News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by adrianN on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:55PM (#39323716)
Hydrogen in cars never stood a chance. It was always used to grab government money to do expensive case studies.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by darkteflon on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:56PM (#39323721)
Japan to California: Hold my beer.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by akira2501 on Saturday February 10, 2024 @12:29AM (#39323858)
Well.. the government decided it wanted to control the car market, it has single handedly set it back several decades at this point.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by forgetfreeman on Saturday February 10, 2024 @01:29AM (#39324094)
Now you get to explain in some detail through what modes a single nation's government controls multinational companies that preside over global markets. Be sure to account for regulatory capture in your explanation. We'll wait.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by akira2501 on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:09AM (#39333357)
I am always eager to rise to the call of a rank bully. Well maybe less eager than you to have the opportunity to be completely rude to a total stranger you disagree with.

Meanwhile, they control companies with laws. Isn't this obvious?

Try charity next time. Or be this rude in real life to people you know and see how it goes. People like you ruin this site.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by forgetfreeman on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @12:18AM (#39354694)
If refusing to let baseless handwaving pass for reasoned arguments ruins the site for you you're gonna have a bad time. In the mean time, "laws" hardly meets burden of proof here when the initial claim is a single nation's government controlling an entire global industry. An industry that is dominated by manufacturers that are not based in the country in question. Did you want to flesh that out a little?
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by akira2501 on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @11:32PM (#39366508)
What is baseless or handwaving about it? It's an incredibly simple statement.

"Well.. the government decided it wanted to control the car market, it has single handedly set it back several decades at this point."

The government /is/ attempting to control the car market. This is happening at both the federal and state level. These laws specify what the market can and cannot sell, the most direct form of control available. These laws inject government money into subsidies for both the consumer and the manufacturer, an indirect form of control.

The article "it" is indefinite but it obviously refers to the /market/, and not the /industry/. A word which never appeared in my original statement.

Did you want to constrain yourself a little?

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by toast0 on Saturday February 10, 2024 @12:35AM (#39323889)
After looking into natural gas vehicles, I don't see how any high pressure gas vehicle could work in the states, except through fleets.

At least natural gas had distribution already (but usually not anywhere near the pressure needed for fueling; and that compression is energy intensive!). The pressure tanks in the vehicle expire, at which point the vehicle turns into a pumpkin. At least early Mirais had 15 year tanks.

In theory, you can replace the pressure tanks, but when I was looking at aging CNG Crown Victorias (circa 2017), it was very hard to find new tanks (and many of them had been sitting for some time, so you're not even getting the full tank lifetime), or someone to install them. When I saw cost estimates, it was in the couple of thousands; not really economical when that money would get you a similar age gas car that will probably never need its gas tank replaced.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by AndrewDavis on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:08AM (#39324231)
That's interesting. In Victoria Australia (Melbourne to me more specific). LPG (liquid petroleum gas) cars were more very successful. Throughout the 80s and 90s almost every taxi was LPG, basically every petrol station also had (and many still do) have LPG. And it was super common if you bought a Ford Falcon or Holden Commodore, two of the most popular cars of the 90s and 00s here that you would convert them to LPG. Typically by installing an additional smaller tank in the boot (trunk as Americans call it) and have a switch in the cabin to switch between the fuels. Maybe the smaller tank might only get a couple hundred kilometres but it was quick, cheap and easy to fill up, simple to swap back to petrol if you needed the range etc. It was so common, I know Ford (and possibly Holden) were offering the factory ready for LPG without a petrol tank.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:23AM (#39324301)
LPG = Liquified petroleum gas = propane (or butane?). CNG = compressed natural gas = methane.

LPG tanks are much more straightforward, 100-200psi (and standardized) than CNG (thousands of psi to usable amounts in the tank because it stays as a gas unless you chill it to like -100C).

NG is a lot cheaper, in theory. In theory, you could refuel at home.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by AndrewDavis on Saturday February 10, 2024 @06:48AM (#39325485)
Ahh interesting. Didn't realise there were such significant differences in storage. Thanks!
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 10, 2024 @03:19PM (#39329817)
For extra fun, CNG and LPG vehicles both exist in North America. Not too common, but they're both out there, usually in fleet operations.

LPG is used for BBQs and some heating, so more widely available, but hard to find cars that use it.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by standeven on Saturday February 10, 2024 @01:23AM (#39324070)
Volkswagen has a good explanation of why they settled on electric instead of H2: https://www.volkswagen-newsroom.com/en/stories/battery-or-fu...
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by emacsen on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:01AM (#39324200)
Fuel cells are not a good solution for small vehicles now, but I think there's an argument to be made fr their use in trucking, where electric vehicles don't make economic sense due to battery weight, poor range, long recharge times, and currently poor towing capacity.

While hydrogen is expensive to produce, difficult to store, and less efficient in transfer than electrochemical batteries, I suspect they'd be a good technology for large fleets of trucks due to weight and range.

Fuel cells can also be made to run on natural gas, which might end up being a good stop-gap, as we already have a strong natural gas production infrastructure and despite its downsides, it's far easier to store than hydrogen.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by armada651 on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:44AM (#39324380)
Most hydrogen is already produced using natural gas as a stop-gap. So making a hydrogen truck operate on gas is just cutting out the middle man.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by more_corn on Saturday February 10, 2024 @11:19AM (#39327338)
Wait so hydrogen is just petroleum with extra steps? Was this whole thing a scam by the oil industry?
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by MobiusHorizons on Saturday February 10, 2024 @01:14PM (#39328687)
The cheapest way to produce hydrogen today does indeed involve methane as the starting material, but the promise of hydrogen was that there is a clear path to producing hydrogen from renewables. We can easily do it today, it’s just currently more expensive. If you think of hydrogen like just the energy storage / transport mechanism this isn’t any different than electric infrastructure, where electricity can be produced by fossil fuels or greener alternatives. Lots of people get upset at hydrogen for this reason, but I really don’t think it is warranted.

The real reasons to be upset with hydrogen are the various impracticalities with the infrastructure and storage. Hydrogen leaks out of solid metal tanks because the atom is so small, and it has to be kept under enormous pressure because it doesn’t liquefy without cryogenic temperatures. There is no reason that I know of to assume these practicality concerns will ever be solved for car sized applications.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by ianburrell on Saturday February 10, 2024 @01:19PM (#39328764)
Most hydrogen today is produced by steam reforming from natural gas. Which means hydrogen cars are more expensive natural gas cars.

There is green hydrogen produced by electrolysis of water. But it more expensive than other sources. It only makes sense when fossil fuel sources aren't allowed.

Hydrogen cars are a bad idea. Now, they aren't green and don't have infrastructure. In clean electricity future, battery cars will be better. Hydrogen will be important in the future for industrial processes that need heat. And maybe for long-distance transportation like planes and ships where electricity won't work. But those only make sense with green hydrogen.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by thatcat on Sunday February 11, 2024 @04:53AM (#39333867)
There is also microbe produced hydrogen extracted from ch4. This would allow using corn as the input similar to ethanol fuel, which already has a large scale production infrastructure.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by adrianN on Monday February 12, 2024 @12:25AM (#39341695)
Solar panels provide orders of magnitude more energy per area than corn and don't require fertilizer or pesticides.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by anordal on Saturday February 10, 2024 @03:18AM (#39324515)
I think you are onto it: Why don't we use a heavier hydrogen-bearing molecule that is actually possible to store as energy bearer?

You mention natural gas; that's one option (CH3 = methane).

Ammonia – NH3 – is another that's starting to look promising and really could use some of hydrogen's hype: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia#Fuel

Not for personal transportation, though – it's toxic – but for big engines in ships and airplanes.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by theodric on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:00AM (#39324699)
> trucks

You're not the only one who thinks so: https://www.hydrogeninsight.com/transport/netherlands-unveil...

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by jillesvangurp on Saturday February 10, 2024 @05:47AM (#39325186)
There are already far more battery powered electrical trucks than there are hydrogen trucks. That race was over before it ever began. Like with hydrogen cars, the gap is growing very rapidly. All sorts of battery powered trucks exist right now in every weight class. Everything from tiny vans to mining monster trucks. The notion that this cannot work is utter nonsense and easily disproved by just pointing at the obvious reality of these things existing in the market right now.

There are only two limiting factors on electrical trucks: cost of batteries and production volume of battery manufacturers. This is a temporary problem. As the production volumes improve, cost will come down. You can cover any range by just using more batteries. Typical trucks in the market have less than half a mwh of battery. This provides them with a useful but not amazing range. Unlike car owners, truck companies typically settle for good enough and don't suffer from range anxiety. They buy the range they need. Mining trucks need batteries in the mwh range. Batteries are heavy of course but this isn't a problem in a vehicle designed for moving heavy things around.

Australia actually has battery powered road trains weighing hundreds of tonnes. Reason: superior torque over any diesel engine and electricity is very cheap (lots of solar power over there). Some of these vehicles are converted decades old diesel trucks. These aren't high tech vehicles. The process for producing them is brutally simple: rip out the diesel engine, replace that with an electrical motor and shove in pallets of batteries where the fuel tanks used to be. It takes minutes to swap batteries with a fork lift truck. Supremely pragmatic and awesome. If Australians can do this in the middle of nowhere, anyone can. Likewise there are logging trucks in Canada that are built locally for the same reason. Hard core power users of trucks are going for electric. They are just better.

The only thing better than electrical road trains is actual trains on rails. Those too can run on electricity. In fact that's very common and has been so for decades. There are far more electrical trains than diesel trains. High speed trains, freight trains, passenger trains. Long trains, short trains. Any kind of train.

Fuel cells can indeed run on gas. The reason nobody is talking about that or seriously considering this as an alternative is that it is far more lucrative for gas companies to use way more gas to produce hydrogen while grabbing subsidies and selling the hydrogen at premium. Never mind that hydrogen has nearly 3x the volume of gas, both in liquid and compressed form. And never mind the high pressures you need for moving it around in gas form. Because doing so in liquid for is stupidly expensive and technically challenging. In compressed gas form, diesel has about 18x the energy density of hydrogen stored at 200 bar. Meaning you need about 18 trucks of hydrogen for every truck of diesel to move a fleet of trucks around. Transporting hydrogen to fuel stations at scale is stupidly expensive and inefficient. Producing, storing, compressing, pumping, transporting, etc. You lose money and energy at every step. It's stupidly inefficient and costly.

That's why Shell just pulled the plug on this business. It was a scam and these things served their purpose. EVs won. Game over. Moving on to the next thing. Of course the exact same thing is going to happen for hydrogen truck fueling stations. But not until after they pocket the subsidies. Until then they'll be talking up how awesome hydrogen trucks are going to be all while battery electrical trucks are actually being awesome all over the place already.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by pfdietz on Saturday February 10, 2024 @08:41AM (#39326062)
The cheapest fuel cells are alkaline cells. If you try to run those on a gasified carbon-containing fuel, they will clog up with carbonates (from the CO2) almost immediately. Ammonia would make more sense, but even then the CO2 in air causes clogging.

Carbon monoxide in gasified fuels can poison fuel cell catalysts.

The fuel cells best suited to carbonaceous fuels are solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) but these operate at 800 to 1000 C; they are not "instant on" devices. They're better as a topping cycle for something like a combustion turbine (which can also serve to pressurize them, increasing current density.) But these are also somewhat fragile (thin ceramic membranes) and any technology operating at 1000 C has lifetime concerns from creep and other degradation processes.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by hotpotamus on Saturday February 10, 2024 @08:55AM (#39326136)
I don't know that hydrogen was a "scam" per se - I think of fuel cells as essentially an alternative battery technology. It wasn't clear 20-30 years ago that lithium batteries would progress as much as they did, and so fuel cells were perhaps a reasonable hedge.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by AtlasBarfed on Saturday February 10, 2024 @09:53AM (#39326536)
Again valid industrial used aside, it was always a Trojan horse fake green tech pushed by oil and gas.

Green hydrogen was simply going to be a "in ten years" moving goalpost while everyone used methane if they actually got hydrogen off the ground.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by cheradenine_uk on Saturday February 10, 2024 @07:11AM (#39325586)
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 10, 2024 @03:35PM (#39329953)
by volume, but great energy by mass (3x gas/diesel), but yeah... the tank issue eats that up.
Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by jillesvangurp on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:59AM (#39324974)
Exactly. It's a very cynical play by oil and gas companies collaborating with car manufacturers. The play here is to get paid to "study" the obvious (it won't ever be profitable to produce these things) while delaying the inevitable (demise of the oil and gas industry and its dependent ICE car manufacturing business). The oil companies are also doing this because the goto method of producing hydrogen involves large amounts of gas. Much larger than would be used if you burned the gas directly in a combustion engine. So, they are getting subsidized to produce more gas while shedding crocodile tears over global warming and green washing their business.

Toyota has very reluctantly produced more EVs in the last year than the total amount of hydrogen cars it has ever produced. That number is in the lower tens of thousands spread over a decade. Their EV production numbers aren't very good either but it absolutely dwarfs their hydrogen car production numbers. And soon on a quarterly and eventually even monthly basis.

Toyota of course is by far the most enthusiastic hydrogen car proponent. They can't shut up talking about it and are flogging that dead horse at every opportunity they have to explain why they are so far behind producing EVs. But for all their talk about hydrogen, they are not lifting a finger to actually scale hydrogen car production. Because it doesn't make any economical sense whatsoever. Never has. They know this very well. Because they've been "studying" this topic for decades. They know everything there is to know about the viability of hydrogen cars. That's the whole reason the number of vehicles is so pathetically low. The number is the absolute bare minimum needed to grab the subsidies. Per vehicle, the subsidies are orders of magnitude the sales price of the car. Which is typically far below cost price. Producing hydrogen car has never been profitable. The game here is to minimize the money lost producing these things while maximizing the subsidies grabbed.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by iraqmtpizza on Saturday February 10, 2024 @05:22AM (#39325073)
If only Toyota were as dumb as Ford and volunteered to lose $60k per EV. Now that would be economic sense.

Now, let's not blame ourselves. It was the people we voted for who gave Toyota money to do nothing. Not us.

Re:Shell closes all of its hydrogen refuelling stations for ... by AtlasBarfed on Saturday February 10, 2024 @09:49AM (#39326505)
Putting valid industry applications aside, consumer hydrogen was always just a FUD just slow down prevent EV adoption and PHEV use by the petroleum companies.

It sucks because it should be a valid path for lots of things, but the grey black blue was all a bullshit screen for methane sales in perpetuity.