; 70,000 Calories per day (ideally in the form of oranges), and something like 25 kg of oxygen.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by eru on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:11AM (#39450377)
Even without the supply nor worry about the acceleration at liftoff (nor even at lithobraking): none of these factors influence the carbon content of your elephants.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by wkat4242 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:24AM (#39450442)
But it does affect their carbon footprint. Green elephants are more sustainable
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by waldrews on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:01AM (#39451612)
Yes, elephants have large footprints.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by pvaldes on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:40AM (#39451835)
Sending elephants is a nonsense. Sea elephants are much better adapted to ice and oceanic conditions.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by Nevermark on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @06:19PM (#39448275)
If they are a mating pair, we can send just two and wait.

On a far more serious note, the day we can send just one AI system (and wait) must be just a few decades away.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by _justinfunk on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:34PM (#39448811)
Ask it to make paper clips.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by Nevermark on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:02PM (#39460857)
I was going to say lifespan rejuvenation devices. But you are right, a simpler first test case is obviously superior.

So paperclips. As many as it can make.

We can request more useful constructions after it has demonstrated skill at that...

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by bitwize on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @09:15PM (#39449446)
Others may have beaten us to the punch; we should keep a look out for a black boxy thing with a 1:4:9 aspect ratio...
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by eru on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:14AM (#39450391)
AI wouldn't solve much here:

Whatever your AI could do, you could do remotely from earth (with some light lag). However, AI can't magically conjure resources like carbon.

You would also need some good robotics and production capacity, preferably able to self-replicate.

AI is great, but it's not solving the greatest current bottleneck here.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by russellbeattie on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @06:46PM (#39448485)
> I had no idea. Wow.

Same here. I just looked up Titan's size [1] and it's in between the Moon and the Earth in size. I know water is just a thin layer on the crust of our planet, but 12x?

If you look up "all of Earth's water in a ball," [2] it's about a quarter the size of the moon. Titan isn't that much larger. It must just be a floating blob of water or someone's estimations/illustrations are way off.

1. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f5/Titan_Ea...

2. https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/all-earths-water-a-single-...

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by vikingerik on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:38PM (#39449239)
Saturn's primordial disc had a lot more water (attracted by Saturn's mass, and less volatile in the colder outer solar system) available to coalesce onto Titan, than in the much hotter and smaller neighborhood of primordial Earth. It's very plausible that Titan has quite a lot more water than Earth. Saturn's other moons are known (by density and gravitational analysis) to also be composed of much water ice, up to 70% or more per moon.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by throwup238 on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:30PM (#39448789)
> If you look up "all of Earth's water in a ball," [2] it's about a quarter the size of the moon.

Are you sure about that math? According to your [2] the diameter of the water ball is 1384 km while the diameter of the moon is about 3,475 km. The volume of the water is less than a tenth of the volume of the moon: ((1384/2) ^ 3) / ((3475/2) ^ 3) => ~6.3%

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by russellbeattie on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @11:53PM (#39450282)
Ah, good to know, thanks. I had just eyeballed it. (I did say someone's estimations were probably off - it just turned out to be mine.)
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by hackeraccount on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:15PM (#39448686)
Is it all the water on Earth or all the water on Earth's oceans? I'm pretty sure those aren't the same... I seem to remember reading that there's a very large amount of water chemically locked up in the Earth's crust.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by zoklet-enjoyer on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:37PM (#39448834)
I never thought about this before, but the volume of water in the atmosphere must be huge too, right?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by chmod775 on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:04PM (#39449034)
Not really. Earth has hardly any atmosphere. The part with any density to speak of is just a thin film. To see for yourself, look closely at any picture of Earth and around around its circumference you will notice how little atmosphere there actually is[1]. It's something many people don't realize, because from down here it looks like it goes up far. The reality is that just 16,000 meters up the atmosphere is unbreathably thin and most of Earth's oxygen lies below you. We have mountains that are higher than the main mass of Earth's atmosphere (50% is below 5.6km)[2].

The mass of Earth's hydrosphere is about 1.4 × 10^21 kg, while the mass of water in Earth's atmosphere is merely about 0.00002 × 10^21 kg[3].

[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f6/Ocean_wo...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrosphere

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by bmitc on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:17PM (#39449114)
What rocky planets and moons have a thicker atmosphere? Or is common for rocky planets to have "thin" atmospheres?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by shiroiushi on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:26PM (#39449168)
Venus has a much thicker atmosphere than Earth, about 92 times the pressure of Earth's at the surface.

As for what's common, we don't have many examples of rocky planets (or moons) with atmospheres in our system to use as examples, and we can't see rocky exoplanets very well at this time, so who knows.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by bmitc on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:40PM (#39449251)
Thicker, or denser? Or did you mean thick as in cake batter and not size?

As far as I can tell, Earth's atmosphere seems to extend further into space than Venus'.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by chmod775 on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:57PM (#39449333)
> As far as I can tell, Earth's atmosphere seems to extend further into space than Venus'.

Depends on where you want to draw the line for "atmosphere".

About 100km out is where the word "pressure" starts becoming near-meaningless on Earth, while on Venus you'd still have about three times as much to work with.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by shiroiushi on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:38AM (#39451445)
>As far as I can tell, Earth's atmosphere seems to extend further into space than Venus'.

Technically, Earth's atmosphere extends infinitely far into space. It's not like there's some force-field holding it in; it just gets less and less dense with altitude. So the line depends on your definition, which must be some threshold.

Anyway, Venus has about 90% of the gravity of Earth, so with 92x as much pressure at the surface (of a slightly smaller solid body), I think it stands to reason that at any given altitude, Venus's atmosphere has much higher density than Earth's. If Venus had far higher gravity, then this might not be the case at some altitude, but since its gravity is lower, then Earth's meager atmosphere should show slightly greater stratification I would think.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by bmitc on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:43AM (#39452634)
That doesn't follow. Planets are dynamical systems, not globs of material in situ. For example, Earth has a more substantial magnetosphere, which protects the atmosphere being blown completely away by the Sun.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @09:08PM (#39449405)
The important concept here is the frost line. That is, in the accretion disk consisting mostly of dust that the planets formed out of, the distance from the newborn sun where water ice could exist in direct sunlight without sublimating and being blown away. This line is somewhere between the asteroid belt and the current orbit of Jupiter. Water inside this line has only arrived here by stray comets, nearly all of the water of the solar system is outside it.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by mr_toad on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @09:14PM (#39449443)
> I know water is just a thin layer on the crust of our planet, but 12x?

Titan has a lot of ice, or maybe water, we don’t really know. Depending how much heat is produced in its core it could have a liquid water/ammonia layer 200 kilometers deep. On the other hand it might be mostly ice.

By contrast the Mariana Trench is only 10 kilometers deep.

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by huytersd on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @09:58PM (#39449668)
If the ocean was 200 km deep, and given Titan’s acceleration due to gravity of 1.35 m/s2, the pressure at the bottom would be 2700 bars. Assuming an average temp of -180C, at that pressure, water would form a type of ice that is denser than liquid water.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by jakogut on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:15PM (#39449755)
Doesn't ice melt under pressure? Is it possible this could still be liquid water at those pressures and temperatures?
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by hirsin on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:25PM (#39449801)
Ice only melts under pressure right around the freezing point - it's that weird overhang on the phase diagram, maybe to around minus fifty C. But by -180C it's always solid.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by pvaldes on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:55PM (#39460123)
If is saltwater the pressure should be even higher, plus the weight of 40km of ice.

200Km is uncharted territory for earth, with a maximum depth of almost 11 Km. But life is able to stand until 800 bars at least. More than this is metabolically defiant in organisms made of cells. Vertebrates can survive 760 bars at least.

The majority of the volume on is oceans could be empty and barred to life, but there is still a lot of space for conventional life (and Titanlings could be very different and defy our standards)

Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by jhjhjhjjhjhj on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:14AM (#39450395)
Your link says the earth water ball has a diameter of 860 miles. Titan has a diameter of 3200 miles. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titan_(moon)) So Titan is 51x the size of the earth water ball by volume. If the oceans are much deeper, then it could genuinely have 12x as much water.
Re:Saturn's largest moon most likely uninhabitable by Chris2048 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:34PM (#39456825)
According to the internets:

Titan is 71.6 × 10^9 km^3 by volume. Earths oceans are 1.335 × 10^9 km^3 by volume.

I've also soon a diagram comparing earths oceans to titan, and the water looks to have a diameter around the same radius as titan, which would mean a volume of 1/8th.

That would require earths oceans to have a volume of about 8.95 × 10^9 km^3, so I guess the illustrations are wrong (or from the perspective of the ocean ball being closer..).

Edit: correction, the diagram was a comparison of water per plant - the ocean ball was titans ocean, not earths..

So 12x earths ocean is 16.02 × 10^9 km^3

that's 1/4.46th the volume of Titan. I guess Titans Ocean ball is bigger than the radius..