Why? Do you use formalized logic when discussing with other people about topics that involve logic? You know, a logic riddle or a philosophical question can be understood and processed even if the only tool you have is your native language. Formalized logic is a big prerequisite that basically cuts out the vast majority of Earth population (just like coding). Now, if you mean that in BENCHMARKS they should use formalized logic syntax, probably yes. But in addition to plain language tests.
1. Completely stops hallucinating, since we can demand it to internally prove its claims before showing the answer;
2. Stops outputting incorrect code (for the same reason);
3. Starts being capable of outputting complete projects (since it will now be able to compose pieces into a larger code);
4. This is also what is needed for an AI to start self-improving (as it will now be able to construct better architectures, in a loop).
That's why I argue getting the AI competent in logical reasoning is the most important priority, and we'll have no AGI until it does. After all, humans are perfectly capable of learning how to use a proof assistant.
Moreover, if an AI can't learn it no matter how hard it tries, you can argue that there is at least one human capability that the AI can't replicate, thus it isn't an AGI.
Maybe not in this century. If you told a medieval farmer that in the future millions of people fly throughout the sky inside giant hunks of metal he wouldn't believe you either.
Do you really think their primary goal is "make a lot of money"?
Way back when GPT was just fresh on the scene I had terrible anxiety about "what is the point of my whole career or even learning any more" but these days I'm much less concerned. I'll ask it something relatively simple, like "make a sentence out of words 'a', 'b', & 'c'" for it to reply with "'a' 'b' 'd' 'e'" for me to then correct it with "oh, you didn't use c" for it to then respond "sorry, here - 'a', 'c', 'd', 'f'" etc.
Definitely an amazing complimentary tool but when they say "can make mistakes, check important..." that's essential.
(f (g (h (g z))))
results in: ((((1 * 2) + 5) * 2) * 3) = ... not 17?
while it would work if the type of f was corrected.Or, again, am I missing something?
Is it not ironic that the supposedly test of AGI is flawed and its human designer fail to see it and denied it when presented with facts. Maybe the test designer is hallucinating just as much as those LLM? :)
Isn't that (h(g(h z)))?
And, FWIW, at least in my test, Gemini gets that in its final answer, though it failed in the two other drafts:
https://g.co/gemini/share/c922e7ef62aa
ChatGPT sputters:
https://chat.openai.com/share/25abbf47-2ed4-4635-a351-90a9a6...
(ETA more Gemini testing suggests its correct answer was a one-off)
It's a little scary that it can be so hard to evaluate the correctness of these LLMs even when we are paying close attention and looking for mistakes. Or maybe the scary part is that we can become biased when we want to believe.
agi may as well be God, the bars some people have.
It makes me sad that the complete and total lack of an objective way to measure these products means that the coming decades will be filled with this kind of hyper-specific gotcha test made in inappropriately confident internet posts.
Literally this could have been down to one extra book in someone's training corpus, or a tokenizer that failed to understand λ as a non-letter. But no matter, "we have a winner!". It's the computer science equivalent of declaring global warming a fraud because it snowed last night.
An AI system that produces right answers 90% of the time but 10% of the time drives your car into a lane divider, or says "there are 4 US states that start with 'K'" or "Napoleon was defeated at the Battle of Gettysburg" is worse than useless: It's dangerous.
As long as we call it a bullshit parlor trick, no problem. But unfortunately people are making important decisions based on these things.
- *Gemini Advanced answer:* `h (h (g (f z)))` (wrong)
Also, Gemini couldn't follow the "answer only with the solution" instruction and provided a bunch of hallucinated justifications. I think we have a winner... (screenshots: https://imgur.com/a/GotG0yF)