News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by darkhorse13 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @04:35PM (#39389275)
Does anyone else feel a sense of doom from these advancements? I'm definitely not a Luddite, I've been working professionally as a programmer for quite some time now, but I just can't shake this feeling. And this is not in the "I might lose my job to this" kind of feeling, that's obviously there, but it's something deeper, more sinister. I don't think I can explain it properly.

Anyway, videos look incredible. I genuinely can't believe my eyes.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by geor9e on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:45PM (#39392040)
I feel the opposite. I've been overwhelmed with a sense of my mortality, that I need to care for my body better, in order to live as long as possible into this age. I feel like I won the lottery of birth date to be able to see this. I get your perspective, and I have no doubt the wealth gap will widen painfully, but I'm also optimistic about humanity's ability to work it out.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by ed_mercer on Thursday February 15, 2024 @11:38PM (#39393213)
Same. It’s absolutely amazing to be alive right now. AGI is our only shot at fixing the planet and fixing/extending our lives.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by davidmurdoch on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:34PM (#39392430)
Where does your optimism come from?
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by geor9e on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:14PM (#39392748)
That's a therapist question. Probably from an engineering career, surrounded by smart folks for whom succumbing to "we're doomed" was never an option, and a solution was something you beat your head against a brick wall for the 999th time about. You just get used to things turning out alright. But the topic has a lot written over the centuries by people who can write better than I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by brink on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:54PM (#39392595)
Not history.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by geor9e on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:17PM (#39392768)
Yes history. If you ignore the clickbait headlines designed to elicit rage, and the news feeds designed to spiral you into a cycle of fear, and just google "poverty graph" to find raw data sources you'll find it's generally a good trend like https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/dataviz-remake-fall-ext...
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by brink on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:48PM (#39392970)
What I mean is the problem with wealth gaps is historically they typically get remedied with violent revolution.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by dogcomplex on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:21AM (#39393479)
Or appeased with a tiny fraction of the total gains - just enough to keep a middle class happily with their basic little toys while wealth inequality grows.

This could easily be the same, except the toy is "you don't have to work anymore and here's some houses and robot chefs! Now play nice while the adults go build star fleets"

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by hansoolo on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:45PM (#39390317)
I think my thoughts went in a similarly sinister direction, when I saw it. I couldn't quiet grasp it.

My mood wasn't euphoric, to say the least.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by a_wild_dandan on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:30PM (#39391913)
Tom Scott elaborated on this experience last year.[1] We should form a support group to commiserate.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPhJbKBuNnA

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by survirtual on Thursday February 15, 2024 @06:03PM (#39390501)
The compute and innovations behind it should be owned by the planet, not by a handful of billionaires. It is far too powerful to be controlled by such a small group of humans, who decide what is "safe" and what isn't.

It took billions of years for all of our ancestors to enable this technology, and now a handful claim it for themselves. The GPUs to run these models cost $20,000+ each, and only the ultra-rich can afford to have that compute.

Compute power needs to be radically redistributed and equalized across the board. This is too much power.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by ThrowawayTestr on Thursday February 15, 2024 @06:21PM (#39390700)
It's amazing that this is what it takes to turn a forum of libertarians into a forum of communists.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by throwaway743 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @07:28PM (#39391363)
> libertarians

Please. Speak for yourself.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by kortilla on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:28PM (#39392385)
>into a forum of communists.

Speak for yourself

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by krapp on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:36PM (#39392453)
Yes, everyone considers themselves a dyed in the wool capitalist until circumstances lead them to realize the difference between the sheep and the wolves.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by dogcomplex on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:29AM (#39393521)
Actually, you can live-render around 12fps videos on a consumer gaming rig using software installable in a night ($3k). Not as fancy internally-consistent videos as these, but still impressive - and that's just an algorithm update and model download away. And every second a corporate AI model is exposed publicly to the world that's more training that can be siphoned to open source models at far more cost effective rates than the initial leaders.

You're impressed by the lions. But us hyenas and vultures will get our turns still too. This is not over. Information innately diffuses.

We need to organize, and we need to build.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by survirtual on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:11AM (#39395192)
The open-source solutions on anything besides image gen are like toys compared to the corporate owned ones -- and even image gen is behind DALLE3. I built video generation on top of stable diffusion 1.5 when it first came out, getting better results than what I've seen published, but it was no where close to this.

A conspiratorial part of my mind feels it is orchestrated; give the masses old / misdirected code so their work goes into dead-ends that can never achieve the results corporate is hoarding. Open Source hasn't even scratched at GPT4 yet, and that is approaching a year old.

The power dynamics need to radically shift. Corporate cannot own all this compute and brain power when it involves birthing AGI. That will create an instant and permanent divide the likes of which will never, ever be cross; you will either be an owner of intelligence indistinguishable from a god, or you will be a mortal. Even the RISK of this happening is laughable that it is being allowed.

We need radically redesigned government, regulation, and public involvement, and we need it yesterday. AGI is a Earth-wide, publicly owned effort, it cannot be relinquished to the owner / slaver class of this planet -- that is madness.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by marvin on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:32PM (#39402569)
In two posts, you went from ~"it's a travesty that only 5000 people have access to the technology that will soon own the world", to ~"it takes at least three years for the state of the art to run on a box owned by myself in my bedroom".

This is a reason for optimism.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by survirtual on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:29AM (#39417249)
Do you understand what AGI is?

Why are people so willing to trust such a small minority with power like that?

If there is even a 1% chance that they decide to "cut the cord", it is still too high. Once AGI is achieved, there is no coming back. Minutes will be like an eternity, and days, let alone years, will be beyond that.

Trusting such a small number of people with that kind of power is obscene, especially when history has time and time again shown what humans do to things which are no longer useful to them.

There has never been a divide like humans w access to AGI and regular humans before. It will be greater than the difference between a human with a modern cell phone and a carrier pigeon -- the pigeon itself, not a human using it.

My money is on the cord being cut. That means as soon as AGI is achieved, an impenetrable two-tiered human species is created; one with AGI backed intelligence, and the majority, without it, or with a dumbed down version as a transitional cookie until a more final solution can be realized. Once it reaches this stage (without any change to public governance over AGI), it will be too late.

We are already a stone's throw from this reality, if it hasn't already happened.

Why is my money on this outcome? Because that thinking brings about necessary change. We as a people have the power to prevent it 100%, and we ought to, now. Instead of relying on the outlandish chance that a historically malevolent elite suddenly gains benevolence and shares access from the kindness of their hearts to a boundless intelligence, there is a window to force access for all. Everyone having access is autonomously balancing.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by dogcomplex on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:20PM (#39437687)
Sounds like we need a public option funding and training foundational models and fueling public research which can outpace corporate models in money and brainpower. This could be a thing if governments weren't horrifically corrupted by corporate interests already, or if we could get off our asses and build some sort of decentralized swarm compute network. I do agree, in terms of raw resources (capital) we are far behind and unorganized. In terms of collective brainpower which could be applied if done right... eh, this shit doesn't seem nearly as hard as the ML experts portray it. Either we're being fed a worldwide false reality bubble, or there's a plethora of low-hanging fruit being discovered daily from just a few foundational model finds, and even though the big firms are gonna scoop those up first it's gonna be pretty hard to ever hide that information for long

Of course they're gonna get a few years heads start - which will feel like centuries in AGI time - but either they wipe us all out during that, or we're gonna put the garbage together and make our own AGI too.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by Trasmatta on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:07PM (#39391726)
I felt the same thing when I saw LLMs writing code for the first time
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by strikelaserclaw on Thursday February 15, 2024 @07:38PM (#39391461)
yes this is both exciting and scary.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by tsunamifury on Thursday February 15, 2024 @07:50PM (#39391591)
The Congress and Until the End of the World lay out some possible outcomes of tech like this.

Specifically the dream fed back to the brain in an endless loop of personalization until individuals no longer share the same world.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by slothtrop on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:25PM (#39390050)
It allows the technical possibility for a post-truth reality, where it's impossible to tell what's true and what isn't. Every piece of information fed through your machine and smartphone. That's the scariest part to me. We need to get ahead of that, because certain interests will be fabricating things with it.

As jobs go, well, we're a long ways from full automation but this represents some serious growing pains that will decimate certain jobs and replace them with few. Not sure what the reaction will be on the consumption side, revulsion or enthusiasm. The "handcrafted" market will still be there but then you wouldn't really know if any AI was used. In a long enough timeline we can hand-wave this away with UBI/negative tax.

But ah, the most at-risk workers are the professional services, white-collar upper-middle class types, even engineers but to a lesser extent. So I wonder what kind of upheaval that would cause.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by sweetbacon on Thursday February 15, 2024 @07:31PM (#39391381)
Certain interests are already fabricating voices in political robocalls in New Hampshire. I chill at what the US will see as we approach the Presidential election this fall. Then again, maybe it will give us an early taste to better prepare for what is to come.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by a_wild_dandan on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:33PM (#39391940)
The proliferation of convincing fakes will be a massive problem in about twenty years ago.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by ShamelessC on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:07PM (#39391722)
> It allows the technical possibility for a post-truth reality

Social media already did that. Donald Trump got elected POTUS which is effectively the sum of all fears w.r.t. a "post truth reality".

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by slothtrop on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:27PM (#39391884)
I agree, but this cranks it up to 11 to threaten every vector, not just facebook feeds. Unfriendly governments will also have a field day.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by antegamisou on Thursday February 15, 2024 @11:38PM (#39393217)
Feeling anything else other than concern is unpopular only on this website where most believe the entire world is cute like the nerds hanging out at the office's game room.

Nothing good is coming out of this. I don't give a shit if you believe this is Luddism.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by trungaczne on Thursday February 15, 2024 @11:42PM (#39393246)
I have felt the same since Stable Diffusion came out.

The thing is, things have value in society partly because human efforts were involved in its making. It's not just about the end result; people still go to concert on top of listening to studio recordings for example, and people still watch humans play chess even though it's clear that good enough algorithms can beat the best humans easily. Technology like these which takes away too much immediate effort (hours needed to create the product) and long term effort (decades of training) are inherently absent of underlying value that I spoke of. Of course, if a person is only interested in consumption, it matters not how the "thing" is created.

Much of the sense of doom I have comes from the inherent erosion of this human effort element in the creative process. Whether we like it or not, the availability of mass produced content naturally threatens crafts themselves. After all, nobody wants to spend a few decades on their skills only to have their creation compared to an AI generated image produced in a few seconds.

I understand there are a lot of hypes around these technology to "humanity" but I have yet to see it. It just feels like more power consolidation to billionaires (especially when done as ClosedAI). There are artists who have tried to incorporate these but they have always felt the need to willingly not label their work as AI-generated or AI-assisted to sell (but still leaves in enough details for keen observers to tell it's AI touched).

As a whole, it just feels wrong. The most optimistic (and reasonable) take I have seen is "Just wait and see". It might feel like a non-argument, but it's the only realistic take between the hyped up techbros and the doomer cult (admittedly, I might belong to the latter group).

I think one of the most worrying thing for me is that regardless of how this plays out, this technology has only added more complexity to our society. That people are divided into camps about how they feel about the technology is simply a symptom about how much uncertainty there is in the future. This last bit will be a personal quarrel, but I personally lose any last desire to have children seeing the AI advancement. It's not right creating sentient life in an age where every year people have to play lottery to see whether technological advancement has deemed their life long effort unworthy.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by Spacecosmonaut on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:43PM (#39400343)
I think you're right. A large part of the joy from creative endevours is actually getting good at something, and having other people enjoy your work. In the face of instant high quality generative AI placating the entertainment needs of the masses, we are creating a society where most people are unable to enjoy human creative expression, in part because human artists are just too slow. Attention spans are already shrinking, and after getting used to generative AI, few people will have the patience to wait for an author to write the second part of his magnum opus.
Re:Sora: Creating video from text by nonbirithm on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:38AM (#39393575)
I think of it like: The only reason humans still drive cars is we have yet to find a good enough way of replacing ourselves with something more effective. It's merely an implementation detail of "getting from A to B" that would be disrupted if a true autonomous solution was discovered. Many would want to optimize away drunk drivers and road rage if it were possible in some faraway future. So something like a steering wheel could be seen like a compromise of sorts, until the next big thing makes them obsolete.

That, and the state of missing a technology in a period of time is irreplaceable once it's been discovered. Nobody can live in an era without social media anymore, barring a global-scale catastrophic reset. So I believe it's important to consider what technology is not yet totally pervasive, for example by realizing there is still a steering wheel for you to grip in your car.

And in my mind, the sinister feeling stems from the fact that all it takes to irreversibly shift society like that is enough smart people with honest intentions but little foresight of what will happen in a few decades as a result of proliferating all this. The problems that result stop being in anyone's control, "throwing it over the wall" so to speak, and instead become yet another fact of life that could weigh us down (mostly I think of the ubiquity of social media and how it has changed human interaction). And it all stems from just a few engineering type people getting overexcited about cool possibilities they can grasp at, not considering there are billions of people unlike them who may have other ideas.

Re:Sora: Creating video from text by jiggawatts on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:06AM (#39395839)
For me, it's my kid. He's just turned three. He had just turned two when GPT4 was announced.

Going back generations, my grandparents' lives were virtually identical to my great grandparents'. My parents grew up with radio, but they were adults by the time TV changed their world. All three generations got the bulk of their information from books and newsprint.

I grew up together with computers. I remember riding that exponential wave of tech like a surfer. From Commodore 64 to a laptop with 64GB of memory, a million-to-one ratio. Tetris to Doom Eternal. Dialup modem to gigabit... in a mobile device that fits in my pocket.

All of this took decades, but now changes like this happen in months.

I keep thinking that "this tech will change my kid's childhood", but what "this" is, is already outdated and being replaced in a blink of an eye, and he hasn't even reached that point yet where he'd notice!

When image generators were first released... what... a year ago... I thought: Wow! One day, when my kid is a little older, I'll be able to use this to create illustrations for stories we make up as we go along! Won't that be great!

I still haven't gotten around to that yet, he's still too young to appreciate that, and anyway, with this Sora I'll be able to create video instead by the time he's old enough!

I keep trying to imagine what his life will be like when he grows up to be a teenager, but realistically I'm having a hard time predicting what will already be outdated by the time he's four.